Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Masculine spirituality


Recommended Posts

bardegaulois
Posted

It struck me a lot lately that much of what we read about spirituality is so very feminine, but what about men? Let's be frank, the idea of mystical espousal or of "falling in love" with the Lord just doesn't really move a man's soul very much. Nonetheless, the example of crusading orders, of missionary Jesuits, of martyr-priests does. I'd dare say in many ways, more active virtues, rather than passive virtues, like discipline, self-sacrifice, courage, duty, diligence, loyalty, and so forth--the types of rhetoric that makes men want to join the military--are far more important to most men.

Any thoughts in general about a more masculine spirituality and what it would look like?

Thanks for your replies.

Posted

St John of the Cross wrote some of the most beautiful mystical love poetry that the Church possesses, and St Joan of Arc was a soldier. Self-sacrifice and courage are recurring themes in the writing of many saints no matter what their sex. In my secular institute, some women relate very much to bridal spirituality, while others don't. I don't. So I don't think it makes much sense to divide spirituality into 'masculine' and 'feminine'. Each person's relationship with God is unique, and we can find inspiration in our spiritual lives from many sources. There's a wealth of different reading material out there.

bardegaulois
Posted

I should add, Beatitude, that I'm not trying to assign arbitrarily one type of spirituality to men and another to women. No, nothing of the sort at all. I'm merely making a classification using terms that might commonly be understood. Maybe it would make a lot more sense if I were to stress that there is an active, bold, audacious sort of spirituality that's very often, to my mind, neglected. I can gladly give some examples from my own experience, but I'd rather the question remain general rather than personal.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Well I guess I'm typically feminine in this way lol. But I was also going to say - there are male Saints who wrote with similar language about the soul, though they of course didn't see themselves as brides of Christ as women would. St John of the Cross comes to mind - who is very serious, ascetic, and mystical. His poetry and books are incredibly beautiful.  But if someone isn't drawn to that language, there are other Saints such as:

St Joseph, St Dominic, St Louis De Montfort, St Thomas More... 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Nihil Obstat
Posted

I appreciate the directness and strength of many male saints and theologians.

Posted

St. Ignatius of Loyola's Spritual Exercises is an excellent example of masculine spirituality. Lots of talk about fighting the good fight as Soldier of Christ against the Prince of Darkness. St. Francis de Sales's writing also breathe masculinity, although of the more civil, gentle variant that might be harder to see in an age where people know the macho parody and not the true form of manliness. 

When it comes to modern spirituality, I'd say St. Josemaria Escriva. 

puellapaschalis
Posted

St Benedict's Rule speaks of the school of the Lord's service and developing good zeal. There's little if anything of the emotive.

Posted (edited)

Let's be frank, the idea of mystical espousal or of "falling in love" with the Lord just doesn't really move a man's soul very much.

uh...excuse you. please don't speak for men please.

 

as christians we're all supposed to fall in love with god. 

Edited by Kia ora
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

St Benedict's Rule speaks of the school of the Lord's service and developing good zeal. There's little if anything of the emotive.

thats interesting because I heard the profession ceremony for nuns (or maybe when they become novices) has a lot of bridal language? Or maybe that's particular communities...

puellapaschalis
Posted

thats interesting because I heard the profession ceremony for nuns (or maybe when they become novices) has a lot of bridal language? Or maybe that's particular communities...

The profession 'ceremony' described in the Rule (as far as I can remember) is sparse. Much of the rest is add-ons from after the time of the Holy Father.

Posted

Does Thomas Merton count as "masculine"? He's very direct, and has written some on the Desert Fathers, who really weren't "feminine" in any sense. I'm not entirely sure what would count as "masculine" spirituality, unless you just mean more hard-core corporal penances and stuff...?

I'm female and don't relate to spousal imagery at all. I don't think the heavily emotive, sappy kind of stuff one runs into in... ahem... people like St. Therese of Lisieux... is really "feminine" so much as it is the product of a certain era in history.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I think its just something that some women relate to and others don't :) ...rather than being for a historical reason, just because we see it all throughout Church history from early Church (St Agnes) to mediaeval to Renaissance to Victorian to today :) 

Posted (edited)

It struck me a lot lately that much of what we read about spirituality is so very feminine, but what about men? Let's be frank, the idea of mystical espousal or of "falling in love" with the Lord just doesn't really move a man's soul very much. Nonetheless, the example of crusading orders, of missionary Jesuits, of martyr-priests does. I'd dare say in many ways, more active virtues, rather than passive virtues, like discipline, self-sacrifice, courage, duty, diligence, loyalty, and so forth--the types of rhetoric that makes men want to join the military--are far more important to most men.

Any thoughts in general about a more masculine spirituality and what it would look like?

Thanks for your replies.

I think it's a mission problem mostly -  there needs to be acknowledgement that outreach needs to happen among men, young men in particular. Some churches, and in some Catholic circles too, there are good mentor activities, men's prayer and activity groups, men's breakfasts etc. It's important to create spaces for men to meet and be formed in a way that allows an openness and exploration of faith. I don't mean some sort of exclusiveness, but an acknowledgement that such things need to happen.

I'm not for saying that certain practices or spiritualities are male/female though, each needs to find their own. However, I think a male/female split sometimes happens and it isn't helpful, especially around Marian devotions etc. I've known guys at college who pray the rosary in secret because some Catholics saw it as a practice for women, especially old women. I rejected all those narrow ideas and took Saint John Paul ll and St Louis De Montfort as two good guides in doing so. But, well, I have a habit of not being bothered about rocking the boat -  others were less willing. In my practices I have some great women saints too -  they rock and get things done too (no messing about):smile4:

Edited by Benedictus
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I think men can (should!) pray the Rosary. Nothing "emasculating" about it AT ALL. The view that the Rosary is for an old ladies club is damaging.

Also St John of the Cross is not at all less masculine for writing poems like Spiritual Canticle. But if someone isn't drawn to such imagery there are lots of Saints with different approaches. :)

Posted

The idea of crusading orders and missionary priests I would consider "feminine" in the sense that they are romantic, yearnings of the heart to be unique and great. Maybe more reflective of little boys than men. A more practical monastic spirituality seems most "masculine," giving men a sort of arena in which to act in daily life rather than giving them romantic fantasies. But everyone's different...I like Jesuits because of the intellectual side and the emphasis on discernment, which reminds me of ancient philosophy as a way of life, constantly thinking, but a lot of men aren't intellectual and would not respond to that.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

The idea of crusading orders and missionary priests I would consider "feminine" in the sense that they are romantic, yearnings of the heart to be unique and great. Maybe more reflective of little boys than men. A more practical monastic spirituality seems most "masculine," giving men a sort of arena in which to act in daily life rather than giving them romantic fantasies. But everyone's different...I like Jesuits because of the intellectual side and the emphasis on discernment, which reminds me of ancient philosophy as a way of life, constantly thinking, but a lot of men aren't intellectual and would not respond to that.

i wouldn't see a missionary priest like St Louis De Montfort as feminine...it also takes very masculine traits to do something like this or to be a crusader.  I think in another discussion it was mentioned that a man having some feminine traits isn't the same as a man who is emasculated. Even Our Lord can be very gentle for instance yet totally masculine. I don't think men need to search for THE most masculine traits ONLY - rather just have strong masculine traits always present. Just like how a woman might be brave and resolute but having strong feminine traits would still make her distinctly feminine. Its not mixing the genders, I actually believe in gender roles etc, I mean I don't think its divided so neatly. :) there are traits all good men have that have traditionally been seen as feminine, but they are not emasculated men at all. 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
PhuturePriest
Posted

Does Thomas Merton count as "masculine"? He's very direct, and has written some on the Desert Fathers, who really weren't "feminine" in any sense. I'm not entirely sure what would count as "masculine" spirituality, unless you just mean more hard-core corporal penances and stuff...?

I'm female and don't relate to spousal imagery at all. I don't think the heavily emotive, sappy kind of stuff one runs into in... ahem... people like St. Therese of Lisieux... is really "feminine" so much as it is the product of a certain era in history.

I find Saint Therese's spirituality is very beautiful. It's not a matter of historical context, but a matter of personality. Some people are more attracted to Saint Nicholas punching Arius in the face, and others are more attracted to Saint Therese and Saint John of the Cross with all their sap and romance. There's nothing inherently wrong in either one.

Posted

i wouldn't see a missionary priest like St Louis De Montfort as feminine...it also takes very masculine traits to do something like this or to be a crusader.  I think in another discussion it was mentioned that a man having some feminine traits isn't the same as a man who is emasculated. Even Our Lord can be very gentle for instance yet totally masculine. I don't think men need to search for THE most masculine traits ONLY - rather just have strong masculine traits always present. Just like how a woman might be brave and resolute but having strong feminine traits would still make her distinctly feminine. Its not mixing the genders, I actually believe in gender roles etc, I mean I don't think its divided so neatly. :) there are traits all good men have that have traditionally been seen as feminine, but they are not emasculated men at all. 

I don't mean that being a missionary priest is femine, but that the fantasy of it is. A missionary priest goes where he is sent and lives an actual daily life...that's different from the romantic fantasy of being a missionary. Same with the crusaser fantasy...the reality of a crusader is plunging your sword in a Muslim's neck and watching him die in a pool of his own blood. The romantic fantasy of soldiering is for little boys who know nothing of real life, until they grow up and discover the reality of war. They need a spirituality to keep them human in the midst of this world, not a spirituality that inflames them to fantasies that are not real. St. Peter drew his sword to slice off Malchus' ear, and Christ gave him a real spiritual lesson...he told him to put his sword away. That's when St. Peter really became a man.

Posted

Saint Benedict. When I want for the first time in a retreat in a benedictine monastery (for male), I really felt... "real man". I mean, not real man in the "macho parody", as said Catlip, but in the sense of quiet man, who know who they are and where they go, who are detached from the prejudice of the world, and who have a real strenght. 

Little story : one of the monk gave us his testimony. He wanted to be a monk, but his father, a violent man, was against it - it was too womanly. The monk found the strenght to follow his vocation while praying... St Joan of Arc ! He thought that if St Joan had the courage to fight the spirit of this time about " a woman should not fight", so he could have the courage to fight his father opposition. 

bardegaulois
Posted

The idea of crusading orders and missionary priests I would consider "feminine" in the sense that they are romantic, yearnings of the heart to be unique and great. Maybe more reflective of little boys than men. A more practical monastic spirituality seems most "masculine," giving men a sort of arena in which to act in daily life rather than giving them romantic fantasies. But everyone's different...I like Jesuits because of the intellectual side and the emphasis on discernment, which reminds me of ancient philosophy as a way of life, constantly thinking, but a lot of men aren't intellectual and would not respond to that.

This is exactly the idea that I'm talking about: not fantasy and romance, but merely the understanding of what needs to be done, and doing it. I've had a lot of friends who've served in the US military, and they've described their lives as endless routine, monotony, and drill, very far from the way a boy playing soldier might think of it. It's at times very trying, but they say they wind up fulfilling their orders for the sake of their comrades, because they know their orders are not merely for the sake of busy work but because the unit will be weaker if they're not fulfilled. In this me-generation era when everyone is a special little snowflake, That sort of practical selflessness is something that is hardly inculcated enough.

That said, though, I'm with you on the Jesuits, for the intellectual life takes labour of a different sort, one that if not fully grounded can lead to some frankly crazy ideas. Seriously, look at the intellectual detritus of late modernity and the patent absurdities being taught as gospel in so many of our universities. Unmoored, we can easily drift away. Thus, we must take caution to discern our orders very carefully, and Ignatius gives us a very pragmatic way to do that, not based merely on desire, but on hard realism as well. One who undertakes such a spiritual practice as the Exercises or a closer following of the Rule of St Benedict should soon find himself not only more in touch with the fallenness of his human estate, but also with the intellectual aloofness to discern what his orders are best to overcome that fallenness by bringing the Kingdom of God ever further into the world.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...