DeeDee Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 I seemed to be getting knocked down on phatmass (what does that mean anyway?) for a lot of my views. I grew up in a very liberal Catholic family, where everyone was accepted as being a child of God. I was taught to love my neighbor as Jesus loved us. Yet when I post my views in some of the forums, I get pounced on by holier than though types, quoting scripture and calling me ignorant. I was hoping to find a group of people outside of my circle of friends where I could discuss things about Catholicism and Christianity in general that I find hard to accept. I get the feeling that probably I should find another source. I can't in good conscience change my views even though I know I'm a renegade or rebel. But then, I always have been. I don't take these things lightly, and my beliefs and views are arrived at by prayer and discernment. They just don't seem to fall in step with conservative Catholicism.
StMichael Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 Catholics are neither liberal or conservative. They are obidient.
Didacus Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 What would you like to discuss? I promise I'll be nice an won't 'thump the bible' at you. I don't know the scriptures enough for that. *blush* I'm not a saint, and I used to have some liberal views. A kind of 'Live and let live' kinda attitude towards others, including homosexuals and pro-choicers. However, I never held the views that thier views where morally correct. All that has changed for me recently; I started my family. The outlook of a man towards life changes the very instant he peers into the eyes of his first born, and I started asking myself serious questions that actually I should have asked myself long before. I am playing 'catch-up' now, trying to learn what I should of learned many years ago. How about yourself? Married, got kids? Do you plan to?
Guest Eremite Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ What StMichael said. St. Paul gave us a rule of thumb for dealing with Catholics who are not living up to the call of Christ and of his Church: [quote]We instruct you, brothers, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, to shun any brother who conducts himself in a disorderly way and not according to the tradition they received from us. If anyone does not obey our word as expressed in this letter, take note of this person not to associate with him, that he may be put to shame. [b]Do not regard him as an enemy but admonish him as a brother. [/b] --2Thessalonians 3[/quote]
DeeDee Posted July 28, 2005 Author Posted July 28, 2005 Thanks a lot.. Exactly what I expected. My late husband used to say, "The last Christian was nailed to a cross." I'm outta here.
kateri05 Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 catholics can not be labeled with political monikers because the Church doesn't operate that way. either you are faithful or you are not, simple as that many people are willing to discuss all kinds of things within the Church but please don't infer that they are bashing you simply because they are preaching the Truth of the Church. disagreeing isn't being rude!
Paladin D Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 Why label yourself a [b]"Liberal Catholic"[/b]? I don't label myself a conservative Catholic, I'm just obediant.
Lil Red Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 i don't think that you've given us a fair shot. you've been posting since july 15? how about sticking around and having an open dialogue with us about what you disagree with and why? i'm sure there are many here who would discuss views with you. yes, sometimes we may disagree, but that happens. don't just run away because you don't like the viewpoint. stay and talk with us. God bless ~ Lil Red
thessalonian Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 (edited) DeeDee, You jumped right out of the shoot calling us intollerant and implying that we are unloving after we explained our position. Those who refuted what you said were very gentle about it. I hope you will stay and bring some of your friends but please try to be more tollerant of us. Blessings Edited July 28, 2005 by thessalonian
thessalonian Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 (edited) [quote name='DeeDee' date='Jul 28 2005, 04:30 PM'] "The last Christian was nailed to a cross." [right][snapback]662886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I do believe she said we are not Christians here. Isn't that kinda judgemental. For liberal Catholics isn't it unchristian to be judgemental? Edited July 28, 2005 by thessalonian
StMichael Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 [quote name='DeeDee' date='Jul 28 2005, 04:30 PM']Thanks a lot.. Exactly what I expected. My late husband used to say, "The last Christian was nailed to a cross." I'm outta here. [right][snapback]662886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] God Bless You.
StColette Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 (edited) [quote name='DeeDee' date='Jul 28 2005, 04:30 PM']Thanks a lot.. Exactly what I expected. My late husband used to say, "The last Christian was nailed to a cross." I'm outta here. [right][snapback]662886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] DeeDee, As you said in the very first post in this thread, that we are to love our neighbor and to accept them as children of God. This is true and everyone on Phatmass upholds this rule. But to completely leave the forum after the post of just a few Phatmassers is very judgemental and is not loving your neighbor very well. I'm not trying to be harsh, I would never want to seem that way. But you shouldn't judge one Phatmasser and expect the rest to be or act that way. Each Phatmasser is completely different than the other. Now as for Liberal vs. Conservative Catholics. We don't really use labels like that around here since all Catholics are called to faithfully follow what the Church teaches. Some Catholics disagree with certain things the Church teaches and they go against them and live the way they want to. While other Catholics may disagree with some things the Church teaches but they faithfully put their views aside and they follow what the Church teaches, even if they disagree. Also everyone on this phorum knows that especially in the Debate Table there is to be no Catholic vs. Catholic debate, whether they be liberal, trad, or conservative. Now Phatmassers do have the ability to calmly discuss their differences and teach one another. I, like all of Phatmass, am unaware of what "liberal" views you may hold. If you would take time to discuss them I can assure you that phatmassers will do so with charity, as charity is the cardinal rule on this phorum. They may disagree with your views on certain subjects but that does not mean they are being uncharitable to you. Phatmass is a place of learning and sharing. It is not a place to bash one another to pieces. So I hope that you'll stay and discuss your beliefs before you decide to pass judgement on all of Phatmass. God Bless, Jennie Edited July 28, 2005 by StColette
Spiritual_Arsonist Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 [quote name='StMichael' date='Jul 28 2005, 05:15 PM']Catholics are neither liberal or conservative. They are obidient. [right][snapback]662867[/snapback][/right] [/quote] This should be put at the top of the Phatmass homepage. The terms "liberal", "conservative", etc are terrible and extremely misleading. Either you are in commuinion with the church OR not. This is for you to decide.
Fidei Defensor Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 And if anything, if you want to throw yourself into the political arena, you are a Catholic liberal or Catholic conservative, not vice versa.
Nathan Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 This is a board made up of mostly faithful Catholics. We follow the teachings of the Church; it's as simple as that. For the most part, "liberal Catholics" aren't very faithful -- they tend to pick and choose the parts of Catholicism that they want to follow. Liberal Catholics have an "anything goes, as long as it feels right" attitude toward things. Basically, liberalism within religion means dissent.
cmotherofpirl Posted July 28, 2005 Posted July 28, 2005 (edited) [quote name='DeeDee' date='Jul 28 2005, 05:10 PM']I seemed to be getting knocked down on phatmass (what does that mean anyway?) for a lot of my views. I grew up in a very liberal Catholic family, where everyone was accepted as being a child of God. I was taught to love my neighbor as Jesus loved us. Yet when I post my views in some of the forums, I get pounced on by holier than though types, quoting scripture and calling me ignorant. I was hoping to find a group of people outside of my circle of friends where I could discuss things about Catholicism and Christianity in general that I find hard to accept. I get the feeling that probably I should find another source. I can't in good conscience change my views even though I know I'm a renegade or rebel. But then, I always have been. I don't take these things lightly, and my beliefs and views are arrived at by prayer and discernment. They just don't seem to fall in step with conservative Catholicism. [right][snapback]662861[/snapback][/right] [/quote] We are neither rebellious or renegade nor liberal or conservative - we are faithful Catholics following the teachings of the Magisterium. We seek to form our consciences WITHIN the teachings of the Church. If there is any topic where you would like to discuss the teachings of the Church, please start a discussion on it. Insulting us and running is not very Christ-like : Edited July 28, 2005 by cmotherofpirl
MC Just Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 (edited) I believe liberalism is a sin, because basically, many liberal minded people open doors to the Evil one. The majority of them are morally and donctrinally Lax., they are for Gay marriage, women priesthood, abortion, and against the infallible Vicar of Christ , and try to justify it. Edited July 29, 2005 by MC Just
HomeTeamFamily Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 i just have two things to say, although they may not be important because deedee has already left 1. as cs lewis wrote in mere christianity.....if you have to justify something, you are probably wrong 2. peesh
Recommended Posts