Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What You Don't Know Can Hurt You


Recommended Posts

Posted

I have a hard time with this because I see the civil and spiritual / sacramental being two distinct things, separate from each other. I don't know why the courts would refuse to recognize the union of two people of the same sex the way the recognize it of opposite sex. They live and act in that relationship in the same way married heterosexual couples do, including kids. Right now they often have to involve lawyers very early in their relationship to ensure each partner will be allowed certain things in the event of something tragic happening -- including the end of someone's life by natural means.

 

It's a hot topic and I haven't fully formed my own views on it. Currently I do support equal civil rights among all people, regardless of sexual orientation. But I also believe sacramental marriage is different than civil marriage, and should stay separated. If I am wrong for that, I am sure I will know that in time.

 

I feel very similarly.

franciscanheart
Posted

I just want to say props for being gay and still remaining Catholic and obeying the teachings...I used to hold the belief being gay was a choice and as a result never really had much sympathy for christians who were gay...Although now realizing it's not a choice I feel more compassion...If God created me to be attracted to males and not females and then I was told I would go to he'll if I fell in love I don't know what I would do...It might be peace out church...So anyhow keep being strong and a great example of a faithful Catholic...Prayers....

 

Thank you, Josh. Lord knows I've wanted to walk away many times. The Eucharist is my rock.

franciscanheart
Posted

I have a question about a subject that has come up a few times in the past and even right now there is a thread relating to it.

 

Should gay/lesbian people who have committed themselves to a chaste life in order to remain faithful to the church be allowed to be priests, nuns, or religious? Do you think the fact that you are gay would somehow make you less able to fulfill that role in the church?

 

I hope that made sense. Or if I worded it this way: Does being gay make a person unfit for these roles? Even if they are 100% faithful to the church, live a chaste life, etc etc.

 

I would very much appreciate your perspective on this subject! I know what my thoughts are but again, they are not popular.

 

When I was first coming to terms with being gay -- when I really started to be out to myself -- I was very torn. I was discerning religious life and stopped because of this. At one point, I decided to keep discerning, sure that if God wanted me in religious life that I would end up there. But it became very hard to have a fruitful discernment because all I could think of when I would sit to pray was the psychological exam. The questionnaires. The interviews. I was brought to tears thinking of the heartache of being told that I would not be able to be a sister because I have an attraction to women -- an attraction that, at the time, was not particularly overwhelming or distracting. It was awful.

 

I stopped discerning. I decided everything I had felt and seen was wrong, that I'd misinterpreted. I was devastated.

 

It took nearly six years to admit all of that in confession and hear for the first time that my homosexuality did not mean I was not called to religious life. That priest gave me great comfort and encouraged me to talk again to my spiritual director and to ask God for direction. He assured me that if God wanted me unto Himself and I was open to Him, it would be -- no matter what.

 

Do I think it should be something people gloss over and don't ask questions about? No. Because I also convinced myself at one point that every inclination I'd had toward the convent was to mask the inclinations I had toward romantic love for women. It was a real possibility. It took a lot of talking and praying and digging to find out if that was really my truth. So, no, I don't think it should ever be a definitive, at least as it concerns religious life.

 

As far as diocesan priesthood is concerned, I don't know, nor do I assume to know what's best. I've no experience and no real knowledge of that particular vocation, and so I cannot and will not speak on that. I'm sure someone here has more information than I do and would be a better response.

franciscanheart
Posted (edited)

AwE-sOme thinking Crosscut, i wonder, i get what your getting at, can a priest live with another man he loves more than anyone else and has to live with him or visa versa for a nun, but they do that anyway don't they in religious orders. But also 1 of the dictionary meanings of gay means homosexual and i may be wrong but doesn't homosexual have something to do with sexual intercourse with the same sex. Than what is the meaning of sexual intercourse? Get your dictionaries out, lets study some words.

 

Easy:

 

http://lmgtfy.com/?q=definition+of+homosexual

 

Easier:

 

 

ho·mo·sex·u·al
ˌhōməˈsekSHo͞oəl/
adjective
 
  1. (of a person) sexually attracted to people of one's own sex.
     
noun
 
  1. a person who is sexually attracted to people of their own sex.
    synonyms: gay, lesbian; More

 

Edited by franciscanheart
franciscanheart
Posted

 
I think the "you can play straight. We can never play white." line in the rap is more about the inability for black people to blend in with the majority. I know a lot of gay people, and most of them don't act "gay"--whatever that even means. If a gay person walks into a store, they are not treated any differently--if a black person walks into a store, they are followed around to make sure they don't steal anything. I didn't interpret that line as meaning "hiding" at all. 

 

I also feel, similar to how comparing gay people with pedophiles is offensive, comparing the struggles gay people go through with that of black people is offensive. It's not even the same ballpark.

 

You're right: it's completely different. Which is why the rapper shouldn't compare apples to oranges and expect people to not say something. He's basically saying homosexual persons have no right complaining because he's black and they ... OH SHIT WAIT: THEY MIGHT BE BLACK TOO.

 

But you get what I mean.

 

Just because black people struggle in different ways than hispanic people or Catholics or gay people doesn't mean that they are the only ones who know suffering and the only ones who get to stand up and say, "This isn't right."

franciscanheart
Posted

There is a strange curious thing: I know more than one gay persons who are quite racist, who say things against immigration or immigrants and this is something that i find strange and disturbing because I wouldn't expect to hear these things form persons that are often themselves victims of discrimination.

But also I think that this fact shows that a sexual inclination is not so fundamental in determining the character and the ideas of a person.

 

I know a lot of black people who are racist, so.

franciscanheart
Posted

Anyway this is what happened and I can't do anything else but trying with all my efforts to avoid, recognize and eventually prevent this happening to other people.

 

I am so sorry. That is so tragic.

franciscanheart
Posted

You're right: it's completely different. Which is why the rapper shouldn't compare apples to oranges and expect people to not say something. He's basically saying homosexual persons have no right complaining because he's black and they ... OH poo WAIT: THEY MIGHT BE BLACK TOO.

 

But you get what I mean.

 

Just because black people struggle in different ways than hispanic people or Catholics or gay people doesn't mean that they are the only ones who know suffering and the only ones who get to stand up and say, "This isn't right."

 

Which reminds me: I'm a Hispanic, lesbian, Catholic woman. Do I need to count all the minority groups for you? ;)

Posted

to be fair, the song is a parody of Macklemore's same love where he makes the comparison between black civil rights struggles and fights over homosexual civil rights... but macklemore's comparison is just between those two struggles to be treated fairly and not discriminated against or hated.  the response where this rapper turns it into a "who is persecuted worse" contest I think was rather inappropriate and inaccurate.  As I mentioned, gay people can often experience hate and discrimination from the people closest to them, like their families, etc, and are often psychologically abused to the point of suicide... so while you might say black people have it worse for being easily recognizable, there are entirely different problems that can make gay people's struggles different, and in some ways worse even if they're not easily recognizable in public like skin color can be.  it's not a perfect analogy, in some ways the one group has it worse and in other ways the other group has it worse... both have definite problems that need to be addressed from a standpoint of civil rights and not allowing discrimination, which is the point of Macklemore's comparison... though of course he uses it to argue gay marriage as a civil right, so there is that, but there are other things gay people deal with for which the comparison to a civil rights issue are definitely apt.

Posted

I know a lot of black people who are racist, so.

 

I know. I wasn't implying anything by the way, only that I find this disturbing, as I don't like racism, and so that with these particualr persons I can't feel much empathy, due to their racist ideas, when and if, for example, they talk about their problems in this society related to their condition.

Posted

When I was first coming to terms with being gay -- when I really started to be out to myself -- I was very torn. I was discerning religious life and stopped because of this. At one point, I decided to keep discerning, sure that if God wanted me in religious life that I would end up there. But it became very hard to have a fruitful discernment because all I could think of when I would sit to pray was the psychological exam. The questionnaires. The interviews. I was brought to tears thinking of the heartache of being told that I would not be able to be a sister because I have an attraction to women -- an attraction that, at the time, was not particularly overwhelming or distracting. It was awful.

 

I stopped discerning. I decided everything I had felt and seen was wrong, that I'd misinterpreted. I was devastated.

 

It took nearly six years to admit all of that in confession and hear for the first time that my homosexuality did not mean I was not called to religious life. That priest gave me great comfort and encouraged me to talk again to my spiritual director and to ask God for direction. He assured me that if God wanted me unto Himself and I was open to Him, it would be -- no matter what.

 

Do I think it should be something people gloss over and don't ask questions about? No. Because I also convinced myself at one point that every inclination I'd had toward the convent was to mask the inclinations I had toward romantic love for women. It was a real possibility. It took a lot of talking and praying and digging to find out if that was really my truth. So, no, I don't think it should ever be a definitive, at least as it concerns religious life.

 

As far as diocesan priesthood is concerned, I don't know, nor do I assume to know what's best. I've no experience and no real knowledge of that particular vocation, and so I cannot and will not speak on that. I'm sure someone here has more information than I do and would be a better response.

 

I imagine all this should have been very difficult for you and I really admire your courage and the fact that you are still in the Church and faithful and a good witness with your experience, and also that you have the courage to tell all these very private and important things here. I am very sorry for your vocation but i don't think it is an impossible life for you. Of course it depends also on you,, on how you would feel living with other women, on how happy you could be. Honestly, I don't think you should have doubts on the fact that you wouldn't be able to be a sister only because you have this attraction. At least, in my opinion, I see you very mature to take a decision with all the seriousness involved. Another thing is if you fear you could suffer in a way that could bring to you too much stress. But I don't think you should completely close this door only due to fear.

PhuturePriest
Posted

to be fair, the song is a parody of Macklemore's same love where he makes the comparison between black civil rights struggles and fights over homosexual civil rights... but macklemore's comparison is just between those two struggles to be treated fairly and not discriminated against or hated.  the response where this rapper turns it into a "who is persecuted worse" contest I think was rather inappropriate and inaccurate.  As I mentioned, gay people can often experience hate and discrimination from the people closest to them, like their families, etc, and are often psychologically abused to the point of suicide... so while you might say black people have it worse for being easily recognizable, there are entirely different problems that can make gay people's struggles different, and in some ways worse even if they're not easily recognizable in public like skin color can be.  it's not a perfect analogy, in some ways the one group has it worse and in other ways the other group has it worse... both have definite problems that need to be addressed from a standpoint of civil rights and not allowing discrimination, which is the point of Macklemore's comparison... though of course he uses it to argue gay marriage as a civil right, so there is that, but there are other things gay people deal with for which the comparison to a civil rights issue are definitely apt.

 

They're discriminated against in different ways. For instance, I've never heard of a black man being bullied so much in school because of his ancestry that he ended up killing himself (NOT saying that's never happened, but just that I've never heard about that happening). At the same time, gay people have never been enslaved (To my knowledge). But as I said before, I don't agree with making a contest of who's had it worse. It's unhealthy and it distracts from actually fixing the problem.

Posted

They're discriminated against in different ways. For instance, I've never heard of a black man being bullied so much in school because of his ancestry that he ended up killing himself (NOT saying that's never happened, but just that I've never heard about that happening). At the same time, gay people have never been enslaved (To my knowledge). But as I said before, I don't agree with making a contest of who's had it worse. It's unhealthy and it distracts from actually fixing the problem.

They were, however, thrown into concentration camps by the German national socialists.

PhuturePriest
Posted

They were, however, thrown into concentration camps by the German national socialists.

 

Valid point.

The Bus Station
Posted (edited)

I just want to reiterate what FH said about SSA and the religious life.  I've been told firsthand by religious from different orders that, in many communities, SSA applicants are dealt with on an individual basis.  I should note that these religious acquaintances of mine are from legit orthodox communities.

 

So yes, you can haz SSA and religious vocationz w00t.

Edited by The Bus Station
PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Franciscan Heart, you may or may not find this of interest, but lately Vox Clamantis (owner of Fish Easters) started a thread on the experience of homosexuals that are also traditional Catholics. Some VERY interesting posts!

 

http://catholicforum.fisheaters.com/index.php/topic,3463606.0.html

 

I thought these posts in particular were very insightful:

 

 

I think that understanding that since same-sex attraction is a disorder, it's not easy to categorize and treat SSA as a "cookie cutter" temptation.  For example, what may be a clear occasion of sin for one homosexual person may be completely neutral, or even spiritually helpful, for another.  The example, for me, is community life.  Some have raised the point with me before, when saying that I would like to live in a religious community, that being in the constant company of men would be a temptation...what they don't understand, though, is that for me, building strong, fraternal, chaste relationships with other men is helpful in the struggle against sin.  For some, though, this may not be the case.  SSA is like any other disorder--it may wax and wane, be stronger for some than others, and manifest itself in various ways.  Not everyone who is "depressed" manifests the same symptoms, or endures the same experiences.  Not everyone who suffers from, I don't know, high blood pressure, or diabetes experiences the same things.

 

I can agree with your experience. When I build healthy male friendships, with good men, I feel little to no sextual desire towards them.

 

It's very fascinating that he says community life helps him fight against temptations. It definitely makes you question the commonly held belief that gay men/women can't be in religious communities because of the overwhelming temptations they'll endure.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Which reminds me: I'm a Hispanic, lesbian, Catholic woman. Do I need to count all the minority groups for you? ;)

 

You're Hispanic!?!? Dude. Could have told me that before I invested so much time and energy into our relationship.

franciscanheart
Posted

You're Hispanic!?!? Dude. Could have told me that before I invested so much time and energy into our relationship.


I like playing white. :ohno: I know: I should be ashamed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...