Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) You're right it is what it is. The Church used to say infants went to hell. Saints said that only a few are saved and the few will watch the majority in hell and even rejoice at their agony. Thankful I can come to know my Creator through a personal relationship and get to know Him intimately and not have to rely solely on what others say about Him. When I hear an authoritive person of the Church say 5 year olds are in hell I can have confidence to know this isn't the case. That infants aren't in hell. That God really does love humanity and didn't die the death He did so a few of the best Catholics of all time could make it to Heaven and everyone else could burn for eternity in hell. Including 5 year olds. I can know that The Gospel is Good News and not how 99 % of humanity burns forever in hell. Thank you Jesus. Thank you Mary. Thank you Father. Thank You Holy Spirit. Edited November 5, 2015 by Guest
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) "wow" lol love how this get turned around on me like I'm the one saying 5 year olds are damned to hell for eternity. That God kills an 8 and 12 year old right after their "first sin" before they can confess and they burn in hell for eternity. Nah that doesn't get a "wow" but me objecting to it does. lol Hilarious. Have a good one. Edited November 5, 2015 by Guest
Credo in Deum Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 "wow" lol love how this get turned around on me like I'm the one saying 5 year olds are damned to hell for eternity. That God kills an 8 and 12 year old right after their "first sin" before they can confess and they burn in hell for eternity. Nah that doesn't get a "wow" but me objecting to it does. lol Hilarious. Have a good one. You are clearly way too emotional and incapable of having a rational conversation about this subject. You have also failed to show how the sermon in the video is incompatible with the Catholic Faith and the Justice of God. All we have heard from you thus far is your emotional ramblings about a God you claim is being portrayed in the sermon vs. what is actually being said, and a God of your own making who apparently is obligated to forgive at least one mortal sin or more, depending on your level of presumption.
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) You are clearly way too emotional and incapable of having a rational conversation about this subject. You have also failed to show how the sermon in the video is incompatible with the Catholic Faith and the Justice of God. All we have heard from you thus far is your emotional ramblings about a God you claim is being portrayed in the sermon vs. what is actually being said, and a God of your own making who apparently is obligated to forgive at least one mortal sin or more, depending on your level of presumption. Rational to you is 5 year olds grinding their teeth for all of eternity in hell then calling it "God's Justice". That's the Good News of the Gospel to you. I'm glad Jesus has shown me this isn't who He is. Or I would of became an atheist a long time ago. Edited November 5, 2015 by Guest
NadaTeTurbe Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 I did not read the whole thread, but even when they're approved, catholic are not bound to believe in private revelation and apparition.
Credo in Deum Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 Rational to you is 5 year olds grinding their teeth for all of eternity in hell then calling it "God's Justice". That's the Good News of the Gospel to you. I'm glad Jesus has shown me this isn't who He is. Or I would of became an atheist a long time ago. The good news of the Gospel to me is a God whom I should neither sin against His mercy by despairing, nor sin against His Justice by presumption. Presumption is what the sermon is addressing, and why we should never commit this sin. The belief that God is obligated to forgive serious mortal sins, whether they be 1-infinite, is presumption. Forgiveness is a gift, and God is not obligated to extend this gift, especially if we reject it by being unrepentant. No healthy relationship has ever worked on presumption. No one would ever expect someone they love to have to put up with an unlimited number of grevious offenses especially when the person committing them isn't sorry. That type of relationship is abusive and unjust, but yet you apply it towards God and then accuse Him of being unjust and uncharitable if He won't be treated like a doormat?! It's scary when a sermon by a saint who is a Doctor of the Church is no longer met with our consideration but rather with accusations of the material as being misguided, ignorant, nonsense, and brainwashing. A true indication of the times we live in when Catholic's are scandalized by a sermon with sound Catholic material. That should be what makes us pause and reflect.
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) Blah Blah Blah I'm objecting against 5 year olds in hell tortured for all of eternity. I'm objecting the idea of God where He allows an 8 year old to commit her "first sin" then suddenly die and be tortured for eternity in hell. I'm objecting the idea that God doesn't forgive me anymore after 5 sins. I'm allowed to object horrible and toxic ideas. God gave me a brain for a reason. but yet you apply it towards God and then accuse Him of being unjust and uncharitable if He won't be treated like a doormat?! You're to much. Me doubting the notion God allows 5 year olds to be tortured in hell for eternity is a work of the Holy Spirit. I deserve a pat on the back. Go ahead and keep believing 5 year olds are abusing God and He has just become a doormat to these evil little kids. Catholics are amesome. Just got done reading a bunch of Facebook post attacking the Pope as usual and some lunatic going on about how aborted babies have no hope of being with God. I love hope. It's so prevalent among the best Catholics of all time. Edited November 5, 2015 by Guest
Credo in Deum Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) Blah Blah Blah I'm objecting against 5 year olds in hell tortured for all of eternity. I'm objecting the idea of God where He allows an 8 year old to commit her "first sin" then suddenly die and be tortured for eternity in hell. I'm objecting the idea that God doesn't forgive me anymore after 5 sins. I'm allowed to object horrible and toxic ideas. God gave me a brain for a reason. Yes, God did give you a brain for a reason, so may know Him. Yet you seem to close your brain off when it comes time to know a God who's ways are not your ways and who's thoughts are not your thoughts. You should get that checked. You object to a 5 year old in hell but you have faild to produce a coherent objection to the revelation other than your emotional ramblings which seem to amount to the view that you believe people who commit mortal sin should get free pass simply because of their age, and that you think we are owed God's forgiveness. Edited November 5, 2015 by Credo in Deum
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 5 year olds don't commit mortal sin. You're not to bright are you? And get over yourself saying I don't know God. I guarantee you I know God. I know Him enough to instantly know 5 year olds aren't in hell. You are a reason people become atheist. You should get that CHECKED.
Credo in Deum Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 5 year olds don't commit mortal sin. You're not to bright are you? Last time I checked there were three requirements for a sin to be mortal and an age limit was not listed as one of them. Sounds like you should brush up on your catechism, Josh.
Credo in Deum Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 You're a clown A Catholic Clown, get it right.
KnightofChrist Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 5 year olds don't commit mortal sin. You're not to bright are you? And get over yourself saying I don't know God. I guarantee you I know God. I know Him enough to instantly know 5 year olds aren't in hell. You are a reason people become atheist. You should get that CHECKED. When a five year old drowns their baby cousin to death because the baby wouldn't stop crying what kind of sin, if any do you think that is?
Benedictus Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 "wow" lol love how this get turned around on me like I'm the one saying 5 year olds are damned to hell for eternity. That God kills an 8 and 12 year old right after their "first sin" before they can confess and they burn in hell for eternity. Nah that doesn't get a "wow" but me objecting to it does. lol Hilarious. Have a good one. Josh - I see your point but I think you're getting caught up on emotive aspects of age and capacity. In times gone by people had to grow up faster and they expected more of them from a much younger age. They viewed children very differently in various periods of time. Most kids were put to work and took on responsibility as soon as they could be trained to do tasks. It wouldn't be unusual for a child from 5 years upwards to be an apprentice or have fairly extensive chore schedules. Private revelation would have been framed by the mindset of the time period and how those experiences were presented or used. The reality is only God knows whether a person has committed a mortal sin, it doesn't matter who they are. We can only work on the basis of our understanding of the remits of when a person has enough capacity to understand the implications of what they do and why. It can be a tricky area, even for adults, but there has to be some sort of scope or teaching, which we have, but there will always be exceptions on all parts of the spectrum. There probably could be a case to say anyone has some baggage or issue that prevents them having committed a mortal sin. That doesn't mean we shouldn't keep evaluating ourselves and trying to do better for the wrongs we do. Our own psyche and ego have a great capacity to distort and find reasons to let ouselves, and people we like, off the hook (but not people who do the same things if we dislike them or they hurt people we like ). It's tough for many people to believe young children can have the capacity to do some very bad things. However, there are young children that do such things, and it's not necessarily linked to something like conduct disorder. There have been cases of children doing arson, sibling/animal abuse, murder, lying, stealing etc. The two boys who abducted, tortured and killed a toddler in England in the 1990's (Bulger Killers) were only 9 or 10 years old at the time. They had done other stuff before that too, when they would have been even younger. Our own idea of whether anyone has capacity is relative to the action and the person concerned. It's often very situational and that's why it's important people, or family units, have an SD or confessor that knows them and can discern these sorts of things more clearly.
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 (edited) @KnightofChrist I would say that's the sin of some idiot low life parents who neglect a 5 year old and his baby cousin. Edited November 5, 2015 by Guest
KnightofChrist Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 I would say that's the sin of some idiot low life parents who neglect a 5 year old and his baby cousin. The parents had left the children with a teenage family member who fell asleep. Likely having no idea that the child would be so annoyed at the cry of a baby that they would kill the baby. So really the child is at no fault, committed no sin whatsoever? What about when a six year old gets into a fight with his friend, loses then runs home grabs a shotgun runs back to his friend and says "I'm going to shoot you" and then shoots and kills his friend, what sin if any did the six year old commit? What about an eight year old who killed three babies, one he strangled to death, the other two he beat to death, what sin if any did the eight year old commit? Or is again just the parents fault and the child is completely innocent of any sin?
Guest Posted November 5, 2015 Posted November 5, 2015 Josh - I see your point but I think you're getting caught up on emotive aspects of age and capacity. In times gone by people had to grow up faster and they expected more of them from a much younger age. They viewed children very differently in various periods of time. Most kids were put to work and took on responsibility as soon as they could be trained to do tasks. It wouldn't be unusual for a child from 5 years upwards to be an apprentice or have fairly extensive chore schedules. Private revelation would have been framed by the mindset of the time period and how those experiences were presented or used. The reality is only God knows whether a person has committed a mortal sin, it doesn't matter who they are. We can only work on the basis of our understanding of the remits of when a person has enough capacity to understand the implications of what they do and why. It can be a tricky area, even for adults, but there has to be some sort of scope or teaching, which we have, but there will always be exceptions on all parts of the spectrum. There probably could be a case to say anyone has some baggage or issue that prevents them having committed a mortal sin. That doesn't mean we shouldn't keep evaluating ourselves and trying to do better for the wrongs we do. Our own psyche and ego have a great capacity to distort and find reasons to let ouselves, and people we like, off the hook (but not people who do the same things if we dislike them or they hurt people we like ). It's tough for many people to believe young children can have the capacity to do some very bad things. However, there are young children that do such things, and it's not necessarily linked to something like conduct disorder. There have been cases of children doing arson, sibling/animal abuse, murder, lying, stealing etc. The two boys who abducted, tortured and killed a toddler in England in the 1990's (Bulger Killers) were only 9 or 10 years old at the time. They had done other stuff before that too, when they would have been even younger. Our own idea of whether anyone has capacity is relative to the action and the person concerned. It's often very situational and that's why it's important people, or family units, have an SD or confessor that knows them and can discern these sorts of things more clearly. Great post and great points. Thanks for taking the time to respond. I agree that young children are capable of evil things. My initial objection and why I started the thread was on the premise that a 8 year old girl dies unexpectedly and goes to hell to be tortured for all of eternity for taking the Lord's name in vain in the second grade. Not murdering anyone or drowing a baby. Then a Sermon gets posted about a 5 year old going to hell and being tortured for eternity for doing the same thing. In the same Sermon other examples are given of children committing their "first sin" and God allowing them to die unexpectedly and then sending them to hell to be tortured for eternity. And also the idea God stops forgiving after you mess up a certain amount of times. As little as five times possibly. Those were my objections. I understand that we have to confess our sins and that grave sins can become mortal and we have the capability to reject God's grace and die in mortal sin. I accept this leads to hell. What I don't expect is God is setting up little kids to fail or that God stops forgiving me after I confessed a sin a certain number of times. If I truly repent and try to change I'm forgiven.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now