Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

my whole family is charismatic

the youth group that i was in was charismatic

Posted

[quote name='let_go_let_God' date='Jul 23 2005, 05:30 PM']Diversity and being so universal is something that is so beautiful in the Catholic faith, but the center shall always remain in the True Presence of Christ.
[/quote]

I don't think one could put it in any better a way than that.. ."passionately in love with the eucharist"!

toledo_jesus
Posted

charismatic catholics make me nervous... :ohno:

Posted

I know this is a basic question, but can someone clearly define a charismatic and a traditionalist? That way I can get my story straight.

Posted

i am not charismatic.... i find the movement to be -- though undoubtedly orthodox in its loyalty to the Magisterium -- to be somewhat influenced by Protestants too much in their worship and outlook on the Holy Spirit -- speaking in tongues, etc...

Posted

[quote name='DannyBoy' date='Jul 22 2005, 11:47 AM']Thanks for clearing that up...I have heard some negative things about the Nat'l Shrine though...anyone else?
[right][snapback]654331[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

what things, pray tell? :detective:

The Nat'l Shrine of the Immaculate Conception is one of the most orthodox churches in the US... EWTN broadcasts live Masses from there for crying out loud. I encourage everyone who visits DC to visit. I attend Mass there like every month and am always drawn up into the Heavenly Liturgy.

photosynthesis
Posted

i LOVE the National Shrine!!! If you're ever there on a Saturday, go to confession!!! their priests are super-orthodox and amazing confessors

MilesChristi
Posted

[quote]i LOVE the National Shrine!!! If you're ever there on a Saturday, go to confession!!! their priests are super-orthodox and amazing confessors[/quote]

Definitely! I go there often on Saturdays for Confession. I've received so much help in my spiritual life from the priests who usually minister there. :)

photosynthesis
Posted

are you from DC?

Posted

[quote]I agree with you, except I don't think I've ever been gifted with glossolalia.[/quote]

I have never heard that term. Praying in tongues and speaking in tongues is supposedly different. It is usually coached the first time by having the person repeat Alleluia several time really fast while interiorly the person is praying or "being open."

I have prayed this way several times. Eventually I got to the point where I realized prayer doesn't mean "action."

See Blesses Teresa of Calcutta's interview about prayer to God.

The interviewer asked: What do you say to God when you pray.
she answered: Nothing, I just listen.
Then the interviewer said: What does God say to you.
She said: Nothing, He just listens.

I'll take Sacred Silence over "Charismatic prayer" anyday. Why? Prayer in silence is charismatic, when we pray, it is to The Blessed Trinity. The Holy Spirit is in all our prayers.


[quote]I love FOP's, I love being able to sing contemporary P+W music in front of the Eucharist, but I never saw that as something Charismatic, just a modern way of expressing a traditional love for Jesus in the Eucharist.[/quote]

I haven't been to a FOP. From what I hear though, it's not for me. I would rather attend a Benediciton with Adoration and ample time for quiet contemplative prayer and some older hymns. I find guitars or P and W music to be distracting. The FOP's remind me of XLT. I'm not exactly sure what "modern" and "traditional" expressions exactly are. I only wish to label the universal practice of the Church. The more formal little "t" traditions do seem to appeal to me more though.

[quote]What I don't really like are the Glory + Praise songs that are trying to be Praise + Worship songs but aren't. Old-school Catholic hymns are awesome, and I appreciate P+W, but the in-between stuff generally doesn't float my boat.[/quote]

I love Praise and Worship music as long as it is outside of Mass and not in front of the Blessed Sacrament.

Posted

[quote]IMHO there are so many beautiful ways that the Catholic mass is celebrated. Although I have not experienced them all, I want to learn more about how different cultures through out the world live out their faith. I mean even from my home parish in northern Minnesota, to the church I attend on campus, to the main parish I attend at college, and my boyfriends parish in south central Minnesota, there are so many differences but each is the same mass, the same prayers, the same meaning.[/quote]

Little "t" traditions and local traditions are wonderful, as long as they develop organically, stay within the rubrics of the Mass, express the Truth of the Faith, and are theologially sound.

[quote]Each type of mass has its own beauty in it. I love the Latin mass parts, I always looked forward to masses with it when I was a little girl, since I was about 9 I haven't heard the Latin mass parts used in any mass that I have attended. I still love when even in thought one of the Latin parts just starts running through my head. There's a part of me that loves the Contemporary mass parts that I typically hear on youth retreats or occasionally at college. Still a part of me loves the "Traditional" mass that I attend where everything is in English. For me at least every mass has it place and being appropreate (sp?)[/quote]

All Masses, no matter what the language of the country in which the Mass is celebrated, should contain some prayers in Latin.

[quote]Diversity and being so universal is something that is so beautiful in the Catholic faith, but the center shall always remain in the True Presence of Christ.[/quote]

I agree that the beauty lies in the Fact of the Church's center, Jesus Christ. I disagree about it's diversity. The Beauty in this reguard in fact lies within the universiality of the Church (the second part of what you said). There is indeed room for diversity.

Posted

[quote] i am not charismatic.... i find the movement to be -- though undoubtedly orthodox in its loyalty to the Magisterium -- to be somewhat influenced by Protestants too much in their worship and outlook on the Holy Spirit -- speaking in tongues, etc...[/quote]

I don't mind being called a charismatic or being called a traditionalist. I'm Catholic. I might be in the Latin Rite of the Church, but I do hold certain theological positions that are not held by the Latin Rite, but held by the Easter Catholics (ie. The priest being the administer of the Sacrament of marriage, That Grace is uncreated, That God has Essence and Energy, No filioque in the Creed).
These are of course personal, private positions that I would really only discuss with other Eastern Catholics.

My point is that I consider myself Catholic and that's it. I'm interested in what is the Truth (and what expresses that Truth to the fullests extent).

let_go_let_God
Posted

[quote name='Oik' date='Jul 24 2005, 02:47 PM']All Masses, no matter what the language of the country in which the Mass is celebrated, should contain some prayers in Latin.
[right][snapback]657170[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I agree with that! :D:

God bless-
LGLG

Posted

[quote name='Crispy' date='Jul 22 2005, 10:56 PM']i got another question:
it sounds to me like speaking in tounges is nothing to be worried about, but i still have a small stigma attatched to it.  i know ppl in my parish, many in fact, that are very "into" their praise and worship styles.  at mass they have their hands in the air, and they are jus very charismatic (which in and of itself i think is fine, at the right time and place mind you).  part of me wonders if ppl get caught up in their emotions, especially when around lots of ppl, and do charismatic things b/c of other reasons than true religious fervor/spirit.  i was a little concerned about smthg like that when i went to steubenville, bc at adoration there were tons of ppl crying and saome even laughing.  i couldnt in good concience accuse all of them of fallacy in their actions, but i jus doubt that all of that was true works of the holy spirit and not jus "getting into the moment"
[right][snapback]655292[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I am a "QUIET CHARISMATIC" Is there such a thing?

What makes me uncomfortable at prayer meetings is the LET'S ALL DO THIS SYNDROME.

Let's all stand up, let's all raise our hands. let's all pray in tongues....etc. I don't like it forced down my throat. When put in a situation like that I wonder what percentage is Holy Spirit and how much is Simon Says. :idontknow:

The Holy Spirit speaks to each one of us as we can understand. And not all the same way. I pray in tongues and sometimes I sing in tongues. When the Holy Spirit asks me to.

I have never been to a Charismatic mass. Doesn't seem like I am missing anything.

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Jul 24 2005, 02:26 PM']i LOVE the National Shrine!!!  If you're ever there on a Saturday, go to confession!!!  their priests are super-orthodox and amazing confessors
[right][snapback]657044[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

just as a sidenote, i dont like the mosaic of Christ in the NS. it looks like an "angry, surfer-dude Jesus"

Posted (edited)

[quote name='toledo_jesus' date='Jul 24 2005, 12:27 PM']charismatic catholics make me nervous... :ohno:
[right][snapback]656916[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I understand how you feel. They make me nervous and I am one.

But not all of them. The ones that concern me are the ones that I see as "going for points." By that I mean when trying to talk to them every other phrase is Praise Jesus or Alleluia or The Lord laid this on my heart or I've been led by the Lord to tell you. I don't trust that. It seems as though they are "wired for sound" and the more phrases they use the more points they get.

I have also noticed that you can't seem to get a word in edgewise. They are too busy talking at you not to you. AND BELIEVE ME I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE.

The Holy Spirit is GENTLE, when He appeared on Pentecost he came as "tongues of fire not baseball bats."

CAN I BE A PRACTICAL CHARISMATIC? :idontknow:

I don't consider myself so much a Charismatic or Traditional Catholic as I do consider myself a Complete Catholic. Remeber the Apostles...yeah those guys. They were balanced, there was a time and place for everything.

I have never been to a Charismatic Mass (that I know of) but I wouldn't be comfortable. i don't like the emphasis being taken off of Jesus. All the hand waving and jumping up and down (worshipping) needs to be saved for another time and place. Start a prayer group.

During Mass Jesus and Jesus only needs to be fhe focus.

Edited by ofpheritup
Posted (edited)

[quote name='MC Just' date='Jul 22 2005, 09:37 AM']I refused to hold hands one time at mass and my father in law was next to me, he got mad and called me an idiot.
[right][snapback]654153[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Well I can assure you, you are not an idiot:

". . .holding hands is a sign of intimacy and not reconciliation, and as such disrupts the flow of the Sacramental signs in the Mass which leads to the Sacramental sign of intimacy with Christ and our neighbor, Holy Communion."

Additionally:

"The prolonged holding of hands is of itself a sign of communion rather than of peace. Further, it is a liturgical gesture introduced spontaneously but on personal initiative; it is not in the rubrics. Nor is there any clear explanation of why the sign of peace at the invitation: "Let us offer each other the sign of peace" should be supplanted in order to bring a different gesture with less meaning into another part of the Mass: the sign of peace is filled with meaning, graciousness, and Christian inspiration. Any substitution for it must be repudiated."

Great site to get it right:

[url="http://www.ourladyswarriors.org/articles/badliturgy.htm"]Bad Liturgy[/url]

Edited by StMichael
Posted

[quote name='dspen2005' date='Jul 24 2005, 08:08 PM']just as a sidenote, i dont like the mosaic of Christ in the NS.  it looks like an "angry, surfer-dude Jesus"
[right][snapback]657548[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

That's 'cause he's Norwegian. ;) :)

toledo_jesus
Posted

[quote name='ofpheritup' date='Jul 25 2005, 08:32 AM']I understand how you feel. They make me nervous and I am one.

But not all of them. The ones that concern me are the ones that I see as "going for points." By that I mean when trying to talk to them every other phrase is Praise Jesus or Alleluia or The Lord laid this on my heart or I've been led by the Lord to tell you.  I don't trust that.  It seems as though they are "wired for sound" and the more phrases they use the more points they get. 

I have also noticed that you can't seem to get a word in edgewise. They are too busy talking at you not to you. AND BELIEVE ME I KNOW THE DIFFERENCE.

The Holy Spirit is GENTLE, when He appeared on Pentecost he came as "tongues of fire not baseball bats." 

CAN I BE A PRACTICAL CHARISMATIC?  :idontknow:

I don't consider myself so much  a Charismatic or Traditional Catholic as I do consider myself a Complete Catholic.  Remeber the Apostles...yeah those guys. They were balanced, there was a time and place for everything.

I have never been to a Charismatic Mass (that I know of) but I wouldn't be comfortable. i don't like the emphasis being taken off of Jesus. All the hand waving and jumping up and down (worshipping) needs to be saved for another time and place.  Start a prayer group. 

During Mass Jesus and Jesus only needs to be fhe focus.
[right][snapback]657969[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


you're cool.
anyway, yeah I do not like the show-off people. man, I never hope to hear a Catholic actually say "the Lord laid this on my heart" in casual conversation. I'll ask them if they are a recent convert or something! I suppose it wouldn't sound as flowery and pretentious if it weren't English and spoken out loud. I don't know.

Posted

surprisingly i have heard some of the hosts on EWTN use that phraseology.... i think one is a convert from Judaism and Evangelical protestantism

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...