Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Introducing The Phorum Purge. Environment Cleanup.


Recommended Posts

Posted

My biggest problem has always been those who call themselves Catholic while blatantly denying the Church teaches a certain thing or saying that the Church is wrong to teach a certain thing. Either get with the program, or move along.

Posted (edited)

You're Catholic? I've read some of your posts which did not seem like you were Catholic.

 

I dont feel that I deserve as being marked as phishy. I have been in contact with people via private message as I attempt to decipher my faith. I have met people who have been good resources of information. 

I will happily accept beign marked as a Non-Catholic but I do not understand what about my presence is deserving of Phishy. 

 

If that is ultimately what the response is to my questions in regards to my faith then i guess Ill just go elsewhere for help since people are not willing on this forum. 

 

From what I understand the last person who was marked phishy and subsequently banned was because we was being kind of gross. 

Edited by CrossCuT
Anastasia13
Posted (edited)

Agree with me being more active.

 

Reality dictates otherwise.

 

So, option 1: Shut down the phorum.

Option 2: Permanently ban any members who consistently take up too much of my time.

Option 3: Come up with creatively brilliant ideas that allow disruptive members to continue posting on phatmass without outright banning them.

I am ok with 2 or 3. 1 would be sad. I have learned a lot here. :|

 

If you are going for 3, you might temporarily require moderation for disruptive members before their posts show. I don't know if this is the same board programming (non-techie here), but there are some boards I have started on where moderators have to approve each of someone's first X number posts before they show on the board. This might be a good training opportunity for disruptive members, but because of the work involved, might require taking on a couple new mods, maybe start with 10 or 20 posts like that?

 

Or temporary ban, like where they can't post for 2 weeks or a month but can come back, like a cooling off period or time-out. Another board I have been on for years has done this.

Edited by Light and Truth
Posted

I'm going out on a limb here ... but I'm going to defend dUSt's actions.

 

a) The report button is there for use.  And yes -- the biggest issue is that when a thread is going beserk it needs to be used, even if it means getting 20-30-40 reports on a single thread.

b) Assuming that people prayed about using the purge form ... I don't see it as clickish (at least -- I am hoping and praying that it isn't the case).

c) Right now it looks like it could be used as a temporary "confinement"  area.  And that's good ... i.e. if a person's actions changes then great.  They come out, and if they follow the rules voila -- no further problems.

d) The purge area is awesome too -- it would give an area that if a thread goes ballistic (more than a Debate Table) for whatever reason, the mods now can toss it in there, and if someone is causing too much of a disruption then put the person there too.  Then now the drama/whatever-you-want-to-call it is limited to this purge board.  And the board becomes a free-for-all.  Heh -- the report button shouldn't apply in there.

 

As a mod (I can say this now) ... it is quite hard.  If you make a decision that a whole bunch of people don't agree with, you can get slammed PUBLICALLY (slamming a mod privately may be a bit better btw).  Yet -- decisions need to be made based on the phorum rules and conscience (I mean -- it is a Catholic phorum).   Vocation Station rules are clear cut.  Other areas are not. 

 

 

 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Creative suggestion: keep the Purge group, change what it entails.
Disruptive members require mod approval for every post during their purge period. A week, a month, whatever. Empower the mods to take care of it without your input, then hold them accountable for its consistent implementation and enforcement.
Allows continued albeit reduced posting. Shifts responsibility to moderation instead of you. Perhaps add a couple mods to handle the increased workload.

franciscanheart
Posted

Agree with me being more active.

 

Reality dictates otherwise.

 

So, option 1: Shut down the phorum.

Option 2: Permanently ban any members who consistently take up too much of my time.

Option 3: Come up with creatively brilliant ideas that allow disruptive members to continue posting on phatmass without outright banning them.

 

We've discussed option two in the past. I think it's probably the best way to go seeing as option three is less than likely to become a reality... unless you re-institute purge-atory.

Anastasia13
Posted

I dont feel that I deserve as being marked as phishy. I have been in contact with people via private message as I attempt to decipher my faith. I have met people who have been good resources of information. 

I will happily accept beign marked as a Non-Catholic but I do not understand what about my presence is deserving of Phishy. 

 

If that is ultimately what the response is to my questions in regards to my faith then i guess Ill just go elsewhere for help since people are not willing on this forum. 

 

From what I understand the last person who was marked phishy and subsequently banned was because we was being kind of gross. 

I think we are OK with her being non-Catholic as long as she does not say she is Catholic.

Posted

... ok so the purge area is gone.  Maybe, just maybe put a "free-for-all" area on the phorum where ballistic threads can go.  And --- if someone's posts keep forcing a thread into the free-for-all then maybe that's a sign that the person needs to be banned.

 

I also think increasing # of mods is a good idea.  Hopefully you can find people who are willing to martyr themselves for the good of all :).

 

And well -- everyone (everyone) needs to respect the mods.  Period.  No Winchester line here.  Use PM and don't slam a mod publically.  That can be quite hurtful, and the mods are humans (even the ones with the thickest skins can get hurt).

 

Finally -- I do think that if there are Church Militants that are not acting as Church Militants (it is fine to joke around, but to be mean towards people or lewd is not) they should be demoted.  Representing the Church is not just with respect to teaching, it is how life is lived, right?

 

Posted

We've discussed option two in the past. I think it's probably the best way to go seeing as option three is less than likely to become a reality... unless you re-institute purge-atory.

I vote for Phurgatory status. I've been here a long time and went from Catholic to atheist to weves. I've been suspended for posts and attitudes that were worse than questioning. People sometimes go through phases. Phurgatory status is a wake up call to think about what you profess and believe while still allowing them to participate to some degree here. It also gives readers a caution when considering what others post. Not everyone who visits are mature adults. Dust has to accommodate a variety of persons while considering what he is morally libel in allowing to occur in a medium he makes possible.
veritasluxmea
Posted

I agree with the purge board, or a modified form of it, as long as reasons are given. 

Credo in Deum
Posted

... ok so the purge area is gone. Maybe, just maybe put a "free-for-all" area on the phorum where ballistic threads can go. And --- if someone's posts keep forcing a thread into the free-for-all then maybe that's a sign that the person needs to be banned.

I also think increasing # of mods is a good idea. Hopefully you can find people who are willing to martyr themselves for the good of all :).

And well -- everyone (everyone) needs to respect the mods. Period. No Winchester line here. Use PM and don't slam a mod publically. That can be quite hurtful, and the mods are humans (even the ones with the thickest skins can get hurt).

Finally -- I do think that if there are Church Militants that are not acting as Church Militants (it is fine to joke around, but to be mean towards people or lewd is not) they should be demoted. Representing the Church is not just with respect to teaching, it is how life is lived, right?



I'll be a Mod and gladly throw others to be martyred. ;)
Posted (edited)

You people don't seem to understand me. You keep saying stuff like, "just deal with the people causing problems".

 

I don't know who is causing problems. Believe it or not, I rarely get a report about a member being disruptive, but I can't count the number of times I've heard "I'm leaving phatmass because of certain members".

 

OK, that is not helpful to me. If I don't know who these mystery people driving everyone away are, I can't rightfully deal with them.

 

So, I created a form. It's getting used. Lots of familiar names on it. Some of these people are staples of the phatmass community. Some names have surprised me. 

 

Whatever.

 

edit: never mind. I can find a better way of saying that. 

Edited by Amppax
Posted

That's fair. But I still think this is an incredibly poor way to deal with the problem. Why don't we just do it all out in the open, and work through our problems like adults? I'm honestly not being snarky, or at least I'm not trying to be. But this whole privately report people we think are toxic to the community and then ban them... I'm just afraid that this solution could really mess up the community we currently have. I've realized over my time here that there is a certain culture to this forum, and it takes some time to adjust to it. When I was first here, some things really bothered me, and I reacted poorly in a few situations. I called out people that didn't need to be called out, but who I thought did because of their style of communication. 
 
It comes down to this: internet message boards are a flawed way of communication, and one which takes time to understand. And each person communicates differently, so it's not even like there's a universal internet message board way of communicating. You just need to spend enough time here to understand how people communicate, what their history is with other posters. If you come in and think you understand everything, you could be pretty upset. And something like this could cause lots of people to get banned, without a proper understanding of the situation. 
 
I just hope this doesn't break up what I've come to love about this place. :(

You are so 2000 late.
Posted

wait wait wait wait .... "m o d s" changed to minions of death?!?!?!?

 

THAT IS COOL!

 

rotfl

Posted (edited)

Hey (former)Boss (aka dUSt):

 

So ... did ya change "Regulator of Phatmassers" to "Minion of Death" yet?   Hmmm?  Or "Vice Enforcer" (and have Phorum Boss change to "The Enforcer").

Edited by cmaD2006
Posted

Ah brillant minds take a few more minutes to hash it out.

 

dUSt -- the Silencer

m o d s -- Enforcers

 

... can be vice versa, but since dUSt can ban, the "Silencer" seems more appropriate.

Credo in Deum
Posted

You can always have dUSt be "The Godfather" and the mods can have henchmen names. People who are Phishy can be known as Fredo's.

OnlySunshine
Posted

All the m o d s are guys.  Did anyone else notice that?  :|

Credo in Deum
Posted (edited)

It's a new thing? Patriarchs and such.

Well maybe not that new.

Edited by Credo in Deum
OnlySunshine
Posted

It's a. New thing. Patriarchs and such.

 

:hehe2:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...