BeenaBobba Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 The stage is all yours. Feel free to discuss whatever you'd like.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 Was she considering the fact that we dished out scripture a bad thing? Does she think we don't need the Scriptures or what? That kinda sounded funny...
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 *is ashamed of PM at the moment* It seems like the heart of what DeeDee was saying is that she has not encountered the charity and caring heart proper to Christians in her experience on this site. While you can't expect too much of this in debates, you would think that this thread at least would manifest it. I'll probably be called a hypocrite or something for speaking my mind, but I'm just concerned because I don't remember PM being like this. Peace.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='DeeDee' date='Jul 28 2005, 03:30 PM']Thanks a lot.. Exactly what I expected. My late husband used to say, "The last Christian was nailed to a cross." I'm outta here. [right][snapback]662886[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Wait, if that were true, than what would you be saying about yourself, dearie? I'm not trying to be spiteful either...
cmotherofpirl Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jul 28 2005, 10:13 PM']*is ashamed of PM at the moment* [right][snapback]663239[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I am not.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 28 2005, 09:17 PM']I am not. [right][snapback]663242[/snapback][/right] [/quote] see what I wrote.. I edited my post.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jul 28 2005, 08:13 PM']*is ashamed of PM at the moment* It seems like the heart of what DeeDee was saying is that she has not encountered the charity and caring heart proper to Christians in her experience on this site. While you can't expect too much of this in debates, you would think that this thread at least would manifest it. I'll probably be called a hypocrite or something for speaking my mind, but I'm just concerned because I don't remember PM being like this. Peace. [right][snapback]663239[/snapback][/right] [/quote] yeah... I know what you mean... vainglory? pride? Are we argueing for the sake of winning an argument, or for the sake of winning souls?
CanCath Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 I must agree with Laudate Dominum.... PM has also disapointed me in this thread. And Futur Nun JMJ makes a very good statement. Also, we have to remember that on PM, others cannot read your intentions... It's not like having a debate face to face. I think it is important to recognize that some people (especially people who have only started posting, and don't know any of you really yet) may feel attacked. And while it is right to defend the Church, it is wrong to attack confused souls. And if she felt attack, it's not entirely her fault... she's entitled to her feelings. Also, I was thinking, obviously, this is a great Phorum for this person to learn to accept the wonderful teachings of our Church. Therefore, the ennemy is probably going to use her feelings against her to trick her into believing that the people on PM are un-charitable.... I think many of you are being unfair. WHile some people (ie Littleless) feed on such abuse (saying things like, 'oh, way to run away like a coward and not prove your point) and continue to post nonsense, other people will feel intimidated and never come back. Which isn't a good thing, because then they go home with no knowledge of the truth. So, all I am saying is that we don't need 50 people telling one person how stupid they are... We need to be MUCH more understanding. People like DeeDee are being deceived, and they need people who know the Truth to show them the light. And I have to say that, this Thread does not do that what so ever.
cmotherofpirl Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='CanCath' date='Jul 28 2005, 10:35 PM']I must agree with Laudate Dominum.... PM has also disapointed me in this thread. And Futur Nun JMJ makes a very good statement. Also, we have to remember that on PM, others cannot read your intentions... It's not like having a debate face to face. I think it is important to recognize that some people (especially people who have only started posting, and don't know any of you really yet) may feel attacked. And while it is right to defend the Church, it is wrong to attack confused souls. And if she felt attack, it's not entirely her fault... she's entitled to her feelings. Also, I was thinking, obviously, this is a great Phorum for this person to learn to accept the wonderful teachings of our Church. Therefore, the ennemy is probably going to use her feelings against her to trick her into believing that the people on PM are un-charitable.... I think many of you are being unfair. WHile some people (ie Littleless) feed on such abuse (saying things like, 'oh, way to run away like a coward and not prove your point) and continue to post nonsense, other people will feel intimidated and never come back. Which isn't a good thing, because then they go home with no knowledge of the truth. So, all I am saying is that we don't need 50 people telling one person how stupid they are... We need to be MUCH more understanding. People like DeeDee are being deceived, and they need people who know the Truth to show them the light. And I have to say that, this Thread does not do that what so ever. [right][snapback]663258[/snapback][/right] [/quote] She is entitled to her feelings and so are we. You can't expect us to agree with someone just to make them feel good and accepted. We are to preach the truth with love. Some people are not ready for the truth yet
Thy Geekdom Come Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 Did this person even have a chance to explain her views? Couldn't we have dealt with her patiently? Some would say I've gotten soft, but we need more prudence...we know where we stand. We don't need to jump around and shout about our orthodoxy and how bitterly we oppose heterodoxy. Let your yes mean yes and your no mean no...I don't see the point in adding so much emphasis and jumping to conclusions. If there was heterodoxy (I'm not familiar with the views held by the poster), then with patient dialogue, we could have won a soul for Christ. However, in our ardent desire to act for orthodoxy, there was a great deal of talk about orthodoxy, what it is, and *that* it's better than heterodoxy...but there was little talk of *why* orthodoxy is correct, there was little of trying to engage in discussion over the issues involved, there was little more than saying "orthodoxy is right and heterodoxy is wrong." A long time ago, I was heterodox...very heterodox. It was because I didn't know Church teaching. If someone had simply jumped around shouting, "you're wrong, we're right," then I would not be where I am today. Luckily, however, I had the faith explained to me, not the politics pushed on me. We must enlighten and discipline, not blind and torture.
StMichael Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jul 28 2005, 09:13 PM']*is ashamed of PM at the moment* It seems like the heart of what DeeDee was saying is that she has not encountered the charity and caring heart proper to Christians in her experience on this site. While you can't expect too much of this in debates, you would think that this thread at least would manifest it. I'll probably be called a hypocrite or something for speaking my mind, but I'm just concerned because I don't remember PM being like this. Peace. [right][snapback]663239[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I do not understand why you are ashamed. The thread starter came in here trying to measure the temprature with a ruler. I've said it once, I'll say it again, there is no hair splitting when it comes to the faith. It is what it is.
CanCath Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' date='Jul 28 2005, 11:47 PM']She is entitled to her feelings and so are we. You can't expect us to agree with someone just to make them feel good and accepted. We are to preach the truth with love. Some people are not ready for the truth yet [right][snapback]663269[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I never once said in my post that we should agree with her to make her feel accepted. Do not put words in my mouth (so-to-speak). I simply feel that some people in this thread have NOT been charitable at all. I believe that most of these posts have not taken into consideration that perhaps this person actually came here to learn, and too seek the Truth. In stead of feeling compassion for this person who is obviously being deceived, this thread has simply poked at her ignorence. There is NOTHING edifying about this thread. And THAT I fine shameful. I have read Deedee's posts and this person does not seem like the type (that sometimes posts here) who comes with a pile of arguments to try to convince us we are wrong... It seems to me that she is trying to understand WHY we believe what we know as Truth. I think things would be much more edifying if we stopped poking at her ignorance (50 people don't need to tell one person how stupid one is...). Find another way to get to her. While for us, Scripture is enough to persuade us... it is not the case for everyone. So, yeah, stop throwing scripture at this person, find out what kind of evidence will convince her. By the way, I would recommend EVERYONE to read this AWESOME book by Patrick Madrid called [i]Search and Rescue[/i].... you might learn a thing or too about using apologetics...
CanCath Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 Raphael, that was brilliantly said. My thoughts exactly.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='StMichael' date='Jul 28 2005, 09:59 PM']I do not understand why you are ashamed. The thread starter came in here trying to measure the temprature with a ruler. I've said it once, I'll say it again, there is no hair splitting when it comes to the faith. It is what it is. [right][snapback]663281[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Well, my issue is not about correct doctrine, it's about attitude. Even if you are correct, your attitude often determines whether or not the person will respect what you have to say. Of course I agree, the faith is what it is, no compromise. But the opinions of honest and sincere people deserve some respect even if you believe they are in error. That's the part I'm hung up about. I can remember a thread a year and a half ago with a Catholic who thought gay marriage was ok. The thread was remarkably charitable. I wonder if that thread were started today how it would look. I'm scared.
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='Raphael' date='Jul 28 2005, 09:58 PM']Did this person even have a chance to explain her views? Couldn't we have dealt with her patiently? Some would say I've gotten soft, but we need more prudence...we know where we stand. We don't need to jump around and shout about our orthodoxy and how bitterly we oppose heterodoxy. Let your yes mean yes and your no mean no...I don't see the point in adding so much emphasis and jumping to conclusions. If there was heterodoxy (I'm not familiar with the views held by the poster), then with patient dialogue, we could have won a soul for Christ. However, in our ardent desire to act for orthodoxy, there was a great deal of talk about orthodoxy, what it is, and *that* it's better than heterodoxy...but there was little talk of *why* orthodoxy is correct, there was little of trying to engage in discussion over the issues involved, there was little more than saying "orthodoxy is right and heterodoxy is wrong." A long time ago, I was heterodox...very heterodox. It was because I didn't know Church teaching. If someone had simply jumped around shouting, "you're wrong, we're right," then I would not be where I am today. Luckily, however, I had the faith explained to me, not the politics pushed on me. We must enlighten and discipline, not blind and torture. [right][snapback]663279[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Amen.
StMichael Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='Laudate_Dominum' date='Jul 28 2005, 10:16 PM']Well, my issue is not about correct doctrine, it's about attitude. Even if you are correct, your attitude often determines whether or not the person will respect what you have to say. Of course I agree, the faith is what it is, no compromise. But the opinions of honest and sincere people deserve some respect even if you believe they are in error. That's the part I'm hung up about. I can remember a thread a year and a half ago with a Catholic who thought gay marriage was ok. The thread was remarkably charitable. I wonder if that thread were started today how it would look. I'm scared. [right][snapback]663299[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Truth is truth. No disrespect was shown to the thread starter. She/ he found an exuse to leave. One has to be open to the message of the faith, not tricked into it. Lying or smoothing over the truth does little to ensure the strength of the faith. If someone was to ask if gay "marriage" was OK, the answer is no. Yes, there are further details as to why, but the answer is still no. Catholics are not liberal nor conservative. I see nothing wrong with that statement. Maybe she/ he was chided by the obedient part.
CanCath Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='StMichael' date='Jul 29 2005, 12:24 AM']Lying or smoothing over the truth does little to ensure the strength of the faith. [right][snapback]663305[/snapback][/right] [/quote] No one is saying ANYTHING about smoothing over the Truth or Lying.
1337 k4th0l1x0r Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 I don't see how you can be disappointed in phatmass here. She waited for three posts until she found something that she construed to be offensive. Just because she was offended by it doesn't mean that what was said was offensive. The first message was about there not being a liberal or conservative Catholic. The second was an experience by someone who has had a positive experience from phatmass and has been having liberal views changing recently. The third included a bible quote and that is probably what was found offensive. The quote is strong, but it emphasizes that those with the faith but aren't obedient are not enemies rather they are brothers. The original poster threw her hands up after this and left. The original poster wasn't looking to debate an issue rather she was looking for an affirmation that it's okay to hold heterodox beliefs. I wouldn't expect any faithful Catholic on phatmass to affirm that and she left before we could really explain the importance of orthodoxy. The 'burden' of being open to the faith is on the individual, not the group
Laudate_Dominum Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 [quote name='StMichael' date='Jul 28 2005, 10:24 PM']Truth is truth. No disrespect was shown to the thread starter. She/ he found an exuse to leave. One has to be open to the message of the faith, not tricked into it. Lying or smoothing over the truth does little to ensure the strength of the faith. If someone was to ask if gay "marriage" was OK, the answer is no. Yes, there are further details as to why, but the answer is still no. Catholics are not liberal nor conservative. I see nothing wrong with that statement. Maybe she/ he was chided by the obedient part. [right][snapback]663305[/snapback][/right] [/quote] All I'm talking about is the difference between: 1. Homosexuality is an abomination and gays ought to repent... etc.. The Church condemns homosexual marriage so you aren't Catholic.. etc. verses. 2. The Church teaches that homosexual acts are instrinsically disordered because... [give sound reasons]... But the Church also calls her faithful to love those fellow children of God who may bear the cross of same-sex attraction... etc.. No watering down is necessary, just better explainations of things.
Aloysius Posted July 29, 2005 Posted July 29, 2005 she posted in an ironmonk thread... lol enough said? ironmonk's style is very blunt sometimes. anyway, she posted in the debate table about gay marriage. she felt overwhelmed with the responses all attempting to prove her wrong and decided that the people who posted them must be cold hearted because they believe homosexual acts are sinful. feeling ashamed of pm seems to just be playing into her game, because really really look at the posts replying to her in the debate table. other than ironmonk's very charecteristic "you are ignorant of scripture" stuff (we should really have like, a warning sign for him ) everyone stayed talking objectively about the topic. she, on the other hand, did not. she responded with ad hominem attacks. she did not defend her position... I mean if you're on a catholic debate table posting that catholic teaching on gay marriage is wrong, you should be prepared to defend yourself, give reasons, and/or refute our points.
Recommended Posts