InHisLove726 Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='USAirwaysIHS' post='1945743' date='Aug 10 2009, 08:26 PM']No it isn't. How could a website on the intertrons be made completely of iron? Preposterous. [/quote]
Theologian in Training Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1945628' date='Aug 10 2009, 06:26 PM']I'm flattered, but I'm not sure I even know what makes me tick.[/quote] So, it begs the question: what happened? This is not meant to be a debate, just a chance to explain yourself, if you so desire.
Fidei Defensor Posted August 11, 2009 Author Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1945943' date='Aug 10 2009, 10:07 PM']So, it begs the question: what happened? This is not meant to be a debate, just a chance to explain yourself, if you so desire.[/quote] My downfall was the doubts. I have always been interested in science. Everything would make sense and could be explained somehow. I accepted that belief in God was a matter of faith, and for a while, I was okay with it. But as time went on, the doubts plagued me and I couldn't be happy because my days were consumed with the doubts. Everywhere and everything was a stake in my belief. To compensate for this, I elected to walk away from it all to give my mind a rest. For me, making an official exit meant I didn't have to ponder the question anymore. I had intentions of revisiting the topic eventually, but I still haven't reached the point at which I want to do so.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1945965' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:30 AM']My downfall was the doubts. I have always been interested in science. Everything would make sense and could be explained somehow. I accepted that belief in God was a matter of faith, and for a while, I was okay with it. But as time went on, the doubts plagued me and I couldn't be happy because my days were consumed with the doubts. Everywhere and everything was a stake in my belief. To compensate for this, I elected to walk away from it all to give my mind a rest. For me, making an official exit meant I didn't have to ponder the question anymore. I had intentions of revisiting the topic eventually, but I still haven't reached the point at which I want to do so.[/quote] Speaking as a natural skeptic (believe me, my faith doesn't amount to a single molecule of mustard, let alone a seed, but I want to believe, I choose to believe), I hope that you do revisit the topic. It is so difficult to want to understand so much...skeptics don't have bad intentions, they just want to be secure in their understanding, but I think that pride comes in as an unintended fault and begins to work on a person so that unless they understand everything, unless they have absolute, tangible proof, they are plagued with the temptation to doubt. As Cardinal Ratzinger pointed out in "Introduction to Christianity," a person can see the beauty and glory of the faith as a castle, and a person to may see how well-constructed that castle is and have great faith in it, but then ask the existential question: what is the castle standing on? Is there really even a castle? How can I know? How can I be sure? Can I trust my senses? Can I trust my logic and reasoning? Can I trust anything? I believe, despite the fact that this believe is constantly the subject of scrutiny in my mind and heart, that the self-doubting existentialism of modern philosophy, while technically a valid question ("does it all really exist? Can I know anything aside from cogito ergo sum?"), is a fool's venture. At some point, philosophers and skeptics have to accept that they can't prove everything is real or that the premises upon which they base their conclusions are grounded in reality. At some point, they have to say, "I'm going to trust my reason and my senses with some self-criticism, but only constructive self-criticism, because to question everything will only waste time and never lead me to real answers." What kind of life does doubt produce? Only one of despair and misery. Eventually a person prone to doubt must decide to let it go and have faith or to live as if life has no meaning. Those are the only two paths that lay before the skeptic. Now, trusting that our rationale is, to the greatest extent of our ability, reasonable, then I think Christianity not only makes the greatest sense of any philosophy or religion, taking into account both a realistic evaluation on all counts of human nature, but also a miraculous and breathtaking view of the infinite, boundless destiny of human potential in God...not only is Christianity the most reasonable, but it is also the most beautiful, appealing to the soul in a greater way than all the masterpieces of the world. That is why I chose to believe...yes, there is always the question in the back of my mind whether it is all true or not, but I'm not going to waste my time on such a meaningless quest as that. Christianity makes sense with my understanding of the world. That's good enough for me. Does that mean that Christianity is a subjective matter? No, I believe not. I believe that everyone would see the world in essentially the same way, a way in which Christianity makes great sense, if people were honest with themselves and didn't second-guess everything. In any event, I don't think the right approach to the temptation to doubt is to avoid the sacraments and stop professing the faith. I think to cut ourselves off from the Church is to do great damage to an already damaged mind. I think instead we must throw ourselves to God's mercy and beg for faith and the courage to trust that the minds He gave us are capable of real understanding. God bless, Micah
Resurrexi Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Raphael' post='1945986' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:46 AM']Speaking as a natural skeptic (believe me, my faith doesn't amount to a single molecule of mustard, let alone a seed, but I want to believe, I choose to believe), I hope that you do revisit the topic. It is so difficult to want to understand so much...skeptics don't have bad intentions, they just want to be secure in their understanding, but I think that pride comes in as an unintended fault and begins to work on a person so that unless they understand everything, unless they have absolute, tangible proof, they are plagued with the temptation to doubt. As Cardinal Ratzinger pointed out in "Introduction to Christianity," a person can see the beauty and glory of the faith as a castle, and a person to may see how well-constructed that castle is and have great faith in it, but then ask the existential question: what is the castle standing on? Is there really even a castle? How can I know? How can I be sure? Can I trust my senses? Can I trust my logic and reasoning? Can I trust anything? I believe, despite the fact that this believe is constantly the subject of scrutiny in my mind and heart, that the self-doubting existentialism of modern philosophy, while technically a valid question ("does it all really exist? Can I know anything aside from cogito ergo sum?"), is a fool's venture. At some point, philosophers and skeptics have to accept that they can't prove everything is real or that the premises upon which they base their conclusions are grounded in reality. At some point, they have to say, "I'm going to trust my reason and my senses with some self-criticism, but only constructive self-criticism, because to question everything will only waste time and never lead me to real answers." What kind of life does doubt produce? Only one of despair and misery. Eventually a person prone to doubt must decide to let it go and have faith or to live as if life has no meaning. Those are the only two paths that lay before the skeptic. Now, trusting that our rationale is, to the greatest extent of our ability, reasonable, then I think Christianity not only makes the greatest sense of any philosophy or religion, taking into account both a realistic evaluation on all counts of human nature, but also a miraculous and breathtaking view of the infinite, boundless destiny of human potential in God...not only is Christianity the most reasonable, but it is also the most beautiful, appealing to the soul in a greater way than all the masterpieces of the world. That is why I chose to believe...yes, there is always the question in the back of my mind whether it is all true or not, but I'm not going to waste my time on such a meaningless quest as that. Christianity makes sense with my understanding of the world. That's good enough for me. Does that mean that Christianity is a subjective matter? No, I believe not. I believe that everyone would see the world in essentially the same way, a way in which Christianity makes great sense, if people were honest with themselves and didn't second-guess everything. In any event, I don't think the right approach to the temptation to doubt is to avoid the sacraments and stop professing the faith. I think to cut ourselves off from the Church is to do great damage to an already damaged mind. I think instead we must throw ourselves to God's mercy and beg for faith and the courage to trust that the minds He gave us are capable of real understanding. God bless, Micah[/quote]
Kitty Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1945965' date='Aug 10 2009, 11:30 PM']My downfall was the doubts. I have always been interested in science. Everything would make sense and could be explained somehow. I accepted that belief in God was a matter of faith, and for a while, I was okay with it. But as time went on, the doubts plagued me and I couldn't be happy because my days were consumed with the doubts. Everywhere and everything was a stake in my belief. To compensate for this, I elected to walk away from it all to give my mind a rest. For me, making an official exit meant I didn't have to ponder the question anymore. I had intentions of revisiting the topic eventually, but I still haven't reached the point at which I want to do so.[/quote] This is almost exactly how I feel as well. I've also noticed, since I have not been attending church for several months now, and really have not been dwelling on religion, that my depression has gotten considerably better, compared to last year.
Ash Wednesday Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Raphael' post='1945986' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:46 AM']a person can see the beauty and glory of the faith as a castle, and a person to may see how well-constructed that castle is and have great faith in it, but then ask the existential question: what is the castle standing on? Is there really even a castle? How can I know?[/quote] What's a castle?
Winchester Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [img]http://piggington.com/files/images/zoolander-mugatu-crazy-pills.jpg[/img]
Fidei Defensor Posted August 11, 2009 Author Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Raphael' post='1945986' date='Aug 10 2009, 11:46 PM']Speaking as a natural skeptic (believe me, my faith doesn't amount to a single molecule of mustard, let alone a seed, but I want to believe, I choose to believe), I hope that you do revisit the topic. It is so difficult to want to understand so much...skeptics don't have bad intentions, they just want to be secure in their understanding, but I think that pride comes in as an unintended fault and begins to work on a person so that unless they understand everything, unless they have absolute, tangible proof, they are plagued with the temptation to doubt. As Cardinal Ratzinger pointed out in "Introduction to Christianity," a person can see the beauty and glory of the faith as a castle, and a person to may see how well-constructed that castle is and have great faith in it, but then ask the existential question: what is the castle standing on? Is there really even a castle? How can I know? How can I be sure? Can I trust my senses? Can I trust my logic and reasoning? Can I trust anything? I believe, despite the fact that this believe is constantly the subject of scrutiny in my mind and heart, that the self-doubting existentialism of modern philosophy, while technically a valid question ("does it all really exist? Can I know anything aside from cogito ergo sum?"), is a fool's venture. At some point, philosophers and skeptics have to accept that they can't prove everything is real or that the premises upon which they base their conclusions are grounded in reality. At some point, they have to say, "I'm going to trust my reason and my senses with some self-criticism, but only constructive self-criticism, because to question everything will only waste time and never lead me to real answers." What kind of life does doubt produce? Only one of despair and misery. Eventually a person prone to doubt must decide to let it go and have faith or to live as if life has no meaning. Those are the only two paths that lay before the skeptic. Now, trusting that our rationale is, to the greatest extent of our ability, reasonable, then I think Christianity not only makes the greatest sense of any philosophy or religion, taking into account both a realistic evaluation on all counts of human nature, but also a miraculous and breathtaking view of the infinite, boundless destiny of human potential in God...not only is Christianity the most reasonable, but it is also the most beautiful, appealing to the soul in a greater way than all the masterpieces of the world. That is why I chose to believe...yes, there is always the question in the back of my mind whether it is all true or not, but I'm not going to waste my time on such a meaningless quest as that. Christianity makes sense with my understanding of the world. That's good enough for me. Does that mean that Christianity is a subjective matter? No, I believe not. I believe that everyone would see the world in essentially the same way, a way in which Christianity makes great sense, if people were honest with themselves and didn't second-guess everything. In any event, I don't think the right approach to the temptation to doubt is to avoid the sacraments and stop professing the faith. I think to cut ourselves off from the Church is to do great damage to an already damaged mind. I think instead we must throw ourselves to God's mercy and beg for faith and the courage to trust that the minds He gave us are capable of real understanding. God bless, Micah[/quote] Thank you for the very thoughtful response. [quote name='Kitty' post='1945999' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:18 AM']This is almost exactly how I feel as well. I've also noticed, since I have not been attending church for several months now, and really have not been dwelling on religion, that my depression has gotten considerably better, compared to last year.[/quote] Yeah, I neglected to mention that part. I also go through cycles of depression, which doesn't make anything easier.
MissyP89 Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='fidei defensor' post='1945965' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:30 AM']My downfall was the doubts. I have always been interested in science. Everything would make sense and could be explained somehow. I accepted that belief in God was a matter of faith, and for a while, I was okay with it. But as time went on, the doubts plagued me and I couldn't be happy because my days were consumed with the doubts. Everywhere and everything was a stake in my belief. To compensate for this, I elected to walk away from it all to give my mind a rest. For me, making an official exit meant I didn't have to ponder the question anymore. I had intentions of revisiting the topic eventually, but I still haven't reached the point at which I want to do so.[/quote] As someone who goes through that same skepticism every day without fail, I've got to know: are you [i]happy?[/i] Sometimes, I find myself so overwhelmed by doubts and the (negative) consequences my faith has had on interpersonal relationships in my life, that I get smothered and feel the need to walk away for a season, and clear my mind. I haven't, though. Deep down, I know myself, and I know I'd feel completely empty if not for my faith. Sure, I'd get some things back perhaps, but I'd lose my reason to have hope. And that smells of elderberries, too. Sometimes, it feels like a lose-lose. I'd rather stay; at least I know I have tools to stay afloat here. Take your time approaching it again...one of the nice things about God is that He's so patient while we work things out. I hope you don't mind if I pray for you--maybe it'll help me, too.
tinytherese Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 Have either of you tried counseling for the depression?
Hassan Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1946174' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:51 PM']As someone who goes through that same skepticism every day without fail, I've got to know: are you [i]happy?[/i] Sometimes, I find myself so overwhelmed by doubts and the (negative) consequences my faith has had on interpersonal relationships in my life, that I get smothered and feel the need to walk away for a season, and clear my mind. I haven't, though. Deep down, I know myself, and I know I'd feel completely empty if not for my faith. Sure, I'd get some things back perhaps, but I'd lose my reason to have hope. And that smells of elderberries, too. Sometimes, it feels like a lose-lose. I'd rather stay; at least I know I have tools to stay afloat here. Take your time approaching it again...one of the nice things about God is that He's so patient while we work things out. I hope you don't mind if I pray for you--maybe it'll help me, too. [/quote] This is why I could never be religious. If your faith were a purely private matter that would be one thing. But all of the Orthodox versions of the major monotheistic religions demand that their followers restrict the rights and liberties of other people. Like your Church and gay marriage. If you don't know, or at least have very strong rational grounds for your faith then how can you be part of the meddling in the lives of others? I'm not kidding when I say this is a major reason why I would not allow myself to return to religion. It just seems irresponsible to needlessly interfere in the liberties of others for an ideology you have adopted or maintained because it gives you "hope".
MissyP89 Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 (edited) Who, me? It's not really like that...it never lasts, and I can shake it off within a few days. I'm too stubborn to stay down for long. Edited August 11, 2009 by MissyP89
MissyP89 Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Hassan' post='1946178' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:56 PM']This is why I could never be religious. If your faith were a purely private matter that would be one thing. But all of the Orthodox versions of the major monotheistic religions demand that their followers restrict the rights and liberties of other people. Like your Church and gay marriage. If you don't know, or at least have very strong rational grounds for your faith then how can you be part of the meddling in the lives of others? I'm not kidding when I say this is a major reason why I would not allow myself to return to religion. It just seems irresponsible to needlessly interfere in the liberties of others for an ideology you have adopted or maintained because it gives you "hope".[/quote] Sweetie, don't go saying I interfere with the lives of others. I don't--hell, I barely talk about my faith out in the real world. Please don't lump me in with others that believe it their responsibility to shove their religion down the throats of others. (And if I'm totally reading you wrong, have mercy--I'm still having my coffee right now. )
Winchester Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Hassan' post='1946178' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:56 PM']This is why I could never be religious. If your faith were a purely private matter that would be one thing. But all of the Orthodox versions of the major monotheistic religions demand that their followers restrict the rights and liberties of other people. Like your Church and gay marriage. If you don't know, or at least have very strong rational grounds for your faith then how can you be part of the meddling in the lives of others? I'm not kidding when I say this is a major reason why I would not allow myself to return to religion. It just seems irresponsible to needlessly interfere in the liberties of others for an ideology you have adopted or maintained because it gives you "hope".[/quote] Every group demands this, regardless. Every individual demands this. I'm certain you do, as well. You find your coercion acceptable, is all.
Hassan Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='MissyP89' post='1946181' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:00 PM']Sweetie, don't go saying I interfere with the lives of others. I don't--hell, I barely talk about my faith out in the real world. Please don't lump me in with others that believe it their responsibility to shove their religion down the throats of others. (And if I'm totally reading you wrong, have mercy--I'm still having my coffee right now. )[/quote] I'm sorry. I didn't mean to make it seem like you were shoving your religion down other people's throats. However your religion does seem to work to limit the rights of others. In that it seems to require its members to oppose things like gay marriage. Even if you personally don't work for this you are lending support to the religion which as a whole does oppose things like the state recognition of gay marriage. I don't mean to make this sound like an accusation. You seem like a nice person. There are many wonderful people here. However they all seem to be willing to either directly or indirectly limit the rights of other, curb their ability to pursue their dreams and goals, on the basis of a "faith", an ideology which they accept because it gives their lives meaning or hope or whatever. That seems to me to be wrong and irresponsible. I'm sure you are a better person than I am. So I don't mean to make it seem as though I'm suggesting such people are just selfish or morally bankrupt. I just think in this particular area it is selfish and irresponsible. I just don't understand how that doesn't bother more people of faith.
Hassan Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Winchester' post='1946184' date='Aug 11 2009, 12:05 PM']Every group demands this, regardless. Every individual demands this. I'm certain you do, as well. You find your coercion acceptable, is all.[/quote] Every group and attempt to regulate society does inhibit the liberty of others. I think there, is a difference between making the best decision possible based on the evidence available, while admitting personal fallibility, and making such a decision based on an ideology not based on evidence but based on a personal need. Like hope or life direction. That doesn't apply to all religious people. But if you simply adopt the faith for personal needs and that faith demands limitations be placed on the rights of others I don't know what you call that other than irresponsible. It doesn't just apply to religions. I'd say the same about a dogmatic Marxist who adopts Marxism because it satisfies some emotion hole in his life.
MissyP89 Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='Hassan' post='1946190' date='Aug 11 2009, 01:13 PM']I'm sorry. I didn't mean to make it seem like you were shoving your religion down other people's throats. However your religion does seem to work to limit the rights of others. In that it seems to require its members to oppose things like gay marriage. Even if you personally don't work for this you are lending support to the religion which as a whole does oppose things like the state recognition of gay marriage. I don't mean to make this sound like an accusation. You seem like a nice person. There are many wonderful people here. However they all seem to be willing to either directly or indirectly limit the rights of other, curb their ability to pursue their dreams and goals, on the basis of a "faith", an ideology which they accept because it gives their lives meaning or hope or whatever. That seems to me to be wrong and irresponsible. I'm sure you are a better person than I am. So I don't mean to make it seem as though I'm suggesting such people are just selfish or morally bankrupt. I just think in this particular area it is selfish and irresponsible. I just don't understand how that doesn't bother more people of faith.[/quote] Understood. I know you know this, but it all hinges on our concept of objective good and sin being the deviation of that objective good--the natural law. It's sort of like society limits [i]your[/i] right to run around naked. That would probably be really freeing and all, but the natural law--and in this case, civil law as well--prohibits it. But, I digress. We're hijacking. You can start a new thread, if you wanted...
Fidei Defensor Posted August 11, 2009 Author Posted August 11, 2009 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1946177' date='Aug 11 2009, 10:54 AM']Have either of you tried counseling for the depression?[/quote] Yes. I'm taking things one day at a time and I've been doing well.
Katholikos Posted August 11, 2009 Posted August 11, 2009 Anyone with a scientific bent would do well to read [i]The Science Before Science, A Guide to Thinking in the 21st Century.[/i] The author is Anthony Rizzi, a theoretical physicist and founder of the Institute for Advanced Physics. Dr. Rizzi is a renowned scientist --he solved a problem in Einstein's theory that had gone unanswered for 80 years. He is also a committed Catholic. This book teaches the art of clear thinking, so lacking in our society. Also recommended reading is John Paul the Great's Fidei et Ratio (Faith and Reason). Science and Reason have the same source -- they both come from the mind of God. Katholikos, ex-Southern Baptist, ex-agnostic, ex-atheist, ecstatic to be Catholic!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now