DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='ofpheritup' date='Jul 22 2005, 11:43 AM']Why does there have to be a difference? The Apostles were "traditional and charismatic." I pray the rosary and I pray in tongues. I go to Adoration, I go to prayer meetings. I love Gregorian Chant and Glory and Praise music. Different things for different times. I am balanced. I would like to see more of the Latin mass in our parishes. I am not comfortable holding hands during the Our Father. I am flexible. I am I guess an enigma. [right][snapback]654158[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Could you elaborate on the tongues? I have been associated with someone having been blessed with the mysticism but they could never recollect having spoken them...You are the first person I have ever heard of who has had recollection.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Jul 21 2005, 09:57 PM']Phatmass is Catholic. Period. [right][snapback]653424[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thanks for the reminder... :
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='MC Just' date='Jul 22 2005, 11:40 AM']and the mass i went to, you would find so many abuses and the mass is literally turned into a show. They also have a charismatic healing mass there once in a while. This is a national shrine im talking about. [right][snapback]654156[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I am sorry to hear of your bad experiences my friend. Know that in me you have someone who totally understands. God bless.
Brother Adam Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 22 2005, 10:39 AM']I truly agree...just nice to know who I could attend mass with comfortably. If praise and worship (aka: The Steubie U Mass) is your bag...great. Its just not for this cat. In the end, we all recieve the same sacraments...we just worship under a different set of parameters. I just feel that others need not me to waive and sway and chant as if there was no tomorrow during the most sacred Liturgy. He sees me...He sees what is inside...just a thought! I will say however...that someone considering themselves to be a liberal Catholic might need to re-evaluate their position in the Church. There are plenty of protestant denominations out there searching for people like that...Catholicism, like that in many liberal American venues (such as those influenced by the Order of the Sisters of Saint Joseph; my experiences only, pardon my passion)...just isn't Roman. Just isn't Him and just isn't the Body of Christ. [right][snapback]654154[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I believe you will find those at "Steubie U" to be some of the most conservitive and orthodox Catholics in the world. The 'liberal' group at FUS is far amiss from being 'liberal' just as the Feenyties call the SSPX liberal. Orthodoxy is the name of our game in every sense of the word. As 'charasmatic' as some masses may get during the school year you won't find a single person holding hands during the Our Father. The friars have weeded the garden of abuses and even those who 'think' they see abuses are mistaken. The friars here aren't 'stupid' and some write books on the liturgy. It was interesting a friend just recently told me a story of a her and a young woman friend of hers who had attended a private mass with Pope John Paul II. She was a "traditionalist" who wore a head covering and all. The Pope specifically asked her to remove her head-covering because it was not the custom where she is from and asked her to be the lector at the mass. She had the gull to say "lectoring is not for woman" and got a stern lecture from the late great JPII. I am beginning to believe all to often both Traditionalists and their opposite, charasmatics, are often equiped with "A little bit of knowledge" when can become dangerous becuase they fail to see the big picture and call people out venomously when they actually have no room to do so.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 (edited) [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Jul 22 2005, 11:57 AM']I believe you will find those at "Steubie U" to be some of the most conservitive and orthodox Catholics in the world. The 'liberal' group at FUS is far amiss from being 'liberal' just as the Feenyties call the SSPX liberal. Orthodoxy is the name of our game in every sense of the word. As 'charasmatic' as some masses may get during the school year you won't find a single person holding hands during the Our Father. The friars have weeded the garden of abuses and even those who 'think' they see abuses are mistaken. The friars here aren't 'stupid' and some write books on the liturgy. It was interesting a friend just recently told me a story of a her and a young woman friend of hers who had attended a private mass with Pope John Paul II. She was a "traditionalist" who wore a head covering and all. The Pope specifically asked her to remove her head-covering because it was not the custom where she is from and asked her to be the lector at the mass. She had the gull to say "lectoring is not for woman" and got a stern lecture from the late great JPII. I am beginning to believe all to often both Traditionalists and their opposite, charasmatics, are often equiped with "A little bit of knowledge" when can become dangerous becuase they fail to see the big picture and call people out venomously when they actually have no room to do so. [right][snapback]654170[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Perhaps Brother Adam...I should have mentioned that I have attended mass at Franciscan...I find it cermoniously beautiful and truly respect the life of the Franciscan Friar and student. (the "style" is just not for me...and my feelings of uncomfortability with your campus can be especially exemplified in the FOP). All things aside, it is also quite evident that you hail from an orthodox campus. When I spoke of liberals I meant liberals...not the Franciscans or anyone entrusted to their care. I do also agree, we are not, nor should we be about attacking others for their practices. It only pleasures me to experience the views and styles of my fellow man. Thank you for your kind reply. I am most humbled as I feel to have upset you. God Bless. Edited July 22, 2005 by DannyBoy
ofpheritup Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 22 2005, 09:48 AM']Could you elaborate on the tongues? I have been associated with someone having been blessed with the mysticism but they could never recollect having spoken them...You are the first person I have ever heard of who has had recollection. [right][snapback]654160[/snapback][/right] [/quote] 1 Corinthians 14:14 I pray in tongues when I "run out of English." There have been times in my life when tragedies have struck and I just did not know how in English to ask. It has been explained to me that the praying in tongues is nothing more than our spirit talking directly to God. 1 Cor 14:2 I have met many many people who pray in tongues. I belong to a prayer group and that is part of our meeting. Once the meeting is over I go to Adoration.
ofpheritup Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='MC Just' date='Jul 22 2005, 09:37 AM']I refused to hold hands one time at mass and my father in law was next to me, he got mad and called me an idiot. [right][snapback]654153[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I do not hold hands during the Our Father nor do I shake hands at the Sign of Peace. It is just something I don't do. I keep my hands close to me, smile and say Peace Be With You. No complaints thus far. It wouldn't matter if there were. I am not there for the congregation.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='ofpheritup' date='Jul 22 2005, 12:26 PM']I do not hold hands during the Our Father nor do I shake hands at the Sign of Peace. It is just something I don't do. I keep my hands close to me, smile and say Peace Be With You. No complaints thus far. It wouldn't matter if there were. I am not there for the congregation. [right][snapback]654193[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I respect your way.
Brother Adam Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 22 2005, 11:11 AM']Perhaps Brother Adam...I should have mentioned that I have attended mass at Franciscan...I find it cermoniously beautiful and truly respect the life of the Franciscan Friar and student. (the "style" is just not for me...and my feelings of uncomfortability with your campus can be especially exemplified in the FOP). All things aside, it is also quite evident that you hail from an orthodox campus. When I spoke of liberals I meant liberals...not the Franciscans or anyone entrusted to their care. I do also agree, we are not, nor should we be about attacking others for their practices. It only pleasures me to experience the views and styles of my fellow man. Thank you for your kind reply. I am most humbled as I feel to have upset you. God Bless. [right][snapback]654180[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm no fan of the FOP's either and do not attend them (other than one). The FOP does not however define life on our campus (thankfully) and there is room for the conservitive non-charasmatic orthodox Catholic. You have not 'upset' me, however you'll have to understand many people come here who are 'looking' to pick a fight with charasmatics or which I always remain weary of new comers for a while. I have many friends who are charasmatic who have been deeply wounded by those who come 'friendly' at first and then attack their way of life and principals. Perhaps it is that you are not one of those people, and as such your presance is most welcome here.
Crispy Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 i really love the traditional styles of mass if they are done right (i.e. good music, etc). i think the charismatic worshoip has its place, but not in the mass. speaking of the Our Father, i read that it was against the rubrics to hold hands there. both my past and current parishes do it, but i jus steadfastly keep my hands down (even if someone is tugging at my wrist). are you allowed to hold hands?
Apotheoun Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 There were at least four Eastern Catholics at FUS (two of them have recently graduated), so not everyone is charismatic.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='Brother Adam' date='Jul 22 2005, 12:45 PM']I'm no fan of the FOP's either and do not attend them (other than one). The FOP does not however define life on our campus (thankfully) and there is room for the conservitive non-charasmatic orthodox Catholic. You have not 'upset' me, however you'll have to understand many people come here who are 'looking' to pick a fight with charasmatics or which I always remain weary of new comers for a while. I have many friends who are charasmatic who have been deeply wounded by those who come 'friendly' at first and then attack their way of life and principals. Perhaps it is that you are not one of those people, and as such your presance is most welcome here. [right][snapback]654222[/snapback][/right] [/quote] My friend...I am truly not one of those people. I understand now, your views and "way" I hope to be able to learn from your experiences. And, I too, hope to be beneficial to you in whatever way I can. Sorry to have given you the negative "newcomer" assumption.
zunshynn Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='MC Just' date='Jul 22 2005, 07:40 AM']and the mass i went to, you would find so many abuses and the mass is literally turned into a show. They also have a charismatic healing mass there once in a while. This is a national shrine im talking about. [right][snapback]654156[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Not the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception?! I'm going to DC in August and I was so excited about visiting there and going to a good mass w/o abuses and stuff. But someone else I talked to said the Basilica is shockingly bad. I don't know what I am... Everyone seems to think I'm a heretic, I will say that I dislike that we no longer hold hands during the Our Father. The laity using the orans posture as they have been seems utterly inappropriate to me. We aren't priests for one thing, and I think it diminishes the sense of communal worship that mass is suposed to be. Mass is not a "me and God" thing. It's an "us and God" thing. (Corny I know but I heard it once and I appreciate what it means.) I can't say that I like holding hands with people. I don't really. But at mass, I am part of a community--its a good thing for me to acknowledge that. Although I have to admit I feel slightly less ridiculous holding hands than I do holding my hands out as if I'm a priest.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='zunshynn' date='Jul 22 2005, 01:30 PM'] Not the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception?! I'm going to DC in August and I was so excited about visiting there and going to a good mass w/o abuses and stuff. But someone else I talked to said the Basilica is shockingly bad. I don't know what I am... Everyone seems to think I'm a heretic, I will say that I dislike that we no longer hold hands during the Our Father. The laity using the orans posture as they have been seems utterly inappropriate to me. We aren't priests for one thing, and I think it diminishes the sense of communal worship that mass is suposed to be. Mass is not a "me and God" thing. It's an "us and God" thing. (Corny I know but I heard it once and I appreciate what it means.) I can't say that I like holding hands with people. I don't really. But at mass, I am part of a community--its a good thing for me to acknowledge that. Although I have to admit I feel slightly less ridiculous holding hands than I do holding my hands out as if I'm a priest. [right][snapback]654305[/snapback][/right] [/quote] In this great community of believers my friend we need not hold hands (its ok too though for we hold hearts. Our hearts are joined with those who have gone before us marked with the sign of faith and to His and Her most Sacred and Immaculate Hearts, That's amore. That's Catholicism...communio de sanctivs!!!
Dave Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='zunshynn' date='Jul 22 2005, 12:30 PM'] Not the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception?! I'm going to DC in August and I was so excited about visiting there and going to a good mass w/o abuses and stuff. But someone else I talked to said the Basilica is shockingly bad. [right][snapback]654305[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No no no ... MC Just wasn't referring to the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception. He was referring to a shrine in Texas whose name I can't remember. So you have no reason to worry.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='Dave' date='Jul 22 2005, 01:40 PM']No no no ... MC Just wasn't referring to the Basilica of the National Shrine of the Immaculate Conception. He was referring to a shrine in Texas whose name I can't remember. So you have no reason to worry. [right][snapback]654318[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Thanks for clearing that up...I have heard some negative things about the Nat'l Shrine though...anyone else?
zunshynn Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 22 2005, 09:34 AM']In this great community of believers my friend we need not hold hands (its ok too though for we hold hearts. Our hearts are joined with those who have gone before us marked with the sign of faith and to His and Her most Sacred and Immaculate Hearts, That's amore. That's Catholicism...communio de sanctivs!!! [right][snapback]654310[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Yes, but expressions of body ARE important. The sacraments are expressed bodily, tangibly. The sign of the cross is tangible. Kneeling is tangible. I think one of the reasons it is important for the priest to be the one to administer communion is because it is a physical sign of him acting persona christi. If I recieve communion from an EM, is it still the body of Christ? Of course, but it lessens the point that it is being given to me by Christ himself. In the same way, certainly not holding hands doesn't mean that I'm cut off from the community in heart, but it is lessened by the tangible sign of holding hands.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='zunshynn' date='Jul 22 2005, 01:47 PM']Yes, but expressions of body ARE important. The sacraments are expressed bodily, tangibly. The sign of the cross is tangible. Kneeling is tangible. I think one of the reasons it is important for the priest to be the one to administer communion is because it is a physical sign of him acting persona christi. If I recieve communion from an EM, is it still the body of Christ? Of course, but it lessens the point that it is being given to me by Christ himself. In the same way, certainly not holding hands doesn't mean that I'm cut off from the community in heart, but it is lessened by the tangible sign of holding hands. [right][snapback]654333[/snapback][/right] [/quote] A respectable reply. I encourage you to frequent escrivaworks.org for some further thoughts on the subject. Also, keep in mind, that we are all called to be ipse christus..Christ himself.
Ash Wednesday Posted July 22, 2005 Posted July 22, 2005 I don't like it when priests turn the liturgy of the eucharist into a broadway show.
DannyBoy Posted July 22, 2005 Author Posted July 22, 2005 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' date='Jul 22 2005, 02:03 PM']I don't like it when priests turn the liturgy of the eucharist into a broadway show. [right][snapback]654369[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I agree...and it happens more often than people think. And, here's a new one...A priest of a local church near where I attend graduate school mentioned him being "name" first and "priest" second. Hard to be obedient to a man of such malcontent for his vocation. Pray for him with me. Lets take some time and pray for all of our priests, the great, good, and those who may be struggling to keep it together...they need us too.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now