Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If the Duggar family was trying their best they wouldn't of handled this situation like they did. They wouldn't be on reality tv when they had some huge skeletons in the closet. If they were trying their best they would of got proper treatment for those involved. Again trying your best is not as easy as it sounds 

​They probably DID think they approached it correctly.

Posted (edited)

​

​Your nest effort cannot be compared to someone elses best effort. People who suffer from physical or mental disabilities may appear to be lazy or not trying to someone who doesnt understand their pain, but you better believe they are trying. 

Do not judge those you do not know.

Who was I judging to begin with? The Bible thumping kid who is involved in adultery and divorse and is always bashing gays on my news feed?

Edited by Guest
Posted

​They probably DID think they approached it correctly.

Well let's be honest they failed miserably.

Posted

Well let's be honest they failed miserably.

​They did

puellapaschalis
Posted

The abuse took place before the first tv special, iirc, when they had 14 children in a small house with two bathrooms. I don't know Jim Bob had begun his real estate business at this point, but it's possible they were struggling and saw providence in the tv offer. And fame and money can be alluring and deceptive.

Posted

I am sad for the Duggars on multiple levels, no one had the right to call them out on this issue. All this did to this family was have them relive the pain and suffering they already went through.

An to act like that this part of their lives is so damning, i would really love to point to a ton of other shows on tv to these executives that show so much worse just as fiction. For TLC to act like their programming is so friggin pristine is nonsense on their part. An for them to act like they have these amesome values and now some how they are tainted is bs as well.

I wasn't a major fan of the show but i thought it was  good  that America had something positive to watch which was faith based. I did feel as if okay why are they so squeeky clean, where is the mud and dirt, and then i just kind of accepted the family for who they were and stopped waiting for the bottom to fall out.

I would rather want to know who leaked the information and what were the motives behind doing so.

I would probably want to watch the show now more than before if anything, I do hope the Duggars file some kind of law suit, i don't know under what grounds they could, but in America one can sue for any reason, so why not.

Posted

Personally, using their family size as a marketing ploy for a reality TV show does not show good parenting in my eyes. They essentially turned their family life into a spectacle like animals in a zoo for people the gawk at. The innocent children will be ridiculed for the perception of their family through no fault of their own. I have NEVER supported the exploitation of your family for monetary gain. 

I think the show should have been canceled a long time ago simply for the sake of preserving the children from the eyes of the masses. There are so many women in Hollywood who have fought for protections against paparazzi filming or taking photos of their children.

Posted

I don't watch TV and never seen it. I agree with what Era said though. Don't go out  reality TV when you got stuff like this to hide. It's all fair game. Pretending it's not is a joke. I cannot stand the squeaky clean Christian image some people try to display. It's fake. It disgust me. I'm thankful to have met a lot of Catholics who are working out their Salvation in fear and trembling and not pretending they are perfect and without flaws. I didn't watch the show so I don't know how squeaky clean this family tried to show themselves to be but any amount is enough to make me never want to watch the show. With all that said prayers for their family and all who are involved.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

​In my list I had:

  1. Homosexual couples
  2. Single parents
  3. Unmarried heterosexual couples
  4. Non- Catholic couples 

This of course assumes the general rules already in place that cover mental illness, abuse, etc etc.

Yeah, I think a just society could legitimately exclude or discourage these couples from adopting. Again, in a general sense. Emergency situations might require other arrangements. 

Posted

Yeah, I think a just society could legitimately exclude or discourage these couples from adopting. Again, in a general sense. Emergency situations might require other arrangements. 

​What would be an emergency situation? Would it be better to keep a child cycling through a foster system on the much elongated waiting list if these groups of people are excluded? Or is it better to place them with a family even if it is not a 1950s leave it to beaver traditional family?

Posted (edited)

So non Catholic couples shouldn't be able to adopt? Are you serious?

Edited by Guest
Nihil Obstat
Posted

​What would be an emergency situation? Would it be better to keep a child cycling through a foster system on the much elongated waiting list if these groups of people are excluded? Or is it better to place them with a family even if it is not a 1950s leave it to beaver traditional family?

When I say emergency situations I am assuming there may be times where a child needs to be moved immediately for his own safety. Something requiring very immediate action. I am not familiar with how things are typically done.

So non Catholic couples shouldn't be able to adopt? Are you serious?

If Catholic couples who are trustworthy are available, sure. Otherwise you deny that child the chance to be raised in the one true faith. But in many cases there simply are not good Catholics available, I am sure. In which case the next preference would probably be a heterosexual non Catholic couple.

Posted

I am sad for the Duggars on multiple levels, no one had the right to call them out on this issue. All this did to this family was have them relive the pain and suffering they already went through.

​ No one has the right to call them out?  Hello?  They put several girls...very young girls... who'd been recently molested on national television and expected that everything would always be fine and dandy.  When the oldest boy was 14 the girls in the house were 11, 10, 9, 8,  and 2.  We can infer that with 4 victims that the four oldest were the ones affected. Less than 2 years after this these girls became a national spectacle.  Is it that judgemental to call that bad parenting?

Posted

​ No one has the right to call them out?  Hello?  They put several girls...very young girls... who'd been recently molested on national television and expected that everything would always be fine and dandy.  When the oldest boy was 14 the girls in the house were 11, 10, 9, 8,  and 2.  We can infer that with 4 victims that the four oldest were the ones affected. Less than 2 years after this these girls became a national spectacle.  Is it that judgemental to call that bad parenting?

​ the viewing audience is not the police or the moral judges of these people, the Duggars do not need the publics blessings on anything that they do nor do they need our judgement it is their lives to live. This doesn't require a cabinet meeting in the congress nor anything else.

The parties involved handled the situation, this isn't some cult we are watching on tv who in turn seduces people to join and then they participate in some worshiping of an idol on an alter in their secret basement and then in turn goes out on the hunt for people.

But they did get caught up in the lime light, they should have been smarter to know that this part of their past would eventually catch up with them.  If this was some public institution we were watching on TV that was some how serving youth in some fashion, then sure bash em all over the place, Penn State took a public whipping and they deserved it , different media, but a public institution and their sports televised and read about often.

At best all anyone can do at this point in time is pray for them.

 

If people want to gossip i suppose that is fun to vent and quarrel on line over it, but it isn't helping the Duggars any, less some how we reduce the family to just being entertainment and forget or ignore altogether that they are people.

PhuturePriest
Posted

​ No one has the right to call them out?  Hello?  They put several girls...very young girls... who'd been recently molested on national television and expected that everything would always be fine and dandy.  When the oldest boy was 14 the girls in the house were 11, 10, 9, 8,  and 2.  We can infer that with 4 victims that the four oldest were the ones affected. Less than 2 years after this these girls became a national spectacle.  Is it that judgemental to call that bad parenting?

​I can only speak for myself, but having been in a similar situation (and coincidentally, it now being two years since it happened), I am doing perfectly well. I'm not struggling with anything whatsoever concerning it, and I'm perfectly healthy like everyone else. 

People act like if you're sexually abused you're mentally scarred and crying in a corner for ten years, when the fact is, you do get over it and heal. 

Now, what would set me back to the beginning is if I were forced to relive the experience in my mind by means of it becoming national news, which is my main objection to whoever revealed this.

Posted

​ the viewing audience is not the police or the moral judges of these people, the Duggars do not need the publics blessings on anything that they do nor do they need our judgement it is their lives to live. This doesn't require a cabinet meeting in the congress nor anything else.

The parties involved handled the situation, this isn't some cult we are watching on tv who in turn seduces people to join and then they participate in some worshiping of an idol on an alter in their secret basement and then in turn goes out on the hunt for people.

But they did get caught up in the lime light, they should have been smarter to know that this part of their past would eventually catch up with them.  If this was some public institution we were watching on TV that was some how serving youth in some fashion, then sure bash em all over the place, Penn State took a public whipping and they deserved it , different media, but a public institution and their sports televised and read about often.

At best all anyone can do at this point in time is pray for them.

 

If people want to gossip i suppose that is fun to vent and quarrel on line over it, but it isn't helping the Duggars any, less some how we reduce the family to just being entertainment and forget or ignore altogether that they are people.

Actually, I disagree.  The viewing audience SHOULD morally poliece the content their viewing.  We'd be alot better if we did that.  Considering the allegations against the dad from 7th heaven and Bill Cosby, I think we'd all be a bit more careful in our viewing habits.

Actually, it was far worse.  The girls were exploited by their own parents.  This is not some creepster in a dungeon that they chose.  Their parents forced them to be "actors" in a happy family when they were dealing with abuse.  Thats horrid.

At this point it's not about gossip.  It should be a big warning.  If you have children who are molested (no matter who the molester) and you place them on television you SHOULD be made to pay for it.  You should be treated as a somewhat dangerous person, willing to place your children's well being on the alter of fame.

The parents should be shamed into anonomity

The Duggars were adimant that they did this show to show that big families worked and that the quiverfull movement was great.  They did this knowingly and willingly at the expense of their daughters.  In non-personhood it should be treated as something that is a warning sign.  Don't put children on the air when they are dealing with trauma.

PhuturePriest
Posted

Actually, I disagree.  The viewing audience SHOULD morally poliece the content their viewing.  We'd be alot better if we did that.  Considering the allegations against the dad from 7th heaven and Bill Cosby, I think we'd all be a bit more careful in our viewing habits.

Actually, it was far worse.  The girls were exploited by their own parents.  This is not some creepster in a dungeon that they chose.  Their parents forced them to be "actors" in a happy family when they were dealing with abuse.  Thats horrid.

At this point it's not about gossip.  It should be a big warning.  If you have children who are molested (no matter who the molester) and you place them on television you SHOULD be made to pay for it.  You should be treated as a somewhat dangerous person, willing to place your children's well being on the alter of fame.

The parents should be shamed into anonomity

The Duggars were adimant that they did this show to show that big families worked and that the quiverfull movement was great.  They did this knowingly and willingly at the expense of their daughters.  In non-personhood it should be treated as something that is a warning sign.  Don't put children on the air when they are dealing with trauma.

​But what if they weren't dealing with trauma at the time? Did you read my above post? It seems like we're assuming that they're perpetually broken, or that they were at the very least still dealing with intense trauma, when in fact the possibility could be that their parents asked and made sure that they were okay with everything, and that they were in a healthy place in order to do the show. We're assuming a lot of variables that we simply do not know, and I don't think that's charitable or just. 

Posted (edited)

​I can only speak for myself, but having been in a similar situation (and coincidentally, it now being two years since it happened), I am doing perfectly well. I'm not struggling with anything whatsoever concerning it, and I'm perfectly healthy like everyone else. 

People act like if you're sexually abused you're mentally scarred and crying in a corner for ten years, when the fact is, you do get over it and heal. 

Now, what would set me back to the beginning is if I were forced to relive the experience in my mind by means of it becoming national news, which is my main objection to whoever revealed this.

​You never ever have bad days, ever?

 

Really?

 

I never said they were broken up crying all the time.  I said that given the circumstances it's a bad idea.  And I stick with it.  Your feelings are you, but you also had anonymity in general...they did not.  They also had no internet (like I assume you had) and very little communication with the outside world.   They were responsible not only for themselves but one (or two) little siblings. They had alot on them. That's a big difference.

Edited by hotpink
Posted

​But what if they weren't dealing with trauma at the time? Did you read my above post? It seems like we're assuming that they're perpetually broken, or that they were at the very least still dealing with intense trauma, when in fact the possibility could be that their parents asked and made sure that they were okay with everything, and that they were in a healthy place in order to do the show. We're assuming a lot of variables that we simply do not know, and I don't think that's charitable or just. 

​I never said intense or that they were perpetualy broken.  But they had 5 damaged kids, 4 of them victims.  Thats a fact.  Trauma dosn't just dissapear especally as puberty hits.  They could of been fine, but they also went down a rabbit hole of fame that they couldn't get out of if things weren't fine.

franciscanheart
Posted

​Im personally not really convinced of the whole traditional family set up having that much of an impact on the child's psyche. Relationships and how we define them is ever evolving and changing. What we thought of as the ideal childhood situation a century ago or a millennial ago may not be the same now. I havent done a ton of research into the topic, but I am more of the mind that a healthy environment with supportive, loving adults (Regardless of the occupants gender, sexual identity, marital status) is the best thing for a child. I mean, we used to think that biracial marriages were the terrible too. Turns out a child can be raised by two people from different ethnic backgrounds and still be normal.

 AMEN to that last part. I come from a biracial family and it was still frowned upon when I was growing up.

​

So non Catholic couples shouldn't be able to adopt? Are you serious?

If you ask the good people of phatmass, YES. Catholics are always preferred over other people, simply because they claim to be Catholic. Always.

I know: it boggles my mind a bit, too. :wacko:

​

​I can only speak for myself, but having been in a similar situation (and coincidentally, it now being two years since it happened), I am doing perfectly well. I'm not struggling with anything whatsoever concerning it, and I'm perfectly healthy like everyone else. 

People act like if you're sexually abused you're mentally scarred and crying in a corner for ten years, when the fact is, you do get over it and heal. 

Now, what would set me back to the beginning is if I were forced to relive the experience in my mind by means of it becoming national news, which is my main objection to whoever revealed this.

​You can't take your experience and decide that it's the rule. It's not. Even putting aside the details of your situation, your situation is not the hard and fast rule on abuse.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...