PhuturePriest Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 Think about what you are saying. Does that mean an adopted child can never know true parental love? Is humanity so ruled by basic sexual activity that true love is only found with those you can mutually and properly stimulate genitalia and share DNA with? It's not the sexuality, it's the complementarity of the sexes that cannot be replicated with two people of the same sex.
franciscanheart Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 This may not be the right phorum for this question but... Does our growing understanding of the human person (brain function, emotional response, personality profiles and makeups) necessitate a change in language on the part of the Church in order to better communicate her understanding of heterosexual partnerships and their superiority to homosexual partnerships?
Not The Philosopher Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 This may not be the right phorum for this question but... Does our growing understanding of the human person (brain function, emotional response, personality profiles and makeups) necessitate a change in language on the part of the Church in order to better communicate her understanding of heterosexual partnerships and their superiority to homosexual partnerships? I think you'd have to be a little more concrete about what you mean here.
CrossCuT Posted June 29, 2015 Author Posted June 29, 2015 (edited) This may not be the right phorum for this question but... Does our growing understanding of the human person (brain function, emotional response, personality profiles and makeups) necessitate a change in language on the part of the Church in order to better communicate her understanding of heterosexual partnerships and their superiority to homosexual partnerships? I think that is a good question, and going on what Ive heard said on PM on numerous occasions, it seems to me that avoiding the literal descriptions of what Catholics view as the homosexual condition being disordered, sinful, etc, would be an abandonment of their faith. I think I have heard people describe it as "tough love". Some Catholics might favor a change of vernacular, but I think they are mostly ostracized from the more traditional groups. (None of this is my opinion, im just trying to sum what I understand of peoples thoughts around here, pls correct me if Im wrong) Edited June 29, 2015 by CrossCuT
KnightofChrist Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 This may not be the right phorum for this question but... Does our growing understanding of the human person (brain function, emotional response, personality profiles and makeups) necessitate a change in language on the part of the Church in order to better communicate her understanding of heterosexual partnerships and their superiority to homosexual partnerships? Why wouldn't this be the right phorum? What is currently wrong (for the lack of a better word) with the Church's current language and what are some examples of that? What would you purpose the language be changed to, what examples do you purpose? Could you guarantee that the changed language would not loose or weaken the Church's unchangeable teaching on marriage and homosexuality?
Nihil Obstat Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 This may not be the right phorum for this question but... Does our growing understanding of the human person (brain function, emotional response, personality profiles and makeups) necessitate a change in language on the part of the Church in order to better communicate her understanding of heterosexual partnerships and their superiority to homosexual partnerships? We understand human biology better certainly, but if anything we understand far less of man as a moral agent. We need to recover that moral grounding as a starting point.
Socrates Posted June 29, 2015 Posted June 29, 2015 But atheists and non Catholics can marry in a perfectly valid manner. It is a natural marriage rather than sacramental, just like anyone, gentile or Jew, from before the time of Christ. Such marriages are a natural good. Yeah, I get tired of ill-informed Catholics saying things like "but a gay marriage is no different in the eyes of the Church than any other non-Catholic marriage."
little2add Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Think about what you are saying. Does that mean an adopted child can never know true parental love? Is humanity so ruled by basic sexual activity that true love is only found with those you can mutually and properly stimulate genitalia and share DNA with? Adoption can be a wonderful thing so long as the parents are man and a woman bound by Holy matrimony
Anomaly Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 (edited) Adoption can be a wonderful thing so long as the parents are man and a woman bound by Holy matrimony Holy Matimony is not a magic spell. It doesn't make the parents any better than whence they started. That is a small and dim view of people and reality. What if it was a single person? A widower? Do you have any idea what percentage of children are abused by biological parents? Its attitudes like that which lead to considering bastards as second class citizens. There is a difference between ideal and tolerable. Edited June 30, 2015 by Anomaly
little2add Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 do you know what Holy Matrimony Is? The matrimonial covenant, by which a man and a woman establish between themselves a partnership of the whole of life, is by its nature ordered toward the good of the spouses and the procreation and education of offspring; this covenant between baptized persons has been raised by Christ the Lord to the dignity of a sacrament
CrossCuT Posted June 30, 2015 Author Posted June 30, 2015 NAMBLA is next. Pedophilia and sexual assault are still illegal. I know its confusing.
Ice_nine Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Pedophilia and sexual assault are still illegal. I know its confusing. No need to be snarky. The definitions of sexual assault has changed before and will likely change again. There's no reason to assume it will be static. Pederasty was (is?) a phenomenon accepted in highly refined cultures. Why is the legal age to consent to sex 18 (or maybe 16 in some jurisdictions)? Why not 14? 13? Where is the line drawn and why can't that be challenged in a court of law? And is pedophilia illegal? Maybe there are laws against child porn and such but just having a sexual attraction to children is not a crime. If you are going to condescend to people at least make sure what you're saying is correct.
franciscanheart Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Why wouldn't this be the right phorum? What is currently wrong (for the lack of a better word) with the Church's current language and what are some examples of that? What would you purpose the language be changed to, what examples do you purpose? Could you guarantee that the changed language would not loose or weaken the Church's unchangeable teaching on marriage and homosexuality? I think you mean "propose". I never claimed to have all the answers. Just asking.
Papist Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Pedophilia and sexual assault are still illegal. I know its confusing. Why you adding sexual assault? All acts should be legal provided that all parties involved have fully consented to engaging in all acts. Anyone who disagrees with that is an intolerable hateful bigot.
franciscanheart Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Why you adding sexual assault? All acts should be legal provided that all parties involved have fully consented to engaging in all acts. Anyone who disagrees with that is an intolerable hateful bigot. Your little friend up there mentioned NAMBLA, an organization known for abusing underage boys.
Papist Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Your little friend up there mentioned NAMBLA, an organization known for abusing underage boys. How's that known?
franciscanheart Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 Oh good word. I need to keep better promises to myself and not engage with people who are so completely incapable of not being total sand bags.
KnightofChrist Posted June 30, 2015 Posted June 30, 2015 I think you mean "propose". I never claimed to have all the answers. Just asking. Yes, sorry for the error. But yes it's very easy for anyone to ask questions. Still if we are going to ask the question you asked earlier it would be good to back it up with what we believe is wrong, or out of date with the Church's current language and try to offer some suggestions of how we can update that language without weakening the Church's teachings on marriage.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now