blazeingstar Posted November 7, 2015 Posted November 7, 2015 Alot of these stories, are disgusting, assorted fiction. They are meant to scare people. There's another story floating around that there was a father who "welcomed" his daughter to hell at age 13 because she "chose" to continue the life of prositution that he sold her into. I think that some of these "visions" are tricks of the devil trying to get people to despair.
Credo in Deum Posted November 7, 2015 Posted November 7, 2015 (edited) Alot of these stories, are disgusting, assorted fiction. They are meant to scare people. There's another story floating around that there was a father who "welcomed" his daughter to hell at age 13 because she "chose" to continue the life of prositution that he sold her into. I think that some of these "visions" are tricks of the devil trying to get people to despair. I don't believe visions which have been approved by the Church and which come from her saints are tricks of the devil. Such a view would not be approved by the Church about a vision she Herself has approved. I think most of us need to ask ourselves if we have really been accepting of what the Church has taught about hell and the visions of her saints, or have we been going in an the opposite direction where the views we hold find no place in the Church' tradition? How many visions from the saints have been on the fewness of souls who are in hell? Where did our own savior say "narrow is the path, and straight the way, and many are those who find it"? Most people have an unrealistic view of God's mercy, and most of the time it is a view the leads to presumption. If we are despairing about what the saints said and what the Church approved, then maybe it is our outlook which needs correction and maybe the devil has worked his way into our lives in areas where we despair because we either don't won't to change or wrongly think change is impossible. Edited November 7, 2015 by Credo in Deum
veritasluxmea Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 I don't believe visions which have been approved by the Church and which come from her saints are tricks of the devil. Such a view would not be approved by the Church about a vision she Herself has approved. If you trace most, probably the majority of stories back to their source they aren't actually approved or come from a saint, or even a blessed or venerable. So it remains a possibility. I take such things with a gain of salt and look for the deeper meaning (hell is bad, don't sin).
Credo in Deum Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 If you trace most, probably the majority of stories back to their source they aren't actually approved or come from a saint, or even a blessed or venerable. So it remains a possibility. I take such things with a gain of salt and look for the deeper meaning (hell is bad, don't sin). If the vision is not approved by the Church, then I don't even bother listening to it.
MarysLittleFlower Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 I would agree on condition that God may grant us the time to repent, if he does and we are truly repentant and strive to sin no more, fighting against the temptation to sin God will forgive us each time. The trouble is however we know not the day nor hour of our death. We are not promised tomorrow, if we choose to sin we have no way of knowing if God will grant us the gift of life long enough for us to repent of our sins. I believe this is a matter of most importance to St. Alphonsus de Liguori when he states "Say not then, O sinner: "As God has forgiven me other sins, so He will pardon me this one if I commit it." Say not this; for, if to the sin which has been forgiven you add another, you have reason to fear that this new sin shall be united to your former guilt, and that thus the number will be completed, and that you shall be abandoned." It is folly to believe we can choose sin and just ask forgiveness later and everything will be ok. It reminds me somewhat of the parable in the Scriptures where a rich man had saved up all his riches and made plans on what to do with those riches (none of it included giving it to God) only to be told by God "Thou fool, this night do they require thy soul of thee." God may or may not give us a certain time to truly repent of our sins. For some as St. Alphonsus observes the amount of times can be few, Saul disobeyed God twice and with the second offense God abandoned Saul. But Saul's repentance was often in vain if memory serves Saul also repented or asked to be forgiven by David and God by extension various times only to quickly turn back to his attempts to kill David. There is also the sin that Onan committed, he refused to father a child by spilling his seed upon the ground. For that one sin God struck him down. In the New Testament Ananias and Sapphira lied to Saint Peter about selling a plot of land and both where struck down dead by God for the one lie. Thanks for the reply, I think what you describe sounds a lot like the sin of presumption... Of course, we should never sin presuming on repentance... Very dangerous and an insult to God's mercy It also refers to the Catholic understanding of predestination, by which all good things, all graces, come from God. This includes the grace necessary for repentance. If a person falls away and does not return, or if a person dies without repenting, it means two things. First, that the person sinned through their own will; it was not caused by God. Second, that God could have given additional grace to call that person to repentance, but did not choose to do so. And that choice was made in perfect justice and perfect love. All that is good comes from God. All that is evil comes from ourselves and from the Evil One. thanks for the reply, - I'm sure God is just and good in how He gives grace ..do you think a person might not be disposed to receive more grace if they dont?
Lilllabettt Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 The very idea of Hell is jarring, if you really think about it. I'm not sure even the worst sinner can grasp the concept of pain for all eternity, whether he has a firm understanding of mortal sin or not. We're so finite, our brain power is so limited, especially in comparison to the amesomeness of the Creator. What human being in his right mind would turn away from eternal happiness and love and choose eternal misery and torment? Even if he did choose it, does he really understand the gravity of his choice? sometimes, feeling bad feels good. that sounds nuts, but it's true for many people. Having experienced that kind of thing myself, I can believe that there may be people who feel good, feeling bad, in Hell. Feeling bad, feeling butthurt etc.,- these things exert a magnetic pull - which has to be resisted by main force. It's terribly heavy work, and I can see a lot of people not wanting to do it.
Norseman82 Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 (edited) After all the demons in hell were once angles in a state of grace. They thought they were right but were really obtuse. Edited November 8, 2015 by Norseman82
Credo in Deum Posted November 8, 2015 Posted November 8, 2015 They thought they were right but were really obtuse. Haha, darn iPhones.
Ice_nine Posted November 9, 2015 Posted November 9, 2015 merged Josh's apology thread with this one cuz i felt lyk it
Seven77 Posted November 9, 2015 Posted November 9, 2015 Alot of these stories, are disgusting, assorted fiction. They are meant to scare people. There's another story floating around that there was a father who "welcomed" his daughter to hell at age 13 because she "chose" to continue the life of prositution that he sold her into. I think that some of these "visions" are tricks of the devil trying to get people to despair. Sometimes in their exuberance, some Saints and spiritual writers use stories without verifying sources…. it would be interesting to find out where St. Gregory wrote the story. I wouldn't put this story on a level as the one you just mentioned though--- where did you read it it? I would be actually very surprised if a saint said that-- I very much doubt it.
dUSt Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 When I read this thread I find myself wondering how some of the posters who are arguing with Josh relate to people in the real world. Josh is obviously out living in the real world, confronting battles every day, if I had to guess, with people who are in direct contradiction to the Church. Some of the people arguing with Josh seem to be approaching him in a way a theology major would debate a philosophy major. It's like two different worlds. One group is safe in an air-conditioned classroom, and the other is out on the front lines getting bloody--and the comfy students seem to be looking down upon the soldier. Just my take.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 When I read this thread I find myself wondering how some of the posters who are arguing with Josh relate to people in the real world. Josh is obviously out living in the real world, confronting battles every day, if I had to guess, with people who are in direct contradiction to the Church. Some of the people arguing with Josh seem to be approaching him in a way a theology major would debate a philosophy major. It's like two different worlds. One group is safe in an air-conditioned classroom, and the other is out on the front lines getting bloody--and the comfy students seem to be looking down upon the soldier. Just my take. I am not sure how you can make that assumption without totally disregarding the experiences and backgrounds of everyone else here who disagrees with Josh's frequent overreactions. Have you seen my air-conditioned classroom?
dominicansoul Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 (edited) When I read this thread I find myself wondering how some of the posters who are arguing with Josh relate to people in the real world. Josh is obviously out living in the real world, confronting battles every day, if I had to guess, with people who are in direct contradiction to the Church. Some of the people arguing with Josh seem to be approaching him in a way a theology major would debate a philosophy major. It's like two different worlds. One group is safe in an air-conditioned classroom, and the other is out on the front lines getting bloody--and the comfy students seem to be looking down upon the soldier. Just my take. So calling people "brainwashed" and then not listening to explanations because they don't jive with his overreaction makes Josh a true soldier living out in the "real world?" got it... Edited November 10, 2015 by dominicansoul
dUSt Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 Have you seen my air-conditioned classroom? Nope. So calling people "brainwashed" and then not listening to explanations because they don't jive with his overreaction makes Josh a true soldier living out in the "real world?" Is this what you think I am saying? Like, for real? If so, I will reply. I am pretty sure that you do not think this is what I am saying though. Your reply seems more geared to a fight rather than an introspective observation.
dominicansoul Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 I thought this entire thread was started as a fight without introspective observation...
dUSt Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 You guys take my comments as you will. I was offering an outside looking in observation. If it makes you defensive, then please see it as an opportunity to become more like a saint.
Anomaly Posted November 10, 2015 Posted November 10, 2015 I thought this entire thread was started as a fight without introspective observation... Not at all. Josh is a passionate person and does tend to react/post with intense emotions. He has posted a lot for a long time, so it should be easy for long time posters to read in context. Josh has a strong sense of mercy and judgement. He believes in God and Jesus. He was affronted and confused at what he interpreted as Saints espousing theological justice in harsh punishment towards children over what he sees as Jesus' love and mercy, particularly towards children. Eventually, patience, sympathy, and politeness communicated a more thorough and complete explanation to Josh. It's human nature to give too much credence to our perceptions that creates our reality. Josh wasn't fighting Orthodoxy as some perceived. He felt he was fighting for the Good News of Jesus. But this is Phatmass.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now