Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

sarcasmguy126
Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' date='Dec 8 2005, 06:54 AM']Just thought every one might be intrested in this topic! Do you think Lord of the Rings movies were that close to the books?
:seesaw:  :shield:
[right][snapback]816616[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

no, not except for FOTR

Posted

Which do you guys think is better Narnia or LOTR? :starwars: :duel:

Posted

[quote name='Gandalf' date='Dec 27 2005, 06:35 PM']Which do you guys think is better Narnia or LOTR? :starwars:  :duel:
[right][snapback]837143[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
LOTR (both books and movies).

But that's kind of comparing apples and oranges. Narnia is aimed more at children, while LOTR is more for older kids and adults.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='Dec 13 2005, 05:08 PM']?????  :huh:  ??????

The outcome of the battles was the same in the movies as in the book.
Quite frankly, I have no clue what you're talking about here.
Re-watch the movies.  Re-read the books.
[right][snapback]824053[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

The outcomes were the same, but the races who fought were different (like the Battle for Helms Deep, in the book, had no elves and in the movies, did).

I like both the books and the movies, but I wish, in they had made Faramir more like the book Faramir and that they hadn't added the Aragorn dying subplot. I still don't get why they did that.

Posted

I can generally understand the changes in the story-line (though without the extended version some stuff really doesn't make sense), but I do have a problem with the way characters are presented and developed. Somebody touched on the subject when speaking of Faramir, but basically none of the characters in the movies have the nobility conveyed by the characters in the books. And I find that the elves are just... wrong.

Posted

I was really hoping for the scouring of the shire in the extended RotK.
I think that part really made me reflect on the meaning of the whole thing. Without the scouring, it's too much like any other fantasy story I've read. We always get the cut from winning the big battle to happily ever after. Life is almost never like that. It's just when you're longing for home that you find that you have to clean up when you get back.

Posted

[quote name='Philomena' date='Dec 27 2005, 07:45 PM']The outcomes were the same, but the races who fought were different (like the Battle for Helms Deep, in the book, had no elves and in the movies, did).

I like both the books and the movies, but I wish, in they had made Faramir more like the book Faramir and that they hadn't added the Aragorn dying subplot. I still don't get why they did that.
[right][snapback]837251[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Jezic said that the movies got it wrong because the men [b]won[/b] the battles.
I didn't like the elves being added their either. Rather pointless. The elves were gay.

The "Aragorn dying subplot" is basically to play up the whole theme of the problem of mortality vs immortality in the union of Aragorn and Arwen (not dealt with mush in the LOTR books, but drawn from Tolkien's footnotes and Silmarillion).
I thought it tended to drag a bit in the movies, and become a little self-indulgent, but it did have a point.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Socrates' date='Dec 27 2005, 09:15 PM']LOTR (both books and movies).

But that's kind of comparing apples and oranges.  Narnia is aimed more at children, while LOTR is more for older kids and adults.
[right][snapback]837201[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

True LOTR is more dense and Narnia is not as much! :detective:

Posted

What is every ones favorite person in LOTR?

photosynthesis
Posted

I liked the movies and now that I have all this free time floating around I decided to start reading The Fellowship of the Ring. Good stuff...except Tolkien is so gosh-darned DESCRIPTIVE. I mean, just get on with it already. so far it's been a good read though.

Posted

Narnia is a much better adaptation of the book than LOTR was. MUCH better. The Fellowship was promising, but by the time The Return of the King came out I had lost all respect for Peter Jackson both as a director and as an interpreter of Tolkien.

I think everything Cam said, and would in addition like to point out that Peter Jackson's only method of creating excitement is to have disgusting battle after disgusting battle, which is not really what LOTR is all about.

I also think King Kong (c.f. the hour and a half of dinosaurs) is basically what Peter Jackson would have turned LOTR into if he hadn't been restrained by those darn books - not that he let them restrain him much. :-\

Not a fan. Those books verge on the sacred for me, and I really really hate the heavy-handed treatment Peter Jackson gave them. I also think he didn't understand them at all.

Posted

i'm watching the Veggie Tales 'Lord of the Beans' right now with my daughter...
2 funny

Posted

[quote name='hope4thenew' date='Jan 8 2006, 01:00 PM']i'm watching the Veggie Tales 'Lord of the Beans' right now with my daughter...
2 funny
[right][snapback]849518[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Agreed, toooooo funny.
I love the Gimli character. 'Got any waffles?' And leg-o-lamb always having to stop to pee. :rolling:

Back on topic. I love the books and liked the movies very much. The faramir heresy was my biggest disappointment.

Posted

[quote name='hope4thenew' date='Jan 8 2006, 02:00 PM']i'm watching the Veggie Tales 'Lord of the Beans' right now with my daughter...
2 funny
[right][snapback]849518[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
I loved the movie I like when the sporks say "Cookie Man Say no"

Posted

Who thinks LOTR Rocks there SOCKS? :deal: :club: :getaclue: :getaclue: :juggle: :starwars: :tvhappy: :bugeyes: :hijack: :wall: :ohno:

Posted

read the trilogy annually :) Favorite character from the book: Faramir
Favorite time to read the walk to Mordor: Lent

Circle_Master
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Tata126' date='Jan 8 2006, 12:26 PM']Narnia is a much better adaptation of the book than LOTR was.  MUCH better.  The Fellowship was promising, but by the time The Return of the King came out I had lost all respect for Peter Jackson both as a director and as an interpreter of Tolkien.

I think everything Cam said, and would in addition like to point out that Peter Jackson's only method of creating excitement is to have disgusting battle after disgusting battle, which is not really what LOTR is all about.

I also think King Kong (c.f. the hour and a half of dinosaurs) is basically what Peter Jackson would have turned LOTR into if he hadn't been restrained by those darn books - not that he let them restrain him much.  :-\

Not a fan.  Those books verge on the sacred for me, and I really really hate the heavy-handed treatment Peter Jackson gave them.  I also think he didn't understand them at all.
[right][snapback]849480[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Wow. I thought the COMPLETE opposite that you did. I thought LotR was a much much better adaptation into movie than the Chronicles of Narnia. Reasons for that in brief: In Chronicles of Narnia the narrator was removed, major scenes were added (the waterfall), Aslan as sovereign was downplayed, the creatures did not exhibit as much creatureness as the books lend them (the horse in "The Horse and His Boy"'s name was Breesdfsdlkjfksddsdsomething and too hard for Shasta to remember - not 'Philip'., Janus the witch was like 7 feet tall in the other book she appears in). In LotR only a small character change was made (Pippin/Merry) and some scenes were cut out to save time.

I also loved LotR because it kept the entire 'temptation of evil' theme intact and easy to see. Power was corrupting and even using it once 'for good' was not an option.

Chronicles of Narnia bugged me because Lewis wrote it for children but not with PG movie guidelines in mind. The scene where Aslan was slayed on the stone table is very graphic in the book, but in the movie it looked like a weak barbershop scene. The book allowed it so that if you knew more, you could envision it more as it was supposed to be, but if you were younger you could still enjoy it. In the movie the entire battle at the end left me a bit bugged as well. Peter even impales a creature, pulls out the sword, and it is clean. A little realism would have helped I think.

But anyway, I have loved Tolkien my entire life. If anyone has read "Leaf by Niggle" I would love to know. That is my favorite story by Tolkien. What is even more interesting is how the end of the world is portrayed in "Leaf by Niggle" compared to how Lewis portrays the end of the world in "The Last Battle".

P.S. I also though King Kong was amazing graphically. I didn't have the experience of 'oo' and 'ahh'ing anywhere in Narnia, but in King Kong over and over again was a 'wow!' experience.

P.P.S. Got Lord of the Bean for Christmas. I love it.

Edited by Circle_Master
Posted

I have in my posession a book entitled "Characters From Tolkien" by David Day. It has every character Tolkien ever created in it. Anyone jealous??? :D:

Posted

[quote name='zealousrap' date='Jan 15 2006, 01:24 AM']I have in my posession a book entitled "Characters From Tolkien" by David Day. It has every character Tolkien ever created in it. Anyone jealous??? :D:
[right][snapback]856487[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Yes, I'm jealous.

How many Glorfindel's are in your book? I'm curious because there is one in the Sil and one in LotR and I'm wondering whether he is the same guy...er...elf.

Circle_Master
Posted

[quote name='OLAM Dad' date='Jan 15 2006, 05:37 AM']How many Glorfindel's are in your book?  I'm curious because there is one in the Sil and one in LotR and I'm wondering whether he is the same guy...er...elf.
[right][snapback]856504[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Yeah he is, isn't that cool? It says that Glorfindel could take 5 Nazghul alone in Lotr/Sil (one of them, I forget now :(). That's why in the book the Nazghul [i]flee[/i] from Glorfindel into the river at Elrond's place. In the movie they skip him entirely, unfortunately.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...