Fidei Defensor Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Quietfire' date='Feb 12 2006, 08:57 AM']Wow, I gotta say this. You sound so selfish and angry right now. I dont mean to be harsh, but listen to yourself. You were born out of wedlock, big deal. Opus Dei does not accept persons born out of wedlock into their order...Big Deal. It is not a personal attack against [i]you[/i], it is simply their rule. The fact that you cannot become a member seems to have clouded your intellect and most definitely, your feelings, now you are hell bend on judging their rules for entry, as well as judging them. It isnt your passion that is offensive, it's your attitude. That should tell you that they stick to their guns, so to speak,(and we need more of this in the Church) and that should be enough for you. Instead you whine, stamp your feet and throw tomatoes and ask us to support you. uh, no...no way. Look, Im sorry you werent accepted. Really. But Im not that sorry when your reaction is like that of a five year old not getting his way. All youre doing is bitching and not listening. Grow up, accept the fact that although you were born out of wedlock, God DOES want you here for a reason, be humble, pray, and wait for further instruction. Pax [right][snapback]884629[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Almost exactly what my feelings are about this. Stop being so angry at Opus Dei because of a rule they have. And honestly, I dont see how being pro-life even has anything to do with this. They are pro-life because they want every human to have the right to be born, because God wills every human life to have equal rights to be born. That doesnt mean they have to accept every human into their Prelature. While you may not like this, it is for them to make the rules because they are in charge. Honestly, no offense, you sound like those women who want to be priests. I know the circumstances are way different, but still.. you are acting in the same type of manner.
ForHimAlone Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 God's providence will always guide everything. If it was the Lord's will that you be a member of Opus Dei, you would have been able to be. Trust in Him- He knows what He wills for you.
Cam42 Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:23 PM']Cam, Does Opus Dei claim to be pro-life or not? If they don't I'll forgive them and move on. [right][snapback]884834[/snapback][/right] [/quote] That is a ridiculous question. Opus Dei is 100% pro-life. Please refrain from making such statements. I would suggest that you discuss this with your spiritual director. I would also suggest that you stop with your questioning of the practices of Opus Dei. They are recognized by the Church and the by-laws are accepted by Rome. I am sorry that you feel slighted by them, however this is an issue for you and your spiritual director to discuss, not me. Please refrain from asking slanderous questions. Thanks.
catholicinsd Posted February 12, 2006 Author Posted February 12, 2006 You can't be pro-life and reject love children from your organization.
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='fidei defensor' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:56 PM']Honestly, no offense, you sound like those women who want to be priests. I know the circumstances are way different, but still.. you are acting in the same type of manner. [right][snapback]884860[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I strongly disagree. There is nothing in Scripture or Tradition that has ever said that women can be priests, thus they would have no reason to ever logically want to join the priesthood. It is simply improper to their state in life. Nor is it ever appropriate for a man to ever deprive a woman of her right to be a mother. This is different, though, because it is perfectly logical for a person conceived out of wedlock to want to be a member of a Catholic organization. To me, this rule seems illogical and outdated. There is a HUGE difference between a man and a woman. But what difference is there between a man conceived in marriage and a man who is conceived out of wedlock? Is one more moral than the other? Is one more pleasing to God than the other? Yeah, rules are rules. But some rules don't make any sense and I think that anyone who disagrees with such a rule would be justified in their disagreement. If you were a bus driver in the 50's when black + white people were segregated, would you have said "rules are rules" to Rosa Parks? I wouldn't have. If this particular organization doesn't want to accept people conceived out of wedlock, then I guess that's their business and you should look into other religious institutes. But I don't understand why they would have this practice, it seems really off to me. As far as opus dei stuff goes, I think you can still have a devotion to St. Josemaria Escriva and live out his spirituality without joining Opus Dei. Not all people are called to such a thing. There are all kinds of Catholic organizations... Legion of Mary, Knights of Columbus, Catholic Daughters, Communion + Liberation, Society of St. Vincent De Paul, etc. I used to be in Legion of Mary and I loved it... they have a special society just for teens.
ForHimAlone Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 02:09 PM']You can't be pro-life and reject love children from your organization. [right][snapback]884868[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I think you should maybe calm down with this a bit until you hear from Opus Dei. That's not fair to the organization at all. Please have respect for the Opus Dei, and trust that the Lord's will will be done in all things.
Cow of Shame Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:18 PM']Opus Dei is a vocation, not a club. [/quote] Yeah. He makes it sound like the Mickey Mouse club sent back his application with a rejection letter & little mouse turds on it. Can I start a Mickey Mouse club? I'm dying to get your applications! Edited February 12, 2006 by Cow of Shame
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 also, I have a question for Cam... Why does Opus Dei have this policy, and how far does it extend? Do you have to be conceived within marriage to be at all invoved with the organization (like to go to their events and Masses) or just to be a numerary or supernumerary? What about cooperators? Also, say a woman has premarital sex and conceives a child... Then she repents of her sins and becomes Catholic. Is she prohibited from joining opus dei? What if she didn't conceive but she had an abortion or used contraception? Or what if you were conceived within marriage, but your parents then divorced + got remarried? Or what if your parents were "married" when they had you, but then had their marriage annulled so their marriage never existed? What does that mean for the child?
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Cow of Shame' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:00 PM']Yeah. He makes it sound like the Mickey Mouse club sent back his application with a rejection letter & little mouse turds on it. Can I start a Mickey Mouse club? I'm dying to get your applications! [right][snapback]884895[/snapback][/right] [/quote] LOL.... if I were going to start my own organization, I think I'd prohibit people with hyphenated last names from joining. If they can't decide what their last name should be, then they must have trouble with decision making. I think i will make it a new requirement for my Photosynthesis School of Assertiveness Training.
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:02 PM']I like the rule. [right][snapback]884902[/snapback][/right] [/quote] why?
Fides_et_Ratio Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:04 PM']why? [right][snapback]884906[/snapback][/right] [/quote] This thread (and most others started by catholicinsd) are perfect examples. If "love children" (as he wants to call them) are so obsessed with being "love children" then they are not fit for religious orders. It's an unhealthy preoccupation that should not be dwelt upon ALL THE TIME (I mean, can he think of nothing else to talk/think about?). There are better things to help a person's sanity/sanctity.
Cam42 Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:01 PM']also, I have a question for Cam... Why does Opus Dei have this policy, and how far does it extend? Do you have to be conceived within marriage to be at all invoved with the organization (like to go to their events and Masses) or just to be a numerary or supernumerary? What about cooperators? Also, say a woman has premarital sex and conceives a child... Then she repents of her sins and becomes Catholic. Is she prohibited from joining opus dei? What if she didn't conceive but she had an abortion or used contraception? Or what if you were conceived within marriage, but your parents then divorced + got remarried? Or what if your parents were "married" when they had you, but then had their marriage annulled so their marriage never existed? What does that mean for the child? [right][snapback]884896[/snapback][/right] [/quote] As I have said, you should contact the Prelature for an answer for this question about policy. I will not respond to this, as I am not an official spokesman for the Work. A cooperator is not a member of Opus Dei, so one does not need to fulfill the requirements in order to be a cooperator. As a matter of fact, one does not need to be Catholic or even Christian to be a cooperator. Please address the remainder of your questions to the prelature. Thank you.
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:06 PM']This thread (and most others started by catholicinsd) are perfect examples. If "love children" (as he wants to call them) are so obsessed with being "love children" then they are not fit for religious orders. It's an unhealthy preoccupation that should not be dwelt upon ALL THE TIME. There are better things to help a person's sanity/sanctity. [right][snapback]884908[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I wouldn't assume that all people conceived out of wedlock are like catholicinsd. He is very young and probably trying to make sense out of his past. There are plenty of fully mature people out there conceived out of wedlock who are over it and have moved on. There are plenty of things out there that scar people for life... abuse, rape, domestic violence, divorce, parents' remarriage, etc. Mental instability is mental instability. You don't have to be a child born out of wedlock to be psychologically damaged. If mental health is the issue, then why wouldn't they do what most religious orders do, and that is requiring a psych evaluation? That makes perfect sense to me.
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:06 PM']As I have said, you should contact the Prelature for an answer for this question about policy. I will not respond to this, as I am not an official spokesman for the Work. A cooperator is not a member of Opus Dei, so one does not need to fulfill the requirements in order to be a cooperator. As a matter of fact, one does not need to be Catholic or even Christian to be a cooperator. Please address the remainder of your questions to the prelature. Thank you. [right][snapback]884909[/snapback][/right] [/quote] you're not the prelature, but you are a member so wouldn't that mean you'd have to know at least something about the organization? how would I go about contacting the prelature? would they even listen to me?
Norseman82 Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:01 PM']also, I have a question for Cam... Why does Opus Dei have this policy, and how far does it extend? Do you have to be conceived within marriage to be at all invoved with the organization (like to go to their events and Masses) or just to be a numerary or supernumerary? What about cooperators? Also, say a woman has premarital sex and conceives a child... Then she repents of her sins and becomes Catholic. Is she prohibited from joining opus dei? What if she didn't conceive but she had an abortion or used contraception? Or what if you were conceived within marriage, but your parents then divorced + got remarried? Or what if your parents were "married" when they had you, but then had their marriage annulled so their marriage never existed? What does that mean for the child? [right][snapback]884896[/snapback][/right] [/quote] Additionally, that would have chilling consequences for those who were adopted, since a lot of adoptees were conceived out of wedlock, I'm sure. If someone who is a member of the Work found out later he or she were adopted and that the birth mother conceived out of wedlock, would he/she then be kicked out? But I would like to hear clarification from Opus Dei (and I did visit their website and found nothing on the topic). I really hope and pray that this is just a misunderstanding, otherwise they are just giving themselves an unnecessary black eye.
God Conquers Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 I think Cam would rather not talk about that particular rule... I can respect that, he is not obligated to do so, especially if he is ending up defending something he doesn't believe in or just starting a huge controversy. I'm just gonna ask my Uni Chaplain about it. (an Opus Dei Priest). I'll get back to phatmass with the answer I get.
catholicinsd Posted February 12, 2006 Author Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 04:06 PM']This thread (and most others started by catholicinsd) are perfect examples. If "love children" (as he wants to call them) are so obsessed with being "love children" then they are not fit for religious orders. It's an unhealthy preoccupation that should not be dwelt upon ALL THE TIME (I mean, can he think of nothing else to talk/think about?). There are better things to help a person's sanity/sanctity. [right][snapback]884908[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I'm not obsessed with it. It's just been bothering me lately.
Cam42 Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:14 PM']you're not the prelature, but you are a member so wouldn't that mean you'd have to know at least something about the organization? how would I go about contacting the prelature? would they even listen to me? [right][snapback]884916[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I know much about the Prelature. I am not, however, going to make a statement for the Prelature. I am not going to risk making a slip of the tongue (sic. keyboard) that would do my person and my vocation damage. There are many others more qualified than myself to speak about this. Also, I have disclosed my vocation after discussion with my spiritual director. He and I have come to the conclusion that I will divulge what I will, but I will not make any statements which are inconclusive about the Work. This is a matter of obedience for me. I would ask that you respect the wishes of my spiritual director and my wishes and contact the Prelature. You may write to them in Rome, or you may email them. As for response, I don't know. Whenever I have corresponded with the Prelature, they have responded to me. So, I would assume they would listen. I can't imagine why they wouldn't. Would you expect a response from the Jesuits if you wrote them or the Benedcitines or the Francisicans? I would suggest the chances are the same. God Bless.
photosynthesis Posted February 12, 2006 Posted February 12, 2006 [quote name='Cam42' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:45 PM']I know much about the Prelature. I am not, however, going to make a statement for the Prelature. I am not going to risk making a slip of the tongue (sic. keyboard) that would do my person and my vocation damage. There are many others more qualified than myself to speak about this. Also, I have disclosed my vocation after discussion with my spiritual director. He and I have come to the conclusion that I will divulge what I will, but I will not make any statements which are inconclusive about the Work. This is a matter of obedience for me. I would ask that you respect the wishes of my spiritual director and my wishes and contact the Prelature. You may write to them in Rome, or you may email them. As for response, I don't know. Whenever I have corresponded with the Prelature, they have responded to me. So, I would assume they would listen. I can't imagine why they wouldn't. Would you expect a response from the Jesuits if you wrote them or the Benedcitines or the Francisicans? I would suggest the chances are the same. God Bless. [right][snapback]884940[/snapback][/right] [/quote] I can respect that you wouldn't want to disclose more info then... But I doubt the prelature in Rome would write back... same thing about the jesuit, benedictines, dominicans, etc. I'm not very important. although i think if i wrote the dominicans + benedictines about discerning a religious vocation, THEN they would most certainly write back i have a lot of nuns stalking me right now.
Recommended Posts