Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

can I ask you a question?? why are you so hung up on this? This is like the 3rd thread you've started on it, and I've seen you mention something else about it.

Don't let something like this define who you are. This wasn't an act you did, and yet God still created you. Thats the most important part here. It doesn't matter for you the circumstances you were brought into this world, the fact that God loved you enough to first off create you, and then send His son to die for you makes all that other stuff just extra fluff.

Theres no need to be ashamed of this. I wouldn't be exceptionally proud of it either. Its just part of life. Don't kill your self esteem over it. Just focus on the things you do in life, theres a lot to be proud of.

Posted

The reason that you cannot be a member of Opus Dei, is because you were conceived outside wedlock.

This is part of the bylaws of the Work. I will not speak further on this, as it is a matter for the Work to discuss if so questioned. If you would like to inquire about it, I would suggest that you write to the Prelature and they will respond in kind.

God Bless,

Cam42

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Feb 11 2006, 10:34 PM']can I ask you a question?? why are you so hung up on this?  This is like the 3rd thread you've started on it, and I've seen you mention something else about it.

Don't let something like this define who you are.  This wasn't an act you did, and yet God still created you.  Thats the most important part here.  It doesn't matter for you the circumstances you were brought into this world, the fact that God loved you enough to first off create you, and then send His son to die for you makes all that other stuff just extra fluff.

Theres no need to be ashamed of this.  I wouldn't be exceptionally proud of it either.  Its just part of life.  Don't kill your self esteem over it.  Just focus on the things you do in life, theres a lot to be proud of.
[right][snapback]884394[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Well forgive me, but I just can't get over it. Do you think it's easy not being able to fill in "Mother's Maiden Name" on applications?

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 11 2006, 10:34 PM']The reason that you cannot be a member of Opus Dei, is because you were conceived outside wedlock.

This is part of the bylaws of the Work.  I will not speak further on this, as it is a matter for the Work to discuss if so questioned.  If you would like to inquire about it, I would suggest that you write to the Prelature and they will respond in kind.

God Bless,

Cam42
[right][snapback]884396[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Do you have their conact information? Namely email?

Posted

Look at your mother in all this also. She made a mistake, and probably had a really tough time dealing with it. But through her strength and courage she carried you to term, and even took it upon herself to raise you the best she could. If she knew you were thinking this way don't you think it would just break her heart? She loves you so much. It might have been easier to do many other things, including aborition, yet she didn't.

I would say you truly are a love child in the sense that the amount of love that your mother has for you is truly exceptional.

Like Era said... this is in the past. Look foward in life.

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' date='Feb 11 2006, 10:50 PM']Look at your mother in all this also.  She made a mistake, and probably had a really tough time dealing with it.  But through her strength and courage she carried you to term, and even took it upon herself to raise you the best she could.  If she knew you were thinking this way don't you think it would just break her heart?  She loves you so much.  It might have been easier to do many other things, including aborition, yet she didn't. 

I would say you truly are a love child in the sense that the amount of love that your mother has for you is truly exceptional. 

Like Era said... this is in the past.  Look foward in life.
[right][snapback]884427[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I am looking forward. And I see the "Mother's Maiden Name" box.

Posted

[quote]Dear Sir or Madam,

I am bastard child, as such I can't join Opus Dei as a full fledged member. Why must this be? Why must I pay for the choices of my parents? You claim to be "pro-life", but you reget the fruit of the movement which you claim to support.

I would greatly appriceate the answers to my questions.

God Bless,[/quote]

I'm going to email this to opus dei.

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 11 2006, 11:34 PM']The reason that you cannot be a member of Opus Dei, is because you were conceived outside wedlock.

This is part of the bylaws of the Work.  I will not speak further on this, as it is a matter for the Work to discuss if so questioned.  If you would like to inquire about it, I would suggest that you write to the Prelature and they will respond in kind.

God Bless,

Cam42
[right][snapback]884396[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
but... why should a such a person be held responsible for the sins of their parents? It's not their fault that they were conceived out of wedlock... such things happen. Jesus was conceived out of wedlock, so obviously we cannot say that He was a mistake.

No one is ever a mistake.

And what if you don't know if your parents were married or not? Whenever I asked my mom if I was conceived before or after they got married, I never get a straight answer.

Then again, I've never felt called to formally join Opus Dei... can you still go to their women's nights of recollection if you are an illegitimate child?

missionseeker
Posted

Have you already sent it?

Posted

That is bizarre... and it feels VERY wrong.

I never heard that before about Opus Dei.


You can be a knight cinsd... all you need to be is a Catholic in good standing with the Church.

Your parents never being married can not alone keep you from joining the Columbian brotherhood.

Posted

I will not speak for the Work. If you have direct questions, I suggest that you contact the Work directly.

Also, the email that you propose to send probably will not be responded to, if sent in that tone. I would suggest that you use more tact.

Posted

Those are the rules of the order. If it does not allow you to, accept it and find another order.

I had a friend who so desired to be a priest. He has a tattoo. Through discernment, he felt called to a particular order and thus lived with them for sometime. When they found out he had a tattoo, he could no longer be a part of the order.

Although he was heartbroken, he saw this as a sign from God and still sought other orders and is thus in Alabama in the seminary of his dreams.

Everything happens for a reason. Trust God and be humble enough to walk away and still discern your call.

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' date='Feb 11 2006, 11:24 PM']Have you already sent it?
[right][snapback]884465[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Yep, why?

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 11 2006, 11:28 PM']
Also, the email that you propose to send probably will not be responded to, if sent in that tone.  I would suggest that you use more tact.
[right][snapback]884470[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

If they don't reply I'll know what to think of them.

missionseeker
Posted

[quote]Dear Sir or Madam,

I am bastard child, as such I can't join Opus Dei as a full fledged member. Why must this be? Why must I pay for the choices of my parents? You claim to be "pro-life", but you reget the fruit of the movement which you claim to support.

I would greatly appriceate the answers to my questions.

God Bless,[/quote]

How about.

Dear Sir or Madam,
something about how you would like to/felt called to join Opus Dei
(a whole paragraph or two depending on how much detail you put in)

But I was concieved/born out of wedlock and as a result, I cannot....

Now maybe something like
I don't understand why this is. ...


That might be a better way to start. I don't know if I would put that in about "pro-life" (though you have a point there)

Posted

[quote name='missionseeker' date='Feb 11 2006, 11:38 PM']How about.

Dear Sir or Madam,
something about how you would like to/felt called to join Opus Dei
(a whole paragraph or two depending on how much detail you put in)

But I was concieved/born out of wedlock and as a result, I cannot....

Now maybe something like
I don't understand why this is. ...
That might be a better way to start. I don't know if I would put that in about "pro-life" (though you have a point there)
[right][snapback]884481[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I think they get alot of email so short & to the point is probably to the best.

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='jmjtina' date='Feb 12 2006, 12:33 AM']I had a friend who so desired to be a priest. He has a tattoo. Through discernment, he felt called to a particular order and thus lived with them for sometime. When they found out he had a tattoo, he could no longer be a part of the order.
[right][snapback]884474[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
That sounds weird. I know priests with tattoos... One of them has a tattoo of a picture of the Holy Eucharist (bread + a chalice) and underneath it says "A priest forever." It is really beautiful, a sign that he wants to persevere to the end.

I also know another who has a tattoo of Our Lady of Guadelupe

I mean, if he has a tattoo of something disgusting or sacreligious then i could see why... but what if it is something holy?

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 11 2006, 10:00 PM']That sounds weird.  I know priests with tattoos...  One of them has a tattoo of a picture of the Holy Eucharist (bread + a chalice) and underneath it says "A priest forever."  It is really beautiful, a sign that he wants to persevere to the end.

I also know another who has a tattoo of Our Lady of Guadelupe

I mean, if he has a tattoo of something disgusting or sacreligious then i could see why...  but what if it is something holy?
[right][snapback]884499[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Wierd? Nah. Knowing priests with tattoos isn't a rule for every order. The order he was first discerning had the rule, holy or not.......and he abided by it.

The seminary where he is at presently has no rule against tattoos and therefore he is studying to be a priest.

I'll know my first priest with a tattoo, but there are many different rules with different orders. That's why it's called discernment.

photosynthesis
Posted

well, that's good that he is still able to go to seminary... i am glad there are seminaries that accept guys with holy tattooos... I think there is something really awesome about having something like the Sacred Heart of Jesus etched into your body forever.

although I'm just weird like that

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 11 2006, 10:18 PM'] Discuss love children, like me, here. 
[/quote]
I think they usually have large noses & gangly feet.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...