Guest Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 (edited) to slow spread of Zika. Thoughts? Edited February 19, 2016 by Guest
NadaTeTurbe Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 Didn't Pope Benedict authorized condoms for prostitutes ?
Not A Real Name Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 4 minutes ago, Josh said: to slow spread of Zika. Thoughts? 2 minutes ago, NadaTeTurbe said: Didn't Pope Benedict authorized condoms for prostitutes ? Source?
NadaTeTurbe Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/22/world/europe/22pope.html for pope Benedict. It's in "Light of the world" (first book by Pope Benedict that I read and it is SO SO great).
KnightofChrist Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 2 minutes ago, NadaTeTurbe said: Didn't Pope Benedict authorized condoms for prostitutes ? No, he did not authorize condoms for prostitutes. He said: There may be a basis in the case of some individuals, as perhaps when a male prostitute uses a condom, wherethis can be a first step in the direction of a moralisation, a first assumption of responsibility, on the way toward recovering an awareness that not everything is allowed and that one cannot do whatever one wants. But it is not really the way to deal with the evil of HIV infection. That can really lie only in a humanisation of sexuality.
Peace Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 The question of whether/when condom use is "acceptable" for sex outside of marriage is kind of an open one I think. You are already sinning to start with. I think that there could be some situations (for example, a husband cheating on his wife with a prostitute and using a condom so that he does not risk giving his wife HIV or some other disease) where the use of a condom could be the "right" thing to do. Another example might be the case of rape. Using a contraceptive drug to prevent pregnancy in that situation might be acceptable.
DominicanHeart Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 The virus is a scary thing. Something needs to fix it
Nihil Obstat Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 https://canonlawblog.wordpress.com/2016/02/18/seven-quick-thoughts-on-the-most-recent-papal-presser/ Seven quick thoughts on the most recent papal presser February 18, 2016 Frankly, I don’t know how he does it. When I fly to Europe I have to sleep all the way over. Not Pope Francis. Anyway, may I offer some comments on some topics mentioned in the latest mid-air papal presser? 1. Pope Paul VI, as I understand it, did approve of religious women threatened by rape using contraceptives. It is obvious, though, that such measures were taken in self-defense against criminal acts and, more importantly, would have occurred outside the context of conjugalrelations. Avoiding pregnancy under outlaw circumstances is not only ‘not an absolute evil’, it’s not an evil act at all. I hope that mentioning this unusual episode in a press chat will not contribute unduly to the world’s misunderstanding of the limitations of Paul VI’s position in this case and of the episode’s non-applicability to firm Church teaching on contraception within marriage. 2. An individual becomes “Christian” by, and only by, (valid) baptism. Donald Trump was apparently baptized Presbyterian, which faith community has valid baptism. Donald Trump is, therefore, as a matter of canon law (c. 204), Christian. Trump might be a good Christian or a bad one—I cannot say, and neither can anyone else. Trump might do and say things consistent with Christian values or in contradiction to them, but his status as baptized, and therefore as Christian, is beyond dispute. 3. There is no legitimate “principle” by which a “lesser of two evils” mayever be licitly engaged in. It is fundamental moral theology that even a small evil action may never be licitly engaged in—no matter how much good might seem to result therefrom and no matter how much evil might seem to be avoided thereby. There are, to be sure, principles by which a good or neutral action that has two effects, one good and one evil, might be licitly engaged in under certain circumstances despite the evil effects; and there are principles by which “lesser evils” may be tolerated(not chosen). But parsing these matters accurately and responsibly requires more time than can be devoted to them in a press conference. 4. Abortion (assuming we are talking about doing an action intended to kill a human being prior to birth, and not just suffering ‘abortion’, i.e., miscarriage) is, Francis observed, always evil. Abortion is not, however, “evil” because it is a “crime”. Not all criminal acts are by nature evil and not all evil acts are crimes. Other factors must be considered lest moral principles and legal principles become confused. 5. The Vatican City State, a sovereign nation, has the right to build, and has chosen to surround itself with, a giant wall. Evidently, building or using a national wall is not a non-Christian act nor a stance contrary to Gospel values. The pope’s criticism of building walls on part of a national border is probably better understood as prudential in nature, not principled. 6. It is important (though some might say it is too late) to distinguish between a Catholic’s stance toward “same-sex unions” and that toward “same-sex marriage”. These are not equivalent terms. Legal recognition of “same-sex unions” might be a good idea, a tolerable idea, or a bad idea, but, per se, “same-sex unions” are things over which reasonable minds (including Catholic minds) may differ; in contrast, Catholics may never approve or support “same-sex marriage”, this, upon pain of contradicting infallible Church teaching, if not of committing heresy. 7. The pope said nothing suggesting confusion about “celibacy” and “continence” (c. 277), although the Crux reporter seems to regard the former as another word for the latter. Anyway, I do not know whether there is such a thing as a (priest) who does not have the “friendship of a woman”, but I would not think the “friendship of a woman” is necessary to make a man ‘complete’. 16 minutes ago, DominicanHeart said: The virus is a scary thing. Something needs to fix it Yeah, good thing the entire world has Planned Parenthood to protect everyone from scary junk!
Not A Real Name Posted February 19, 2016 Posted February 19, 2016 1 hour ago, DominicanHeart said: The virus is a scary thing. Something needs to fix it Don't worry. Once they've obtained their fear objective, Zika will go the way of Ebola.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 Look, we should not beat around the bush here. IF the pope said that couples could licitly use contraceptives to avoid children during this health scare, THEN the pope was wrong. Perhaps he misunderstood, perhaps he misspoke. Perhaps he was inculpable for the mistake, and perhaps he did not say it at all. I certainly hope that is not what he said. But IF what he said is as I described above, THEN he is wrong, period. Do not let yourself be deceived. We cannot afford further weakening of Catholic moral teaching.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 Lifesitenews appears to confirm by way of Fr. Lombardi that the Pope did say what he was reported as saying. Big surprise. I will reiterate, IF the pope said that contraceptive use could be licit in this case, THEN the pope is wrong.
Peace Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 34 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: Lifesitenews appears to confirm by way of Fr. Lombardi that the Pope did say what he was reported as saying. Big surprise. I will reiterate, IF the pope said that contraceptive use could be licit in this case, THEN the pope is wrong. Sources please. That was my general impression of what has been taught by various popes, but I do not know if there are any dogmatic statements that would completely rule out contraception to prevent the spread of diseases such as HIV. What about the case where one married spouse contracts HIV, say through a blood transfusion? Apparently the only option for the other spouse is A) contract this deadly disease yourself and risk having your children get it too, or B) never have sex again. I am not entirely convinced that the Church would rule out contraception in this situation, but if you have something directly on point I will consider it. The point of using the condom here is to prevent the transmission of disease during sex. They are not using it to prevent pregnancy, although that is the consequence.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 Basic moral philosophy totally prohibits it. If contraception is inherently evil, then no reason justifies its use. That would be consequentialism. There are three relevant considerations in evaluating the moral quality of an act. These are the moral object, the intent, and the circumstances. The moral object, the active blocking of fertility, is inherently evil, and a defective moral object renders the entire act evil. The intent and circumstances are considerations which are subordinate to the moral object, though I would argue that the intent is at least suspect if not totally irredeemable. But even if the intent were irreproachably pure, the defective moral object makes the intent not strictly relevant in terms of the act's permissibility. Veritatis Splendor lays this out nicely. Please read that rather than taking my word for it, convincing though I may be.
Spem in alium Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 The pope said that avoiding pregnancy is not an absolute evil and suggested it could be practiced by people in areas at risk of Zika. He said nothing about contraception being okay, and there are other, natural ways of avoiding pregnancy which are licit: natural family planning and abstinence being two of them. Of course, though, his words are more likely to be read as supporting the use of contraception, partly because that is what many people want to hear. I do think though that if he did not intend to come across in this way, there should be some sort of clarifying statement. It seems rather ambiguous and difficult to arrive at an exact understanding.
MarysLittleFlower Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 (edited) 19 hours ago, Peace said: The question of whether/when condom use is "acceptable" for sex outside of marriage is kind of an open one I think. You are already sinning to start with. I think that there could be some situations (for example, a husband cheating on his wife with a prostitute and using a condom so that he does not risk giving his wife HIV or some other disease) where the use of a condom could be the "right" thing to do. Another example might be the case of rape. Using a contraceptive drug to prevent pregnancy in that situation might be acceptable. My understanding is that if the pill can cause contraception (simply if couple is not celibate), its not allowed even if the intent is something else. I checked with a priest known for orthodoxy and he confirmed. (I wouldn't advise the pill even to celibate people though cause its very unhealthy to take it and a person may get used to it and have a hard time quitting if they marry). I assume its the same with condoms. If someone has a serious reason to avoid pregnancy or has HIV their only option is periodic continence or complete abstinence (depending on what it is). It may sound harsh ..I fully believe a person can live a full meaningful life being celibate. 3 hours ago, Spem in alium said: The pope said that avoiding pregnancy is not an absolute evil and suggested it could be practiced by people in areas at risk of Zika. He said nothing about contraception being okay, and there are other, natural ways of avoiding pregnancy which are licit: natural family planning and abstinence being two of them. Of course, though, his words are more likely to be read as supporting the use of contraception, partly because that is what many people want to hear. I do think though that if he did not intend to come across in this way, there should be some sort of clarifying statement. It seems rather ambiguous and difficult to arrive at an exact understanding. Hmm maybe he meant abstinence? I hope it would be clarified. As we know the Church allows that for sufficient reasons.. 6 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: Basic moral philosophy totally prohibits it. If contraception is inherently evil, then no reason justifies its use. That would be consequentialism. There are three relevant considerations in evaluating the moral quality of an act. These are the moral object, the intent, and the circumstances. The moral object, the active blocking of fertility, is inherently evil, and a defective moral object renders the entire act evil. The intent and circumstances are considerations which are subordinate to the moral object, though I would argue that the intent is at least suspect if not totally irredeemable. But even if the intent were irreproachably pure, the defective moral object makes the intent not strictly relevant in terms of the act's permissibility. Veritatis Splendor lays this out nicely. Please read that rather than taking my word for it, convincing though I may be. That seems to be what I was taught too. What about the comment on Pope Paul VI and rape? Edited February 20, 2016 by MarysLittleFlower
Peace Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 7 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: Basic moral philosophy totally prohibits it. If contraception is inherently evil, then no reason justifies its use. That would be consequentialism. There are three relevant considerations in evaluating the moral quality of an act. These are the moral object, the intent, and the circumstances. The moral object, the active blocking of fertility, is inherently evil, and a defective moral object renders the entire act evil. The intent and circumstances are considerations which are subordinate to the moral object, though I would argue that the intent is at least suspect if not totally irredeemable. But even if the intent were irreproachably pure, the defective moral object makes the intent not strictly relevant in terms of the act's permissibility. Veritatis Splendor lays this out nicely. Please read that rather than taking my word for it, convincing though I may be. I am not so convinced that the use of a condom or other contraceptive means is intrinsically evil. Let's take the case of rape as an example. The Church says that even in the case of rape, once there has been conception, abortion cannot occur. That is because abortion is an intrinsic evil. Can't be done under any circumstances. But can a rape victim use a contraceptive drug to prevent conception? Can a woman who is being raped ask the rapist to wear a condom? If the answer to either of these questions is "yes" which some people seem to suggest, then I think it is pretty clear that the use of a condom by itself is not intrinsically evil. What makes the use of a condom evil is the specific purpose for which the condom is used - specifcially, the use of a condom by a married couple for the specific purpose of preventing pregnancy. So can you then make an argument that if the condom is used not to prevent pregnacy, but to prevent the spread of some disease like HIV from one person to another, that the double effect test is satisfied? I think you can make a reasonable argument. For example: http://marccortez.com/2010/11/23/the-pope-condoms-and-the-principle-of-double-effect/ To determine whether PDE applies to this scenario, we must see if the scenario meets the following conditions: The Nature of the Act: The act in question must be at least a morally neutral act (i.e. it cannot be an intrinsically bad act). Means-End: The bad effect cannot be the means by which the good effect is accomplished. Right-Intention: The bad effect cannot be that which is intended by the actor. Proportionality: The good effect must be equivalent to or greater than the corresponding bad effect. And, as I see it, the condom-use scenario meets all four conditions. The Nature of the Act: It seems to me that even for Catholic theologians, condom use is a morally neutral act. In and of itself, using a condom has no moral consequences (e.g. using it as a water balloon). It is one particular result of using a condom (preventing conception and, consequently, separating the sexual act from its procreative function) that is instrinsically wrong. Means-End: As in most PDE scenarios the good effect and bad effect are inseparable. Wearing a condom during the sexual act (assuming that the condom does not malfunction) necessarily results in both consequences. But, it seems clear that the bad effect in this situation is not the means for accomplishing the good effect – i.e., a person does not seek to separate the sexual act from its intended purposes as a means to preventing the spread of a deadly disease. The two consequences are inseparable, but the one is not the means for accomplishing the other. Right-Intention: This is critical. For this situation to come under PDE, the actor must intend the good effect and not the bad one. So, in this scenario, the person using the condom must intend to stop the spread of a deadly disease and not to prevent procreation. Proportionality: The benefit of preventing the spread of a deadly disease must outweigh the drawback of separating the sexual act from its procreative function. As with most PDE scenarios, there is a strong element of subjectivity in this final step. But, it is certainly not obvious that this scenario violates this condition. Now, I am not saying that the above analysis is correct. I think you can put forth a good argument that the test is not satisfied as well. But I think the matter is still an open question within the Church. I don't think that there are any dogmatic statements that compel the conclusion that condoms cannot be used as a means to stop the spread of a disease (although many in the Church have suggested this). I don't think there are any papal encyclials that really address the issue head on, either. Humanae vitae was written well before the AIDS outbreak and I don't think it was really written with that modern problem in mind. Another hypothetical for you - let's say that one spouse has contracted HIV through a blood transfusion and that the other spouse has not yet contracted it. By some miracle of technology, a new condom is created that is a fiddler of sorts. This new condom prevents the HIV virus from being transmitted, while at the same time not preventing contraception. It fiddlers out HIV but does not fiddler semen. Can the couple use the condom? Sure they can. They are using the condom not to prevent contraception, but to prevent the spread of disease. Let's say that they use this new condom during intercourse, but for whatver reason one time it does not work properly and has the unintended consequence of preventing conception. Have they sinned because the condom did not work and had the unintended consequence of preventing pregnancy? I don't think they have sinned in this scenario. If technology has not yet developed and they are left with a regular condom, I do not know if they have sinned if they choose to use it for the purpose of preventing the transmission of HIV from one spouse to anohter, if their intent is not to stop contraception and they would have otherwise used the new condom were it available. Sure, you can make some distinctions between the two scenarios, but I think there is at least a decent argument that they are morally equivalent, as long as there is no specific intent to stop procreation, and as long as the use of a condom itself is not wrong in every circumstance. . . I do think it is kind of an open question for the Church, and perhaps there will be a new encyclical in the future that addresses the question head on . . . *fiddler not fiddler* LOL. Why does Phatmass automatically change Fi-L-ter to "Fiddler"?
Guest Posted February 20, 2016 Posted February 20, 2016 (edited) I started listening to Catholic AM radio a few weeks ago after seeing a bumper sticker. I've enjoyed it although it's challenging sometimes not to turn it off out of frustration. It gets intense and challenges the way I think about things. They were going on and on about this this morning. I thought Patrick Madrid and this other guy were going overboard. Talking about a possible schism and misrepresenting what this female caller was trying to say. They were extremely dogmatic and legalistic and saying things like the gates of hell won't prevail and 2000 years of Church teaching. I understand this response and respect it. It was tough to listen to though. They would not budge on understanding how it could be in parents loving nature not to want to intentionally set out to have children that would be affected by this virus. I'm not saying they aren't right for arguing it the way they did but there was no discussing this with them. Edited February 20, 2016 by Guest
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now