dUSt Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 The church should just outsource annulments > http://www.catholicannulment.us :lies:
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 Thank you. Can scandal be given if the one who creates 'scandal' is stating something quite right and truthful? What I anyway can see taking place in The Church is something that has existed for many years indeed and worsens, and that is the lack of formation of laity. We laity can be like windmills generally speaking, we can turn(or be led astray) by the slightest of breezes and at times without reference to how sound that breeze might be, sometimes it is just gossip-related type matters and/or some whim of media sensing sensationalism and headlines without slightest reference to truth. Not at all unusual for media to completely not understand Catholicism, merely likes to present that it does. It sells and especially at times if the headlines are negative. To my way of thought if some rightful and truthful move on the part of The Church (as hierarchy in this instance) leads many to jump to completely incorrect conclusions, then it seems to me that the problem is with those who have "jumped" and there is a pastoral problem needing addressing. Certainly, it seems to me, quite ambiguous terms like "welcoming" needs to be addressed and defining what exactly it does mean in a particular instance.
truthfinder Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Scandal would usually apply to causing others to sin by your own sin; but discussing these situations without necessary tact and temperance may also suffice. Quotes from the catechism: 2284 Scandal is an attitude or behavior which leads another to do evil. the person who gives scandal becomes his neighbor's tempter. He damages virtue and integrity; he may even draw his brother into spiritual death. Scandal is a grave offense if by deed or omission another is deliberately led into a grave offense. 2285 Scandal takes on a particular gravity by reason of the authority of those who cause it or the weakness of those who are scandalized. It prompted our Lord to utter this curse: "Whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a great millstone fastened round his neck and to be drowned in the depth of the sea."85 Scandal is grave when given by those who by nature or office are obliged to teach and educate others. Jesus reproaches the scribes and Pharisees on this account: he likens them to wolves in sheep's clothing.86 2286 Scandal can be provoked by laws or institutions, by fashion or opinion.
Maggyie Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Someone explain to me. I'm confused I guess. Your friend who is coming back to the church but who is in an adulterous second "marriage" comes to you. He wants to take holy communion, but he has no intention of stopping sexual relations with his "wife." What do you, an orthodox Catholic, tell him? Don't do it, it's sacreligious? That USED to be what "good Catholics" believed. I believe there were apologetics resources on this very website that explain this in detail. What will we do with that? Discreetly delete it? Think of all the updated materials the professional Catholics of the world will be able to sell. Do you think they will defend the new teaching (er discipline) with as much enthusiasm as they did its EXACT opposite? You betcha. Do you tell your friend the truth? You're waiting for your bishop to decide if it's a mortal sin or not? Maybe it is, maybe not. Makes a lot of sense right? So, people who have sex outside of marriage get a pass if they're legally married to their sex partner. Their sin doesn't count as one that needs to be stopped prior to holy communion. It's a special sin. Really? Just them? What about gay couples who are married civilly? What about people who masturbate or steal cars for a living or sell drugs? Which sins count? The situation of the divorced and remarried somehow deserves special consideration because it's "difficult" and a "reality" of the world we live in. Well I've got news for you. EVERY situation is difficult. EVERY sin is a reality. Why do some have to be "tolerated but not accepted" but MY sin isn't tolerated? I'm infertile through no fault of my own, if I want to use ivf to conceive you're going to seriously tell me that sin needs to be confessed beforehand but ongoing public adultery doesn't? Perhaps this will finally quiet those people who believe the Church's teachings are forever. Either the Church has changed its teaching about the nature of sin, the nature of marriage, or the nature of the Eucharist. Comparing this to the change in age for receiving is totally facile. Now perhaps there really won't be any changes but just the fact this is even discussed at the highest levels should give you pause. What else that you firmly believe today isn't so firm and eternal, after all? What else can be changed based on the popular sins of the day? If the answer isn't "none of it" maybe it's "all of it."
truthfinder Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Maggie, as of right now, this hasn't changed one iota. The sin is still a sin, and will be further compounded by sacrilegious communion. All that's changed is that the synod has made it more difficult for us to "instruct the ignorant and admonish the sinner."
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 (edited) Thank you for the definition of scandal, Truthfinder. I do wonder if it is a case of "scandal" per se, or a case of a pastoral problem re formation etc. with laity. What I don't think The Church as hierarchy understands is that generally speaking those in the stress and tumble of daily secular life do not have the time most often to sit and read Church documents and prayerfully ponder over them. They do not have time to research matters they might not understand. Already laity to my limited experience are jumping to incorrect conclusions about what The Church is now teaching on homosexuality and marriages outside The Church and receiving Holy Communion. And in our Sunday homilies, Father still relates The Gospel to daily life - and I am all in favour of this. Why can't Father announce prior to the homily proper re handouts at Mass - and there be a handout at Mass with headlines e.g. "What the Synod is really all about and homosexuality and marriage and receiving Holy Communion". But there is absolutely nothing. Silence completely on the subject as if there was no problem, but there is. It might be different in other parishes and I hope so. Of course, it is a potential that Father is out of touch with what is happening in his parish at least amongst a fair few. That just might be another pastoral problem that needs addressing. _____________ If someone in a second marriage with a valid first marriage spoke to me about going to Holy Communion, I would tell them that this is still very much forbidden in Church Law despite some things that media might be reporting. If someone said that homosexuality was now acceptable in The Church, I would correct their thinking. Edited October 25, 2014 by BarbaraTherese
truthfinder Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Thank you for the definition of scandal, Truthfinder. I do wonder if it is a case of "scandal" per se, or a case of a pastoral problem re formation etc. with laity. What I don't think The Church as hierarchy understands is that generally speaking those in the stress and tumble of daily secular life do not have the time most often to sit and read Church documents and prayerfully ponder over them. They do not have time to research matters they might not understand. Already laity to my limited experience are jumping to incorrect conclusions about what The Church is now teaching on homosexuality and marriages outside The Church and receiving Holy Communion. And in our Sunday homilies, Father still relates The Gospel to daily life - and I am all in favour of this. Why can't Father announce prior to the homily proper re handouts at Mass - and there be a handout at Mass with headlines e.g. "What the Synod is really all about and homosexuality and marriage and receiving Holy Communion". But there is absolutely nothing. Silence completely on the subject as if there was no problem, but there is. It might be different in other parishes and I hope so. Of course, it is a potential that Father is out of touch with what is happening in his parish at least amongst a fair few. That just might be another pastoral problem that needs addressing. _____________ If someone in a second marriage with a valid first marriage spoke to me about going to Holy Communion, I would tell them that this is still very much forbidden in Church Law despite some things that media might be reporting. If someone said that homosexuality was now acceptable in The Church, I would correct their thinking. I'm tending toward using 'scandal' in the more secular notion of the word, but, and this is a big but, the purposeful or tacit acceptance by illegitimate unions is scandalous in the sinful sense according to the catechism because they have lent approval to these people becoming/continuing in sin. Scandal also the catechism states is definitely applicable for those who teach, particularly those who are weak. This would in my mind apply especially to some at the synod and the world today is so weak. It's usually much better to teach things are black and white, and leave the discussion of the grey to the well catechized (those in the heirarchy) and to one's confessor.
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 The Church is organic and alive, a living organism, and growing into the fullness of Truth, which is the Fullness of Christ. http://www.drbo.org/x/d?b=drb&bk=50&ch=14&l=26#x "[26] But the Paraclete, the Holy Ghost, whom the Father will send in my name, he will teach you all things, and bring all things to your mind, whatsoever I shall have said to you." There can be absolutely no growth without change, it is absolutely impossible. All change is not necessarily positive, just as change is not necessarily negative. But if we are growing, then there MUST be change on some level or other. This is not to state change on Faith and Morals - on doctrinal matters ......... that cannot be ever! These are matters of our foundation in Christ. But there are many other levels on which The Church functions and this includes pastoral matters. But many are presuming that The Church is changing or intends to change, about to change, matters of doctrine or dogma - and this is not so, nor any real and reliable indication that it might be so. And there is a sort of hysteria developing, even already developed, on that score........to my mind. If a matter is disciplinary, then I think that the potential is there for disciplinary matters to change. This is not at all to state that disciplinary matters will change. Just as we were told that celibacy for the priesthood was a disciplinary matter that will never change. Change can present a threat to some and their sense of security, meaning that their investment is possibly not in Christ and His Promise that He would be with His Church until the end of time and not to fear on that score. We all need to wait until Pope Francis makes his statements (probably some sort of Apostolic Exhortation or similar document) after the final sitting of the Synod in 2015 and their recommendations to him. We have a fairly long road to go yet until that point, and a roller coaster it will be especially where media is concerned. They have been gifted a potential for more sensationalism re Catholicism.
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 The Church has not changed moral matters relating to invalid marriages, homosexuality and on who can and cannot receive Holy Communion - nor is there any really reliable indication that She intends to do so. Certainly matters have been reported by media as matters raised by those attending the Synod. They are only matters raised, if media is reporting accurately, in honest and open discussion as Pope Francis requested. Better, to my mind, to throw this pebble into the pool of Catholic cultural consciousness and prayerfully than to stir up a sort of hysteria amongst the faithful about matters that just do not exist other than in the minds of some arriving at conclusion from media reports of what is being said by those who attended the Synod. They just might be quite accurate reports too - but this does not mean at all that The Church will or is changing on the above matters. I think that those who are jumping to incorrect conclusions in a quite public manner, as Catholic discussion sites are, just might be doing as much damage as some of those who attended the Synod might be by speaking to general media.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Well what it says, or not, from the front is one thing. What concessions it allows and eases in from the side is another. Of course it would need to use theology and play semantics as it goes. But I'd say not to look at what a person, or the church, says alone but look at what it does in practice (or intends to do). When doing both, at least to me, it becomes clear that the church has shifted a notch on its tone of theology over the centuries, despite claims it doesn't by some. I expect the same tactics going forward despite denials by some that this never happens. Thank you for your observations! And I probably should clarify what I posted previously (because sleep is a wonderful, wonderful thing) -- certainly some things will come as a result of the synod. I suppose my concern has to do with people (and the news media) interpreting and carrying out what comes of it and whether or not it will help stem the tide of confusion we seem to be drowning in these days. Though I suppose as the saying goes, "it's better to light a candle than curse the darkness" and it's a sentiment I should keep in mind. St. Pius X, pray for us.
HisChildForever Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 I read a brief snippet that the Synod discussed artificial contraception. One remark sounded conservative and another liberal. Unfortunately I can't remember specific quotes. Does anyone have any details on this?
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 (edited) ...............edit................ It's usually much better to teach things are black and white, and leave the discussion of the grey to the well catechized (those in the heirarchy) and to one's confessor. I am all for absolutely teaching that things are black and white if that is the truth of the matter. If there are areas of grey then that should be taught too since it is the truth of the matter and certainly, Pope John Paul II in his Apostolic Exhortation "Reconciliation and Penance" went into grey areas. We can be well assured that if The Church proclaimed that things are absolutely black and white, the media (for one only for absolutely sure) would jump right on it and start yelling that it is untrue and that The Church is preaching untruths and yelling about the grey areas. In a way I am in favour of this should it ever occur and most unlikely to totally impossible as more like it. I used to call media "the watchdog of truth" .............. in the long ago now. Certainly, The Church can and does state that areas of grey can be sorted out in the Confessional - but then I for one have received incorrect information in the Confessional. Insofar as I am aware, Father is not infallible in the Confessional, although one can never go astray by in good faith taking up his advice.....another subject. Edited October 25, 2014 by BarbaraTherese
truthfinder Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 I agree with the points you're making; I guess I'm saying that their needs to be a balance. It's not exactly best to tell children about mental reservation; it's a moral teaching which is saved for when they know more. Or else you'll get told lies all the time. Same goes for teachings on marriage or anything else. A balance between the spiritual good of all and the subtle understandings of the rules.
Maggyie Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 Change can present a threat to some and their sense of security, meaning that their investment is possibly not in Christ and His Promise that He would be with His Church until the end of time and not to fear on that score. This is sort of the ultimate trump card, which most recently I've personally seen deployed in abuse situations. Basically whatever Father/Sister/bishop says is right and best, because Veni Creator Spiritus, so shut up. You, the ordinary baptized Christian with only half as much access to the Holy Spirit as these others, just have to fold your hands, close your eyes and dooooo the trust fall. Like this is basically when Babe Ruth said he was going to hit a home run and then followed through. It's a guarantee. Like the warranty on my used car (actual comparisons that have been made to me when questioning some parish politics) Don't raise objections because you're starting to make me think you're disloyal and squirrel-like, with your memory of how we used to do it and what your grandma always believed and what you learned as a child was right and wrong. The grown ups are talking now. Somehow I don't think that's how Christ meant it but hey now my hysteria may be getting to me and addling my brains. If it's a matter of doctrine it can't be changed and the fact it's now on the table to potentially be changed (put there by the pope) should make all sphincters tighten and cold sweats break out upon every brow. If it's a matter of discipline the "guarantee" doesn't apply. Discipline can and has been royally caboosed in the past and certainly will be in the future. Don't get me wrong I'm still going to Mass and using my envelopes (esp the envelopes) but you can't blame me for side eyeing the whole thing.
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 I agree with the points you're making; I guess I'm saying that their needs to be a balance. It's not exactly best to tell children about mental reservation; it's a moral teaching which is saved for when they know more. Or else you'll get told lies all the time. Same goes for teachings on marriage or anything else. A balance between the spiritual good of all and the subtle understandings of the rules. Certainly, a serious moral evil can be presented as grave matter morally. This just might be (MIGHT BE) what some in the Synod may have been reflecting on from a pastoral viewpoint. Invalid marriage, homosexuality and receiving Holy Communion in the state of mortal sin are all subjects of grave matter morally. Mortal sin is another subject of its own in which grave matter features. This is where perhaps many in-the-pew ordinary quite adult Catholics can misunderstand in that grave matter to them is immediately mortal sin and without any further qualification whatsoever. Teaching children is a very delicate and sometimes 'sweat of the brow and seat of the pants' type of matter indeed - and they need to be informed on each level that hopefully they can grasp without complicating things - despite which, it can be amazing just how children can complicate what one had thought was quite simply presented and a straightforward matter. I have two now adult and independent sons.
BarbTherese Posted October 25, 2014 Author Posted October 25, 2014 This is sort of the ultimate trump card, which most recently I've personally seen deployed in abuse situations. Basically whatever Father/Sister/bishop says is right and best, because Veni Creator Spiritus, so shut up. You, the ordinary baptized Christian with only half as much access to the Holy Spirit as these others, just have to fold your hands, close your eyes and dooooo the trust fall. Like this is basically when Babe Ruth said he was going to hit a home run and then followed through. It's a guarantee. Like the warranty on my used car (actual comparisons that have been made to me when questioning some parish politics) Don't raise objections because you're starting to make me think you're disloyal and squirrel-like, with your memory of how we used to do it and what your grandma always believed and what you learned as a child was right and wrong. The grown ups are talking now. Somehow I don't think that's how Christ meant it but hey now my hysteria may be getting to me and addling my brains. If it's a matter of doctrine it can't be changed and the fact it's now on the table to potentially be changed (put there by the pope) should make all sphincters tighten and cold sweats break out upon every brow. If it's a matter of discipline the "guarantee" doesn't apply. Discipline can and has been royally caboosed in the past and certainly will be in the future. Don't get me wrong I'm still going to Mass and using my envelopes (esp the envelopes) but you can't blame me for side eyeing the whole thing. LOL :) Amazing conclusions.
Lilllabettt Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 This is sort of the ultimate trump card, which most recently I've personally seen deployed in abuse situations. Basically whatever Father/Sister/bishop says is right and best, because Veni Creator Spiritus, so shut up. You, the ordinary baptized Christian with only half as much access to the Holy Spirit as these others, just have to fold your hands, close your eyes and dooooo the trust fall. Like this is basically when Babe Ruth said he was going to hit a home run and then followed through. It's a guarantee. Like the warranty on my used car (actual comparisons that have been made to me when questioning some parish politics) Don't raise objections because you're starting to make me think you're disloyal and squirrel-like, with your memory of how we used to do it and what your grandma always believed and what you learned as a child was right and wrong. The grown ups are talking now. Somehow I don't think that's how Christ meant it but hey now my hysteria may be getting to me and addling my brains. If it's a matter of doctrine it can't be changed and the fact it's now on the table to potentially be changed (put there by the pope) should make all sphincters tighten and cold sweats break out upon every brow. If it's a matter of discipline the "guarantee" doesn't apply. Discipline can and has been royally caboosed in the past and certainly will be in the future. Don't get me wrong I'm still going to Mass and using my envelopes (esp the envelopes) but you can't blame me for side eyeing the whole thing. girrrrrrlllllll you on a roll. all thats missing is a set of well-timed finger snaps.
CatherineM Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 From my experience, a truly sacramental marriage NEVER ends in divorce. Make annulments free, make them less complicated, and put ten times as many people on the job in the tribunal to speed up the process, and this problem disappears. Have someone in each parish who handles the process like we do with baptism or confirmation. Take the stigma of failure out if it as if it is a regular process of the parish.
dUSt Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 What if the Church said: - Your second marriage was invalid and a mortal sin - Confess, repent -- that sin is forgiven - Now, as for "living in sin" -- for the sake of the healthy family and children, this is somewhat out of your control at this point, therefore, not a mortal sin In other words, the sin has taken place already. Confess, repent, that is done. Now you are at a completely different place in your life and any sin from this point on must be judged based on your current situation. Is that changing doctrine? Legit question. I personally think the above situation is dangerous as it opens up possibilities of all kinds talk, like, gay couples who've already adopted children, etc. But seriously, what if a gay couple with children really do want to come back to the Church and start living a faithful Catholic lifestyle? Even if they do "live as brothers or sisters", how would them receiving communion be perceived? Isn't it impossible for them not to cause scandal--therefore, impossible for two people who find themselves in that situation to be in full communion with the church?
dUSt Posted October 25, 2014 Posted October 25, 2014 From my experience, a truly sacramental marriage NEVER ends in divorce. Make annulments free, make them less complicated, and put ten times as many people on the job in the tribunal to speed up the process, and this problem disappears. Have someone in each parish who handles the process like we do with baptism or confirmation. Take the stigma of failure out if it as if it is a regular process of the parish. What about eliminating the tribunal all together? Each parish has a dedicated priest that handles annulments. After a few hours of talking, a properly trained priest would know whether or not a valid marriage occurred. You change the annulment process from forms and waiting to an actual face-to-face session that takes a day and probably has about 10x more spiritual benefit.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now