Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What You Don't Know Can Hurt You


Recommended Posts

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

Ok Phetus, you took that question a little too literally.  I meant to ask FH, if she felt these same sex attractions as a child growing up?

 

And I was relaying the opinion of a reliable source on the subject as a whole. No harm done.

Edited by The Phetus
franciscanheart
Posted

Ok Phetus, you took that question a little too literally.  I meant to ask FH, if she felt these same sex attractions as a child growing up?

Yes

franciscanheart
Posted

There's a very renowned Catholic speaker who is gay who says he struggles with the idea that people are born gay. Not because it's impossible or somehow theologically problematic, but because he says we don't really know anything we're born with. "Can you remember a time when you couldn't speak? No, but that's because your mind alters reality according to your experiences." I can't remember a time where I didn't have a stammer, but we know for a fact no person is born with one.

 

And I'm not saying any of that to be controversial or hurtful, but just because I heard it today and it was relevant to Freedom's question.

It's also an opinion.

PhuturePriest
Posted

It's also an opinion.

 

One that makes sense. But again, it's possible that people are born gay. There's just no solid proof of it as of yet.

franciscanheart
Posted


One that makes sense. But again, it's possible that people are born gay. There's just no solid proof of it as of yet.

 

It makes sense to you. It's also your opinion.

 

 

And just for the record, being gay doesn't make you a "reliable source" on all things gay. (Good luck in college!)  :like:

PhuturePriest
Posted

It makes sense to you. It's also your opinion.

 

 

And just for the record, being gay doesn't make you a "reliable source" on all things gay. (Good luck in college!)  :like:

 

No, but he has studied the science of it and is a renowned speaker. Show me scientific proof, and I'll believe you. As of yet, there is nothing. But again, it really doesn't matter. It's not like it's theologically problematic if people are born gay or not, so why the hostility?

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Drama-drama

 

Saddle up. You started it. lol

PhuturePriest
Posted

Saddle up. You started it. lol

 

As per usual, it is all Freedom's fault.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

As per usual, it is all Freedom's fault.

 

Sometimes it's wise to bite your tongue and see how conversations play out. I don't often find it useful to tell gay people how they likely did or did not (for lack of a better term) develop their gayness. I doubt Franny would have responded with "Oh, I was definitely born gay." She's always quite bluntly honest and probably would have responded with phrasing similar to how the question was rephrased "I began experiencing these attractions as a  child" or some such thing.

 

Then again, maybe I just know Franny well enough to know how she's likely to respond and I have unrealistic expectations of how other people should conduct conversations.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Sometimes it's wise to bite your tongue and see how conversations play out. I don't often find it useful to tell gay people how they likely did or did not (for lack of a better term) develop their gayness. I doubt Franny would have responded with "Oh, I was definitely born gay." She's always quite bluntly honest and probably would have responded with phrasing similar to how the question was rephrased "I began experiencing these attractions as a  child" or some such thing.

 

Then again, maybe I just know Franny well enough to know how she's likely to respond and I have unrealistic expectations of how other people should conduct conversations.

 

I didn't say she did or didn't, I was just reminded of what one person said about it and wanted to interject it into the conversation. I wasn't answering for Frannie.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I didn't say she did or didn't, I was just reminded of what one person said about it and wanted to interject it into the conversation. I wasn't answering for Frannie.

 

No, you didn't explicitly say that and I didn't mean to indicate that you had. It just kind of comes across that way when person A asks person B a question and person C says "person V thinks it's not likely."  What person V thinks isn't really relevant to person B's personal experiences. I don't particularly buy the "born this way" thing hook, line, and sinker, but frankly I can't know for fact that it's never happened and in my experience, in most cases, it's rather a fruitless line of discussion because whether or not they were born that way they are still gay. How it came to be changes nothing. I'm more interested in helping Franny (and others) to live as genuinely and purely as they can, to be as holy as they can, and support them when they need it.

Vincent Vega
Posted

No, but he has studied the science of it and is a renowned speaker. Show me scientific proof, and I'll believe you. As of yet, there is nothing. But again, it really doesn't matter. It's not like it's theologically problematic if people are born gay or not, so why the hostility?

 

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14146-gay-brains-structured-like-those-of-the-opposite-sex.html#.U_4s_rxdUWE

 

Of course, they probably wouldn't have been so hasty to publish their findings if they had known that a renowned RC apologist speaker would dissent.

PhuturePriest
Posted

http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn14146-gay-brains-structured-like-those-of-the-opposite-sex.html#.U_4s_rxdUWE

 

Of course, they probably wouldn't have been so hasty to publish their findings if they had known that a renowned RC apologist speaker would dissent.

 

Yes, this seems incredibly compelling, except the study itself admits it might happen in the womb or in early infancy. They're not certain.

 

But again, it doesn't really matter, as I have said since my very first post.

Posted

 Just thinking out loud here: I don't think that anyone is born gay because I don't think babies have sexual attractions.

Posted

Well, defining attraction is difficult. Even if a child is unable to express certain sexual desires, their genetic code is still there. Maybe it requires puberty to surface? Although some gay people say they have known that aspect about themselves since they were old enough to think. 

 

But it is genetic; everything* is genetic. Therefore you are born with it.

 

*ok maybe not everything ...like breaking your leg isnt genetic. Or other sorts of things that happen later.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I still really, really don't think this line of speculation is helpful or beneficial.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I still really, really don't think this line of speculation is helpful or beneficial.

 

[mod]Inappropriate content. - dUSt[/mod]

Edited by dUSt

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...