Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What You Don't Know Can Hurt You


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

Yeah, but that's not limited to chaste homosexuals and celibates though. The same falls true for married men and women who are in a struggling marriage and find themselves falling for someone else, and even more true for those who get married and 5 years down the road end up in an abusive relationship where they have to divorce for the sake of their children and health but maybe don't qualify for an annulment. I don't think the idea of being in a position where you could fall for someone and have it be reciprocated is limited to some small select group of people.


I think you missed one of the connections or posts. The point Al was helping to make was that it was not necessary for a homosexual to be involved in a romantic relationship with someone in order to experience romantic pain. Because the potential of a relationship is never an option for us, falling for someone of our own sex is especially difficult because it can never be fully recognized. Am I making sense? We aren't suggesting that homosexuals are the only ones who experience romantic pain, just saying that we experience pain despite the fact that -- living as chaste, faithful, homosexual Catholics -- we do not experience romantic relationships. (Please tell me if I'm incoherent.)
 
 

I would imagine the thing that makes it harder for those living a chaste homosexual life would be that usually men and women's best friends (aside from a spouse) are the same gender. As a married man I don't go out for a night on the town with the girls, so my social opportunities to fall for someone I can't have are more limited since I'm not attracted to the guys I hang out with. This entire paragraph is speculation though.


I can appreciate where this might be more easily understood by you. But remember that you are thinking with your heterosexual brain in the context of your heterosexual experiences. I imagine you have plenty of relationships with women to whom you are not attracted or with whom you are not inclined to fall in love. I have [i]plenty[/i] of relationships with heterosexual women and do not fall for them. Why? Because they are not gay. I have never once fallen for a straight woman. I may have been enamored. I may have had a "schoolgirl crush" or something resembling it. But it was never serious and never something that really stole my time or attention.

 

Al may have a different experience, but that has been mine and the experience of many of my good friends who are also gay or bi.

 

Unnecessary information but an interesting point: some of my very best friends are gay males. A lot of lesbian women I know have very good gay, male friends. There is something really nice about being gay that allows us a certain freedom to have really intimate relationships with both sexes that, in many heterosexual circles, would otherwise raise a lot of questions.

franciscanheart
Posted

Sounds pretty accurate to me.
 
Interestingly enough I've actually had a chance to watch the news tonight, something I never do (not because I don't want to, it's just the time is always lacking.) So as I ate my dinner with CNN on the whole Arizona Freedom of Religion mandate was being talked about. Of course the whole thing was painted as a bill supporting hate, but they had a gentleman on explaining the context behind the bill. As it happened, a baker and photographer were both sued by gay couples because they were told they did not feel comfortable participating in their (pseudo) marital ceremony. All this bill does is protect such private business owners from involving themselves in something contrary to their conscience. I never understood why someone would fight to force someone offer a service, I mean do you really want a baker to make you a wedding cake against their will? Furthermore, all this is disturbingly close to forcing Churches to "marry" gays. We're really getting to the point where even the Church is not sacrosanct, and I've even heard there are liberal lawyers fighting to amend the bill of rights so that they protect the freedom of "worship" and not religion. A poignant distinction. 
 
Very disturbing how everything is turning out. Hopefully our gay Catholic bothers and sisters will stand up to fight the good fight.


I posted the below a few pages ago. Did you watch any section of these videos? I'd be interested in your responses to Anderson, and what things you would support that came out of the mouth of the bumbling (state) congressman.

 

Here are a couple interesting videos about proposed Arizona legislation for anyone interested in watching / responding / discussing.
 
http://edition.cnn.com/video/api/embed.html#/video/bestoftv/2014/02/24/ac-sen-melvin-defends-az-law-1.cnn
 
(I actually jumped back with wide eyes around minute eight of this first video. There's definitely discussion points here if you're willing to hear them.)
 
http://www.cnn.com/video/api/embed.html#/video/bestoftv/2014/02/24/ac-sen-melvin-defends-az-law-2.cnn

Posted

yeah I've never fallen for a straight guy myself either, straight friends of mine I tend to automatically and easily friendzone with no difficulty... and of course my experience is different because I've been in love with a girl and had many romantic relationships with other girls before too, so while I have on a couple of occasions experienced that romantic pain we're talking about here, having that fact that I'm also attracted to girls does kind of mitigate that for me.  back when I was a bit mixed up and confused and thought I had to really be 100% chaste gay because of my attractions (around the ages of 14-16ish I think was the time period here), I remember those romantic pains were deeply combined with a deep sense of hopelessness... I mean think about it, standard post-breakup reply is "there are plenty of fish in the sea"... I remember thinking along the lines of something like, for me there were no other fish, I was choosing not to take the fish in front of me and also not to look for a new one, no silver lining.  but of course as I developed and understood that many of the struggles I rationalized through some lens of whether my "SSA" could go away or not, it had all just been a kind of shifting fluid sexuality thing (still is fluid from time to time, shifting between Kinsey 2 and 4 I'd say, depending on the circumstances of my life in any given time) and I really settled as definitely attracted to both, then my experience definitely changed and even though there have been occasions of falling for someone, it's much easier for me to be able to let that go.  so I'd guess for those who really are exclusively gay, that experience of hopelessness in the romance department is still a huge part of the pain they experience in seeking to live out chastity.

Posted

I posted the below a few pages ago. Did you watch any section of these videos? I'd be interested in your responses to Anderson, and what things you would support that came out of the mouth of the bumbling (state) congressman.

 

 

I didn't watch the videos and don't really plan on it.  I read the actual amendment to the law which I posted a number of pages back (and which are linked to in the article below.  The law just re-iterates more explicitly the right to religious freedom:

 

(from: http://reason.com/blog/2014/02/21/news-flash-its-already-legal-to-deny-ser)

 

Actually, Arizona’s laws already give businesses the right to discriminate against gays. Sexual orientation is not included in Arizona’s public accommodation laws. Discrimination against gays is actually legal in a lot of places in America still. What Senate Bill 1062 does is essentially tweak the state’s existing freedom of religion laws to say that, no really, people in Arizona have the right to the free exercise of religion. You can read the bill here and see what is being changed in blue text. It’s not very much.

 

I'd suggest reading the whole article as well as the law itself.
 

franciscanheart
Posted

I didn't watch the videos and don't really plan on it.  I read the actual amendment to the law which I posted a number of pages back (and which are linked to in the article below.  The law just re-iterates more explicitly the right to religious freedom:
 
(from: http://reason.com/blog/2014/02/21/news-flash-its-already-legal-to-deny-ser)
 
Actually, Arizona’s laws already give businesses the right to discriminate against gays. Sexual orientation is not included in Arizona’s public accommodation laws. Discrimination against gays is actually legal in a lot of places in America still. What Senate Bill 1062 does is essentially tweak the state’s existing freedom of religion laws to say that, no really, people in Arizona have the right to the free exercise of religion. You can read the bill here and see what is being changed in blue text. It’s not very much.
 
I'd suggest reading the whole article as well as the law itself.

I've read the law and understand what it's doing. I was asking Mortify if he'd seen the videos since he was just commenting on a news story he saw today. Anderson raises a lot of really great points that the congressman is unable to reasonably argue. The preemptive moves they're making are unnecessary based on the fact that they do not have standing laws protecting gay people in any way.
Posted (edited)

I've read the law and understand what it's doing. I was asking Mortify if he'd seen the videos since he was just commenting on a news story he saw today. Anderson raises a lot of really great points that the congressman is unable to reasonably argue. The preemptive moves they're making are unnecessary based on the fact that they do not have standing laws protecting gay people in any way.

 

Which is what the reason.com article says.  Nevertheless, the change to law appears to be benign and reaction to it way out of proportion. 

 

And I didn't mean to interrupt the conversation w/ mortify, just level-setting the issue (at least in my pov) since it's been mentioned a few times before Mortify chimed in.

 

 

Edited by NotreDame
franciscanheart
Posted

Which is what the reason.com article says.  Nevertheless, the change to law appears to be benign and reaction to it way out of proportion.

Can you see, though, where the side who feels attacked and belittled could say the same about the time, money, and energy spent trying to revise this?
Posted

Can you see, though, where the side who feels attacked and belittled could say the same about the time, money, and energy spent trying to revise this?

 

Well, as an orthodox catholic who believes in religious freedom I feel like I am actually on the side that's being attacked and belittled - not just in AZ, but nationally. 

 

And with their neighbors in New Mexico being sued and prosecuted for not wanting to take part in a gay ceremonies I can understand the desire to clarify the law to make it harder for a judge to impose his/her own views absent explicit law (as happened in NM.)

 

And I don't here the other side complaining about time/money/energy wasted.  I hear them complaining about different things.
 

PhuturePriest
Posted

Important question I don't believe has been asked: do you support the legalisation of gay marriage? I'm kind of in the middle on it. In one sense, I absolutely agree that homosexual unions are intrinsically immoral. But I also believe premarital sex and contraception are intrinsically immoral, too. Should those be against the law as well? The idea that gay marriage should be illegal but not premarital sex seems to stem from prejudice to me, but I don't know. I haven't heard an argument for why one should be illegal and not the other.

franciscanheart
Posted

Well, as an orthodox catholic who believes in religious freedom I feel like I am actually on the side that's being attacked and belittled - not just in AZ, but nationally.

And with their neighbors in New Mexico being sued and prosecuted for not wanting to take part in a gay ceremonies I can understand the desire to clarify the law to make it harder for a judge to impose his/her own views absent explicit law (as happened in NM.)

And I don't here the other side complaining about time/money/energy wasted. I hear them complaining about different things.

If you'd listened to or watched the videos, you would have. Also mentioned is that NM has laws protecting gay people in areas that AZ does not. So it's not the same. Anyway, I'm not actually opposed to your thinking re: people being able to deny marriage-related services, so it doesn't much matter. Just wanted Mortify to check it out for more devils-advocate questions / things to think about.
Posted

Peace be with you,

 

Important question I don't believe has been asked: do you support the legalisation of gay marriage? I'm kind of in the middle on it. In one sense, I absolutely agree that homosexual unions are intrinsically immoral. But I also believe premarital sex and contraception are intrinsically immoral, too. Should those be against the law as well? The idea that gay marriage should be illegal but not premarital sex seems to stem from prejudice to me, but I don't know. I haven't heard an argument for why one should be illegal and not the other.

 

FP, I understand we don't live in a perfect system, but we should always strive to have civil law reflect natural and moral law. I think it's a poor argument to say that since there is no penalty for contraception and premarital sex we ought to remove laws that prohibit same sex unions. 

Posted (edited)

I just want to say props for being gay and still remaining Catholic and obeying the teachings...I used to hold the belief being gay was a choice and as a result never really had much sympathy for christians who were gay...Although now realizing it's not a choice I feel more compassion...If God created me to be attracted to males and not females and then I was told I would go to he'll if I fell in love I don't know what I would do...It might be peace out church...So anyhow keep being strong and a great example of a faithful Catholic...Prayers....

Edited by Guest
PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Peace be with you,


FP, I understand we don't live in a perfect system, but we should always strive to have civil law reflect natural and moral law. I think it's a poor argument to say that since there is no penalty for contraception and premarital sex we ought to remove laws that prohibit same sex unions.

But premarital sex is just as intrinsically immoral as sex between those of the same gender. It seeks hypocritical to me to say straight people can sin in whatever way they want, but gay people can't. Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

Peace be with you,

 

If you'd listened to or watched the videos, you would have. Also mentioned is that NM has laws protecting gay people in areas that AZ does not. So it's not the same. Anyway, I'm not actually opposed to your thinking re: people being able to deny marriage-related services, so it doesn't much matter. Just wanted Mortify to check it out for more devils-advocate questions / things to think about.

 

I did not see the clip you mentioned and so I can't comment on it, if I get a chance to watch it I'll make some points about it.

 

I feel there is a polarization being set here. Many of us who were sitting on fence have to choose sides now. I've noticed many articles about the whole gay rights issue, including supposed denial of sacraments, and even television shows portraying normalcy of same sex couples marrying and raising children. It's clear the top of the pyramid is engineering the rest to find homosexuality acceptability and any view prohibiting or limiting it as either backwards or discriminatory. The question is what will happen when the litigation hits the sanctuary, and the Church starts getting sued for refusing to wed same sex couples. Then the stakes will get very interesting. 

Posted

But premarital sex is just as intrinsically immoral as sex between those of the same gender. It seeks hypocritical to me to say straight people can sin in whatever way they want, but gay people can't.

 

It's not an apples to apples comparison.  Just like the government wasn't stopping people from having premarital sex, neither was the gov't stopping gay people from having ceremonies. 

 

Legalizing gay marriage isn't allowing citizens to do something they couldn't do before.  It's forcing governments to take positive action to recognize and enforce contracts that they previously wouldn't have. 

brandelynmarie
Posted

Fran, you are a brave daughter of God. :) Just wanted say that....

Posted
I'm sorry, what? Seriously? Pedophiles? This is exactly the kind of ignorant, hateful poo I can't stand. I'll never apologize for my disgust at someone suggesting I'm like a pedophile. There is a difference between falling in love with another adult person who is mature and evolved and capable of returning love. There is a difference between establishing an adult relationship and connection with another adult and molesting children. Yeah, there's a difference. And it's a big one. I loathe the idea that it's okay to compare the two. And yes, I lack respect for anyone who believes otherwise. Those are the people I will never be able to talk to. I cannot handle it. They disgust me.

 

 

It's probably not the most tactful way to say what he was saying and I veer from bringing up that point because it's usually perceived as offensive as possible (gay people are pretty much pedophiles). There are some people who believe that homosexuality and pedophilia are inextricably connected, and those people I would call ignorant at best perhaps hateful at worst. Let's not deal with them for now.

 

However, I think the point of the comparison is not that the two groups (homosexuals and pedophiles) are both predatory/harmful to others but I think it's to illustrate that just because you have no or little control over your inclinations doesn't make the actions that would flow from these inclinations to be OK. It can be taken as the more hateful "gays are just like pedophiles!!1!" but in this relativistic culture it is usually a more effective analogy because almost everybody thinks having sex with children is morally egregious (unlike other sexual behaviors e.g. polygamy, pre- and extra-marital sex etc) and I think the point is to get people to understand "see, here's a case where you believe being 'born that way' does not excuse a person from pursuing certain sexual ventures, albeit for different reasons). When the statement is not qualified carefully (and even when it is) it's really easy for it to sound really offensive so I would caution someone to throw it as a one-liner on a rap track.

 

 

Also, you are similar to a pedophile in certain ways, but so is everyone else. Depends on what point you're trying to illustrate. I'm a human, so are pedophiles. Pedophilia is a paraphilia and so is having a really intent foot fetish. God is similar to the Devil in that they are both supernatural beings whose intelligence far surpass the smartest homo sapiens. But there are crucial differences between God and the Devil and between being aroused by feet and being aroused by children. Sometimes people focus on differences other times it's the similarities but that shouldn't imply that two things are wholly opposite or that they're one in the same.

 

 

This is not to say you shouldn't be hurt by the comparison. You feel how you feel and that's that. And often times the ignorance and hate behind the comparison is real and not merely perceived, so I get the sensitivity. I wouldn't probably like being compared to a pedophile so often even if it was on legitimate grounds (like say Jane was a pedophile and physically I looked very similar to Jane so everyone was always telling me that "hey you look JUST like Jane zomg"). But I think this rapper dude (who is kinda wack imo) worded his point really terribly especially with the "and you're better how?"

Posted

While I understand the point of it, the whole analogy is ridiculously out of line in so many ways.  Firstly, the "born this way" argument isn't even really the thing homosexuals base anything on.  It's not like if you could convince them they weren't born that way all the sudden Ellen and Portia would break up and Neil Patrick Harris would turn into a real life version of Barney Stinson.  Heck, you could even invent a magic pill that cured them of their attractions and most would likely refuse to take it... that's the whole point of X Men: The Last Stand.

 

Anyway, the analogy fails further.  You could compare anyone who says they can't change something about themselves to a pedophile... "hey man, I don't like asparagus, I can't change, I've tried it many times, I just don't like it".... "then how are you any better than a pedophile?"... "man, I just don't like country music, I can't change no matter how many times I try to listen to it, I can't get into it"... "then how are you any better than a pedophile?"... sure here you're arguing that there's an immoral dimension to it--but that's the argument you have to make, the analogy is totally irrelevant from their perspective.

 

It's an analogy that's tapping into the worst kinds of associations and prejudices, even if it ostensibly denies them.  If you want to have an argument with a homosexual, you have to convince them that there's something wrong about what they do, get into a discussion about natural law and sexual morality, chastity, etc.  don't compare them to a pedophile--they already know why pedophilia is wrong-because minors are not capable of giving true consent and it is therefore inherently a form of rape and abuse.  That's why they hold pedophilia to be wrong... and you have no compelling argument for them that even comes close to an analogy for them about homosexuality.  come up with an argument about that and have that argument... the other thing is pointless, won't convince anyone of anything, and just serve to reinforce bad and baseless prejudices. 

franciscanheart
Posted

Someone hold my earrings. (Yes, they're studs, but mama doesn't fight in Tiffany's.) :annoyed:

Posted

 

However, I think the point of the comparison is not that the two groups (homosexuals and pedophiles) are both predatory/harmful to others but I think it's to illustrate that just because you have no or little control over your inclinations doesn't make the actions that would flow from these inclinations to be OK.

 

 

Then here's an idea: Compare homosexual acts to other acts that don''t involve a predatory act. There are tons. Jacking off, for instance. There's one. But since most people who like to compare homosexual acts to acts of pedophilia probably masturbate like wild monkeys, they're not willing to do that.

 

A truly consensual sexual sin of any sort is not comparable to predatory sexual acts. 

 

I know why people make the comparison because I'm pretty sure I used to, but I was wrong. At some point, I got something resembling a heart. Luckily, no one bashed my throat in with a wiffleball bat, and so I survived to become less of a bastard.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...