Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Anyone like Dogma?


Recommended Posts

PadreSantiago
Posted

I was wondering if anyone liked this movie. It's one of my favorites; it got a lot of slack before it was released but it's mostly harmless. I mean it's got a mushy mud pie monster in it. But I really like the way it mixes drama and comedy while messing around with biblical mythology a bit.

Posted

That movie is a piece of trash. Yes, I saw it.

Posted

[quote name='PadreSantiago' date='Nov 12 2005, 02:21 PM']I was wondering if anyone liked this movie.  It's one of my favorites; it got a lot of slack before it was released but it's mostly harmless.  I mean it's got a mushy mud pie monster in it.  But I really like the way it mixes drama and comedy while messing around with biblical mythology a bit.
[right][snapback]786487[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

No. It is a not so subtle attack upon the Catholic Church. It was and is a horrible movie. H-O-R-R-I-B-L-E!!!!!!!!

PadreSantiago
Posted (edited)

It wasn't an attack on the catholic church at all. The writer and director Kevin Smith was raised catholic. It's just having a little fun with catholic dogma. Now I could see how someone could be offended by some of the ludness the cursing, mushy mud pie monster etc. But why did the religious stuff upset you? I thought it was very interesting. Espeically the idea that jesus was black since it really makes no sense at all for jesus to be white. Also god being portrayed as a woman was great; she was so sweet like a child.

Edited by PadreSantiago
Posted

It was a pretty funny film. Its not Clerks, but it has its own charm.

"No ticket."

PadreSantiago
Posted

I agree Clerks is way funnier but dogma is more than just funny it makes you think too. Dogma is kinda like chasing amy, they are both dramedies in a way. And they just started shooting Clerks 2: Passion of the clerks btw I am pumped!

Posted

I couldn't finish watching it, I only got half way through before I pressed the eject button on my VCR.

Posted

Even before I was Catholic, I thought it was a dumb movie.

Guest Rick777
Posted

That movie is sooooooo blasphemous to Our Lord its disgusting.

Posted

It's a bad movie if you think enough about it, but it's a really good movie if you think about it even more.

Posted

I thought it was alright.

It should be noted that when Smith made the movie, he had sort of fallen away from the Church and was going through a crisis of faith (he was even shopping around at various Protestant churches for a time, apparently) -- the things he took "shots" at in the movie were the things troubling him. He was purging. But, Smith maintains that making the flick helped him come to terms with and re-embrace his Catholicism.

Posted

I always suspected whoever wrote that movie had to have had some real knowledge of Catholocism. since it was deliberate about directly contradicting every dogma, it was clear that it had at least a decent understanding of what the dogmas were in the first place... I always wondered if, while they always skimp on research for serious films about catholocism, they had actually researched for the non-serious. ah well, guess it answers my question that the writer was at the time questioning the Church

Posted

I watched this movie before Ieven believed in God, and even then I though the movie was utter trash. A waste of 90 minutes of one's precious life.

Posted

[quote name='Aloysius' date='Nov 14 2005, 08:12 AM']I always suspected whoever wrote that movie had to have had some real knowledge of Catholocism.  since it was deliberate about directly contradicting every dogma, it was clear that it had at least a decent understanding of what the dogmas were in the first place... I always wondered if, while they always skimp on research for serious films about catholocism, they had actually researched for the non-serious.  ah well, guess it answers my question that the writer was at the time questioning the Church
[right][snapback]788223[/snapback][/right][/quote]

Writer-director Smith was born and raised Catholic. He was an altar boy for several years, in fact, and apparently had a very strong faith up until his twenties, when he had begun to question the Church, and wrote DOGMA as a kind of catharsis. Despite its silliness, it was a very personal film for Smith. And as he says, the process of making the film helped him re-embrace the Catholic faith, with all its dogma.

Guest Rick777
Posted

Thats great that this movie helped him embrace the faith but unfortunately it trashed our Church and may have harmed others spirituality, he should speak against this blasphemy now that hes back. Welcome Back Smith!

Posted

[quote name='Rick777' date='Nov 14 2005, 08:02 PM']Thats great that this movie helped him embrace the faith but unfortunately it trashed our Church and may have harmed others
[right][snapback]789075[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

This is the problem that artists face, isn't it? As an artist, though, whether you're a filmmaker or a writer or whatever, you can't self-censor yourself. You can't really worry about what influence your work may have on people. You just have to be honest with yourself and hope for the best.

Guest Rick777
Posted

Thats very easy to say but thats not facing reality. Reality is there is a line people should not cross especially as Catholics, God as a woman? Blasphemy. He knew what he was doin, anyways whats done is done, he made a blasphemous movie.Asfor artists not worrying about what influence they may have on people, that remark is kinda dumb. Jesus said cursed is the man who leads His children astray.Thats honesty.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...