Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Just thought every one might be intrested in this topic! Do you think Lord of the Rings movies were that close to the books?
:seesaw: :shield:

Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' date='Dec 8 2005, 06:54 AM']Just thought every one might be intrested in this topic! Do you think Lord of the Rings movies were that close to the books?
:seesaw:  :shield:
[right][snapback]816616[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

More or less. There were some pretty significant moves away from the books though.

Fellowship:
One of the oddest changes from the book is that Sauron doesn't have a body; Saruman tells Gandalf that he isn't yet able to 'take physical form'. It's hard to see how this could be true - what use would the Ring be to Sauron, if he didn't have a finger to wear it on? The book makes it very clear that he does have a physical form - 'He has only four [fingers] on the Black Hand, but they are enough', says Gollum in The Two Towers, and this is confirmed explicitly by Tolkien among his letters. Actually, this does seem to be a misinterpretation rather than a deliberate change, because Peter Jackson has himself described Sauron in at least one interview as being no more than a floating eyeball.

Arwen's role has been greatly expanded in the film. In the book, Aragorn and the Hobbits are aided by a golden-haired Elf named Glorfindel, not by Arwen, and the flood that saves Frodo from the Black Riders is the work of Elrond and Gandalf.

Two Towers:
Perhaps the most obvious and significant difference is in the way the various storylines of The Two Towers are presented. Tolkien's original was literally divided into two books: the first tells us the complete story of Aragorn's adventures in Rohan and the overthrow of Isengard, and then the second returns to Frodo and Sam, and concentrates on their journey through the borderlands of Mordor. It was Tolkien's hope that a movie version of the book would preserve this separation of the story. Of an earlier attempt to film the book, he wrote, 'It is essential that these two branches should each be treated in coherent sequence.' (The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien, No 210, dated 1958, with original italics). Nonetheless, it is perhaps not too surprising that the current movie version follows a more conventional approach, cutting between the various storylines as they develop, rather than treating them as entirely separate.

The film contains several sequences that are entirely the invention of the film-makers, with nothing directly comparable in the books. Perhaps the most extensive of these is the battle between the Rohirrim and the Wargs on the road to Helm's Deep. That battle is unique to the film version, as are Aragorn's subsequent adventures (he falls into a river which sweeps him away from the others, and eventually spies the armies of Saruman approaching before riding to Helm's Deep).

The story of Frodo's meeting with Faramir has been radically modified. Tolkien's Faramir is one of the most insightful and compassionate characters in the book, intelligent enough to divine the importance of Frodo's mission, and to let him continue without hindrance. In the movie, he's lost all these qualities - deciding to take the Ring to Minas Tirith, he drags Frodo and Sam some forty miles out of their way, allowing a Nazgûl to discover the Ring in Osgiliath, before he realises he's made a mistake.

In fact, the idea of the Ring being revealed to one of the Ringwraiths in Osgiliath threatens to undermine the entire plot. The whole purpose of Frodo's mission is to bring the Ring to Mordor in secret. His only hope of success is in Sauron's ignorance of the Ring's whereabouts, but here we seem to see one of Sauron's slaves discovering its exact location, and on the very borders of his master's realm. It's not completely clear how Frodo survives this encounter - no such dangerous and foolhardy adventure occurs in the book.


Return of the King:
Probably the best known omission from the movie is Gandalf's final confrontation with Saruman among the ruins of Isengard, where he breaks Saruman's staff and casts him out of the Order of Wizards. This scene is included in the Extended Edition, though with some departures from the original story.

In the book, Saruman dies in the Shire at the hands of Gríma, who is then shot by Hobbit archers. The film follows the same sequence of events, but the players and location are different: Gríma attacks Saruman on Orthanc, and is then shot by Legolas in place of the Hobbits.

Another slight change here relates to Saruman's palantír. The original story has Gríma throw it from the tower as a missile, but the movie has Saruman fall from the tower with it, after which the Seeing-stone rolls out from his cloak. This explains how it came to be lying in the water to be found by Pippin, which was left as something of a mystery in the movie's theatrical version.

There's a brief scene in the book that sees Gandalf meet the Lord of the Nazgûl at the broken Gate of Minas Tirith. The fact that this scene was omitted from the movie would hardly be significant, except that earlier in the film the Witch-king assures his lieutenant that he will deal with the Wizard, but the two never actually meet. This oddity is addressed in the Extended Edition, though in that version the encounter takes place within Minas Tirith, with the Witch-king mounted on his Winged Creature. In this version, too, the Nazgûl Lord has acquired the power to destroy Gandalf's staff at a distance, though it isn't completely clear how he manages this.

Probably the most significant omission from the movie is the sequence known as the 'Scouring of the Shire'. In the book, Frodo and his companions return only to find that Men and corrupt hobbits have allied themselves and taken over the Shire. While they've been away, the green fields have been turned into an blighted industrial wasteland, in which the Shire-hobbits live their lives regulated by 'The Rules'. So Frodo and his companions have to fight another battle before the true ending of the book, freeing the Shire and defeating the evil 'Sharkey', who turns out to be none other than Saruman.

The movies were good and they will rank as great movies and epics for years to come, but the movies are interpretations of the book, from one man. I don't think that Peter Jackson was completely faithful to Tolkien, but I think that because of the scope of the work, he wasn't too far off the mark.

Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' date='Dec 8 2005, 07:54 AM']Just thought every one might be intrested in this topic! Do you think Lord of the Rings movies were that close to the books?
:seesaw:  :shield:
[right][snapback]816616[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


I think that they were as close to the books as Peter Jackson could make them. Because he had 2 or 3 different stories happening at once, he couldn't draw from Frodo too much by showing everything that happened to Aragorn (just an example). He also had the time to worry about. I know people who love Tolkien, but didn't want to sit through a 3 hour movie. I believe Peter Jackson did a good job with keeping it as close to the book as he could.

Guest concrete girl
Posted

Do you guys think PJ will make the Hobbit?! :)

Posted

They are going to make the hobbit it is just that they are going over the coppyrights right now!

Guest concrete girl
Posted

Awesome! I heard rumors about PJ doing it but nothing official.




quote=Gandalf,Dec 9 2005, 06:14 PM]
They are going to make the hobbit it is just that they are going over the coppyrights right now!
[right][snapback]818996[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

I downloaded an unoffical "trailer" of the Hobbit.

...

And it was a fake...a purrty good fake though.

Posted

[quote name='onathing1' date='Dec 8 2005, 09:04 AM']I think that they were as close to the books as Peter Jackson could make them.  Because he had 2 or 3 different stories happening at once, he couldn't draw from Frodo too much by showing everything that happened to Aragorn (just an example). He also had the time to worry about. I know people who love Tolkien, but didn't want to sit through a 3 hour movie. I believe Peter Jackson did a good job with keeping it as close to the book as he could.
[right][snapback]816704[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Peter Jackson also made some significant additions and changes. (For instance a lot was added to build up that Aragorn/Arwen romance.)

The movie would've moved faster without all those scenes of Aragorn and Arwen pining away for each other. (Arwen only gets a few sentences devoted to her in the original books.)

The most problematic changes were the changing of Faramir and the story involving him and the ring (which upset a lot of Tolkienites) and of the story with Treebeard and the Ents. (In the book, Treebeard was well aware of Saruman's destruction of the forests before meeting Merry and Pippin.)

Overall, Jackson did a good job, though.
And I thought leaving out the anti-climatic "Scouring of the Shire" sequence at the end was a wise move cinematically (though, of course, this necessitated changing how Saruman dies).

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='Dec 10 2005, 08:40 PM']Peter Jackson also made some significant additions and changes.  (For instance a lot was added to build up that Aragorn/Arwen romance.)

The movie would've moved faster without all those scenes of Aragorn and Arwen pining away for each other.  (Arwen only gets a few sentences devoted to her in the original books.)

The most problematic changes were the changing of Faramir and the story involving him and the ring (which upset a lot of Tolkienites) and of the story with Treebeard and the Ents.  (In the book, Treebeard was well aware of Saruman's destruction of the forests before meeting Merry and Pippin.)

Overall, Jackson did a good job, though.
And I thought leaving out the anti-climatic "Scouring of the Shire" sequence at the end was a wise move cinematically (though, of course, this necessitated changing how Saruman dies).
[right][snapback]819935[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]


Psssttttt.....it is Inklings not Tolkienites.

Posted

Leaving out the "scouring" may have been a wise move cinematically - but that was one of the senses of the book where you could see that (contrary to the beliefs of a lot of the residents of the Shire) those earth shaking political changes happening off in the rest of the world can come home . . . it sort of emphasizes the point that in the face of evil, there is no safe haven . . . and that men of good will everywhere have to be engaged in the struggle against evil . . . or something like that . . .

Posted

Peter did a great job... If he stayed THAT close to the book, we wouldn't be as interested. the stuff he left out was poetic and really couldn't be shown on screen. I'm not talking about the actual poems, I mean the scenes, they were too beautiful for film and risky to put in. What Jackson DID put in the film was great.

Posted

[quote name='Asher' date='Dec 10 2005, 09:56 PM']Peter did a great job... If he stayed THAT close to the book, we wouldn't be as interested. the stuff he left out was poetic and really couldn't be shown on screen. I'm not talking about the actual poems, I mean the scenes, they were too beautiful for film and risky to put in. What Jackson DID put in the film was great.
[right][snapback]820016[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I tend to disagree. I think that Tom Bombadil was a fairly important moment.

Also, the Scourging of the Shire is important.

See my above post.

TheOliverOrder88
Posted

I think if Peter Jackson did a "literal film-translation" of the book it would have been a lot longer. You have to remember, from a movie standpoint, you cannot keep people's attention that long. People get bored too easily. If we had the end-Shire part, it would have been too long on top of being a bit too long.

I think it was good...for a movie. With the depth and complexity that was Lord of the Rings, Jackson did a great job in giving you that multi-layered feel. He couldn't have put all those scenes in, there are some things you must leave out....to keep peoples attention.

For instance the third one, you have everything leading up to the big battle...then the big battle with everything it entailed, the aftermath of the battle, then the decision to go to the Black Gates. Along with the continued trials of Frodo and the Ring, Shelob, the capturing of Frodo, the rescuing of Frodo, the journey of to the big mountain, the asscent, and then Gollum again,...the aftermath of the ring...

The part where everyone meets up.

After all of that you have describe what happens to all of them...


You know you have a good book, when you cannot literally translate it to film. Yeah Jackson took some things out, so what. It doesn't take from the books, it adds to them. People think they know the story of the Lord of the Rings...they don't.

Posted

I completely agree with Jackson's choices of leaving the Tom Bombadil and Scouring of the Shire sequences out of the movies. This is for purely cinematic reasons. I am not at all implying that Tolkien should have left them out of the books.

The Tom Bombadil section does almost nothing to further the plot, and while die-hard Tolkien fans might have appreciated it, most of the movie audience would have found it a bizarre and confusing diversion. Tom Bombadil is one of Tolkien's more unique and enigmatic characters, but, as many have noted, he doesn't quite "fit" in.

While the Scouring of the Shire, is interesting and offers some of Tolkien's insight and opinion's on issues contemporary to him (it is the closest LOTR comes to social/political satire), even in the book, it comes as something of an anti-climax, and loses its interest after the climatic and heroic events of the preceding chapters. To movie audiences, it would've made the movie just seem to drag on long after the "ending." Cutting this section seems to me an obvious director's choice.

I know some will disagree, but these are just my opinions.

Posted

[quote name='Asher' date='Dec 10 2005, 07:56 PM']Peter did a great job... If he stayed THAT close to the book, we wouldn't be as interested. the stuff he left out was poetic and really couldn't be shown on screen. I'm not talking about the actual poems, I mean the scenes, they were too beautiful for film and risky to put in. What Jackson DID put in the film was great.
[right][snapback]820016[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

true... though with tom, you would have to add SO much more, even though he was an awesome character. But if you think about it from a filmmakers stance, it would be a 10 hour movie with tom. :D:

Posted

I think that they were close enough to the books to be a good story, but some important things were changed.

The ones that upset me the most are how the men of ME win the two big battles. Neither of those is like the book.

Posted

[quote name='jezic' date='Dec 13 2005, 10:02 AM']The ones that upset me the most are how the men of ME win the two big battles. Neither of those is like the book.
[right][snapback]823260[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
????? :huh: ??????

The outcome of the battles was the same in the movies as in the book.
Quite frankly, I have no clue what you're talking about here.
Re-watch the movies. Re-read the books.

Posted

they needed more of the scouraging in it besides the mirror in the water thingy (my mind is going blank I'm getting tired, lol)

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Wow Merry CHRISTMASS Tolkien LOVERS!!! :starwars: :duel:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...