Nihil Obstat Posted August 29, 2015 Posted August 29, 2015 Dude, we are well aware of your need to remedy "vagueness". insert wry grin here -> IDGI. Am I supposed to be insulted? The Fr O'Rourke story comes from the fabulous movie "Doubt." We need to have a class on Catholic-themed Philip Seymour Hoffman movies. Also in that scene, PSH plays a priest giving a homily, and it is understood that he is referencing Meryl Streep's nun character. The conflict between these two crackles with deliciousness and no more so than when Father basically calls her an "ignorant, badly brought up female" from the pulpit. Also in context it has an element of misogyny to it, which adds a layer because the priest in the movie is supposed to be a 60s liberal. layerssssssss Excellent film.
Lilllabettt Posted August 29, 2015 Author Posted August 29, 2015 (edited) OK. I didn't comment in the other thread. But as I watched the situation in Ferguson unfold, I was reminded very strongly of the situation in Northern Ireland and my experiences there. How many Ulster Protestants still can't understand the Catholic suspicion of the police. The police force is mostly drawn from their number, and they are adamant that the police are only there to help and protect society, and they think that Irish Catholics who are wary with the police are just hanging onto conflict and trying to create trouble. But the Catholic population has had a vastly different experience with law enforcement, and even though the situation in NI is much better than it was, they aren't easily going to forget the humiliation of being stopped by B men or 'specials' (Protestant neighbours in uniform, given authority to treat them like croutons, who sometimes participated in revenge killings) and active police collusion with Protestant paramilitaries. This isn't ancient history, this is recent. Black American families also remember obvious and painful police collusion in violent acts of racism under segregation - and again, this isn't some old history that everyone would forget about if only political parties didn't talk about it. This is living memory. Structural racism didn't end with the Jim Crow era either. I doubt the use of lynching imagery in the opening post was an accident, and at risk of being called a prissy prick, I'm going to say that it was hugely inappropriate given this legacy. Darren Wilson isn't dead and a highly doubt that the opinion of Lil Red on Phatmass is going to concern him all that much or have a terrible effect on his life. The fact that he shot dead another person may do so - I've spoken with many ex-soldiers who have killed and it's not always easy to skip off back to normality after doing a thing like that, even if they believe 100% that they were in the right. The police as an institution are not going to build trust as community guardians while people keep ending up dead. Even if you believe wholeheartedly in the ability of the state to investigate state officials with pure impartiality, the outcome of this investigation leaves a major question unanswered - why a policeman needs to shoot twelve bullets into an unarmed guy by way of defence. In the inner-city area where I live when in the UK, police deal with violence regularly (there is a gang problem there), most police aren't armed with guns, and they still manage to defend themselves without either killing people or getting killed themselves. There are non-lethal ways to subdue someone. It's not a stark choice between murdering a teenager and the police officer getting killed himself. My brother is a soldier. It doesn't stop me from being highly critical of the army. The fact that I love him and value his safety does not mean that I am going to turn a blind eye to the safety and wellbeing of all the families whose lives that army helped to tear apart, as though it was either their lives or their life of my brother, and he had the right to turn killer just because I wanted him to be safe. It doesn't work like that. BLAH BLAH BLAH How can I be clearer about this? What you are talking about is exactly what I am talking about and denouncing. People just *knew* the cop was guilty because they just *know* cops are racist. OR they *knew* the cop was guilty because they found out he was white and Michael brown was black and people just *know* how white cops and black men interact. Well guess what? THATS CALLED PREJUDICE. THAT'S CALLED RASH JUDGMENT And guess what? THEY WERE WRONG. Am I the only one infuriated by the irony?? People disgusted by how our justice system lynches black men turning around and trying to lynch white cops? Or I guess just being "OK" with other people lynching them because, hey, black folk got history with white cops? Do we get that thinking someone is more likely to be guilty because of their skin color or occupation IS THE REASON SO MANY BLACK MEN GET SENT TO JAIL???? This attitude IS THE PROBLEM. i am COMPLETELY unmoved by your thoughts on your brother/being critical of the army. Something tells me if your brother killed someone in self-defense, and the world media descended on him announcing his guilt, you would have a problem with it. Or maybe not. Maybe you think him being made to pay for something he didn't do would be "worth it" to shed light on the injustice perpetrated by the army on a systemic level. You might think it's worth it - ruining one innocent man's life so as to bring attention to wider social problems. I do not think it is worth it. I think it is an evil bargain. I believe individual human beings are more valuable than the triumph of a particular ideology. OK? Edited August 29, 2015 by Lilllabettt
beatitude Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 BLAH BLAH BLAH Don't you get it? How can I be clearer about this? What you are talking about is exactly what I am talking about and denouncing. People just *knew* the cop was guilty because they just *know* cops are racist. OR they *knew* the cop was guilty because they found out he was white and Michael brown was black and people just *know* how white cops and black men interact. Well guess what? THATS CALLED PREJUDICE. And guess what? YOU WERE WRONG. Am I the only one infuriated by the irony?? People disgusted by how our justice system lynches black men turning around and trying to lynch white cops? The existence of structural violence within an institution doesn't mean that all individual policemen are racist. I don't think anybody said that. I think your determination to make all criticism of police violence about your fiance is leading you to assume that everybody else's thought processes must be like that too. That's a massive assumption to make, as is the idea that Michael Brown was attempting to "lynch" the policeman - I haven't seen anyone seriously making that claim. You also don't deal with whether shooting twelve bullets at someone in self-defence is necessary. I didn't particularly expect you to. I also don't expect you to be moved by my own views on the military or my thoughts on my brother - although I think there is an irony in the fact that your whole post is based on your thoughts about your fiance, and you evidently expect those to stand as a decent argument. I mentioned my brother to show that it is possible to be deeply critical of an institution while still care very much about the individuals in it. And for them to be good individuals. I don't know your history, but I have been an aid worker in war zones and I have had surgeons paging the psychosocial department to ask if we can send someone over to try and calm people down while they operate without anaesthetic, because there was none left in supply. One of my best friends out there lost her two little cousins and walked into their room when the shelling was over to find parts of them all over the walls. I just remember a foot and chunk of leg still in its shoe. I suspect I've seen death a lot closer up than you have, so the emotive reasoning along the lines of "Well, just wait until it happens to you" doesn't work - I've already seen what an army can do to people and nothing can change what I saw, not even the possibility of something happening to my brother. I don't expect you to be moved by that either, but I do expect you to consider that you're not the only person who has loved ones caught up in violent situations. Sometimes you talk as though you're the only person with any life experience whatsoever and consequently with any right to speak. (I'm surprised the phrases "kum-by-ah" and "in the real world..." haven't made an appearance yet.) Other people also have views informed by their situations and experiences in life, and for some people those experiences involve their communities being crushed by police and the knowledge that they are less likely to see justice because of who they are - but apparently that's just BLAH BLAH BLAH, not another irony: you expecting people to view Mike Brown's death through the lens of your personal situation, but getting outraged when they persist in viewing it through the lens of anyone else's.
Ice_nine Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Lilla, I doubt I will convince you of anything but I'll trade you one diatribe for another. Prejudice and bias goes both ways. I could accuse you of being biased in favor of the police, of the government etc and therefore more willing perhaps to turn a blind eye to the actual evil that they commit, and therefore willing to ignore the cries of a community of people (disenfranchised and disempowered as they are). I would say that's even more pernicious than what you're accusing others of. However, people are generally unwilling to confront their biases and see how they color the stances they take. We all have them anyway, and there are reasons, some legitimate and some not, that they exist. But I will confess I have a bias against the police. When stories like these break I typically predict/guess that that a cop is guilty (do you assume that they are not?), while I'm also open to the possibility that he or she is not. However, I also have little faith that our justice system shows parity enough to convict cops when they are actually guilty. I was SHOCKED when the 6 cops in Baltimore were in indicted. Let me explain the reason for my bias. I am not part of, but I try to listen to, the Black community. And what I hear from them is lots of pain, anger, and frustration from instances of racism from people and from police. I can either assume that they are being histrionic and overreacting OR I can assume that there are genuine reasons for feeling how they do. When one faces a system of habitual injustice and prejudice they are likely to develop an us vs. them mentality (can you blame them? I can't) so they MAY see racism when it genuinely isn't there in a particular instance, but I can understand the reaction and sensitivity whenever there is violence between races. I think the Michael Brown case was not a strategic case to advance the awareness of police brutality--too many unknowns, the incriminating security footage of Brown prior--but that alone should tell you something. The ensuing violence was a reaction. Was it reaction to one isolated case? No it was more like the straw that broke the camel's back. You know, speaking of being safe at night in your quiet room in your warm bed, I will say it's very EASY to say "now let's just all calm down and be rational about this," when your community is not bearing the brunt of injustice. We are not purely rational creatures when we are involved in conflict. (You even give way to emotional appeal in your op when detailing the trials and tribulations of your boyfriend). So when people, including myself and others on phatmass, appear to you to be "calling for blood" you understand it as us "having an axe to grind," whereas I see it as standing with a community that is oppressed and victimized. You know, it's not that it's fair for one innocent (which, I'm going to mince words and say that Brown's killer is not necessarily innocent, but the DOJ found him "not guilty" of a particular crime, in any case . . .) man be "lynched" to shed light on systematic racism it's when instances like these arise there are SWATHS of people who think we are living in a post-racial society and that there is no systematic issue of police brutality. To them, that the police did not act as a piece in a wider racialist system is a foregone conclusion because there IS no such thing as racism in the police force except for some few, isolated incidents. When people come in with that attitude it is very frustrating and that's part of the reason why people press the issue of systematic racism so much. )Let's not forget that hundreds of thousands of dollars IIRC were crowdfunded for Darren Wilson well before he was cleared and the KKK showed their implicit support of him). So when people are coming in with these assumptions it's not that I *know* this particular cop is guilty because he is white and the dead kid is black or that I *know* this particular cop is racist, it's that I KNOW there is an actual problem with racism and police brutality against black people in this country. I feel like I have to prove these things every time these debates come up (which is a fool's errand, I know) and I may use the particular incident as leverage in asserting my argument. Again, that doesn't mean I KNOW that particular cop is guilty. I'm aware how it may seem like that's the case. Do you see this distinction? Furthermore I have distrust for the cops because they have always had a sordid history with black people, from COINTELPRO and the war on drugs, to the hoards of killings and beatings captured on video today. I don't know how people can ignore these things. It's very aggravating. Do people really think cops are all unequicovally the "good guys." Take a look at some declassified documents or youtube vids today. To believe in the "good guy" croutons is insane? I also operate with the axiom that power corrupts and people tend to abuse power. Cops are given a huge amount of power. I have severe doubts that many people can handle that responsibly (think Stanford Prison experiments). All these things lend to my bias. That I admit, because I'm so "self-aware." Now, I probably wasted an hour of my saturday night for nothing, but that's nothing new for me. Take care.
Lilllabettt Posted August 30, 2015 Author Posted August 30, 2015 The existence of structural violence within an institution doesn't mean that all individual policemen are racist. I don't think anybody said that. I think your determination to make all criticism of police violence about your fiance is leading you to assume that everybody else's thought processes must be like that too. That's a massive assumption to make, as is the idea that Michael Brown was attempting to "lynch" the policeman - I haven't seen anyone seriously making that claim. You also don't deal with whether shooting twelve bullets at someone in self-defence is necessary. Le me try again. Criticize police violence all you want. The very second you start feeding innocent individuals to your political movement and calling it "justice" - you've lost all legitimacy. Michael Brown wasn't trying to lynch the cop - the people in the street demanding the cop be tried and convicted as an obviously guilty son-of-a-so-and-so were trying to lynch the cop. Maybe we should all re-read "To Kill A Mockingbird" to see how the justice system can be used to lynch an innocent man. Repeat: it does not matter if you are 100% right about police violence, racism, etc. It is EVIL to target an innocent person as part of your political movement. period. Rash judgment is WRONG. No matter how bad you think the system is. PERIOD. This Ferguson incident is the rare occasion when so many people who were SO convinced of the rightness of their rash judgment can get solid feedback that they were absolutely incorrect. Hopefully the embarrassment is deep enough to make a lasting impression.
Maggyie Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 You're asking too much Lilla. In the 21st century we don't have individuals, we have identity groups. Everyone has an ideology and all the other people are just scenery in it.
MarysLittleFlower Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 (edited) Could it be that we are somehow all speaking past each other with this? Its true there is corruption in the government. Maybe police. Maybe military. Schools. Hospitals. Businesses. ETC. Some are trying to point to that. Others are saying that in fighting corruption, we should not make assumptions about individuals but look at each one separately: as a person, not a faceless member of such and such group. Could we all agree though with those two points - that there is corruption, but we shouldn't fight it by targeting individuals who may be innocent? Our Lord teaches - fight evil with good. Hatred with love. If we fight things like racism with racism what good would that do. Some are maybe reminding of this, while others are reminding of the racism being serious. Can we all agree on those points? Edited August 30, 2015 by MarysLittleFlower
dUSt Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 The Management Clique is the main engine behind Phatmass' (current) downturn. Well done @Lilllabettt on outing it - the downturn, that is. "Management Clique" is my word painting. Can someone please explain to me what is going on? I can't fix anything if everything is worded in vague code. From my viewpoint, you are doing no better than those who you are complaining about. Solution anybody?
MarysLittleFlower Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 For my part I have no clue what the reference is to It seems like its some controversy with two sides to it that some members know about (maybe due to a particular thread) and others don't.
Nunsense Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Can someone please explain to me what is going on? I can't fix anything if everything is worded in vague code. From my viewpoint, you are doing no better than those who you are complaining about. Solution anybody? I have vague ideas about what was being implied here but since I can't be sure and could very well be totally off base, it would be nice if the complaint was just voiced clearly and with no ambiguity. The other option of course is for the complainant(s) to PM you directly so you can deal with any perceived problems but there may be hesitations about doing this because you don't always seem to respond well to complaints. Once before when I personally tried to express my concerns to you via a PM, you called me a Debbie Downer and basically made me feel discounted. I felt shut down and decided that I just wouldn't bother addressing any concerns to you anymore - I just observe now and let things run their course, assuming that it will all come out in the wash over time. I respect and admire what you do here with phatmass and still think it's the best Catholic forum online. But that doesn't mean it couldn't use some improvements in some areas. It just depends on how open you are to suggestions from those who post here. But you are right - you can't make changes if you don't know what the problem is, so I hope someone clarifies this point for you, and for all of us who enjoy being here.
Lilllabettt Posted August 30, 2015 Author Posted August 30, 2015 Lilla, I doubt I will convince you of anything but I'll trade you one diatribe for another. Prejudice and bias goes both ways. I could accuse you of being biased in favor of the police, of the government etc and therefore more willing perhaps to turn a blind eye to the actual evil that they commit, and therefore willing to ignore the cries of a community of people (disenfranchised and disempowered as they are). I would say that's even more pernicious than what you're accusing others of. However, people are generally unwilling to confront their biases and see how they color the stances they take. We all have them anyway, and there are reasons, some legitimate and some not, that they exist. But I will confess I have a bias against the police. When stories like these break I typically predict/guess that that a cop is guilty (do you assume that they are not?), while I'm also open to the possibility that he or she is not. However, I also have little faith that our justice system shows parity enough to convict cops when they are actually guilty. I was SHOCKED when the 6 cops in Baltimore were in indicted. Let me explain the reason for my bias. I am not part of, but I try to listen to, the Black community. And what I hear from them is lots of pain, anger, and frustration from instances of racism from people and from police. I can either assume that they are being histrionic and overreacting OR I can assume that there are genuine reasons for feeling how they do. When one faces a system of habitual injustice and prejudice they are likely to develop an us vs. them mentality (can you blame them? I can't) so they MAY see racism when it genuinely isn't there in a particular instance, but I can understand the reaction and sensitivity whenever there is violence between races. I think the Michael Brown case was not a strategic case to advance the awareness of police brutality--too many unknowns, the incriminating security footage of Brown prior--but that alone should tell you something. The ensuing violence was a reaction. Was it reaction to one isolated case? No it was more like the straw that broke the camel's back. You know, speaking of being safe at night in your quiet room in your warm bed, I will say it's very EASY to say "now let's just all calm down and be rational about this," when your community is not bearing the brunt of injustice. We are not purely rational creatures when we are involved in conflict. (You even give way to emotional appeal in your op when detailing the trials and tribulations of your boyfriend). So when people, including myself and others on phatmass, appear to you to be "calling for blood" you understand it as us "having an axe to grind," whereas I see it as standing with a community that is oppressed and victimized. You know, it's not that it's fair for one innocent (which, I'm going to mince words and say that Brown's killer is not necessarily innocent, but the DOJ found him "not guilty" of a particular crime, in any case . . .) man be "lynched" to shed light on systematic racism it's when instances like these arise there are SWATHS of people who think we are living in a post-racial society and that there is no systematic issue of police brutality. To them, that the police did not act as a piece in a wider racialist system is a foregone conclusion because there IS no such thing as racism in the police force except for some few, isolated incidents. When people come in with that attitude it is very frustrating and that's part of the reason why people press the issue of systematic racism so much. )Let's not forget that hundreds of thousands of dollars IIRC were crowdfunded for Darren Wilson well before he was cleared and the KKK showed their implicit support of him). So when people are coming in with these assumptions it's not that I *know* this particular cop is guilty because he is white and the dead kid is black or that I *know* this particular cop is racist, it's that I KNOW there is an actual problem with racism and police brutality against black people in this country. I feel like I have to prove these things every time these debates come up (which is a fool's errand, I know) and I may use the particular incident as leverage in asserting my argument. Again, that doesn't mean I KNOW that particular cop is guilty. I'm aware how it may seem like that's the case. Do you see this distinction? Furthermore I have distrust for the cops because they have always had a sordid history with black people, from COINTELPRO and the war on drugs, to the hoards of killings and beatings captured on video today. I don't know how people can ignore these things. It's very aggravating. Do people really think cops are all unequicovally the "good guys." Take a look at some declassified documents or youtube vids today. To believe in the "good guy" croutons is insane? I also operate with the axiom that power corrupts and people tend to abuse power. Cops are given a huge amount of power. I have severe doubts that many people can handle that responsibly (think Stanford Prison experiments). All these things lend to my bias. That I admit, because I'm so "self-aware." Now, I probably wasted an hour of my saturday night for nothing, but that's nothing new for me. Take care. It's interesting to me that you bring up the Baltimore case - because that has the potential to be another attempted lynching. It remains to be seen but it started off on the wrong foot being overcharged. ( I don't know of any mainstream legal opinion on either side of the fence that thinks it wasn't overcharged.) we'll see. I don't assume the cops are innocent. i think the government, including police as an institution, naturally gain more and more power until they devour the people who fed them. I have worked in poor neighborhoods and served black and brown people my entire adult life. I see very well how the system ensnares poor people and how rich people (mostly white) have the resources to avoid these ensnarements or at least deal effectively with them. I see how black people get swept into the judicial system very oung. It is painfully evident to me on a daily basis what privileges I derive from the system as a white woman and how police acting in implicitly racist ways prop up this system that allows me to have those benefits. Heres my thing: "You people" think cops are guilty until proven innocent, just the way white people on a jury tend to think black men are guilty until proven innocent. My sweetie has to go to deal every day with "you people" --- people who hate him, think he is either up to no good or is about to be up to no good. My sweetie never did nothing to nobody. "You people" don't care. And if he got into trouble "you people" would assume he is guilty, no matter what. It's wrong. It's not Christian. If you are aware of your bias, that's good. You should be actively resisting giving in to it when you hear about these incidents. Just the same as I actively resist the racist bias that has been beaten into my head by our racist society since I was young.
Nunsense Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Heres my thing: "You people" think cops are guilty until proven innocent, just the way white people on a jury tend to think black men are guilty until proven innocent. My sweetie has to go to deal every day with "you people" --- people who hate him, think he is either up to no good or is about to be up to no good. My sweetie never did nothing to nobody. "You people" don't care. And if he got into trouble "you people" would assume he is guilty, no matter what. It's wrong. It's not Christian. If you are aware of your bias, that's good. You should be actively resisting giving in to it when you hear about these incidents. Just the same as I actively resist the racist bias that has been beaten into my head by our racist society since I was young. "You people"? Now who's lumping individuals into groups?
Lilllabettt Posted August 30, 2015 Author Posted August 30, 2015 (edited) Can someone please explain to me what is going on? I can't fix anything if everything is worded in vague code. From my viewpoint, you are doing no better than those who you are complaining about. Solution anybody? I have no beef with management and I don't need any redress. I can handle myself. Near the bottom of this thread http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/135290-best-complete-factual-account-of-what39s-happening-in-ferguson/?page=10 one of your Mediators of Meh made a political edit and then closed the thread. My personal view is that closing a thread is kind of a nuclear option. It's use in this circumstance was imo prissy and ... whiny and ... ick. And awfully hasty - who knows why so hasty.<---- conspiracy But whatevs. Instead of reasoning with me, an attempt was made to shut me up. Those who are forced to mix with me usually know better than to make that mistake. I responded as I typically do by taking what was annoying and blowing it up bigger. Hence this thread. Happy Birthday, Merry Christmas, etc. I feel like I have resolved the modding side of things to my satisfaction. My idea is why whine about it when I can just get what I want another way. My point has now gotten way more attention than it ever would have if the "best complete factual account" thread had been permitted to die a natural death. So I don't care. Going forward I'm happy to focus on the content of this thread (the rash judgment in this community, reflective of the wider rash judgment of American society as a whole, where this police officer is concerned) rather than on the process which brought the thread into existence (prissy over-modding.) "You people"? Now who's lumping individuals into groups? It's ironic nunsense. Do you see the "" scare quotes. Good grief. Edited August 30, 2015 by Lilllabettt
Nunsense Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 It's ironic nunsense. Do you see the "" scare quotes. Good grief. You need to work on your irony skills, Lill, you just come across as aggressive and angry all the time - not ironic.
Lilllabettt Posted August 30, 2015 Author Posted August 30, 2015 You need to work on your irony skills, Lill, you just come across as aggressive and angry all the time - not ironic. you might need to work on social cues. i am grouchy more often than not these days. point taken. but meh ---you can take me or leave me. and call me Lilla please. Lill brings to mind my failed hip hop career. very traumatic.
Nunsense Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 you might need to work on social cues. i am grouchy more often than not these days. point taken. but meh ---you can take me or leave me. and call me Lilla please. Lill brings to mind my failed hip hop career. very traumatic. Maybe I didn't get your oh so subtle intention there "Lilla", but it seems you are the one who has the problem with social cues. You criticize before you even acknowledge a point. A bit of counter-communication technique there? Simply admitting to being grouchy doesn't change anything to irony. You still sound aggressive. And the good news isthat I don't have to take you or leave you. I can just read what you post and choose to respond or not.You can react or not to what I post. We both have free will. Sorry to hear about your trauma with the hip hop though. Hope you can recover in time. Sounds horrific.
Peace Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Well this is an interesting thread. Let me weigh in as the current Negro-in-residence of Phatmass. And as one of the resident lawyers. I can see where both sides are coming from. I wasn't pleased with Ferguson. The account seemed rather fictitious to me. I doubted that there should have been a conviction in that case. And as a practical matter for people who care about police misconduct, I found it to be a bit unwise that people would use this case as one to attempt to bring attention to the issue. I think the guy was on camera robbing a store about 10 minutes before his encounter with the police. The problem is that when you have cases that seemingly should strike outrage and change - nobody seems to care. Take that Eric Garner case for example - a police ofificer kills someone on camera with a choke-hold for selling cigarettes - a jury sees no problem with it whatsoever - and the story gets a whole day and a half of media coverage? If the media decides to carry Furguson for whatever reason, it may not be a good case, but perhaps folks feel like they have to use whatever they can to bring attention to issues that are important to them. The issue that Lillabett raised is an example of a general pattern that we see in the USA. For the most part I agree with her. Trials should be neutral and concerned with discovering whether there is sufficient evidence to impose a remedy prescribed by law. But for the general public they often become vehicles for addressing larger social issues while ignoring the specifics of the incident at hand. For example, based on the evidence in the OJ Simpson trial, it is pretty clear that he should not have been convicted. There was no hard evidence against him. You have no eye-witnesses putting Simpson at the crime scene. You have no murder weapon. The first police officer on the scene and the prosecution's primary witness comitted purgury in front of the jury. The forensic investigation and subsequent handling of the chain of evidence was bungled beyond belief. "The glove didn't fit". And the legal burden of proof for a conviction in a criminal case is very high. But does anybody really care about any of that? Nope. Most black people were happy to see him go free because they saw it as vindicating their assertion of racism in the police force. I am not sure why most white people believe that he should have been convicted - but it certainly is not based on the evidence presented during the trial and legal standard used to convict. In the public-eye the trial was about racism in the police force, domestic violence, celebrity, inter-racial relationships and so forth . . . As a lawyer that is disconcerting, as it was with Furguson. Why does that happen? Again - I think it happens because we live in a country that still has significant issues that need to be addressed (such as police misconduct or racism in the criminal justice system) and that have not been given the attention that they deserve. When blacks try to raise the issue of police misconduct in a legitimate forum the reaction by many whites seems to be "Police Misconduct? What police misconduct? Things look fine to me. Stop whining and trying to bring up the race-card." So when issues that should be addressed in a legitimate way are ignored or downplayed, marginilized groups latch onto whatever they can in order to try to bring attention to the issues that they feel deserve attention. You can expect to continue to see things like that until the fundamental issues are addressed. Because is difficult for marginalized groups to effect needed change through institutions, while legitimate in most respects, that are biased againsed them, certain groups feel that their voices are not being heard and that the only way they can effect change is to boycott, riot, destroy, etc. You are destined to have chaos until you have a society in which there is fundamental justice at all levels. . . So I would say that if you want a system where your husband will not be treated with automatic suspicion by certain groups, just keep doing your best to try to make the system just at all levels. When people no longer percieve the criminal justice system as being biased, the chances of that happening to your husband become less and less . . . But, from a practical standpoint, I would not worry so much about your husband getting railroaded by the "lynch mob" if he should need to kill someone while on duty. That happens many hudrends of times per year in the USA, and it is extremely rare for a police officer to be even be prosecuted, let alone convicted. Out of the thousands of times that police officers have killed in the course of their duties, it seems that we get a Furgeson once every 5 or 10 years or so. Plenty of people might be suspicious about the police, or complain about them in the media, but rarely is there any concrete action taken against police officers. Perhaps that is part of the reason why when a case starts to get media attention, it tends to explode . . . And so endeth my ramble. . . Well this is an interesting thread. Let me weigh in as the current Negro-in-residence of Phatmass. And as one of the resident lawyers. I can see where both sides are coming from. I wasn't pleased with Ferguson. The account seemed rather fictitious to me. I doubted that there should have been a conviction in that case. And as a practical matter for people who care about police misconduct, I found it to be a bit unwise that people would use this case as one to attempt to bring attention to the issue. I think the guy was on camera robbing a store about 10 minutes before his encounter with the police. The problem is that when you have cases that seemingly should strike outrage and change - nobody seems to care. Take that Eric Garner case for example - a police ofificer kills someone on camera with a choke-hold for selling cigarettes - a jury sees no problem with it whatsoever - and the story gets a whole day and a half of media coverage? If the media decides to carry Furguson for whatever reason, it may not be a good case, but perhaps folks feel like they have to use whatever they can to bring attention to issues that are important to them. The issue that Lillabett raised is an example of a general pattern that we see in the USA. For the most part I agree with her. Trials should be neutral and concerned with discovering whether there is sufficient evidence to impose a remedy prescribed by law. But for the general public they often become vehicles for addressing larger social issues while ignoring the specifics of the incident at hand. For example, based on the evidence in the OJ Simpson trial, it is pretty clear that he should not have been convicted. There was no hard evidence against him. You have no eye-witnesses putting Simpson at the crime scene. You have no murder weapon. The first police officer on the scene and the prosecution's primary witness comitted purgury in front of the jury. The forensic investigation and subsequent handling of the chain of evidence was bungled beyond belief. "The glove didn't fit". And the legal burden of proof for a conviction in a criminal case is very high. But does anybody really care about any of that? Nope. Most black people were happy to see him go free because they saw it as vindicating their assertion of racism in the police force. I am not sure why most white people believe that he should have been convicted - but it certainly is not based on the evidence presented during the trial and legal standard used to convict. In the public-eye the trial was about racism in the police force, domestic violence, celebrity, inter-racial relationships and so forth . . . As a lawyer that is disconcerting, as it was with Furguson. Why does that happen? Again - I think it happens because we live in a country that still has significant issues that need to be addressed (such as police misconduct or racism in the criminal justice system) and that have not been given the attention that they deserve. When blacks try to raise the issue of police misconduct in a legitimate forum the reaction by many whites seems to be "Police Misconduct? What police misconduct? Things look fine to me. Stop whining and trying to bring up the race-card." So when issues that should be addressed in a legitimate way are ignored or downplayed, marginilized groups latch onto whatever they can in order to try to bring attention to the issues that they feel deserve attention. You can expect to continue to see things like that until the fundamental issues are addressed. Because is difficult for marginalized groups to effect needed change through institutions, while legitimate in most respects, that are biased against them, certain groups feel that their voices are not being heard and that the only way they can effect change is to boycott, riot, destroy, etc. You are destined to have chaos until you have a society in which there is fundamental justice at all levels. . . So I would say that if you want a system where your husband will not be treated with automatic suspicion by certain groups, just keep doing your best to try to make the system just at all levels. When people no longer percieve the criminal justice system as being biased, the chances of that happening to your husband become less and less . . . But, from a practical standpoint, I would not worry so much about your husband getting railroaded by the "lynch mob" if he should need to kill someone while on duty. That happens many hudrends of times per year in the USA, and it is extremely rare for a police officer to be even be prosecuted, let alone convicted. Out of the thousands of times that police officers have killed in the course of their duties, it seems that we get a Furgeson once every 5 or 10 years or so. Plenty of people might be suspicious about the police, or complain about them in the media, but rarely is there any concrete action taken against police officers. Perhaps that is part of the reason why when a case starts to get media attention, it tends to explode . . . And so endeth my ramble. . . LOL. How did I end up quoting myself? Read it twice please. It was that good.
puellapaschalis Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Can someone please explain to me what is going on? I can't fix anything if everything is worded in vague code. From my viewpoint, you are doing no better than those who you are complaining about. Solution anybody? The situation as I perceive it is that there is a core group of people - you, @dUst, and those who have been on Phatmass for a very long time. Some are Mediators of Meh and some are not (or are no longer). Your clique is so tight-knit that some in the group get a free pass on speaking charitably (which is the link I make with @Lilllabettt's OP) and on expression Catholic orthodoxy. That's what I mean by the Management Clique. This is the second post I've made in the last few months in which I've tried to word this. When I PM'd you, about a separate issue relating to my profile and account, I received no reply at all. So to tie in my concerns with those in the OP: rash judgement happens on Phatmass, and it gets overlooked because people know some of those doing it are 'important', long-standing members who are in with the boss.
Ice_nine Posted August 30, 2015 Posted August 30, 2015 Good post Peace. Heres my thing: "You people" think cops are guilty until proven innocent, just the way white people on a jury tend to think black men are guilty until proven innocent. My sweetie has to go to deal every day with "you people" --- people who hate him, think he is either up to no good or is about to be up to no good. My sweetie never did nothing to nobody. "You people" don't care. And if he got into trouble "you people" would assume he is guilty, no matter what. It's wrong. It's not Christian. I'm glad you understand privilege and worked with brown people yaddyadda that's all well and good. Why does it matter if I think a cop is guilty? It's just what I think. It literally does not matter and has no effect on any actual outcome. The structural inequality does not care about a few thousand/million people whining on the internet. We're just talking, making guesses and assumptions. I don't think the DOJ gives one beaver dam about all of that. No institution does. I think you're blowing this way the hell out of proportion. Did anyone claim to actually know what happened that day? We're all just using the information we have, and yes you ARE allowed to factor in a history of police brutality against black people when you're trying to figure out what went on. It's part of the puzzle. I don't know anything about your man. I question anyone though who chooses an occupation that is inherently violent and that permits you to use violence to enforce stupid, stupid laws and one that shows a stunning level of hypocrisy when it comes to enforcing laws amongst the populace vs. enforcing laws amongst their own. I'm allowed to do that, too even if you don't like it. Of course I concede that any given police officer may start out with noble intentions (maintaining those intentions in that environment is another story, but I'm sure it's possible), but I'm allowed to have my suspicions. Doesn't mean I'm 100% sure of anything. I deal with probabilities. Almost nothing is certain. You have a horse in this race, I get it. But you should probably take it down a few notches if you want to call people out for being un-Christian. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now