Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Anyone like Dogma?


Recommended Posts

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted (edited)

+JMJ+

The movie smells of elderberries. Period.

Edited by Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

FSW is right, the movie is garbage. It might be maybe a little bit possibly okay sometimes is it weren't so darn sacreligious.

DemonSlayer
Posted (edited)

[quote name='kujo' post='1023761' date='Jul 14 2006, 04:58 AM']
That is YOUR interpretation of the comments. It may (or may not) by what Mr. Smith meant.
[/quote]
When he talks about kneeling, bowing and saying the same thing at the same time, he's most probably talking about Mass; and he's saying that it's meaningless.

More from the article:[quote]Asked to comment on the inspiration for Dogma, Smith becomes reflective. In some ways, he says, "it’s more personal than anything else I’ve ever done"; it expresses "everything I’ve ever thought or felt about religion." [b]Yet he’s quick to preempt religious criticism: He insists that the film is "no indictment of religion," and should be taken about as seriously as "an episode of Laverne & Shirley."[/b] After all, this is a movie "with a rubber mushy mud pie monster"; how serious could it possibly be?

Having thus established that his most personal expression of everything he’s ever thought or felt about religion is nothing to take seriously, [b]Smith proceeds to sum up what is at the heart of these thoughts and feelings, using an Animal Farm-type mantra: "Faith good; religion not good." A "very simple philosophy,"[/b] he adds, really only what most of us know to be common sense.

[b]"You said earlier that Dogma wasn’t an indictment of religion…"
"I said that? No I didn’t. I have never used the word ’indictment,’"[/b] he says with certainty.
"Well, actually, I wrote it down…"
"You’re taking notes?" He seems genuinely startled.
I read aloud: "’No indictment of religion.’ Those are your exact words."
[b]He snaps ruefully. "beaver dam."
"But you also summarized the philosophy behind the film with the words ’Faith good, religion not good.’"
"’Not so good,’ I think I said," he amends quickly.[/b] Duly noted, I smile.

He eyes me quizzically, perhaps wondering if he’s given me what I wanted. Smiles apologetically. "I’m just really tired right now. I’ve kind of spent the last few years working through all this." I am thinking: [b]That’s Kevin Smith’s beef with religion? An anti-ceremony hang-up?[/b][/quote]

Edited by DemonSlayer

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...