Faithful heart Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 We pray for souls in purgetory, is it ok to pray for the souls in hell? Will any amount of prayer free them from the clutches of satan? Are they all doomed, end of story?
Dave Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 Souls in hell are stuck there, unfortunately. However, souls in hell hated God while on earth, and in hell they hate Him even more. So even if it were possible for souls in hell to repent and go to heaven, they still wouldn't choose to do so.
kdewolf2 Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 C.S. Lewis said the gate to hell was locked from the inside.
vianney Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 I wouldnt say the souls in hell hate God. The souls in hell will NEVER get out. The souls on Earth didnt neccesarily hate God either they just didnt follow his laws. If I die with a mortal sin on my soul tommrow does that mean that I hate God. NO does it mean I am going to hell? YES CS Lewis description of it was good.
Uncle Gus Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 Just as in heaven, we are perfected in virtue, in hell we are perfected in vice. We are stripped of our "image of God"ness, we become demonic in nature. In hell, yes, we hate God.
Aloysius Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 but we didn't necessarily hate him on earth, as we were not perfected in vice that makes sense.
Theologian in Training Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 Just to play "angel's advocate" and to take a more "pastoral" approach. What about the person who was in the state of mortal sin, was not well-educated in the faith, knew about confession, but never confessed, and merely went to Church because his family went, and died suddenly? Do you really tell their spouse or children that he went to Hell and is damned for eternity? Remember, I am merely playing angel's advocate, and don't want to be attacked for it. It is something that becomes more of a reality the more people you meet, especially in a parish setting. God Bless
Jake Huether Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 Just as in heaven, we are perfected in virtue, in hell we are perfected in vice. We are stripped of our "image of God"ness, we become demonic in nature. In hell, yes, we hate God. Exactly. That reminds me of, Matthew 13:12 Whoever has will be given more, and he will have an abundance. Whoever does not have, even what he has will be taken from him.
BlueRose Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 I'm starting to get annoyed with the Catholic Church. I'm tired of hearing constant, "You'll go to hell if you.." and "You'll go to hell if you don't...". Are all my Baptist friends going to hell because they don't go to confession? How about the Jews and the Non-Denominational's and on and on...? Question: Is it a Mortal Sin when you commit a sin but know you are wrong in the process of doing it? (I'm not clear on this...) Well if that's true, then do you HAVE to confess it to a priest in order to get into heaven? Say you're sorry but don't confess it? Are you going to hell then? This whole thing irks me.
ironmonk Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 I'm starting to get annoyed with the Catholic Church. I'm tired of hearing constant, "You'll go to hell if you.." and "You'll go to hell if you don't...". Are all my Baptist friends going to hell because they don't go to confession? How about the Jews and the Non-Denominational's and on and on...? Question: Is it a Mortal Sin when you commit a sin but know you are wrong in the process of doing it? (I'm not clear on this...) Well if that's true, then do you HAVE to confess it to a priest in order to get into heaven? Say you're sorry but don't confess it? Are you going to hell then? This whole thing irks me. The Catholic Church was built by Christ and has the keys to the kingdom. If you feel that you are getting annoyed with the Church, then it would be because of misunderstanding... read a little Catechism each day... it will help... http://www.USCCB.org There are three things for something to be mortal. Please see http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14004b.htm#III The Catholic Church does not say anyone is going to hell. If someone dies with mortal sin, their soul is in grave danger... but we do not know why they commited that mortal sin. Who goes to hell is up to God... people from all faiths can be saved on the day of Judgement. God's mercy is beyond our knowledge. I hope this helps in your understanding, if you would like some other links that directly reflect the teachings, let me know... Here is one more link: http://www.catholic-pages.com/dir/last_things.asp (Heaven, Hell, & Purgatory) God Bless, Your Servant in Christ, ironmonk
Jake Huether Posted November 10, 2003 Posted November 10, 2003 I'm starting to get annoyed with the Catholic Church. I'm tired of hearing constant, "You'll go to hell if you.." and "You'll go to hell if you don't...". Are all my Baptist friends going to hell because they don't go to confession? How about the Jews and the Non-Denominational's and on and on...? Question: Is it a Mortal Sin when you commit a sin but know you are wrong in the process of doing it? (I'm not clear on this...) Well if that's true, then do you HAVE to confess it to a priest in order to get into heaven? Say you're sorry but don't confess it? Are you going to hell then? This whole thing irks me. Short answer to your question, YES. In order for a sin to be Mortal, it has to be an objectively mortal sin, you must know that, and you must do it. Edit: - See the site Ironmonk posted for the more accurate response. If you are ignorant of the fact that it was mortal, then it wasn't a mortal sin that you commited. However, if you later come to realize that it was, then yes you should confess it. And, frankly, I don't see where you're comin' from. We are the furtherst from telling people "you're goin' to hell..." Catholics don't pass judgment on people, only sins. If we say someone is going to hell, it is conditional. And the conditions are such that the three points above must be met + the person would have to be unrepentant when they die. We can say for sure, in general, that if a person dies in mortal sin without confessing they are goin' to hell. But to say for instance that Hitler is "for sure" in hell, is wrong. We can't make that judgment, because we don't know if he repented, nor do we know if he was ignorant as to the mortality of the sins he was commiting.
BlueRose Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 Thanks guys for your reply. I think I have a better understanding of this hell business. Just a few more questions. Ironmonk - I read that link about mortal sins, etc. Not all but most. Is it basically saying that a mortal sin is something that you do that is purposely against God or one of his children? Wow, it's still confusing. I mean I get it but then I wonder, "ok so what about this? and this?" Like maybe calling up a former-friend and chewing him/her out for being rotten to you when maybe it would have been best to leave it alone. Wouldn't that be a venial sin? Or even a sin at all? Hmm... Also, about confession. Say you have a sin on your heart but you go to confession and don't confess it aloud, but are still sorry. Is it absolved? Or if you don't say specifically what it is but make a generalization, like saying that you've committed the sin of greed or hatred or of lust, and keep in special mind the PARTICULAR sin - is it the same? Hmm - good thing about the Cahtolic Church: It is a lot like a family. You can get mad at it, but it won't cast you away for doing so. Instead it continues to teach.
Faithful heart Posted November 11, 2003 Author Posted November 11, 2003 So, do any of you pray for the souls in hell. Would that be against God to do so? Are people in hell just demons out for no good? I know how people get to hell, I am confused about how we should feel about them.
IcePrincessKRS Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 Also, about confession. Say you have a sin on your heart but you go to confession and don't confess it aloud, but are still sorry. Is it absolved? Or if you don't say specifically what it is but make a generalization, like saying that you've committed the sin of greed or hatred or of lust, and keep in special mind the PARTICULAR sin - is it the same? You are supposed to confess all your sins. I recall, as a kid, learning from the Balitmore Catechism (maybe some of you all remember them?) The chapter that covered confession showed a boy going into the confessional, his arms laden with boxes. The next picture he comes out, but instead of all those boxes being gone, he still has all of them plus one more because he did not confess all of his sins. There is another boy who goes in and comes out free of boxes, having confessed everything. The point of relating this is that we cannot deliberately not confess a sin that we know we've committed. Forgetting a sin is one thing, but not confessing it on purpose is another. I honestly am not sure if we aren't forgiven for the sins we do confess, but I do believe (I don't know, but I believe) that when we purposly refuse to confess a sin we are committing another sin. Its like lying to the priest, and while he won't know we are holding back and it isn't necessarily hurting him any, it IS hurting our souls. If my opinion here is somehow theologically unsound I know I'll will be corrected by one of our resident Smart People and of course I will conform my belief to the Church's teaching. But what I've stated above is what I've always been taught. Obviously those images made a big impression on my little 7 year old mind if I still remember them 15 years later!
IcePrincessKRS Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 So, do any of you pray for the souls in hell. Would that be against God to do so? Are people in hell just demons out for no good? I know how people get to hell, I am confused about how we should feel about them. In a way, I guess we should feel sorry for them... but they also brought it upon themselves. Our prayers don't do anything to relieve their suffering like they do for the souls in purgatory. There's really nothing we can do for them. We can't say for sure who is in hell, but as I said, we know that we cannot do anything for them. Pray for the souls in purgatory. They need our prayers, and they will pray for us as well, returning the favor. Does that help at all?
Donna Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 (edited) Faithful Heart, Even if we were to pray for souls in hell, it would do them no good. Ditto with Satan. He and the damned have already been judged. This is an irreversible sentence: to spend eternity as one has lived their life. That is the objective means by which we speculate about the fate of any deceased: how did they live their life? A story about a plane going down: The priest aboard said, "Call to mind your sins!" so as to give general absolution. Well, some did invoke the mercy of God w/ all their heart. But others cursed and wailed against God the moment before the end. Please God that we all die a happy and holy death, in the state of grace. And yet there are deathbed conversions and who knows what happens the last second of life? Only God. The moment of our death is the most important in our lives and the Church (Good Mother that she is) does not lie to us, and does not let us forget our inevitable fate of death, and that we must prepare for it. Every Hail Mary pleads for the Mother of God to intercede for us "at the hour of our death." God does not send anyone to hell. People choose to serve under the banner of Him, or not. In John, Chapter one it says of Jesus: "In Him was the light and the light was the life of men [meaning man/woman]... This is the true light, that enlighteneth every man come into the world... [which means all are given sufficient grace to be saved]. "...He came unto His own , but they received Him not..." [so it really is up to each individual where their life and eternity is spent]. Our response should be that of the seers of Fatima, esp. Blessed Jacinta Marto, pre-occupied with the vision of hell Our Lady showed these young children. Our Lady at Fatima said to the three: "You have seen hell where the souls of poor sinners go. To save them, God wishes to establish in the world devotion to my Immaculte Heart." And also: "Pray, pray much and make sacrifices for sinners who have no one to pray for them," [thus the easier to be led to hell]. "Say after every decade of the Rosary: O Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fire of hell; lead all souls to heaven, especially those in most need[of Thy mercy]." It is salutary to meditate on the reality of hell (save for the scrupulous) and in order to beg that we persevere in the state of grace. Edited November 11, 2003 by Donna
hyperdulia again Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 i'm not sure who this is a response to, but we should never presume to know in anyone's subjective case whether or not they have committed a mortal sin, this is a matter for the persons informed and conformed conscience to decide with the aid of a priest, during the sacrament. that being said if you know that something was objectively a mortal sin you should always confess it.
Donna Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 bluerose, how's life... i echo ice princess and add that it is mortal sins she speaks of. we are obliged to confess mortal sins. THO' IT IS HELPFUL AND SALUTARY TO CONFESS VENIAL SINS. please do ask in confession, or out of it, a learned priest for the specific questions you have ['is such-and-such a sin...']. or, write to one, some people have 'spiritual direction' by letter. try to be patient; god knows you're trying to find all this stuff out. [eek, sorry 4 caps]. anyway, in the instance of willfully concealing a mortal sin in the confessional, this a sacrilege, and one is lying to god first and foremost; mocking the holy ghost and etc; no absolution is gained in that instance [all the boxes the boy leaves confession with] but the newest box of sacrilege is bigger than all the others put together. repeat, willfully concealing a mortal sin... and, these are all a means to an end; our lord we can reckon did not die on the cross so that we could grit our teeth through life paranoid and resentful of his commands. the psalms are full of david [reformed adulter/murderer] saying 'i delight in thy commandments', let's pray for the understanding of these virtue's, allow ourselves to be taught by the faith, and the grace to keep them out of love for god as well as that holy fear of the lord which is 'the beginning of wisdom'. whew.
Donna Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 theo, i sure wouldn't say that as a priest, after the fact. what good would that do, unless maybe the wife or children spoke their fears in private to him. one lady did this w/ the cure of ars. but what do i know...the priest is like the watchman, is he not [not just the bishop being the watchman]...if he fail to instruct the flock, and etc; theo, my dad died suddenly as a protestant. i've tried to gain the plenary indulgence for him a number of times... have mass said... pray for him. today i tried to gain the indulgence for my g'pa, never met him, died protestant in the 1930's. so, even w/ the no salvation outside the church, we must hope. even bl. pio nono [pius ix] immediately invoked god's mercy on cavor -that apostate who helped steal the papal states and vexed altar and throne for years- when that man died outside the church. and straightaway pio nono said mass for him, his archenemy, so to speak. god bless you, theo.
IcePrincessKRS Posted November 11, 2003 Posted November 11, 2003 bluerose, how's life... i echo ice princess and add that it is mortal sins she speaks of. we are obliged to confess mortal sins. THO' IT IS HELPFUL AND SALUTARY TO CONFESS VENIAL SINS. please do ask in confession, or out of it, a learned priest for the specific questions you have ['is such-and-such a sin...']. or, write to one, some people have 'spiritual direction' by letter. try to be patient; god knows you're trying to find all this stuff out. [eek, sorry 4 caps]. anyway, in the instance of willfully concealing a mortal sin in the confessional, this a sacrilege, and one is lying to god first and foremost; mocking the holy ghost and etc; no absolution is gained in that instance [all the boxes the boy leaves confession with] but the newest box of sacrilege is bigger than all the others put together. repeat, willfully concealing a mortal sin... Thanks for clarifying that for me Donna, I was pretty sure that that was the case! (Guess I should have been more specific.) :)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now