Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Anyone like Dogma?


Recommended Posts

Posted

well what would had been right to use as God? couldnt God appear as woman if God pleased?

Guest Rick777
Posted

First of all this movie wasn't defending the faith or poking little jokes at it this movie was going all out and trying to disrespect the church. Do you think Jesus would approve of this movie?Say you were sitting down on your couch watching this movie and Jesus came and sat next to you when Alanis Morisette(a woman) came out and acted as His Father, do you think He would say, oh how hilarious! HA HA HA!!!!! No! He would probably say something along the lines of this movie is blasphemy, why are you watching it?!

Posted

i really didnt like hte movie

Posted

OK, I'll admit, my comment came across as kind of flaky. ;)

But my point is, we live in a world of vastly different viewpoints and opinions. Any artistic statement about the world coming from one solid position is going to offend [i]somebody[/i], some group of people. If an artist worries about that and takes pains not to offend [i]anybody[/i], he's dead. He might as well forget about it, because it's impossible.

Guest Rick777
Posted

blasphemy to our lord....whether he was being artistically free <_< or whatever....

Posted

i have never liked this movie...and as far as K. Smith coming back to the Church, that's wonderful! but there comes a time when your actions cause public scandal, and cause others to doubt their faith. that's what this movie does. i agree with what others have said....it's trash.

PadreSantiago
Posted

So first off god cannot be personified. The idea that God is an old man with a beard or a woman is just ludicris. But if you think about it, women make life, they hold the key to life. So why can't god be a woman? What's blashemous against speculating?

  • 4 weeks later...
Posted

i saw the movie on t.v. a few times [and i guess they edit out the mushy mud pie monster], and at first i was all like "this is the greatest movie ever! haha" but then i really got to know the Lord. then i was thinking about that movie, and i was like "wow, this does have a lot of things that goes against my faith." to me its like a comidy version of the Da vinci code. it blends the Truth of out faith with Fiction. but ppl wont know the difference, so it can be a very dangerous movie to watch. i'll admit, tho, there are a lot of funny parts in that movie.

Posted

my girl said I cant watch it cause I will get mad....and you dont want to see me mad

[img]http://www.bbc.co.uk/science/hottopics/superheroes/images/hulk.jpg[/img]

Posted

I think the greatest redeaming point of the movie is the scene wherein the protagonist realizes she's the niece of Jesus, and then the Trent Reznor-looking English guy challenges the audience to sympathize with the 12-year-old Jesus. "Jesus wept", Scripture says, and the movie closely hones in on that message. It is not unlike God to demand super-human strength from us mortals, and yet He's always there to grant us super-human strength.

I'm not just defending the movie to be the whacky inflammatory jerk I like to play, but because it represents the tortuous relationships with faith held by the X Generation. There's no way in hell you could make a movie reaching the appropriate audience without making some deliberate slips that'll rile people up, but when it does so, Dogma is pretty innocuous. Kevin Smith was well aware that his "loophole" in dogma wasn't the least bit sound, but as a comedy he had the prerogative to not care. Do you think that some misunderstanding that transubstantiation is when angels rip off their wings, or that plenary indulgences entail nothing but walking through a door, will really cause people to take a stand against Catholicism?

No. The average movie-goer will not invest the mental energy to peer below the surface, and they'll remain either faithful or hedonistic accordingly. The curiosity it provokes could only cause a more interested view into researching further, and coming to the truth.

Kind of like that episode when the bully yells "your epidermis is showing!--That's funny because that's your hair". The average viewer will think that epidermis is hair, but someone who's actually curious will learn for herself a fancy word for skin.

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

interesting.. I've never seen the movie and I hope I never do.

I'm easily offended when it comes to such matters. :(

Posted

the only problem is that the serious part of the message they try to say, that we shouldn't so much believe in dogmas or whatever and everyone could then just get along, is the most dangerous part. the rest of it is just basic funnies and kicks, but the conclusion is purported as a serious outlook, and that's what the average viewer would probably take out of it.

eh... but I've never been too concerned with it... it's certainly easier to prove a relativist wrong than an opposite-minded dogmatist I suppose... hehe

PadreSantiago
Posted

[quote name='Snarf' date='Dec 8 2005, 11:59 PM']I think the greatest redeaming point of the movie is the scene wherein the protagonist realizes she's the niece of Jesus, and then the Trent Reznor-looking English guy challenges the audience to sympathize with the 12-year-old Jesus.  "Jesus wept", Scripture says, and the movie closely hones in on that message.  It is not unlike God to demand super-human strength from us mortals, and yet He's always there to grant us super-human strength.

I'm not just defending the movie to be the whacky inflammatory jerk I like to play, but because it represents the tortuous relationships with faith held by the X Generation.  There's no way in hell you could make a movie reaching the appropriate audience without making some deliberate slips that'll rile people up, but when it does so, Dogma is pretty innocuous.  Kevin Smith was well aware that his "loophole" in dogma wasn't the least bit sound, but as a comedy he had the prerogative to not care.  Do you think that some misunderstanding that transubstantiation is when angels rip off their wings, or that plenary indulgences entail nothing but walking through a door, will really cause people to take a stand against Catholicism?

No.  The average movie-goer will not invest the mental energy to peer below the surface, and they'll remain either faithful or hedonistic accordingly.  The curiosity it provokes could only cause a more interested view into researching further, and coming to the truth.

Kind of like that episode when the bully yells "your epidermis is showing!--That's funny because that's your hair".  The average viewer will think that epidermis is hair, but someone who's actually curious will learn for herself a fancy word for skin.
[right][snapback]817744[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


well said! What I liked a lot was the whole aspect of the angels being jealous of the humans. They were created first but god gave humans the choice to believe in god or not where as obviously the angels have no choice. But in the end he just wanted to be back in god's grace, I think it's a beautiful story. Also I think you'd be hard pressed to find a movie that blends religion, drama, comedy, great dialouge, and a rubber mushy mud pie monster together and actually make it poignant and thought provoking.

  • 7 months later...
Guest DouglasFir
Posted

[quote name='PadreSantiago' post='790543' date='Nov 15 2005, 05:11 PM']
So first off god cannot be personified. The idea that God is an old man with a beard or a woman is just ludicris. But if you think about it, women make life, they hold the key to life. So why can't god be a woman? What's blashemous against speculating?
[/quote]

Can I step in and defend the movie further? I don't have the script to hand but their is a line towards the end where Rufus points out that "God isn't really a woman" - it's just that because they're seeing God there has to be something they can relate to and this time around it was a woman.

Also I noticed someone mentioning Kevin coming back to religion... you know he never really left. He is a catholic and always has been with no leave of abscence as far as I'm aware!

You'll be glad to know that the events in Dogma affected the characters in Kevin's movies as in the upcoming...

[url="http://www.clerks2.com"][img]http://www.clerks2.com/myspace/july21myspace.jpg[/img][/url]

... Jay and Silent Bob have now found God and carry a Bible with them! Although if Dogma, a pro-faith movie, offended you then I probably wouldn't recommend seeing Clerks II (although if you want a good comedy about frienshdip and making the right decisions in life then you should check it out).

God the Father
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Rick777' post='790463' date='Nov 15 2005, 06:26 PM']
blasphemy to our lord....whether he was being artistically free <_< or whatever....
[/quote]

Blasphemy to our Lord? [i]In a movie?!?[/i] Quick! Quick! The sky is falling, we must tell the president!

If your faith was affected by the movie Dogma, you were too young to watch the movie.

Edited by God the Father
DemonSlayer
Posted

It may be pro-faith, but not pro-religion.
[quote]"I believe faith is important." "When you believe in something… that’s something that’s inside you, something nobody can take away from you. But that’s not the same thing as religion. In church, you know, the emphasis is all on ceremony, not what’s inside. I don’t see what’s important about standing, kneeling, bowing, lighting a candle, whatever. You know, just because we all say the same thing at the same time, that doesn’t mean anything — all that means is we all learned the same book. I can’t really get my head around the whole corporate worship process. You know what my idea of church would be, would be to get ten, fifteen people together in a room, and then all just sit there in abject silence."[/quote]
- Kevin Smith ([url="http://www.decentfilms.com/sections/articles/2584"]source[/url])

Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1021725' date='Jul 11 2006, 12:42 PM']
It may be pro-faith, but not pro-religion.

- Kevin Smith ([url="http://www.decentfilms.com/sections/articles/2584"]source[/url])
[/quote]

In that quote, he is right to a certain degree. All of what we believe as Catholics--the Eucharist, veneration of Our Blessed Mother, purgatory, the rosary-- is for nothing unless we know exactly what it is that we believe. It's the whole thing about mindless-repetition of prayers and gestures: if they do not come from your heart, they serve absolutely no purpose.

So, when we are "kneeling, standing and lighting candles," unless we do so with a sincere heart, we might as well not do it.

DemonSlayer
Posted (edited)

But when he says "I don’t see what’s important about standing, kneeling, bowing, lighting a candle, whatever.", it sounds like he's saying that rituals are pointless, not just if you don't believe in it; but that God doesn't require them

Edited by DemonSlayer
Posted

[quote name='DemonSlayer' post='1023523' date='Jul 13 2006, 07:56 AM']
But when he says "I don’t see what’s important about standing, kneeling, bowing, lighting a candle, whatever.", it sounds like he's saying that rituals are pointless, not just if you don't believe in it; but that God doesn't require them
[/quote]

That is YOUR interpretation of the comments. It may (or may not) by what Mr. Smith meant.

Posted

The movie "Dogma" has relatively no correct dogma in it, but it has its funny moments.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...