Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What You Don't Know Can Hurt You


Recommended Posts

Posted

Also, you are similar to a pedophile in certain ways, but so is everyone else. Depends on what point you're trying to illustrate. I'm a human, so are pedophiles. 

 

tumblr_lcttnsi9AX1qb5bn1.gif

Posted

All dogs have four legs; my cat has four legs. Therefore, my cat is a dog

 

Waka waka. Bunga bunga.

 

Tacos

 

Franciscans of the Immaculate

 

a2 +b2 = c2

 

Later y'all

Posted

P.S. It was Colonel Mustard in the library with the candlestick. I've left you more than a fair share of clues. Have you figured it out? 

 

xoxo Gossip Girl

 

P.P.S. Seriously end of thread hijack. 

The Bus Station
Posted (edited)

Nvm.

Edited by The Bus Station
Posted

I have a question about a subject that has come up a few times in the past and even right now there is a thread relating to it.

 

Should gay/lesbian people who have committed themselves to a chaste life in order to remain faithful to the church be allowed to be priests, nuns, or religious? Do you think the fact that you are gay would somehow make you less able to fulfill that role in the church?

 

I hope that made sense. Or if I worded it this way: Does being gay make a person unfit for these roles? Even if they are 100% faithful to the church, live a chaste life, etc etc.

 

I would very much appreciate your perspective on this subject! I know what my thoughts are but again, they are not popular.

Posted

I can appreciate where this might be more easily understood by you. But remember that you are thinking with your heterosexual brain in the context of your heterosexual experiences. I imagine you have plenty of relationships with women to whom you are not attracted or with whom you are not inclined to fall in love. I have plenty of relationships with heterosexual women and do not fall for them. Why? Because they are not gay. I have never once fallen for a straight woman. I may have been enamored. I may have had a "schoolgirl crush" or something resembling it. But it was never serious and never something that really stole my time or attention.

 

Yes and no. I have a lot of female co-workers, and we have some family friends that include women of course, but I do not have any social friends that are female that do not fall in the "family friends" category. Any female friend that I have is also a friend of my wife.

 

I'm not quite sure what the underlined has to do with my post, because that'd be like me saying I have plenty of relationships with homosexual women and do not fall for them because they are not straight and that I have never fallen for a homosexual woman. That doesn't say anything about my ability to fall in love with a co-worker or other female friend that I wouldn't be able to have though.

 

Is there a possibility that I would fall in love with a co-worker and have to cut off that relationship or maybe even change jobs? Certainly there is - and that could be painful on multiple levels, painful for my wife that it even happened, painful for me for the loss of the friendship, and painful for me for the need to change jobs, and possibly painful for my family for the paycut I might have to take to do it. The fact is that I spend as much if not more time with my co-workers than I do with my wife. I also have to be extremely cautious about how social my relationships with former co-workers become. I have to make sure that if I want to go out to lunch with an old female boss and catch up, I bring along another former co-worker to make sure it is a group setting to minimize chances of something beyond "old co-worker/friend" status forming. I'm not trying to say that's the same, because although a romance can't form with those people, I do have an active relationship which in itself makes it easier. Because I'm head over heels in love with my wife, it makes it a lot more difficult to fall for someone else. Anyways, this is somewhat tangental. I just wanted to point out that just because someone isn't celibate/gay doesn't mean they aren't subject to forbidden romance that can cause deep and serious pain.

Posted

In other more on topic news then my post above, democrats in my state just put out bills to legalize same sex marriage and anti-discriminatory laws against LGBT. Kind of the opposite of Arizona. I don't know how far they'll go as our legislature has a significant republican majority though.

franciscanheart
Posted

Yes and no. I have a lot of female co-workers, and we have some family friends that include women of course, but I do not have any social friends that are female that do not fall in the "family friends" category. Any female friend that I have is also a friend of my wife.

I'm not quite sure what the underlined has to do with my post, because that'd be like me saying I have plenty of relationships with homosexual women and do not fall for them because they are not straight and that I have never fallen for a homosexual woman. That doesn't say anything about my ability to fall in love with a co-worker or other female friend that I wouldn't be able to have though.

Is there a possibility that I would fall in love with a co-worker and have to cut off that relationship or maybe even change jobs? Certainly there is - and that could be painful on multiple levels, painful for my wife that it even happened, painful for me for the loss of the friendship, and painful for me for the need to change jobs, and possibly painful for my family for the paycut I might have to take to do it. The fact is that I spend as much if not more time with my co-workers than I do with my wife. I also have to be extremely cautious about how social my relationships with former co-workers become. I have to make sure that if I want to go out to lunch with an old female boss and catch up, I bring along another former co-worker to make sure it is a group setting to minimize chances of something beyond "old co-worker/friend" status forming. I'm not trying to say that's the same, because although a romance can't form with those people, I do have an active relationship which in itself makes it easier. Because I'm head over heels in love with my wife, it makes it a lot more difficult to fall for someone else. Anyways, this is somewhat tangental. I just wanted to point out that just because someone isn't celibate/gay doesn't mean they aren't subject to forbidden romance that can cause deep and serious pain.


You've done well to point out that you are also in an "easier" position or a position of lessened pain because you do have a committed relationship which, I will add, is approved by the Church. That is never a possibility for me.

I'm not asking you to cry me a river, but it would be a bit ridiculous to presume that the challenges we face in the arena of romance are exactly the same. :)
franciscanheart
Posted

In other more on topic news then my post above, democrats in my state just put out bills to legalize same sex marriage and anti-discriminatory laws against LGBT. Kind of the opposite of Arizona. I don't know how far they'll go as our legislature has a significant republican majority though.


What are your thoughts on anti-discrimination laws?
Posted

People tell me I look like a pedophile all the time. But I digress.

 

But yeah, I think comparing homosexuality to pedophilia or bestiality is stupid.

 

I think comparing homosexuality to adultery or masturbation is a better argument because these are non-predatory things among consensual adults that all people may struggle with at some point in their lives. Also, most people do not think masturbation is sinful, and some don't even think adultery is sinful. Just like most/some people do not think homosexuality is sinful.

 

I think the real strategy here should not be comparing homosexuality with anything, but rather, defining where the moral line should be--and if morality is absolute--or if it is relative to each individual's whims and desires. In other words--I think we should stop telling homosexuals how wrong they are, and start showing them the beauty and truth found in the Church.

Posted

somewhat off topic (again, couldn't send a PM) but.. Fran,  I know we don't nearly talk as much as we did in the old days (the whole landscape of phatmass has changed since then, obviously), but I want you to know I still care about you and you are in my prayers. That's all :) God bless you and your Guardian Angel :)

Posted

People tell me I look like a pedophile all the time. But I digress.

 

 

Odd, you look a Pope Francis cartoon to me.

Posted

My main concern for forcing people against their morals to do something or lose their business or job, is what it will lead to. Here where gay marriage has been legal for a bit, marriage commissioners are losing their jobs for refusing to do gay weddings. There are some very vocal advocates here who are trying to get it passed that ministers who won't preform ceremonies for gays lose the right to do weddings for straights too.

I personally think the church should be out of the civil marriage business, so don't go off about that on me.

Posted

Must not hijack thread to promote anarchist agenda.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

I personally think the church should be out of the civil marriage business, so don't go off about that on me.

 

I've thought that is the Church separated itself from the civil side of marriage and concerned itself with the sacramental side. The wedding itself is a Church affair, but the couple needed to go down to the court house or whatever to fill out their civil paperwork, then if divorces did happen it makes it clearer that the sacrament is not tied to the civil function and an annulment would still be needed.
 

Posted

I've thought that is the Church separated itself from the civil side of marriage and concerned itself with the sacramental side. The wedding itself is a Church affair, but the couple needed to go down to the court house or whatever to fill out their civil paperwork, then if divorces did happen it makes it clearer that the sacrament is not tied to the civil function and an annulment would still be needed.
 

 

Priests in our diocese won't witness the sacrament until the government gives them permission.

 

 

franciscanheart
Posted

Priests in our diocese won't witness the sacrament until the government gives them permission.


Same here.
Posted

canon law actually requires them to conduct it in conjunction with civil marriage ceremonies except if there's a reason not to in which case they need the permission of the local ordinary.  of course in some countries the civil law marriage is done at the courthouse apart from the Church, but as canon law envisions it this is not an ideal situation, and even in such situations they are only supposed to sacramentally marry you if you also get the civil marriage.  the Church's current stance strongly prefers that civil and sacramental marriage be intertwined and only allows for them to be disentangled if civil marriage laws are unjust.

 

Can.  1071 §1. Except in a case of necessity, a person is not to assist without the permission of the local ordinary at:

 

2 a marriage which cannot be recognized or celebrated according to the norm of civil law

 

(it is clearly envisioned and encouraged in many places that this means the minister of the sacrament should also simultaneously administer the civil vows as the ideal as far as the Church currently recommends)... 

 

that's just the current state of canon law though, one could certainly make an argument that we ought to split off the civil from the sacramental/canonical marriage and ignore the civil... but the Church does not currently wish to do that and I doubt they will make that leap anytime soon... unless they are forced to do so by laws that require religious ministers to officiate at same sex marriages which I would contend is unlikely to happen in the USA in our lifetime, despite the precedents set in other countries, because our supreme court rigorously applies the 1st amendment in a far more absolute way than most countries apply their freedom of religion clauses.

franciscanheart
Posted

somewhat off topic (again, couldn't send a PM) but.. Fran,  I know we don't nearly talk as much as we did in the old days (the whole landscape of phatmass has changed since then, obviously), but I want you to know I still care about you and you are in my prayers. That's all :) God bless you and your Guardian Angel :)

 

Thanks, Tony. :) Back at ya, friend. (And I've cleared my inbox of like five extra messages in case anyone else tries to PM me. I had a couple conversations start since clearing and it took up all my extra space.)

Posted (edited)

canon law actually requires them to conduct it in conjunction with civil marriage ceremonies except if there's a reason not to in which case they need the permission of the local ordinary.  of course in some countries the civil law marriage is done at the courthouse apart from the Church, but as canon law envisions it this is not an ideal situation, and even in such situations they are only supposed to sacramentally marry you if you also get the civil marriage.  the Church's current stance strongly prefers that civil and sacramental marriage be intertwined and only allows for them to be disentangled if civil marriage laws are unjust.

 

Can.  1071 §1. Except in a case of necessity, a person is not to assist without the permission of the local ordinary at:

 

2 a marriage which cannot be recognized or celebrated according to the norm of civil law

 

(it is clearly envisioned and encouraged in many places that this means the minister of the sacrament should also simultaneously administer the civil vows as the ideal as far as the Church currently recommends)... 

 

that's just the current state of canon law though, one could certainly make an argument that we ought to split off the civil from the sacramental/canonical marriage and ignore the civil... but the Church does not currently wish to do that and I doubt they will make that leap anytime soon... unless they are forced to do so by laws that require religious ministers to officiate at same sex marriages which I would contend is unlikely to happen in the USA in our lifetime, despite the precedents set in other countries, because our supreme court rigorously applies the 1st amendment in a far more absolute way than most countries apply their freedom of religion clauses.

I don't think government granting permission to get married is very civil. It seems extremely uncivil to involve a criminal syndicate in the proceedings.

 

Marriage licensing is an innovation.

Edited by Winchester

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...