KnightofChrist Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 When I read this thread I find myself wondering how some of the posters who are arguing with Josh relate to people in the real world. Josh is obviously out living in the real world, confronting battles every day, if I had to guess, with people who are in direct contradiction to the Church. Some of the people arguing with Josh seem to be approaching him in a way a theology major would debate a philosophy major. It's like two different worlds. One group is safe in an air-conditioned classroom, and the other is out on the front lines getting bloody--and the comfy students seem to be looking down upon the soldier. Just my take. Or from another perspective those of us that responded to Josh, even though we are fallen and imperfect human beings, did so out of love for our brother, out of love for the Church, and out of love for the Saints and Doctors of the Church. I admit that at first I did not reply to him in the best manner that I could. The way in which he made his statements to me was hurtful, hostile and emotional. I am use to being called "brainwashed" and having other extremely negative language directed towards me by those that are against the Church when I'm out there "on the front lines," but by not fellow Catholics. That did make me a little upset which is why in anger I said Josh was trash talking, but it is wrong to return negative emotion for negative emotion. Still I love Josh as my Christian brother and after thinking and praying about it I chose not to give up on him and attempted to talk to him in manner that wouldn't make the thread more emotional. But I don't believe others made the same mistake I did and they did their very best in a loving, calm and professional way to talk to Josh about the subject that was troubling him. Perhaps by responding in a calm and professional way is the reason you see it as some sort of theology or philosophy major? The trouble is that it is always very hard to speak to someone when they are hostile and emotional. It's hard to reason with them, it's hard to talk calmly with them because they can say things to or that push your buttons. Again I failed at first, but afterwards I did my best to focus on just the topic of mortal sin and hell itself. Because doing that prevented me from making the same mistake again I did not want to return anger for anger. I wanted to speak to Josh in the best most reasonable manner that I could, out of love and respect. Not like a lofty professor who strokes his bread and looks down from his pipe on with those whom he disagrees. As Catholics we're on the same side, we all have our struggles, we're on the battle lines together surrounded by the enemies of the Church, and we all live in the one real deal Holyfield world.
chrysostom Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 This is sort of off-topic, and piggybacking off KoC's post about emotions and conversation (so more general speculation and not about the current thread) but I do have to say I can find conflict very hard to deal with. I mean, NO one is going to say conflict is "easy". But there are some times when I recognize personality traits of mine that just don't mesh with someone else's, particularly in face-to-face conflict. If someone is mad at me I will often clam up inside. I would respond with perhaps the bare minimum of expression, and say what I need to say but with the minimum of words used. Sometimes this deflects potential conflict if the person is just lashing out a little or venting, in which case that is a positive outcome. But if their problem is with me in particular, my response appears to be utterly inadequate, which may or may not be true depending on the situation. At that point I will feel caught in a catch-22. My lack of outward emotional response (remember I'm clamming up inside!) will seem like I'm not taking them seriously, even if I'm technically saying the right words. This can make them more mad at me and I just clam up more. On the other hand, if I responded in a more "usual" way by raising my voice and gesticulating, etc (even though the words are the same in both cases), I know that their default response to that is also to fire shots right back and escalate. What's a guy to do? Now thankfully this almost never happens now, maybe once or twice in the last five years. It happened more during my early-to-mid teenage years. I've grown up a lot since then. Still, I recognize that it can still happen at some point in the future. I wonder if anyone has had similar experiences.
dUSt Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Not like a lofty professor who strokes his bread and looks down from his pipe on with those whom he disagrees. Are you talking about a culinary professor?
dominicansoul Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Not at all. Josh is a passionate person and does tend to react/post with intense emotions. He has posted a lot for a long time, so it should be easy for long time posters to read in context. Josh has a strong sense of mercy and judgement. He believes in God and Jesus. He was affronted and confused at what he interpreted as Saints espousing theological justice in harsh punishment towards children over what he sees as Jesus' love and mercy, particularly towards children. Eventually, patience, sympathy, and politeness communicated a more thorough and complete explanation to Josh. It's human nature to give too much credence to our perceptions that creates our reality. Josh wasn't fighting Orthodoxy as some perceived. He felt he was fighting for the Good News of Jesus. But this is Phatmass. I think people find attitude in others' words on the internet, when the attitude isn't intended. Josh started calling others "better Catholics than him" just for disagreeing with his outrage. I know that's definitely not my intention to come off to him as a "holier than thou" when I'm the worst sinner on phatmass. But like you said, this is phatmass, where misunderstandings abound and drama erupts over nothing. But at least it keeps people posting instead of having to wait hours and hours for some interaction on here...
Seven77 Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Thanks for getting my joke @Seven77 @dUSt Ha-- no problem, that's what I'm here for. I just can't get over the image of a man that looks like a pipe stove with glasses rubbing a freshly baked loaf and referring to it as “my precious." lol.
KnightofChrist Posted November 11, 2015 Posted November 11, 2015 Are you talking about a culinary professor? Hahaha, Freudian slip! I hadn't eaten all day and the whole time I was writing my last post out my stomach was shouting I want steak and a beer! But my wallet was saying you can afford a ham sandwich and a free glass of water. The bread on the sandwich was pretty good, as far as bread goes anyway. @dUSt Ha-- no problem, that's what I'm here for. I just can't get over the image of a man that looks like a pipe stove with glasses rubbing a freshly baked loaf and referring to it as “my precious." lol. Hey now I'd rather have bread than a beard, bread is easier to eat and not something you'd have to explain to a shrink.
Freedom Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 I agree Josh, personally I don't think we would find any children in hell, and there is even reason to hope it is entirely empty (besides the devil). Hope all you want, but it's not just the devil in hell…unfortunately I think people generally underestimate a child's capacity to do evil. If I recall correctly, Ted Bundy placed kitchen knives; surrounding them around his aunts bed while she was sleeping. He did this at the age of 3.
Norseman82 Posted November 12, 2015 Posted November 12, 2015 When I read this thread I find myself wondering how some of the posters who are arguing with Josh relate to people in the real world. Josh is obviously out living in the real world, confronting battles every day, if I had to guess, with people who are in direct contradiction to the Church. Some of the people arguing with Josh seem to be approaching him in a way a theology major would debate a philosophy major. It's like two different worlds. One group is safe in an air-conditioned classroom, and the other is out on the front lines getting bloody--and the comfy students seem to be looking down upon the soldier. Just my take. I understand what you are saying and have observed that a lot of Catholics use orthodoxy as a cover to act like "poster children for Massengill" and may be why we have studies that say that religious children are meaner than non-religious (there is a thread on that study). On the other side of the extreme, there are those that would use the same words you're using to try to discredit Catholic teaching as "out of touch" with the modern world.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now