Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do you believe in freedom of worship?


Do you believe in freedom of worship as described in Libertas?  

11 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Futurepriest tells me he clicked on yes, but meant to click no. Perhaps the forum software still allows moderators or administrators to change voting numbers?

@dUSt, @Credo in Deum?

Posted

​Then you have no moral leaders period, including yourself.

What do you mean by moral leader?  Someone to tell me what is moral or not?  Religious claims are not the sole or epitome of morality.  There are too many competing claims by religions with too wide of a variety of behaviors.  

Nihil Obstat
Posted

What do you mean by moral leader?  Someone to tell me what is moral or not?  Religious claims are not the sole or epitome of morality.  There are too many competing claims by religions with too wide of a variety of behaviors.  

What do *you* mean by moral leader? You said it first. :)

veritasluxmea
Posted

I think we should just not have any religion.

​

ok john lennon

​The ironic thing is, John Lennon was religious. He was into Buddhism and New-Age spirituality later on in life. Basically, he just didn't like Christianity- hence the following quote from him: "Christianity will go. It will vanish and shrink. I needn't argue with that; I'm right and I will be proved right. We're [the Beatles] more popular than Jesus now; I don't know which will go first - rock and roll or Christianity." 

Posted

What do *you* mean by moral leader? You said it first. :)

Oh.  Apparently you were just being nonsensical in your original response.

 

 

 

Credo in Deum
Posted

Futurepriest tells me he clicked on yes, but meant to click no. Perhaps the forum software still allows moderators or administrators to change voting numbers?

@dUSt, @Credo in Deum?

Sorry, Nihil.  I haven't been able to find a way to change the voting numbers. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Oh.  Apparently you were just being nonsensical in your original response.

 

 

 

I am interested in discussion here. Not so much in cheap platitudes.

Frankly I am more interested in opinions from Catholics. Your own positions are often interesting though.

Posted

I am interested in discussion here. Not so much in cheap platitudes.

Frankly I am more interested in opinions from Catholics. Your own positions are often interesting though.

My original post was an observational comment in reference to your comment on the fact the Church has a smaller role in society.   The Church once held what you desired.  The profile, authority, and power in society.   Do you really only blame the lay populace for its current marginalization?

 

and judging by your poll choices, I imagined non-Catholics were welcomed to opine.   "Sorry" if it's unpleasant. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

My original post was an observational comment in reference to your comment on the fact the Church has a smaller role in society.   The Church once held what you desired.  The profile, authority, and power in society.   Do you really only blame the lay populace for its current marginalization?

 

and judging by your poll choices, I imagined non-Catholics were welcomed to opine.   "Sorry" if it's unpleasant. 

Welcome, sure. Am I interested? Occasionally. Your opinions yes. Crosscut's, today, not really.

Anyway,

I do not think I said the laypeople at large are to blame. I some sense certainly we are, but exclusively, I do not think so.

truthfinder
Posted

Wow, it looks like I've got hours worth of posts to catch up on.  

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Wow, it looks like I've got hours worth of posts to catch up on.  

Yes. Please read the entirety of Leo XIII's writing and then summarize it for me in a paper of 7000-14000 words, accompanied by a paper of around 4000 words describing the political climate of his time.

Then the history thing.

 

Kthxbai. I look forward to reading it tomorrow.

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

Futurepriest tells me he clicked on yes, but meant to click no. Perhaps the forum software still allows moderators or administrators to change voting numbers?

@dUSt, @Credo in Deum?

​Having to live with his original answer can be FP's "penance" for logging into Phatmass during Lent. :)  (Next year, FP will know better than to publicly post any Lenten intentions that might be noticed by the likes of us.)  :)

PhuturePriest
Posted

​Having to live with his original answer can be FP's "penance" for logging into Phatmass during Lent. :)  (Next year, FP will know better than to publicly post any Lenten intentions that might be noticed by the likes of us.)  :)

​It's not a sin to do something you gave up. As I haven't been on the internet whatsoever for the past week due to computer problems, I don't think being on Phatmass a little bit is that big of a deal.

However, it is becoming abundantly clear that many members do not want me here whatsoever.

Ancilla Domini
Posted

​However, it is becoming abundantly clear that many members do not want me here whatsoever.

​We're just all paying attention to your lenten resolutions and making sure that you stick to them, because we want you to be holy. We're just such a good pham. :P

IgnatiusofLoyola
Posted

​Having to live with his original answer can be FP's "penance" for logging into Phatmass during Lent. :)  (Next year, FP will know better than to publicly post any Lenten intentions that might be noticed by the likes of us.)  :)

​

​It's not a sin to do something you gave up. As I haven't been on the internet whatsoever for the past week due to computer problems, I don't think being on Phatmass a little bit is that big of a deal.

However, it is becoming abundantly clear that many members do not want me here whatsoever.

​Dude. I was teasing you. :) I thought that was evident from all the smileys in my post, but apparently not. Note for the future: At least in my case, if I am making a post that is intended to be serious (including seriously critical), I do not use a lot of smileys. That said, sometimes you seem to be begging to be teased. :) In another thread, you made a remark about being more popular than Lil Red. Of course, you're going to be teased about a remark like that, because being as popular or as amesome as Lil Red is a goal that only a few will ever achieve, and that achievement would take years. :notworthy:

Also, consider the source in my post. You took my use of the word "penance" (in quotes) to mean that I was accusing you of sinning in posting on the Internet. Seriously, I am not versed well enough in Catholicism to know that my use of the word "penance" meant that I thought you had sinned. When I post on Phatmass, I don't pick my words as carefully as I used to do when I was paid for writing reports that took hundreds of hours of work. "Penance" was the first word that came to mind. Plus, I put "penance" in quotes in that context to try to indicate that I wasn't trying to be literal. Obviously I failed, but I tried. :idontknow:

You are under no obligation to justify your Internet posting to me (especially to me) or to anyone else on Phatmass. Your Lenten practices are between you and God. If you want to share them, fine. But, you are under no obligation to do so. I would be suprised if any Phatmass member did NOT fall short of their Lenten intentions in some way. And, sometimes it's better not to share everything on Phatmass.

That said, you set yourself up for teasing when your Lenten intention was an "absolute"--that you said you wouldn't post on Phatmass at all during Lent. You could just as easily have posted something like, "I will try to cut back on posting on Phatmass," even if your actual goal was not to try to post at all during Lent. Then no one would have grounds for teasing you. Also, rather than making an excuse, you could have replied something like, "Yeah, my bad. You guys are so great I couldn't live without you. :P "  It took me far too long (decades, actually) to learn that honest humility--actually admitting I made a mistake--when used in the right context is seen as a sign of strength, not weakness. I come from a family where, even as an adult, everything I say "can and will be used against me" so I learned to always keep my guard up with my family. If I had learned about the strength of humility when I was your age, I would have had a happier life.

I suspect you have no idea how many people on Phatmass pray for you. And, I'm not talking about "pity praying." I mean honestly wanting you to be happy, successful, and fulfilled in what God wants for your life. Believe it or not.

Posted

​We're just all paying attention to your lenten resolutions and making sure that you stick to them, because we want you to be holy. We're just such a good pham. :P

​Actually I just enjoy teasing FP. I'm the horrible older sister who teases her little brother mercilessly. When I used to do it to my nephew however he would stare at me and say 'Stop teasing, Nannie!' (his name for me) and that put me in my place! :P 

When a person posts their Lenten intention for the whole world to see and then breaks it over and over again and makes excuses for doing so, well, that's bound to cop a certain amount of flak. Just saying. :dance3: 

 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

So for those of you who do disagree with Pope Leo, what are your thoughts on that situation? Was he just straight up wrong when it came to the nature of true liberty? Was he wrong on the Christian constitution of states? Or the nature of the state itself? Was he right in the late 1800s, but wrong later?

PhuturePriest
Posted

​

​Dude. I was teasing you. :) I thought that was evident from all the smileys in my post, but apparently not. Note for the future: At least in my case, if I am making a post

​I never said you did. I said "some members on Phatmass". If I meant you, I would have said "You and others", which is different.

I also never said I wouldn't post on Phatmass. If you look at what I said, it was actually quite ambiguous. I took a break so I wouldn't lose my mind because the drama was becoming too much.

However, we are hijacking Nihil's thread, and I am very much interested in the question he just asked.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Puellapaschalis is too afraid to vote~! I know she has seen the thread because she liked one of my posts, but she is scared to answer! Neener neener.

 

tumblr_mtx0jwgQUN1sk0qvvo1_r1_500.gif 

Posted

​I never said you did. I said "some members on Phatmass". If I meant you, I would have said "You and others", which is different.

I also never said I wouldn't post on Phatmass. If you look at what I said, it was actually quite ambiguous. I took a break so I wouldn't lose my mind because the drama was becoming too much.

However, we are hijacking Nihil's thread, and I am very much interested in the question he just asked.

Isn't that funny because the original post actually said:

------------------------------

Posted 23 February, PhutuePriest said:

"I blatantly and unashamedly changed what you said because I was too lazy to go back a few pages.

As it turns out, I am also giving up Phatmass for Lent. It was something I decided to do on Ash Wednesday. All for the better, as it is best to decide to get off before Phatmassers start ripping each other apart like beasts because they haven't had coffee for three weeks. :|?
​-----------------------------

 

I don't see what's so ambiguous about that. :P  But good intentions are paving the highway to somewhere so perhaps I shouldn't be admonishing the sinner? (Stop teasing, Nunsense!)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...