Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is This Controversial? Do You Agree/disagree?


Recommended Posts

Mary+Immaculate<3
Posted

This reminds me of what Jason Evert talked about when addressing guys, but the same can be applied to women.

 

He basically said that if someone tries to think of sex as bad, and therefore tries to not think of it, he will go neurotic. What is needed is not the supression of sexual desire, but the perfection of it. For example, someone sees a person they find very physcially attractive, and they start to lust after him. Instead of trying to divert their thoughts, which is next to impossible, they need to first say a prayer of gratitude for this beautiful person. Not only does this stop the sin, but it causes one to recognize this person's worth in God's sight.

 

Additionally, this argument is illogical, it uses inductive reasoning. One person's accidetal, perpetual virginity doesn't account for all the wonderful marriages which have lasted precisely because they waited. Furthermore, it concludes that it is the fault of a worldwide institution, instead of the individual's personal upbringing/education/wordlview.

Posted

Whatever. I sincerely doubt that Jesus would have reacted to the story of a person's emotional pain in the way any of you reacted.

 

Your reactions are so "up in arms" that anyone, in their pain, might possibly think of blaming the Church, that you are ignoring the story and the person behind it.

 

If/when any of you shared a story of serious emotional pain, I would try to understand your pain and show sympathy and caring and love before passing judgement.

 

If you are examples of the kinds of things members of the Catholic church would say, and the judgements you would pass, about ANY person obviously in serious emotional pain--whether Catholic or Protestant--it should be immaterial--then I don't want any part of it. I'm ashamed to be associated with all of you.

 

So leave Phatmass then, no loss to us.

 

Most of us are around her age and have dealt with the same socio-economic factors.  She did not come on here looking for advice, we were given a re-posted blog.  My feelings is that it is self-centered and very egotistical with little focus on the other...the people she snubbed, the people she idolized, even her husband, to which point, in the eyes of the church, she's not yet married to.

 

If she approached us, or Jesus, we would of given appropriate advice.  However, whenever people tried to play mind games with Jesus He totally pawned them.  I feel like He'd do the same here.
 

Posted

So leave Phatmass then, no loss to us.

 

Well, that's not nice... more opinions are always better,  but i agree with the implicit idea you are expressing... threatening to leave when you don't like something is a sort of intellectual blackmail.
 

Posted

Well, that's not nice... more opinions are always better,  but i agree with the implicit idea you are expressing... threatening to leave when you don't like something is a sort of intellectual blackmail.
 

 

 

No, it isn't nice, but it's an extention of the whole problem I have with the author in the article.  The "Everyone is a meanie, I don't want any part of the club so I'm going to complain but still be a part of it"

Posted

So leave Phatmass then, no loss to us.

 

 

Blazeingstar ... that was inappropriate. 

 

I actually understand Iggy's point.  She was questioning the attitude.  She didn't exactly say "ok I quit and will leave."

 

People -- please remember that we do not know each other's histories, and we are called to be charitable at all times.  This is NOT debate table (which is why I wondered about whether to move it or not) where a more combative tone is more tolerated.

 

We have had members on phatmass leave, or come close to it, because of some underlying "attitudes" that can be hurtful.  It's taken the moderating team some time to build the phamily back up.

 

So please, please remember to be charitable with your comments.  And if you don't like someone's comments go ahead and say so IN A CHARITABLE MANNER.

Posted

And I dislike that I'm seen as some kind of meanie.  But whatever.  I really don't care or have the time for what Iggy said, and I really don't care about her membership status.

 

So for what it's worth, I'm sorry I spoke harshly Iggy.  You are entitled to your own opion

PhuturePriest
Posted

Whatever. I sincerely doubt that Jesus would have reacted to the story of a person's emotional pain in the way any of you reacted.

 

Your reactions are so "up in arms" that anyone, in their pain, might possibly think of blaming the Church, that you are ignoring the story and the person behind it.

 

If/when any of you shared a story of serious emotional pain, I would try to understand your pain and show sympathy and caring and love before passing judgement.

 

If you are examples of the kinds of things members of the Catholic church would say, and the judgements you would pass, about ANY person obviously in serious emotional pain--whether Catholic or Protestant--it should be immaterial--then I don't want any part of it. I'm ashamed to be associated with all of you.

 

I quite clearly stated other people taught her false theology. This is laying the blame onto other people, which is rather different than saying "Pfft, what a crazy bunch of hormones, am I right, guys?"

Posted

No, it isn't nice, but it's an extention of the whole problem I have with the author in the article.  The "Everyone is a meanie, I don't want any part of the club so I'm going to complain but still be a part of it"

 

yeah, I agree... that's why I said up front this was sort of a lose-lose thread.  If I was honest, I wouldn't appear "compassionate", if I wasn't honest, well... then it felt to me like I had to jump into someone else's pity party - unless I wrote  a big long reply with a bunch of qualifiers, but who got time for dat?

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

Well, that's not nice... more opinions are always better,  but i agree with the implicit idea you are expressing... threatening to leave when you don't like something is a sort of intellectual blackmail.
 

 

You misunderstand me. My statement was in no way a threat to leave. (I'm sure that is a disappointment to some.)

 

I can be be disappointed in, or even ashamed of my friends sometimes, but despite that, friendship and love is strong enough to rise above those feelings. I'm sure I disappoint my friends here sometimes. And, they certainly don't agree with everything I post.

 

In the past, I have taken several "sabbaticals" from Phatmass for various reasons, but I aways find myself returning. 

 

I would think it would be considered a good thing to have some non-Catholics on Phatmass. Especially since I am not someone who hangs around on the Debate thread trying to bait people. I listen a LOT, when I'm not making posts that are usually too long. :smile2: (I've been trying to develop the art  of the quick, witty, on-point remark for almost four years now, and I still am not very good at it.)

 

As I understand it, Catholics are called upon to evangelize non-Catholics. I would think that Catholics would welcome any non-Catholics who choose to visit Phatmass, because it is a yet another opportunity for Catholics to be visible examples to non-Catholics of the way that Catholics live out Jesus' commandments to love God, and to love their neighbors as themselves.

 

There are only a few visible non-Catholics on Phatmass, but I think we are useful in at least one way. Phatmass has LOTS of guests whom we know nothing about. I wouldn't be surprised if at least some of the guests are not Catholic. I hope that being reminded by the visible presence of myself and other non-Catholics that there are non-Catholics reading your posts, might also be a reminder that there are almost certainly other, invisible non-Catholics reading your posts, as well. So, all your posts, whether that is their primary purpose or not, end up being part of your evangelism to non-Catholics.

 

For the record (and anyone who has read my profile knows this), I do not consider myself a Protestant, since I am not protesting anything. "Protestant" is listed as my religion because that was the option offered that was closest to being accurate. For a long time I had no religion listed, but I decided I didn't want to mislead anyone who doesn't know me, and might not realize that I am not Catholic. However, I am not an Evangelical Protestant.

 

I am also not anti-Catholic. The Pope would call me a "person of goodwill." If I had the great honor to meet Pope Francis, I have no doubt that he would give me a heartfelt blessing, just as he would give a heartfelt blessing to a Catholic.

 

Phatmass has changed me, and continues to change me, in ways that I sometimes don't even recognize at first. Sometimes I surprise myself, and realize, "Hey, you're thinking like a Catholic." Among the visible signs of my friendly feelings toward the Catholic church in general is that I wear a Miraculous Medal 24/7, as well as a St. Joseph medal. Almost all my charitable contributions in the past few years have been to Catholic organizations, mostly to a couple of Communities of Religious Sisters and nuns, but also to others, including Phatmass. (I try to put my money where my posts are.)

 

I don't know dUST very well, but in our few conversations, dUST has been nothing but kind and welcoming to me. At least right now, God wants me here on Phatmass for His own reasons, some of which I know and some of which I likely am totally clueless.

 

Bottom line: Unless dUST decides otherwise, you (plural) aren't going to get rid of me that easily. :smile2:

 

Sorry for the OT post. Back to the scheduled program.......

ChristinaTherese
Posted

I don't see why she's blaming the church when most of the things that she references are protestant.

 

That and people will always have inverse reactions to some things.   She could of been taken down a notch...SHE was the smug one, and she ignored the words about sex, not those who taught her.

 

 

This is the problem, right here. She made it into an idol; she says it herself. For her, her faith was reduced simply to a somewhat unhealthy view of purity. Whether that is her fault, her parents', her priest's, I do not know, but it seems clear to me, based on this article, that her idea of sexual purity was, in essence, her god.

 

Is/was this person Catholic?

The blog this was posted on is run by someone who works for an Anglican diocese, so we can assume that the writer is a Protestant.

 

I have seen some of this from Protestants before. They have a tendency of setting virginity up on a pedestal to a point where it's unhealthy. But I'm not going to comment any further because i don't want to get caught up in this particular thread. I just wanted to add that fact (about the blog owner being a Protestant) so it wasn't just conjecture.

Posted

The blog this was posted on is run by someone who works for an Anglican diocese, so we can assume that the writer is a Protestant.

 

I have seen some of this from Protestants before. They have a tendency of setting virginity up on a pedestal to a point where it's unhealthy. But I'm not going to comment any further because i don't want to get caught up in this particular thread. I just wanted to add that fact (about the blog owner being a Protestant) so it wasn't just conjecture.

That seems like more of a Baptist thing (not JUST Baptists, of course) than an Anglican thing, though.

Posted

You misunderstand me. My statement was in no way a threat to leave. (I'm sure that is a disappointment to some.)

(...)

 

Bottom line: Unless dUST decides otherwise, you (plural) aren't going to get rid of me that easily. :smile2:

 

Sorry for the OT post. Back to the scheduled program.......

 

Not disappointed.  I'm neutral, and you're somewhat entertianing.

 

Didn't realize you were a prot.  Don't pay attention to that sort of stuff.  Except for Hassan who makes it known her beef with the Church everyone else kind of blends in.

 

 You do know that if someone got tired of seeing another poster they could always block them, right?  We don't need DuST to ban anyone to not have to deal with them.

ChristinaTherese
Posted

Not disappointed.  I'm neutral, and you're somewhat entertianing.

 

Didn't realize you were a prot.  Don't pay attention to that sort of stuff.  Except for Hassan who makes it known her beef with the Church everyone else kind of blends in.

 

 You do know that if someone got tired of seeing another poster they could always block them, right?  We don't need DuST to ban anyone to not have to deal with them.

Just FYI, Hasan is a guy.

Posted

The blog this was posted on is run by someone who works for an Anglican diocese, so we can assume that the writer is a Protestant.

 

I have seen some of this from Protestants before. They have a tendency of setting virginity up on a pedestal to a point where it's unhealthy. But I'm not going to comment any further because i don't want to get caught up in this particular thread. I just wanted to add that fact (about the blog owner being a Protestant) so it wasn't just conjecture.

 

I didn't look at the source, sorry about that.  Yes this seemed to be an issue more with my protestant friends at college....but there was a huge divide.  I think that more of the damage was done to the girls who'd suffered assaults and had to deal with that, than those who were all prideful. 

Posted

Just FYI, Hasan is a guy.

 

Meh, I can't keep up with his/her SN's.  Reminds me of a Budge light and fluffy.  

Posted

I did look at the source... Didn't realize it was anglican, but noticed it was a guy's blog and the post was by a girl, but without an intro like "look what my friend wrote." 

 

Can the OP explain how she ran across this blog?  And ditto whoever said this seemed like less of an anglican thing than a baptist or evangelical issue.

Posted

I don't think this is a Prot vs Catholic thing at all. As Catholics we stress virginity before marriage, we even have a form of consecrated life dedicated to virginity (CVs). But I think that the whole purity thing 'can' become a problem for some people - of any faith, especially those who are scrupulous or perhaps a little obsessive/compulsive.

 

This woman is in a lot of pain. She does mention her husband and talks about how good he is, but she can't seem to let go of her need for 'purity' so her focus is on her needs and not his. I think the problem here is in not understanding the sacrament of marriage and how this sanctifies the physical act of intimacy between a husband and wife but I think it is also about fearing the loss of something that she won't be able to get back (a control issue).

 

So personally I don't think this is a faith issue completely, but also a psychological one. She needs help from her pastor/priest to understand the holiness of sex within marriage, but she needs some therapy to deal with her psychological block about it as well. Her husband needs support too, to help him help his wife deal with this. Otherwise... if they can't work this issue out, maybe they need an annulment?? That way she could stay a virgin and he could find a wife that wants to be a wife. Just saying.

 

 

Posted

 

 

So personally I don't think this is a faith issue completely, but also a psychological one. She needs help from her pastor/priest to understand the holiness of sex within marriage, but she needs some therapy to deal with her psychological block about it as well. Her husband needs support too, to help him help his wife deal with this. Otherwise... if they can't work this issue out, maybe they need an annulment?? That way she could stay a virgin and he could find a wife that wants to be a wife. Just saying.

 

It's not a faith issue at all.  It's wholly psychological.  It's a form of body dysmorphia.

 

This is like someone writing an article about how Lent made them anorexic.  I wouldn't really care how much pain they were in, they don't have the right to blame the church.    A priest abused you, yes, then you can blame the church, but not becuase your brain can't handle our teachings.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Okay, wow, there's a lot here already in this thread, and I'll add my full comments when I have more time. 

 

I don't think anyone's pointed out the idea that maybe when she's talking about the Church, she's not thinking the big theological institution guided by the Holy Spirit.  Maybe she's picturing the people in the Church.  

Posted

Okay, story time!

 

I had a lot of anxiety about sex too.

 

There is a condition called vaginismus where penetration of any kind can be extremely painful for a woman. It's based on psychological problems and usually associated with being erroneously taught that sex is bad/scary/will hurt. For some women it's literally impossible to have sex because of how excruciating/scary it is. Trying to be vague because this is not Raising Small Humans, but basically when fear and anxiety causes muscles to clench involuntarily it can be very very painful. It's not just a mental thing, there is real, terrible pain that results from this. It's not a matter of just pushing through - that can actually compound the problem as the muscles and brain continue to make the connection that intercourse = torture.

 

I was probably a good candidate to have this condition - I wasn't even able to successfully have a pap smear, at first - but with the help of a good obgyn and some resources to control my anxiety, I "pre-beat" it and my wedding night was fine. Was my probably idolizing purity? Not really, it was more ignorance and fear of that part of the body as an unknown zone.

 

I feel so terrible for this girl and how scared she must have been leading up to her wedding day. How unhappy the honeymoon must have been, etc. Nobody deserves that kind of horrible experience.

 

The good thing is that the cure rate is close to 100% with a few months of physical therapy and cbt.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...