Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

[quote name='Circle_Master' date='Jan 15 2006, 06:54 AM']Yeah he is, isn't that cool?  It says that Glorfindel could take 5 Nazghul alone in Lotr/Sil (one of them, I forget now :().  That's why in the book the Nazghul [i]flee[/i] from Glorfindel into the river at Elrond's place.  In the movie they skip him entirely, unfortunately.
[right][snapback]856525[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I can't stand that Peter Jackson took Glorfindel out of the story. :(

He's the guy who uttered the prophecy which said that the witch-king of Angmar would not fall at the hand of man (as we all know Eowyn, a woman, kills him).

I like to go along with the view that Glorfindel died but was sent back by the Valar as a companion of the Istari because he was so cool. And yeah, he would have whooped the Nazghul.. Although in ancient times he died along with the Balrog he was fighting (but you can say the same of Gandalf).

Circle_Master
Posted

I can understand not having Tom Bombadil though. I'm still not sure why he was in the books.

Posted

[quote name='Circle_Master' date='Jan 14 2006, 10:08 PM']Wow.  I thought the COMPLETE opposite that you did.  I thought LotR was a much much better adaptation into movie than the Chronicles of Narnia.  Reasons for that in brief: In Chronicles of Narnia the narrator was removed, major scenes were added (the waterfall), Aslan as sovereign was downplayed, the creatures did not exhibit as much creatureness as the books lend them (the horse in "The Horse and His Boy"'s name was Breesdfsdlkjfksddsdsomething and too hard for Shasta to remember - not 'Philip'., Janus the witch was like 7 feet tall in the other book she appears in).  In LotR only a small character change was made (Pippin/Merry) and some scenes were cut out to save time.

I also loved LotR because it kept the entire 'temptation of evil' theme intact and easy to see.  Power was corrupting and even using it once 'for good' was not an option.

Chronicles of Narnia bugged me because Lewis wrote it for children but not with PG movie guidelines in mind.  The scene where Aslan was slayed on the stone table is very graphic in the book, but in the movie it looked like a weak barbershop scene.  The book allowed it so that if you knew more, you could envision it more as it was supposed to be, but if you were younger you could still enjoy it.  In the movie the entire battle at the end left me a bit bugged as well.  Peter even impales a creature, pulls out the sword, and it is clean.  A little realism would have helped I think.

But anyway, I have loved Tolkien my entire life.  If anyone has read "Leaf by Niggle" I would love to know.  That is my favorite story by Tolkien.  What is even more interesting is how the end of the world is portrayed in "Leaf by Niggle" compared to how Lewis portrays the end of the world in "The Last Battle".

P.S. I also though King Kong was amazing graphically.  I didn't have the experience of 'oo' and 'ahh'ing anywhere in Narnia, but in King Kong over and over again was a 'wow!' experience.

P.P.S. Got Lord of the Bean for Christmas.  I love it.
[right][snapback]856379[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

WHAT????? You complain about a two-minute waterfall scene (NOT major, I might add) but you're ok with the attack of the whargs on the way to Helm's Deep, and Faramir kidnapping Frodo, and ridiculous dream sequences, and ... oh, the list goes on.. *ahem* Bree is NOT the same horse as the one Edmund was riding. If you remember, Bree doesn't arrive in Narnia until the children have been kings and queens for years. And what's to stop a horse in Narnia being named Philip, I'd like to know?? Yes, I was disappointed in Jadis (I mostly noticed that she was supposed to be beautiful), but I was far more disappointed in Elrond, and Arwen, and Galadriel, and Faramir. I really liked that the battle scenes weren't disgusting. They were exciting but still appropriate for children. Sure, there are things there that wouldn't have happened in a real battle. In a real battle, anybody who does a crossed-sword block follows up and kills his opponent, and Jadis didn't kill Peter. But I think that Peter Jackson's battle scenes were overblown, overtheatrical, and disgusting, and I was really happy to see a battle sequence that I could watch without flinching or covering my eyes. I also tend to think that the only way Peter Jackson knows to make a movie exciting is to add more battle sequences (c.f. my comment on King Kong).



By the way, I'm going to pretend not to have noticed the Tom Bombadil comment. (HE WAS CENTRAL TO THE WORLDVIEW!!!!)



Don't get the wrong idea - I'm not arguing strongly because I'm angry, I'm arguing strongly because I have very very strong opinions on this subject.

Posted

I think this whole coversation is nothing but a silly waste of time and I haven't wasted enough time, silly me. :)

Arwen basically replaced the G-elf in PJ's movies. She enters the movie at the same moment that Glorfindel should have.

Since we're discussing things in the movies that annoy I'll add to the list.

Haldir and Celeborn. He elves are not supposed to be sissy boys.
Haldir and Co did not belong at Helm's Deep
King Theoden should not have been so undecisive and weak.
The giving of the gifts should not have been relegated to the extended edition.
I understand leaving out Tom B. but not the Barrow Downs. Aragorn just suddenly appearing with a bunch of hobbit size swords is silly.
Leaving out the Scouring of the Shire was a real pity.

There are many, many more. PJ did some things really well too in my opinion. These are some of the things/characters that I thought were very well done.

Sauron (the eye)
Gollum
The Balrog
Boromir
Gandalf
Sam
The Witch King of Angmar
The Shire
The fireworks

What have I left out?

Circle_Master
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Tata126' date='Jan 17 2006, 01:00 AM']WHAT?????  You complain about a two-minute waterfall scene (NOT major, I might add) but you're ok with the attack of the whargs on the way to Helm's Deep, and Faramir kidnapping Frodo, and ridiculous dream sequences, and ... oh, the list goes on..  *ahem* Bree is NOT the same horse as the one Edmund was riding.  If you remember, Bree doesn't arrive in Narnia until the children have been kings and queens for years.  And what's to stop a horse in Narnia being named Philip, I'd like to know??  Yes, I was disappointed in Jadis (I mostly noticed that she was supposed to be beautiful), but I was far more disappointed in Elrond, and Arwen, and Galadriel, and Faramir.  I really liked that the battle scenes weren't disgusting.  They were exciting but still appropriate for children.  Sure, there are things there that wouldn't have happened in a real battle.  In a real battle, anybody who does a crossed-sword block follows up and kills his opponent, and Jadis didn't kill Peter.  But I think that Peter Jackson's battle scenes were overblown, overtheatrical, and disgusting, and I was really happy to see a battle sequence that I could watch without flinching or covering my eyes.  I also tend to think that the only way Peter Jackson knows to make a movie exciting is to add more battle sequences (c.f. my comment on King Kong).
By the way, I'm going to pretend not to have noticed the Tom Bombadil comment.  (HE WAS CENTRAL TO THE WORLDVIEW!!!!)
Don't get the wrong idea - I'm not arguing strongly because I'm angry, I'm arguing strongly because I have very very strong opinions on this subject.
[right][snapback]858498[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

The waterfall scene was the first time in the movie Peter began to accept he would fight in the conflict and that he must help Narnia. Before that he was there only to get Edmund and return home. It is a key turning point in the movie. The book didn't even have it. The question is why wouldn't the book have that? Because the disney narnia was warped so much it needed something like that.

In LotR you'll also remember that Faramir DID capture Frodo and hold him hostage. And if you can only pick 3 inconsistencies from 1000+ pages of LotR that's rather amazing!

My point with Bree is not that he should have existed, but that 'philip' is not a horses name. It is a disney-horse name and has nothing to do with C.S. Lewis. It is another thing they decided to do whereby warping the world Lewis created. In a related topic the animals all sounded like animals in the book - they did not sound like humans. That's another disneyfication.

On the battle scenes we'll have to agree to disagree. I am coming from the more typical guy position that realism is essential. There is a lot of blood in battle, I want to see it in battle. The disney battle in Narnia looked like a kid's battle, especially with the blurring people at the end of it. Not realistic in the least bit which is what would have helped me to 'get with the movie.'

[quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Jan 17 2006, 05:39 AM']Arwen basically replaced the G-elf in PJ's movies.  She enters the movie at the same moment that Glorfindel should have.[/quote]
Yeah, silly women ;-)

[quote]Since we're discussing things in the movies that annoy I'll add to the list.

Haldir and Celeborn.  He elves are not supposed to be sissy boys.
Haldir and Co did not belong at Helm's Deep
King Theoden should not have been so undecisive and weak.
The giving of the gifts should not have been relegated to the extended edition.
I understand leaving out Tom B. but not the Barrow Downs.  Aragorn just suddenly appearing with a bunch of hobbit size swords is silly.
Leaving out the Scouring of the Shire was a real pity.[/quote]
I'll agree, I wish those things were a bit better. Although I think Peter Jackson showed a good contrast between the first King Theoden and the second one as he wasn't under Saruman's influence anymore.

And the barrow downs could have been added, although more people would have complained about 'movie length' for that to happen. Same goes for the scourin of the shire. I was really really looking for that in the extended edition as well :(.

Edited by Circle_Master
Posted

[quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Jan 17 2006, 04:39 AM']
Since we're discussing things in the movies that annoy I'll add to the list.

Haldir and Celeborn.  He elves are not supposed to be sissy boys.
Haldir and Co did not belong at Helm's Deep
King Theoden should not have been so undecisive and weak.
The giving of the gifts should not have been relegated to the extended edition.
I understand leaving out Tom B. but not the Barrow Downs.  Aragorn just suddenly appearing with a bunch of hobbit size swords is silly.
Leaving out the Scouring of the Shire was a real pity.

[right][snapback]858524[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I agree with all the scenes you mentioned OLAM Dad. I though these were also annoying.

Gollum framing Sam and Frodo sending him home was dumb.
Legolas' ninja moves like sliding down the stairs on a shield and twirling onto a horse without looking.
Legolas' horrible dialogue ("...a diversion")
Denethor jumping off the tower after lighting himself on fire

Maria

  • 9 months later...
Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' post='1110719' date='Nov 4 2006, 09:03 AM']
I am BACK!!!
[/quote]

At the turning of the tide?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...