Peace Posted February 22, 2016 Posted February 22, 2016 (edited) I do feel like the HIV infected prostitute makes the moral decision when she decides to use a condom though, especially if her intent is to stop transmission of the disease. I do think that a different framework should apply to situations like that, where there is a sinful context in which the actors are operating in, in the first place. It kinds of seems that the traditional framework that is applied when deciding whether an action is moral has a set of assumptions that don't apply to the context in which the prostitute question is raised. The question seems likely to remain in the realm of academia though. Even though it might be the moral choice for a HIV infected prostitute to use a condom, the Church can't exactly get into the business of teaching people how to sin the least badly. Edited February 22, 2016 by Peace
Spem in alium Posted February 23, 2016 Posted February 23, 2016 Just thought I'd share: http://americamagazine.org/content/all-things/pope-francis-zika-and-contraception
Nihil Obstat Posted February 24, 2016 Posted February 24, 2016 Interesting article run by Rorate today. Whether or not you like Rorate should be irrelevant; in this article they simply publish verbatim an open letter written by Fr. Richard Cipolla, who as I understand it is a pastor at St. Mary's parish in Norwalk, Connecticut. I will link and copy/paste it here with no comment. http://rorate-caeli.blogspot.com/2016/02/dear-pope-francis-parish-priest-writes.html "Dear Pope Francis" - A parish priest writes to the Pope following the confusion caused by his recent interview Dear Pope Francis: I write this letter to you as a priest to the Bishop of Rome and as a son to a father. I write with a heavy heart, and I know that heaviness of heart is shared by many of my Catholic brethren both clergy and laity. I watched the early news one morning last week to find that one of the headlines proclaimed that in an interview on the flight from Mexico to Rome you indicated that the Church’s teaching on contraception may be undergoing a change. As in the past, I went to the official translation of the interview to ascertain what you said. You never said that the teaching contained in Humane Vitae is no longer part of Church teaching. But you did speak about contraception not being an absolute evil and then went on to offer an example concerning Paul VI’s allowing nuns to use contraceptives because they were in danger of rape, which, even if that were the case, is a context quite different from marriage. You must be able to see how secular reporters could take your words and jump to the conclusion that your words were a signal that the Church’s teaching on the moral evil of contraception is undergoing a change toward a more permissive view. Dear Pope Francis, you are not a good teacher in these situations. Teaching the truth about good and bad is a difficult task in a secular and self-centered world. It requires both clarity and nuance, neither of which was present in any of the conversations you had with the reporters. Often when I am perplexed or disheartened I turn to the writings of Blessed John Henry Newman. Please allow me to send you the two following passages from his writings that I believe would be of great benefit to you and to all who are commissioned to teach the Catholic faith in an authentic manner. The first quote is from Newman’s Letter to the Duke of Norfolk, that amazing work in which Newman talks about conscience and its relationship to the teaching of the Church, specifically the teaching of the Petrine Office. "The sense of right and wrong, which is the first element in religion, is so delicate, so fitful, so easily puzzled, obscured, perverted—so biased by pride and passion, so unsteady in its course, that, in the struggle for existence amid the various exercises and triumphs of the human intellect this is at once the highest of all teachers, yet the least luminous." Dear Pope Francis, what Newman is telling you and me is that teaching right and wrong is very difficult and must be approached with great humility and careful use of reason. Emotion and off-the –cuff remarks have no place in the teaching of right and wrong, and certainly no place in random remarks with reporters who are much more savvy than you are on how to get headlines in the morning news. The second quote from Newman is from Development of Christian Doctrine, which some consider his magnum opus. This section deals with the need for Revelation in matters of faith and moral and the teaching role of the Church. "The common sense of mankind…feels that the very idea of revelations implies a present informant and guide, and that an infallible one; not a mere abstract declaration of Truths unknown before to man, or a record of history, or the result of an antiquarian research, but a message and a lesson speaking to this man and that…We are told that God has spoken. Where? In a book? We have tried it and it disappoints; it disappoints us, that most holy and blessed gift, not from any fault of its own, but because it is used for a purpose for which it was not given. The Ethiopian’s reply, when St. Philip asked him if he understood what he was reading, is the voice of nature: “How can I, unless some man shall guide me?” The Church undertakes that office." The teaching Office of the Church is as important as Scripture. We do not believe in sola scriptura. And you, Pope Francis, are the head of that Teaching Office. But you are not the Church. You are the Pope, the Supreme Teacher of the Church. But you are not the Church, nor can the Church be reduced to you alone. The latter error of reductionism is embraced not only by worldly reporters but also by faithful Catholics. This is the result of the transformation of the papacy in the past fifty years into a world super star, which transformation is a deformation in the development of the doctrine of the papacy. That you bear the burden of the Supreme Teacher of the Church in an unbelieving world is the reason why you are loved by the Catholic faithful and are the object of their prayers. But please remember that your burden is the burden of the Cross, and therefore you must always be seen as a sign of contradiction by the world, such that when the world sees you and hears you, they see through you to the Cross of Jesus Christ and the love and mercy of God that the Cross shows forth. Please accept a piece of filial advice from a humble priest. Make a long, silent retreat this Lent and do what has to be done to listen to the God who is not heard in earthquake, storm or fire but in a tiny whispering sound. Yours faithfully, Father Richard G. Cipolla
Peace Posted February 24, 2016 Posted February 24, 2016 Is he implying that Pope Francis believes that he alone is the Church? It certainly seems that way. Not a good thing to accuse someone of.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 24, 2016 Posted February 24, 2016 7 minutes ago, Peace said: Is he implying that Pope Francis believes that he alone is the Church? It certainly seems that way. Not a good thing to accuse someone of. I did not really glean that from the letter at all, personally.
Peace Posted February 24, 2016 Posted February 24, 2016 2 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: I did not really glean that from the letter at all, personally. His way of writing makes it ambiguous. He could have written "many people might make the mistake of reducing the Church to you alone" but instead he writes "But you are not the Church alone". There is no reason to tell someone, in a direct letter, that he is not XYZ unless you presume that the person views himself as XYZ. But that is just how I read it.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 24, 2016 Posted February 24, 2016 1 minute ago, Peace said: His way of writing makes it ambiguous. He could have written "many people might make the mistake of reducing the Church to you alone" but instead he writes "But you are not the Church alone". There is no reason to tell someone, in a direct letter, that he is not XYZ unless you presume that the person views himself as XYZ. But that is just how I read it. Oh, that part. Well I am seeing that as the author referring to the tendency of quite a few modern Catholics to simply treat the person of the pope as the be-all and end-all of Catholicism, and I think he is inferring that this tendency is both contributing to and being contributed to by Pope Francis' 'interview magisterium'.
Peace Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 2 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: Oh, that part. Well I am seeing that as the author referring to the tendency of quite a few modern Catholics to simply treat the person of the pope as the be-all and end-all of Catholicism, and I think he is inferring that this tendency is both contributing to and being contributed to by Pope Francis' 'interview magisterium'. Maybe. I dunno man. I don't think all of that needs to be said in public. Do you know if that was a private letter that got leaked somehow, or did he just post it on the internet?
Nihil Obstat Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 (edited) 32 minutes ago, Peace said: Maybe. I dunno man. I don't think all of that needs to be said in public. Do you know if that was a private letter that got leaked somehow, or did he just post it on the internet? I do not think Rorate is really known for leaks, although I guess one could ask. I believe this priest has written for them before. (EDIT: A quick check, which I had missed before, indicates that Fr. Cipolla is actually the one who posted the article.) There is merit in open letters. Whether or not it is warranted in this case is really more a reflection of your belief as to whether or not the situation itself is worthy of concern, more so than whether the idea of the letter itself is problematic. Paul corrected Peter publicly. Edited February 25, 2016 by Nihil Obstat
Peace Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 (edited) 23 minutes ago, Nihil Obstat said: I do not think Rorate is really known for leaks, although I guess one could ask. I believe this priest has written for them before. (EDIT: A quick check, which I had missed before, indicates that Fr. Cipolla is actually the one who posted the article.) There is merit in open letters. Whether or not it is warranted in this case is really more a reflection of your belief as to whether or not the situation itself is worthy of concern, more so than whether the idea of the letter itself is problematic. Paul corrected Peter publicly. I dunno. Somtimes I think it would be better for Pope Francis to speak with greater clarity too. I don't think that the gravity of a subject makes it more appropriate for an open letter. I might think that my neighbor needs to stop cheating on his wife. That is serious. That doesn't mean my rebuke should be more amenable to a public letter than by rebuking him privately. In this particular case, what do you think is the benefit of making the lecture public? It adds a greater shame factor therefore the Pope is likely to speak more clearly in the future? Somehow I doubt that. The letter to me just seems like something else that will cause division among traditionalists and us attenders of the NO. But I guess the open letter is cool. Letting folks speak their mind does seem to be something that Pope Francis encourages. Edited February 25, 2016 by Peace
Nihil Obstat Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 3 minutes ago, Peace said: I dunno. Somtimes I think it would be better for Pope Francis to speak with greater clarity too. I don't think that the gravity of a subject makes it more appropriate for an open letter. I might think that my neighbor needs to stop cheating on his wife. That is serious. That doesn't mean my rebuke should be more amenable to a public letter than by rebuking him privately. In this particular case, what do you think is the benefit of making the lecture public? It adds a greater shame factor therefore the Pope is likely to speak more clearly in the future? Somehow I doubt that. The letter to me just seems like something else that will cause division among traditionalists and us attenders of the NO. But I guess the open letter is cool. Letting folks speak their mind does seem to be something that Pope Francis encourages. Well, I think that the rationale would be that since the issue itself is public and affects essentially all Catholic laypersons, it should likewise be addressed in a public manner. Ideally through a clarification - and some would argue an unqualified retraction - from Pope Francis. So it is a public response to a public comment, requesting a public action. To me that makes sense, and in no way does it detract from the value and prudence of private correction.
Peace Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 1 minute ago, Nihil Obstat said: Well, I think that the rationale would be that since the issue itself is public and affects essentially all Catholic laypersons, it should likewise be addressed in a public manner. Ideally through a clarification - and some would argue an unqualified retraction - from Pope Francis. So it is a public response to a public comment, requesting a public action. To me that makes sense, and in no way does it detract from the value and prudence of private correction. I see. I guess I didn't read it as him asking Pope Francis to issue a correction. I thought the main jist was "take your job as a teacher more seriously and speak more clearly." I didn't see the need to go into all of that publicly. If he just wrote "I think what you wrote about contraception was wrong and here are my reasons why" I would be cool with it. But then again, if he went down that route, he would have to explain why Pope Francis is wrong, and that becomes more difficult (see the debate in this thread).
Nihil Obstat Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 39 minutes ago, Peace said: I see. I guess I didn't read it as him asking Pope Francis to issue a correction. I thought the main jist was "take your job as a teacher more seriously and speak more clearly." I didn't see the need to go into all of that publicly. If he just wrote "I think what you wrote about contraception was wrong and here are my reasons why" I would be cool with it. But then again, if he went down that route, he would have to explain why Pope Francis is wrong, and that becomes more difficult (see the debate in this thread). I kind of read that as implied or even entailed, just from my perspective within the traditionalist milieu.
Amppax Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 2 hours ago, Nihil Obstat said: I do not think Rorate is really known for leaks, although I guess one could ask. I believe this priest has written for them before. (EDIT: A quick check, which I had missed before, indicates that Fr. Cipolla is actually the one who posted the article.) There is merit in open letters. Whether or not it is warranted in this case is really more a reflection of your belief as to whether or not the situation itself is worthy of concern, more so than whether the idea of the letter itself is problematic. Paul corrected Peter publicly. The only thing I dislike about this kind of open letter is that it is a priest taking it upon himself to publicly correct the Pope. I think something like this is more appropriate from a Cardinal or Bishop. Then again, if I'm remembering correctly, Catherine of Siena rebuked the Pope of her own time, and she was lay. I don't remember if that was a public or private correction. So I suppose my initial take is that I have no problem with the correction per se, simply a problem with who's making it.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 22 minutes ago, Amppax said: The only thing I dislike about this kind of open letter is that it is a priest taking it upon himself to publicly correct the Pope. I think something like this is more appropriate from a Cardinal or Bishop. Then again, if I'm remembering correctly, Catherine of Siena rebuked the Pope of her own time, and she was lay. I don't remember if that was a public or private correction. So I suppose my initial take is that I have no problem with the correction per se, simply a problem with who's making it. Yeah, I understand that. But at some point a priest like this one must think to himself "yeah, a cardinal should be the one who does this, but none have." Not sure there would be a hard and fast rule as to when that becomes a valid concern, but certainly eventually that fact becomes relevant.
StMichael Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 On February 19, 2016 at 6:22:29 PM, Nihil Obstat said: Look, we should not beat around the bush here. IF the pope said that couples could licitly use contraceptives to avoid children during this health scare, THEN the pope was wrong. Perhaps he misunderstood, perhaps he misspoke. Perhaps he was inculpable for the mistake, and perhaps he did not say it at all. I certainly hope that is not what he said. But IF what he said is as I described above, THEN he is wrong, period. Do not let yourself be deceived. We cannot afford further weakening of Catholic moral teaching. Would give this props, but being moderated now for 4 months for no reason whatsoever. Regardless, Pope Francis, and I quote from Father Jonathan Morris who is seen regularly on TV, "is a handful."
Amppax Posted February 25, 2016 Posted February 25, 2016 http://www.ncregister.com/daily-news/popes-comments-on-contraception-in-accord-with-magisterium-philosophers-say/#.Vs-HHVsrLC1 Presented simply as further interesting commentary on the issue. Peace and Nihil, you'll note that Fr. Gahl (the philosopher in question) teaches at Santa Croce, like some of the other scholars I had mentioned.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now