Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='dspen2005' date='Jul 25 2005, 09:06 PM']surprisingly i have heard some of the hosts on EWTN use that phraseology.... i think one is a convert from Judaism and Evangelical protestantism
[right][snapback]658812[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
what phraseology? glossolalia?

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Jul 25 2005, 08:29 PM']what phraseology?  glossolalia?
[right][snapback]658850[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I've been led by the Lord to tell you that we meant this type of language. He laid it on my heart, praise Jesus. Alleluia, brother!

Posted

or, Jesus told me last night to tell you this....

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='Oik' date='Jul 24 2005, 04:39 PM']I haven't been to a FOP. From what I hear though, it's not for me. I would rather attend a Benediciton with Adoration and ample time for quiet contemplative prayer and some older hymns. I find guitars or P and W music to be distracting. The FOP's remind me of XLT. .... I love Praise and Worship music as long as it is outside of Mass and not in front of the Blessed Sacrament.
[right][snapback]657162[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
What's XLT?

as far as glossolalia goes, it's a linguistic term for the gift of tongues. Here's the Catholic Encyclopedia entry:

[url="http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14776c.htm"]http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/14776c.htm[/url]

I have never been to a FOP that was just music the whole time. I might be biased, since the only FOP's I've been are in Fairfax, VA. Usually, it starts out with some communal prayers, led by the priest. Then there is some contemporary praise + worship music. All the song lyrics were in line with Catholic teaching. Then, the priest gives a meditation, which goes for a good long while... he talks for longer than a homily would be at Mass. And it's not laden with Protestant langage. It's just a regular, normal Catholic meditation. Then there is ample time (at least 15 minutes) where the whole congregation prays in silence. Then there is more music, and then things wind down... People sing "Holy God We Praise Thy Name" and say the Divine Praises, and there is a procession and a Benediction.

I also love the First Friday Two Hearts devotion nights, which are at a parish near my college. It starts out where the priest hears confessions for awhile, and people pray the Rosary and Divine Mercy Chaplet. Then there is a Mass in honor of the Sacred Heart of Jesus..., then 2 hours of silent adoration. Then there is a Mass for the Immaculate Heart of Mary, and then more adoration, and then a procession and benediction. It lasts all night, like until 2am. this parish has perpetual adoration, too, which is awesome.

It's possible to get into FOP's with praise + worship music, and Two Hearts nights. I think the Church needs both right now.

I used to be pretty involved with InterVarsity Christian Fellowship, so involved that I was in leadership. It was, and still kinda is, the only source of fellowship on campus for Christians. I am doing my best to facilitate Catholic fellowship, but it is really hard. At their meetings, we would always sing P&W music, and I didn't like it.... why? Because the Eucharist wasn't there. There was no focus for our worship.

I think one of the main questions is... does praise and worship music praise God? I think the answer is yes. Why praise God with P+W music in a regular old room when you could do it before the Blessed Sacrament? Why exclude Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament from this type of worship?

Singing praise +worship music without the Blessed Sacrament makes it harder to focus on God. That is when I start focusing on the instrumentalists, and my own singing. I start to think, "Hey, i sound good." I focus on the way I sing, my technique. and taking voice lessons and singing in opera isn't very good for my humility either.

also, P+W music isn't always charismatic. a better way to describe it is contemporary.

I'm not knocking P+W. when I graduate, I want to sing in a big Cathedral choir with robes, and Latin, and classical hymns. I love that kind of worship. I love Two Hearts devotion nights, and I think if I had the oppurtunity to go to a Latin Mass I would love it. But I do like P+W when it is focused on Jesus in the Blessed Sacrament and not on the instrumetnalists or singers.

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Jul 25 2005, 09:30 PM']I've been led by the Lord to tell you that we meant this type of language.  He laid it on my heart, praise Jesus.  Alleluia, brother!
[right][snapback]658854[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
while that kind of talk often suggests a flawed understanding of the process of discernment, what's wrong with saying stuff like "Alleluia" and "Praise God"? I hear Catholics say stuff like "I feel like God's calling me to do___" or "God is calling me to _______", and I don't think there's anything wrong with that. But those type of Christians sound way to assured that their discernment is correct.

Posted

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Jul 25 2005, 06:55 PM']you're cool.
anyway, yeah I do not like the show-off people.  man, I never hope to hear a Catholic actually say "the Lord laid this on my heart" in casual conversation.  I'll ask them if they are a recent convert or something!  I suppose it wouldn't sound as flowery and pretentious if it weren't English and spoken out loud.  I don't know.
[right][snapback]658795[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Thanks for the support. What I have a problem with is not so much the phrases themselves. Because sometimes the Holy Spirit does let me know who needs help (not necessarily why).

What I object to is "getting beaten over the head with it." The people that I am thinking of don't seem to be able to communicate without those phrases dominating the conversation.

This is funny (kind of but not really) I went to someone's house to help make cookies. The whole process was chocolate chips...praise Jesus...2 cups of flour...praise Jesus...etc. IT IS PHONY..I didn't stay long. When I told her I wasn't able to stay, she said praise Jesus. And I am standing there thinking "at last we agree on something." :D:

The Holy Spirit doesn't work that way. Remember the "tongues of fire not baseball bats" reference? HE IS GENTLE

I have been ridiculed because at prayer meetings I am more comfortable just sitting and listening. I am not knocking the lifestyle. I am just tired of having it shoved down my throat.

  • 6 months later...
Posted (edited)

I see beauty in both charismatic and traditional worship. As long as the focus remains on Christ and not the self, I think both are equally just as amazing. I'd also have to agree that not all Catholics are meant to have the same gifts...aka...some have the gift of tongues, some have the gift of prophecy, but not everyone has both, for not all are meant to have both. God gives different gifts of the Holy Spirit to different people according to their needs. Check out this verse from scripture:

1corinth12:4-11
There are different kinds of spiritual gifts, but the same Spirit gives them. There are different ways of serving, but the same Lord is served. There are different abilities to perform service, but the same God gives ability to all for their particular service. The Spirit's presence is shown in some way in each person for the good of all. The Spirit gives one person a message full of wisdom, while to another person the same Spirit gives a message full of knowlege. One and the same Spirit gives faith to one person, while to another person he gives the power to heal. The Spirit gives one person the power to work miracles; to another, the gift of speaking God's message; and to yet another, the ability to tell the difference between gifts that come from the Spirit, and those that do not. To one person he gives the ability to speak in strange tongues, and to another he gives the ability to explain what is said. But it is one and the same Spirit who does all this; as he wishes, he gives a different gift to each person.

Another scripture verse that speaks on tongues that can be checked out is 1Corinth 14 which is kinda long to type here :)

Edited by jpamericanka
Ora et Labora
Posted

[quote name='thedude' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:39 PM']I wouldn't say PM is charismatic.  Charasmatic and traditional aren't the only liturgical "classifications" if that is the correct term.  The vast majority of Novus Ordo Masses are not charasmatic.
[right][snapback]653331[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

i wouldnt say it is either...i would say the majority is traditional.

Ora et Labora
Posted

are there definite definitions of the words charasmatic and traditional?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 21 2005, 04:34 PM']:saint: Curious to know just how many reserved traditionalist-type Catholics there are out there PhatMass...I don't mean pre-V2 just more reserved and introverted...Holla if you here me!!! :shades:
[right][snapback]653229[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Please, let's not do what has been done in so many protestant churches and split because we worship differently. Bottom line, we are all Catholic. We should begin to act like Catholic's and set aside our differences. Some of us prefer to give praise to God in a certain way while others choose to give praise to God another way. Either way is acceptable as long as it your praise is focused on God. If we continue at this rate, I wouldn't be surprised if this Phatmass Phamily of ours wages war against itself.

Edited by Anthony
Posted (edited)

I was in a charismatic prayer community for 8 years, and I strongly believed that being charismatic was really the way to be FULLY open to the movement of the Holy Spirit. Since distancing myself from this group, I have seen such a wide variety of flaws in my actions and words. I saw a lack of contemplation. I actually had a VERY hard time developing myself as an individual outaide of the community. It took a while, but I have reached a point now where I feel that I can take the good from the "charismatic" experience and combine it with my love for silence and contemplation. It's funny to think I've moved so far from what I used to preach so loudly. I tried to go to a charismatic conference thinking it would get my prayer life back on track, and it did, but only because I was mortified at the actions of the people and I spent the whole time in adoration praying that God would forgive the abuses that occur everyday.

Anyway, that's my story, and I'm sticking to it :)

Note: No more hand-raising, loud-talking, preaching from me. I can still respect certain aspects of charismatics, such as praying together, and praying with one another. But I just can't see why everything has to be such a performance. I do still have a love for praise and worship in the proper setting.

Edited by Nicole8223
Posted

another question i had....where is the line between charasmatics and traditionalists? i tend to consider myself a traditionalist who's on fire for God and loves the gifts of the Holy Spirit....aka....I love a traditional mass but i also love praying in groups and being enthusiastic about my faith. Is there a definite line? :idontknow:

Posted

[quote name='jpamericanka' date='Feb 23 2006, 11:50 AM']another question i had....where is the line between charasmatics and traditionalists? i tend to consider myself a traditionalist who's on fire for God and loves the gifts of the Holy Spirit....aka....I love a traditional mass but i also love praying in groups and being enthusiastic about my faith.  Is there a definite line? :idontknow:
[right][snapback]895612[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

There doesn't always have to be a line. One can be both and take the best of both.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

I'm glad this thread came back and the topic of hand holding and hand shaking was brought up.

Here is something that really, I mean REALLY irritates me.

If you're shaking someone's hand, [b]act like you mean it.[/b] Look them in the eye and say "peace be with you." One of the most irritating things I've come across during the peace offering was facing someone to greet them and wish them peace, and they sorta grab your hand and aren't even looking at you. :maddest:

It's because of these habitual, half-assed gestures I find the whole peace offering to be out of place, and an interruption in the Communion rite. I'm not a grouch about the concept behind these kinds of things, I wouldn't mind if it was done at the beginning of mass or at some other time if they want to have some of that good old "community" stuff. But having someone give you a lukewarm greeting by briefly shaking your hand in a disinterested way while staring off into space in some other direction prior to the pinnacle of the mass -- the consecration and reception of communion -- just leaves a really bad taste in my mouth. :maddest:

Posted

no I don't think that that term applies to us. The whole charasmatic movement scares me a little and at the very least is not to my personal taste

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...