Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Masculine spirituality


Recommended Posts

Posted

I don't mean that being a missionary priest is femine, but that the fantasy of it is. A missionary priest goes where he is sent and lives an actual daily life...that's different from the romantic fantasy of being a missionary. Same with the crusaser fantasy...the reality of a crusader is plunging your sword in a Muslim's neck and watching him die in a pool of his own blood. The romantic fantasy of soldiering is for little boys who know nothing of real life, until they grow up and discover the reality of war. They need a spirituality to keep them human in the midst of this world, not a spirituality that inflames them to fantasies that are not real. St. Peter drew his sword to slice off Malchus' ear, and Christ gave him a real spiritual lesson...he told him to put his sword away. That's when St. Peter really became a man.

This is why I don't try and divide spirituality into 'masculine' and 'feminine' - we end up with sexism like this. Era, do you even see what you're saying? You are classifying feminine spirituality as "something for little boys who know nothing of real life", who need something that will enable them to "really become a man" instead of "inflaming them to fantasies that are not real". So in your eyes, feminine spirituality = unrealistic dangerous daydreams. Masculine spirituality = the words of Jesus himself.

This is what happens when we impose cultural ideas of masculinity and femininity onto the Gospels. Women end up getting degraded. I want a spirituality that's Catholic Christian and that's enough for me.

Posted (edited)

This is why I don't try and divide spirituality into 'masculine' and 'feminine' - we end up with sexism like this. Era, do you even see what you're saying? You are classifying feminine spirituality as "something for little boys who know nothing of real life", who need something that will enable them to "really become a man" instead of "inflaming them to fantasies that are not real". So in your eyes, feminine spirituality = unrealistic dangerous daydreams. Masculine spirituality = the words of Jesus himself.

This is what happens when we impose cultural ideas of masculinity and femininity onto the Gospels. Women end up getting degraded. I want a spirituality that's Catholic Christian and that's enough for me.

I consider romanticism feminine, and that's not entirely a bad thing. Generally speaking, women live in fantasies, which men are adept at exploiting. When men become too fantastical, they lose the cultural grounding of masculinity. That's something that introverts and contemplatives have to deal with, because they live strongly by feeling. I think there is a masculine and feminine side to every soul, but when talking about surface level masculinity, fantasizing is not a positive. Men are expected to put their heads down and be practical. But I'm prejudiced because I am thinking through the lens of traditional culture where women are not just abstract members of the economy but truly gendered mothers and wives. I'm not a huge fan of modern abolition of gender so I admit I may be "sexist" by those standards. Today men and women are economic partners wheras traditionally the man is the provider and the woman the nurturer. That's a large topic for another thread.

Edited by Era Might
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I believe there are differences between men and women and masculinity and femininity but I wouldn't say that femininity is about fantasies .. Why can't the interior contemplative world be real? :) Our Lady is perfectly feminine... Did she live in a fantasy world? Not at all... I think there are differences just different ones.

I don't believe in abolition of gender either but my view of femininity is different. 

Posted (edited)

I believe there are differences between men and women and masculinity and femininity but I wouldn't say that femininity is about fantasies .. Why can't the interior contemplative world be real? :) Our Lady is perfectly feminine... Did she live in a fantasy world? Not at all... I think there are differences just different ones.

I don't believe in abolition of gender either but my view of femininity is different. 

Mary is a good example, she believed the angel whereas Joseph, initially, was practical: he wanted to put her away quietly. Same with Elizabeth and Zachariah, he lost his speech because he didn't believe the angel. Fantasy is not all there is to femininity, but women generally are believing romantics, they want to be swept off their feet...and often end up heartbroken when they believe in the wrong person.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Mary's initial response to the angel was, "How can this be, since I am a virgin?" I don't know how much more practical you can get. Ultimately she believed in the angel's message because she had perfect trust in God, not because she was predisposed to live in fantasy land by her XX chromosomes.

Joseph did not immediately know what was going on because unlike Mary he had had no angelic vision, only the news that Mary was pregnant. Once the angel appeared to him in a dream, he was no longer afraid and understood immediately what he had to do. He woke up and acted faithfully on a dream. That doesn't say much for this theory either.

Zechariah lost his speech because he was arrogant, not because he was practical. Sarah had a similar reaction to the angel's news of her pregnancy, so it's difficult to see this scepticism as a man's trait. Zechariah was a priest, occupying a very prestigious social position, and he was used to being the one who decided how everything should go. God silenced him so that he could finally learn to listen as well as to talk. Elizabeth carried the painful stigma of a barren woman (a 'real' experience devastating enough to shatter a thousand fantasies, especially in that culture) and consequently she did not have as much pride to get over. There was no pride compromising her ability to listen.

Contemplative nuns and monks do not live primarily by feelings. This is a myth that they work very hard to dispel.

Neither your theory nor your evidence for it has any logical basis. You seem to be trying to disguise the lack of substance by using sociological phrases that don't even make sense in this context. I don't think anyone is just an "abstract member of the economy", and whether or not someone is a mother or a wife is irrelevant to your ideas on gender - I'm not sure what a "truly gendered mother" is supposed to be, one that has a pram in the exact shade of pink as her uterus? You also have to ignore most men's experiences if you are going to paint heartbreak and loss of a dream as a female preserve. You could say that they are 'feminine' traits present in both sexes, but that's just an arbitrary classification, especially as ideas of what's feminine and what's masculine have changed over time and from place to place. I could say that such traits are the result of our previous incarnations as kangaroos with about as much chance of proving it.

Posted (edited)

Generally speaking, women live in fantasies, which men are adept at exploiting. When men become too fantastical, they lose the cultural grounding of masculinity. That's something that introverts and contemplatives have to deal with, because they live strongly by feeling.

Introverts live strongly by feeling? LOL.

You speak of fantasy, which is unrestrained imagination. Unrestrained - this is why the 'fantasy' genre in popular culture is prone to all kinds of sinister dreams and desires. 

Tradition (not Tradition-with-a-T per se, but pre-19th c. thought as a whole) regards such dreams and desires as disordered, and therefore prefers to speak of imagination. 

I wouldn't classify women as being more 'believing romantics' than men. People who go to the extreme to realize a dream (capturing someone's heart, finding the Holy Grail, migrating to the desert to find God) are more often men. Women possess to much common sense for such things. 

Edited by Catlick
Posted

Introverts live strongly by feeling? LOL.

You speak of fantasy, which is unrestrained imagination. Unrestrained - this is why the 'fantasy' genre in popular culture is prone to all kinds of sinister dreams and desires. 

Tradition (not Tradition-with-a-T per se, but pre-19th c. thought as a whole) regards such dreams and desires as disordered, and therefore prefers to speak of imagination. 

I wouldn't classify women as being more 'believing romantics' than men. People who go to the extreme to realize a dream (capturing someone's heart, finding the Holy Grail, migrating to the desert to find God) are more often men. Women possess to much common sense for such things. 

I never thought I'd say it, Catlick, but I agree with you.

Posted

Mary's initial response to the angel was, "How can this be, since I am a virgin?" I don't know how much more practical you can get. Ultimately she believed in the angel's message because she had perfect trust in God, not because she was predisposed to live in fantasy land by her XX chromosomes.

Contemplative nuns and monks do not live primarily by feelings. This is a myth that they work very hard to dispel.

I don't think anyone is just an "abstract member of the economy", and whether or not someone is a mother or a wife is irrelevant to your ideas on gender - I'm not sure what a "truly gendered mother" is supposed to be, one that has a pram in the exact shade of pink as her uterus? You also have to ignore most men's experiences if you are going to paint heartbreak and loss of a dream as a female preserve. You could say that they are 'feminine' traits present in both sexes, but that's just an arbitrary classification, especially as ideas of what's feminine and what's masculine have changed over time and from place to place. I could say that such traits are the result of our previous incarnations as kangaroos with about as much chance of proving it.

Mary's response is more properly  translated "How shall this come to pass?" i.e.,  "What magic will be used to make this happen?"  The question is not sarcastic, it is in earnest. It has the quality of openness, not doubt. Mary believes God can and will make her a mother, even though she is a consecrated virgin. She is ready to believe.   

People have noticed that women are more ready to believe. Of course this must therefore be a negative thing. Anything that is pronounced in women - especially pregnancy and birth - is devalued. Men cannot do most reproductive work, therefore it is worthless. Women are more ready to believe than men, therefore that quality is equivalent with gullibility and an unwholesome desire to live in a fantasy land. 

Sex distinction is undeniable - even plants have male and female. But gender is something proper only to humanity. Its existence reflects the truth that complementary of the sexes is far deeper and more profound than how they fit together anatomically. 

Capitalism, naturally, has no use for gender. It would prefer the efficiency of uniformly androgynous "human" resources. In practice this has meant a campaign to strip women of gender identity and encourage them to pattern themselves after the male model - wonderfully free from any messy, overhead-sapping activities: Pregnancy, childbirth, nurturing of children; Reasoning through dilemmas by factoring in relationships rather than exclusive reliance on abstract logic, etc.  It is not an accident that the rise of industrial production has coincided with human rejection of belief in religion, magic, etc. and the proclamation that gender is dead. After all these things are not "productive."

I say a human being stripped of its gender is no longer fully human. It is a cog - albeit a productive cog - in an economic machine.

“Every person deserves the chance to live a healthy, productive life.”  - motto of the Gates Foundation. "Productivity"  ( i.e., integration with androgynous values of capitalism, especially of traditional, highly gendered societies.)

 

 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I think that St Joseph does show faith because his initial worry came from feeling unworthy to be Our Lady's husband and not having an explanation, but when he was told, he believed. For this reason I'd agree more with Beatitudes analysis of the persons in the Bible. Our Lady also believed because of her holiness.

However, I also notice how the women in the Bible stayed with Our Lord at the Crucifixion and only one man did, St John. So I think it makes sense to say that women believe more easily. BUT... why should this be a negative thing? This is a trait that Our Lord seems to love. Men can have it too obviously. I think I'd agree with Lilllabettt's thoughts here on gender. 

I think that St Joseph does show faith because his initial worry came from feeling unworthy to be Our Lady's husband and not having an explanation, but when he was told, he believed. For this reason I'd agree more with Beatitudes analysis of the persons in the Bible. Our Lady also believed because of her holiness.

However, I also notice how the women in the Bible stayed with Our Lord at the Crucifixion and only one man did, St John. So I think it makes sense to say that women believe more easily. BUT... why should this be a negative thing? This is a trait that Our Lord seems to love. Men can have it too obviously. I think I'd agree with Lilllabettt's thoughts here on gender. 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted

I totally disagree with our society rejecting gender as something real because this simply expresses who we are and matches the differences in the sexes. For example .. Women can give life. They can be physical or spiritual mothers.

Some feminine traits I believe are receptivity, trust, and giving and nurturing life. This is linked to their sex, not made up culturally. So does that mean only women can have these traits? We do see them somehow prominent in women including those who stayed with Jesus the whole way. But as the souls relation before God has some feminine characteristics, men can have these traits too. Some they should have - gentleness for instance. But men do not become emasculated by them because they are balanced by appropriate masculine traits that are still there and still prominent.

Also all are called to trust God and believe Him, regardless of there being some femininity in the trait. (I say so because it is the receptive dependent person who needs to trust - a wife is this before her husband, so its feminine, but we are ALL this before God). This doesn't make us all androgynous in an internal way. Certain traits show prominence especially in family life.

If we get rid of this, as people tend to think today, its like - men and women should act the same, have the same roles, even look the same in ways. I see that as insulting to my femininity. By the way, I don't think these feminine  traits mean that women are unecessarily gullible, over emotional, or live in some fantasy world. This is not femininity. It is femininity unbalanced by virtue. Just as an aggressive man is masculinity unbalanced by virtue.

God made both masculinity and femininity and if we study St Paul's exportation to marriedcouples the roles he describes demonstrate women having a feminine role in marriage and men having a masculine one. 

Posted

Mary's initial response to the angel was, "How can this be, since I am a virgin?" I don't know how much more practical you can get. Ultimately she believed in the angel's message because she had perfect trust in God, not because she was predisposed to live in fantasy land by her XX chromosomes.

Joseph did not immediately know what was going on because unlike Mary he had had no angelic vision, only the news that Mary was pregnant. Once the angel appeared to him in a dream, he was no longer afraid and understood immediately what he had to do. He woke up and acted faithfully on a dream. That doesn't say much for this theory either.

Zechariah lost his speech because he was arrogant, not because he was practical. Sarah had a similar reaction to the angel's news of her pregnancy, so it's difficult to see this scepticism as a man's trait. Zechariah was a priest, occupying a very prestigious social position, and he was used to being the one who decided how everything should go. God silenced him so that he could finally learn to listen as well as to talk. Elizabeth carried the painful stigma of a barren woman (a 'real' experience devastating enough to shatter a thousand fantasies, especially in that culture) and consequently she did not have as much pride to get over. There was no pride compromising her ability to listen.

Contemplative nuns and monks do not live primarily by feelings. This is a myth that they work very hard to dispel.

Neither your theory nor your evidence for it has any logical basis. You seem to be trying to disguise the lack of substance by using sociological phrases that don't even make sense in this context. I don't think anyone is just an "abstract member of the economy", and whether or not someone is a mother or a wife is irrelevant to your ideas on gender - I'm not sure what a "truly gendered mother" is supposed to be, one that has a pram in the exact shade of pink as her uterus? You also have to ignore most men's experiences if you are going to paint heartbreak and loss of a dream as a female preserve. You could say that they are 'feminine' traits present in both sexes, but that's just an arbitrary classification, especially as ideas of what's feminine and what's masculine have changed over time and from place to place. I could say that such traits are the result of our previous incarnations as kangaroos with about as much chance of proving it.

When I referred to introverts and contemplatives I was referring to men, not monks and nuns. They have particular difficulties integrating their way of being into a practical masculinity. This is not sexist just reality and can be demonstrated in many literary figures...I happened to be reading through a bio of a Franz Kafka yesterday who struggled mightily with this.

Anyway, I have no "theory" and mainly was aaddressing myself to the OP who is also a man and I think gets what I'm saying based on his last post. You seem to take masculinity and femininity as theoretical models which have a theoretical "spirituality." I take them as real-world ways of being which practical spirituality not only strengthens but also tames. A feminine spirituality should tame the excesses, say, of womanly fantasy, and male spirituality should tame, say, male aggression.

Carl Jung's "Man and his Symbols" is interesting for the examples it provides of how myths and stories and dreams are ways of dealing with problems around feminity and masculinity. Fables like the king who chops off the head of multiple wives, or rite of passage fables about how men and women mature and break out of excessive traits of the opposite gender.

Im typing on my phone so can't say much more, but this discussion is not so serious as you seem to be taking it. Men have to live in the real world, not in historical theory about changing understandings of gender. Maybe it's sexist to point out and deal with masculinity and fen femininity in the real world, idk, but a good spiritual father will advise a young man to tame fantasies because it won't help him be what a woman needs in the real world.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Just to tie this in with masculine spirituality... Various men have commented that the Latin Mass is very well suited to masculinity. I think that is true. But I am a woman and I love the Latin Mass, and I realized that this liturgy balances the feminine and masculine traits and roles extremely well.

Men are drawn to the order, consistency of the Mass and they have an active role serving at the altar. Women can emulate Our Lady through praying and veiling. This is more feminine and many women get upset when this is said because they want to do active work, but - what is wrong with simply praying at Mass? I'd prefer that any day!

I know there are indults and things but indults dont mean its the norm. PJPII wrote he preferred there to be altar boys.

The Mass is also not about "rights" - even the priests duty is not a "right".

Also, the beauty of the Mass appeals to both men and women. As a woman, I am NOT drawn to banal lyrics of many modern hymns. I am also drawn to the beautiful polyphonies. Some have very 'tender' words but the men like them too cause theyre real and spiritual, not sentimental.

As a woman the horizontal community meal approach does not suit me either. So men who like the TLM for its masculinity: it is also well suited to women and masculinity and femininity are balanced very well there:)

BY THE WAY... I'm not saying all Novus Ordo has banal music and little reverence or the horizontal approach only. VII called for Latin, chant and more reverence. I'm speaking here of the really super modernised liturgies. Not the Mass they show on ewtn or what you'd find in a solid Carmelite convent. I prefer the TLM but this post only addresses it in comparison to the liberal liturgies we find. 

Era,  I can agree with your quote here... Living in a fantasy land is femuninity lacking virtue. However gender differences are real.

"I take them as real-world ways of being which practical spirituality not only strengthens but also tames. A feminine spirituality should tame the excesses, say, of womanly fantasy, and male spirituality should tame, say, male aggression."

 

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Just to clarify, I'm not saying that because men and women have different tendencies therefore one is good or the other bad, or that these tendencies are absolute. But a man has to learn how to be a man, and that requires him to understand gender in the real world. Some men are aggressive brutes, others are passive introverts. The purpose of a masculine spirituality IMO is to help both these men better integrate themselves into a balanced gender role. The introvert has to learn how women expect social gestures...the brute has to learn how women are vulnerable and their emotions not to be played with because he can. To me, that's male spirituality, not abstract theories about the endless ways of being. Spirituality should be practical and accomodating.

Posted

Just to clarify, I'm not saying that because men and women have different tendencies therefore one is good or the other bad, or that these tendencies are absolute. But a man has to learn how to be a man, and that requires him to understand gender in the real world. Some men are aggressive brutes, others are passive introverts. The purpose of a masculine spirituality IMO is to help both these men better integrate themselves into a balanced gender role. The introvert has to learn how women expect social gestures...the brute has to learn how women are vulnerable and their emotions not to be played with because he can. To me, that's male spirituality, not abstract theories about the endless ways of being. Spirituality should be practical and accomodating.

Just to clarify, I'm not saying that because men and women have different tendencies therefore one is good or the other bad, or that these tendencies are absolute. But a man has to learn how to be a man, and that requires him to understand gender in the real world. Some men are aggressive brutes, others are passive introverts. The purpose of a masculine spirituality IMO is to help both these men better integrate themselves into a balanced gender role. The introvert has to learn how women expect social gestures...the brute has to learn how women are vulnerable and their emotions not to be played with because he can. To me, that's male spirituality, not abstract theories about the endless ways of being. Spirituality should be practical and accomodating.

KnightofChrist
Posted

!!!!COMBO BREAKER!!!

Posted

Just to tie this in with masculine spirituality... Various men have commented that the Latin Mass is very well suited to masculinity. I think that is true. But I am a woman and I love the Latin Mass, and I realized that this liturgy balances the feminine and masculine traits and roles extremely well.

Men are drawn to the order, consistency of the Mass and they have an active role serving at the altar. Women can emulate Our Lady through praying and veiling. This is more feminine and many women get upset when this is said because they want to do active work, but - what is wrong with simply praying at Mass? I'd prefer that any day!

I know there are indults and things but indults dont mean its the norm. PJPII wrote he preferred there to be altar boys.

The Mass is also not about "rights" - even the priests duty is not a "right".

Also, the beauty of the Mass appeals to both men and women. As a woman, I am NOT drawn to banal lyrics of many modern hymns. I am also drawn to the beautiful polyphonies. Some have very 'tender' words but the men like them too cause theyre real and spiritual, not sentimental.

As a woman the horizontal community meal approach does not suit me either. So men who like the TLM for its masculinity: it is also well suited to women and masculinity and femininity are balanced very well there:)

BY THE WAY... I'm not saying all Novus Ordo has banal music and little reverence or the horizontal approach only. VII called for Latin, chant and more reverence. I'm speaking here of the really super modernised liturgies. Not the Mass they show on ewtn or what you'd find in a solid Carmelite convent. I prefer the TLM but this post only addresses it in comparison to the liberal liturgies we find. 

Era,  I can agree with your quote here... Living in a fantasy land is femuninity lacking virtue. However gender differences are real.

"I take them as real-world ways of being which practical spirituality not only strengthens but also tames. A feminine spirituality should tame the excesses, say, of womanly fantasy, and male spirituality should tame, say, male aggression."

 

this is kind of all over the place

PhuturePriest
Posted

Mary is a good example, she believed the angel whereas Joseph, initially, was practical: he wanted to put her away quietly. Same with Elizabeth and Zachariah, he lost his speech because he didn't believe the angel. Fantasy is not all there is to femininity, but women generally are believing romantics, they want to be swept off their feet...and often end up heartbroken when they believe in the wrong person.

So? Men often have romantic ideas of being the knight in shining armor sweeping fair lady off her feet. 

The involvement of swords doesn't make something non-romantic. 

Posted (edited)

So? Men often have romantic ideas of being the knight in shining armor sweeping fair lady off her feet. 

The involvement of swords doesn't make something non-romantic. 

Yes, men have fantasies too, and then have to live with the consequences. That was my point about the missionary priest...he is not fantasizing about missionizing, he is living his life in a mission...that's a big difference I happened to be thumbing through a book by Rod Dreher the other day called "How Dante Can Save Your Life" and he has a quote from JRR Tolkien in a letter to his son:

The older Tolkien warned his son to be wary of courtly love, which exalts "imaginary Deities, Love and the Lady. The woman is another fallen human being with a soul in peril," Tolkien wrote, adding that the courtly ideal "inculcates exaggerated notions of 'true love,' as a fire from without, a permanent exaltation, unrelated to age, childbearing, and plain life, and unrelated to will and purpose."

Old Mexican rancheros are full of tales of love and loss...Latin culture is romantic in a way ours isn't, and brutal in a way ours isn't, as fantasy and reality are very hard to distinguish.

Edited by Era Might

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...