Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Masculine spirituality


Recommended Posts

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I find Saint Therese's spirituality is very beautiful. It's not a matter of historical context, but a matter of personality. Some people are more attracted to Saint Nicholas punching Arius in the face, and others are more attracted to Saint Therese and Saint John of the Cross with all their sap and romance. There's nothing inherently wrong in either one.

tumblr_lgkyodqe8c1qgrkbso1_500.jpg

St. Therese has been very dear to my heart lately, so.... Agent Cooper Thumb Up for you. Her prose is an acquired taste, but over time, I've discovered there's a great deal of honesty, wisdom and humanity in her that often gets overlooked. At the moment, I struggle with the style of St. Louis de Montfort. That said, I'll give it some time.

Spirituality is as diverse as there are saints and people, to the point where I struggle to even attach labels like "masculine" or "feminine" to it, myself. And fortunately, everyone has a lot to choose from.

Does Thomas Merton count as "masculine"? He's very direct, and has written some on the Desert Fathers, who really weren't "feminine" in any sense.

His earlier writings were excellent. That said, were his latter works not pretty questionable and heavily influenced by Buddhism? 

Posted

 

Mary's response is more properly  translated "How shall this come to pass?" i.e.,  "What magic will be used to make this happen?"  The question is not sarcastic, it is in earnest. It has the quality of openness, not doubt. Mary believes God can and will make her a mother, even though she is a consecrated virgin. She is ready to believe.

...

Capitalism, naturally, has no use for gender. It would prefer the efficiency of uniformly androgynous "human" resources. In practice this has meant a campaign to strip women of gender identity and encourage them to pattern themselves after the male model - wonderfully free from any messy, overhead-sapping activities: Pregnancy, childbirth, nurturing of children; Reasoning through dilemmas by factoring in relationships rather than exclusive reliance on abstract logic, etc.  It is not an accident that the rise of industrial production has coincided with human rejection of belief in religion, magic, etc. and the proclamation that gender is dead. After all these things are not "productive."

I say a human being stripped of its gender is no longer fully human. It is a cog - albeit a productive cog - in an economic machine.

I don't think Our Lady was being sarcastic, I think she was expressing a genuine curiosity. It's also a very practical curiosity. There is another instance in the Gospels where she demonstrates that pragmatic quality: she notices that the bride and bridegroom at Cana are in danger of running out of wine, she anticipates their worry over it, and she quietly decides to mention it to Jesus. She is not a good example for this idea that women are all for romance and daydreams while men are practical.

I disagree with part of what you write about capitalism and gender. It's true that pregnancy and menstruation are treated as defects that get in the way of productivity (there are still plenty of people who think it's reasonable not to employ women who are likely to take a career break for children), but on the whole gender is very profitable. Makeup manufacturers, fashion designers, even sanitaryware companies - they'd all be making a lot less money if women didn't buy into the gendered expectation that they should have this nail polish, that handbag, this hair removal product, those specially perfumed pads.

Anyway, I have no "theory" and mainly was aaddressing myself to the OP who is also a man and I think gets what I'm saying based on his last post. You seem to take masculinity and femininity as theoretical models which have a theoretical "spirituality." I take them as real-world ways of being which practical spirituality not only strengthens but also tames.

I take them to be socially constructed boxes that men and women are crammed into and that make very uncomfortable living spaces. I don't think there is any such thing as 'masculine spirituality' or 'feminine spirituality' - there is the soul and God. Neither Jew nor Greek, neither slave nor free, neither male nor female, but all one in Christ Jesus. I'm not saying that men and women don't have different experiences (having the capacity to carry and nurture life within you does affect who you are, even if you never give birth), just that it is facile and harmful to treat these basic differences as evidence that one sex is innately more romantic than the other, or that the other has a hardwired preference for CocoPops over Rice Krispies. It requires a huge suspension of logic.

veritasluxmea
Posted

His earlier writings were excellent. That said, were his latter works not pretty questionable and heavily influenced by Buddhism? 

That's what I heard too. He had some struggles with his vocation later in life and it appears he started looking to Buddhism for answers to his conflicts. 

This article from Catholic Answers covers it well. 

I’m going to be a bit critical of Merton’s interest in and writings on Asian philosophy and religion, not because I don’t admire his brilliance, but because his commitment to orthodox Catholicism appears suspiciously attenuated by the end of his life. In the 1969 book Recollections of Thomas Merton’s Last Days in the West, Benedictine monk Br. David Steindl-Rast wrote that Thomas said that he wanted "to become as good a Buddhist as I can." When he flew out of San Francisco for Asia on October 15, 1968, he left with the expectation of religious discovery, as if his monastic life at the Abbey of Gethsemani was a spiritual precursor to the insights he would gain in the East. He wrote in his journal:

He writes as if his Christianity and his Buddhism had already become enmeshed into a new hybrid religion, with "Christian mantras and a great sense of destiny," and he expresses his desire never to return until he has found mahakaruna, the Buddhist notion of "great compassion." As a Christian, I admire Buddhist mahakaruna, but as a Christian I also know that one need not look beyond Christianity to find it. I wonder—and we shall never know in this life the answer—what "home" Merton was headed for that day in October. (via catholic answers)

Posted

This is a common perception of Merton, but to my knowledge, he never said anything that contradicts Catholicism. We are not forbidden as Catholics to learn about other religions, to admire the truths that we find in them, or to use their vocabulary/concepts if they help us to become better Christians. Of course, on that latter one, one ought to be very careful. But Merton was a very learned man, so I trust he was capable of that.

veritasluxmea
Posted (edited)

I think a lot of it depends on how you interpret his personality/writing style too. Unlike St Thomas of Aquinas, who literally never refers to himself except to say I object that... Thomas Merton is very personal, relational, "spiritual but not technical" in a sense. (I'd say he's a more feminine writer that way!) So a lot of it is about interpretation of his person, what influences his inner world, what his inner state is. He's constantly spiritually seeking and changing, not settling or growing deeper in one obvious direction. Like Gabriela said he doesn't outright contradict the Church... but I read some of his later ideas as being dangerous. He found Christ and pretty much seems to have stuck with Him, but it's not really how traditional/usual Catholicism rolls. So if you're mature I'd say Thomas Merton is fine. 

Just my two cents though. He's certainly a complex man so no summary of him will ever really be complete. 

Edited by veritasluxmea
PhuturePriest
Posted

tumblr_lgkyodqe8c1qgrkbso1_500.jpg

St. Therese has been very dear to my heart lately, so.... Agent Cooper Thumb Up for you. Her prose is an acquired taste, but over time, I've discovered there's a great deal of honesty, wisdom and humanity in her that often gets overlooked. At the moment, I struggle with the style of St. Louis de Montfort. That said, I'll give it some time.

Spirituality is as diverse as there are saints and people, to the point where I struggle to even attach labels like "masculine" or "feminine" to it, myself. And fortunately, everyone has a lot to choose from.

May I ask what it is about Saint Louis that you struggle with? I can venture a guess, but I'm always curious about this type of thing.

Posted (edited)
I take them to be socially constructed boxes that men and women are crammed into and that make very uncomfortable living spaces. I don't think there is any such thing as 'masculine spirituality' or 'feminine spirituality' - there is the soul and God. Neither Jew nor Greek, neither slave nor free, neither male nor female, but all one in Christ Jesus. I'm not saying that men and women don't have different experiences (having the capacity to carry and nurture life within you does affect who you are, even if you never give birth), just that it is facile and harmful to treat these basic differences as evidence that one sex is innately more romantic than the other, or that the other has a hardwired preference for CocoPops over Rice Krispies. It requires a huge suspension of logic.

I honestly don't know how to live in a world where "there is the soul and God." I'm not saying that by way of argument, just that I don't see any other way for human beings to be human except through gendered roles, which are not perfect, but are vital to the space in which we live. But I think you're reference to St. Paul is worthwhile, because there is a tension within Christianity about gender and sex and general...it's emphasis on celibacy and flight from the world make a lot of human culture difficult to assimilate (at least theoretically, historically the church has just assimilated itself). This topic is too large for this thread, but I agree with what Lilllabettt was getting at about gender and capitalism. But my experience of gender has been largely shaped through Latin/Central American culture, which is gendered in a traditional way that American life is not, so I am not really able to speak on the experience in American relationships. I have a Central American friend who is not "machismo" but he can't accept the American idea of 50/50 partnership between man and woman. For him it's always 60/40, and that's pretty much an accepted gendered relationship in that culture. I mention him because to come to approach that culture with an ungendered spirituality would fall on deaf ears...both men and women have certain expectations, primarily that of pursuer/submitter and worker/lover. He's a man, and I know men pretty well because I am one and have been around many. The sort of generic monastic spirituality to which I can easily accommodate (because I approach the world intellectually) does not work in the real gendered world. Anyway, I'm not arguing, just offering a real-world perspective, of course limited by the slice of the real world that I inhabit.

Edited by Era Might
Ash Wednesday
Posted

May I ask what it is about Saint Louis that you struggle with? I can venture a guess, but I'm always curious about this type of thing.

It's not the Saint himself, and certainly not his spirituality, more just the writing. The mistake I make is trying to read older writings like I would a modern book. Another writing in particular I'd like to tackle and digest right now is Trustful Surrender to Divine Providence. 

Posted

 

 

OK, well pink, and high heels, and hair dos and make-up -- these things are not what it means to "be a woman." Those things are not the essence of femininity.  It's actually kind of offensive when people attempt to reduce gender to such things - to what one wears or what toys one plays with. These expressions of gender are acceptable in capitalist society because, as you say, there is money to be made. But true gender identity has very little to do with how a person relates to things. It has much more to do with relating to people. 

I think we can get lost in word choice here. Daydreaming, romance, whatever we are going to call it. You know, being a romantic does not prevent one from being eminently practical as well.  You might emphasize the practicality in Mary's curiosity; I think what is remarkable is her unblinking acceptance that through some magical process she is going to be a virgin mother. A virgin mother. You can't make this stuff up. But Mary didn't give it a second thought. Her question boils down to, more or less: "I'm going to be a virgin and a mother? wow! What spell are you going to use?" 

There are mountains and mountains of cross-cultural research  going back decades showing that women are more religious than men. More likely to claim a religion, more likely to practice, more likely to pray, etc.  Now some religions are more female-dominated than others, but the fact regardless is that women are far more likely to be religious relative to men in the same culture.  

Why is that? Because women wear make up and pink?

Women are themselves mysteries in a way men simply are not. Especially in the area of sexuality, so closely linked to gender. Women do not ask themselves: did he have an orgasm? Is the baby mine?  For women this mystery is a reservoir of power; for men it is a rebuke, a humbling. The woman knows, the man cannot know unless she deigns to reveal it.  Women are far more comfortable with mystery, with the unknown, with magic, and the impossible. Men are much less likely to be comfortable with, far more likely to reject, assertions about reality that are unexplained.  

Also in the mountains of research: Men use reason and logic to wade through dilemmas, discern the truth, etc. Women use empirical evidence (their experience). Because women's experiences are a mystery to men. Men's experiences are not so much a mystery to women. 

This has nothing to do with shaving legs or plucking eyebrows.

 

 

Posted

I think a lot of it depends on how you interpret his personality/writing style too. Unlike St Thomas of Aquinas, who literally never refers to himself except to say I object that... Thomas Merton is very personal, relational, "spiritual but not technical" in a sense. (I'd say he's a more feminine writer that way!) So a lot of it is about interpretation of his person, what influences his inner world, what his inner state is. He's constantly spiritually seeking and changing, not settling or growing deeper in one obvious direction. Like Gabriela said he doesn't outright contradict the Church... but I read some of his later ideas as being dangerous. He found Christ and pretty much seems to have stuck with Him, but it's not really how traditional/usual Catholicism rolls. So if you're mature I'd say Thomas Merton is fine. 

Just my two cents though. He's certainly a complex man so no summary of him will ever really be complete. 

You make a very good point: His writing style does expose his inner world much, much more than many other writers who have been declared saints. Writing in that way certainly makes one a great deal more vulnerable to criticism. I wonder: If the other saints had revealed their inner worlds as openly as Merton, would we have canonized them, or would the devil's advocate have had too much against them?

My struggles in this world have been primarily interior, and so I appreciate Merton's writing—even his later writings—a great deal. I find in him an honesty, both personal and intellectual, that I have not found in any other Catholic writer. He's not afraid to expose his whole humanity, and that takes serious guts, because it opens one to so much criticism. But it also is the only way for a person to really allow others to understand and relate to him deeply. And that is why I give thanks to God that Thomas Merton, at least, was willing to "sacrifice himself", in a sense, so that others with serious internal struggles could see that they are not alone.

bardegaulois
Posted

Thanks to all who replied. There's a lot of grist to chew on here, to which I likely won't be able to respond individually as I was away most of the time this thread was up. Informing this whole idea is that I am planning on living much more of a "Benedict-Option" lifestyle soon, taking on duties for the community around me that others cannot do. It's not typically "churchy" by any stretch of the imagination, but taking on all of this vital work, combined with a horarium of the Divine Office, study, and spiritual reading, seems not like a burden but rather a duty, and duty comes first. Forgive me, but even though I know of a very rich tradition of very emotional spirituality, I can't help but see it as somewhat effete and self-indulgent, at least for a man of my station. And if it be laborious, as it shall be at times, then it is to be penance for my past transgressions and those of others around me.

In short, it's an obedient response to a definite call that manifests through necessity. Obedience would certainly have been a problem for me in the past due to the imprinting on me of having been at the short end of many misuses of authority in my younger days, but it takes a lot of time for people really to get over themselves in this culture of perpetual adolescence. Most never realize that they have to at some point, and that's likely at the root of a good many of the myriad social illnesses we face today. Thus, I have the necessities here and now in front of me that simply must be dealt with, even if my first choice would be to be doing other things, like saying or serving the Latin Mass daily or teaching theology. They are simply impossible for various reasons, and now I have to do what I've been given. Odd, though, there might be greater sanctity and virtue to be gained from what's in front of me, rather than my preferences, and that's really what matters in the end.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...