Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:42 PM']I'm not obsessed with it. It's just been bothering me lately.
[right][snapback]884937[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Then take it up with a qualified counselor or spiritual director. These are not issues for public display.

You have my prayers.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:15 PM']I strongly disagree.  There is nothing in Scripture or Tradition that has ever said that women can be priests, thus they would have no reason to ever logically want to join the priesthood.  It is simply improper to their state in life.  Nor is it ever appropriate for a man to ever deprive a woman of her right to be a mother.

This is different, though, because it is perfectly logical for a person conceived out of wedlock to want to be a member of a Catholic organization.  To me, this rule seems illogical and outdated.  There is a HUGE difference between a man and a woman.  But what difference is there between a man conceived in marriage and a man who is conceived out of wedlock?  Is one more moral than the other?  Is one more pleasing to God than the other?

Yeah, rules are rules.  But some rules don't make any sense and I think that anyone who disagrees with such a rule would be justified in their disagreement.  If you were a bus driver in the 50's when black + white people were segregated, would you have said "rules are rules" to Rosa Parks?  I wouldn't have.

If this particular organization doesn't want to accept people conceived out of wedlock, then I guess that's their business and you should look into other religious institutes.  But I don't understand why they would have this practice, it seems really off to me.

As far as opus dei stuff goes, I think you can still have a devotion to St. Josemaria Escriva and live out his spirituality without joining Opus Dei.  Not all people are called to such a thing.  There are all kinds of Catholic organizations...  Legion of Mary, Knights of Columbus, Catholic Daughters, Communion + Liberation, Society of St. Vincent De Paul, etc.  I used to be in Legion of Mary and I loved it...  they have a special society just for teens.
[right][snapback]884871[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Note my line about this being completely different circumstances. I only meant it as in he is after something he wont get, and he shouldnt be throwing a big stink over it.

Posted

[quote name='photosynthesis' date='Feb 12 2006, 05:49 PM']I can respect that you wouldn't want to disclose more info then...  But I doubt the prelature in Rome would write back...  same thing about the jesuit, benedictines, dominicans, etc.  I'm not very important.

although i think if i wrote the dominicans + benedictines about discerning a religious vocation, THEN they would most certainly write back :)  i have a lot of nuns stalking me right now.
[right][snapback]884943[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Well, the way we discern our vocation isn't exactly "traditional" as in the form of most other vocations. We don't have a postulancy or a novitiate. You also don't need to contact the Prelate of Opus Dei in order to express interest. What you need to do is seek out a center and speak with a numerary or a priest of the Society.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:09 PM']You can't be pro-life and reject love children from your organization.
[right][snapback]884868[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Yes they can. Just like they can reject anyone else.

Posted

From what I understand concerning Opus Dei is that you are far too young to even be considered at this point.(if in fact you are only 14)
Usually around college age is more appropriate. Im not saying that that is the norm, but it is more usual.

Maturity is another major point, which sadly you seem to be lacking.

Case in point. You are here, ranting about not being accepted in a group that will help you discern your future. Would I want you in my organization knowing the minute you dont get your way your gonna go balistic and be on the internet blabbing about how 'horrible' my organization is?
It isnt a "mickey mouse" club (as some have mentioned) that you join and think all is fine fine and that's it. It is a LIFELONG commitment. It isnt something that you hang around with for a while and then decide that 'oh, well, i wont go anymore ive got better things to do' type of arrangement. From what I understand, I can honestly say that [b]I[/b] am not Opus Dei material, and I dont need a spiritual director to tell me that.

They dont kid around, they are that serious. And no matter how wonderful I may think it would be to be a part of that organization, I know in my heart...I dont have the heart to give such a commitment. My obligations demand that I be somewhere else, and I am ok with that. God has other plans for me and I am listening to Him.

People involved with Opus Dei are serious about what they are doing. Im not saying that you or anyone else isnt. What Im saying is that we ALL cant be part of it.
They assist people in discerning lifelong commitments. Dude, at 14 you are in no position to be able to do that. Sorry, trust me on this. I am more than twice your age and after investigating them, I cant believe that you are willing to make this kind of decision at your age.
If you were a bit more mature, you would realize that maybe, just maybe God is preparing you Himself. If you have a goal that you wish to reach, and if for some reason, Opus Dei is not a part of that goal, it is God's will...not yours. You need to accept this and MOVE ON. You have to stop fighting God's will, and for God's sake you need to stop the whining. This above everything else proves your immaturity.

I truly dont mean to sound harsh. Like I said earlier, you have the passion, but you also have a lousy attitude. Think for a moment about all those people within the Church that dont 'get their way'. What happens to some of them? They get disgusted and leave, or create schisms within the Church- or worse yet, they stay and create chaos. Organizations like Opus Dei, I would think, try to avoid that. There are people that have gotten involved with Opus Dei and it was a negative effect for everyone involved...not a good thing. Not at all.

Look, move on from this. It does you no good. You are truly loved no matter what. That is what the most important thing should be. Your mother loved [b]you[/b] so much that she gave birth to [b]you[/b] and raised [b]you[/b] in a time when the answer to pregnancy is abortion. God loves [b]you[/b] so much that He created your soul and holds [b]you[/b] in the palm of His hand every moment of your existance. [b]You[/b] are amazing, because God created you. [b]You[/b] are amazing because [b]you[/b] are here. Nothing else should matter. Big deal, O.D. doesnt want you. You're 14 and headed for bigger things. Maybe even a future Pope down the road. HEY, it could happen!!
Are you going to let this control and ruin your life?



Let the demon go.

Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 04:01 PM']Then take it up with a qualified counselor or spiritual director. These are not issues for public display.
[right][snapback]884951[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Phamily: what is more appropriate for public display - complaining about an injustice, or saying you like it:

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 03:02 PM']I like the rule.
[right][snapback]884902[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' date='Feb 12 2006, 04:01 PM']You have my prayers.
[right][snapback]884951[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Actually, if you actually like mean-spirited rules that punish innocent people for the sins of others that they have no control over, then it is [i]you[/i] that need prayers. Remember that what you do to the least of these you do to Christ. Don't be counted among the goats on judgement day.

photosynthesis
Posted

[quote name='fidei defensor' date='Feb 12 2006, 06:40 PM']Yes they can. Just like they can reject anyone else.
[right][snapback]884978[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
They can. But just because they have the authority to do something doesn't make it reasonable.

Posted

just like a child of gay parents has no control of what their parents are doing and shouldn't be expelled from a Christian school

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Quietfire' date='Feb 12 2006, 06:51 PM']From what I understand concerning Opus Dei is that you are far too young to even be considered at this point.(if in fact you are only 14)
Usually around college age is more appropriate.  Im not saying that that is the norm, but it is more usual.

Maturity is another major point, which sadly you seem to be lacking.

Case in point.  You are here, ranting about not being accepted in a group that will help you discern your future.  Would I want you in my organization knowing the minute you dont get your way your gonna go balistic and be on the internet blabbing about how 'horrible' my organization is?
It isnt a "mickey mouse" club (as some have mentioned) that you join and think all is fine fine and that's it.  It is a LIFELONG commitment.  It isnt something that you hang around with for a while and then decide that 'oh, well, i wont go anymore ive got better things to do' type of arrangement.  From what I understand, I can honestly say that [b]I[/b] am not Opus Dei material, and I dont need a spiritual director to tell me that.

They dont kid around, they are that serious.  And no matter how wonderful I may think it would be to be a part of that organization, I know in my heart...I dont have the heart to give such a commitment.  My obligations demand that I be somewhere else, and I am ok with that.  God has other plans for me and I am listening to Him.

People involved with Opus Dei are serious about what they are doing.  Im not saying that you or anyone else isnt.  What Im saying is that we ALL cant be part of it. 
They assist people in discerning lifelong commitments.  Dude, at 14 you are in no position to be able to do that.  Sorry, trust me on this.  I am more than twice your age and after investigating them, I cant believe that you are willing to make this kind of decision at your age. 
If you were a bit more mature, you would realize that maybe, just maybe God is preparing you Himself.  If you have a goal that you wish to reach, and if for some reason, Opus Dei is not a part of that goal, it is God's will...not yours.  You need to accept this and MOVE ON.  You have to stop fighting God's will, and for God's sake you need to stop the whining.  This above everything else proves your immaturity.

I truly dont mean to sound harsh.  Like I said earlier, you have the passion, but you also have a lousy attitude.  Think for a moment about all those people within the Church that dont 'get their way'.  What happens to some of them?  They get disgusted and leave, or create schisms within the Church- or worse yet, they stay and create chaos.  Organizations like Opus Dei, I would think, try to avoid that.  There are people that have gotten involved with Opus Dei and it was a negative effect for everyone involved...not a good thing.  Not at all. 

Look, move on from this.  It does you no good.  You are truly loved no matter what.  That is what the most important thing should be.  Your mother loved [b]you[/b] so much that she gave birth to [b]you[/b] and raised [b]you[/b] in a time when the answer to pregnancy is abortion.  God loves [b]you[/b] so much that He created your soul and holds [b]you[/b] in the palm of His hand every moment of your existance.  [b]You[/b] are amazing, because God created you.  [b]You[/b] are amazing because [b]you[/b] are here.  Nothing else should matter.  Big deal, O.D. doesnt want you.  You're 14 and headed for bigger things.  Maybe even a future Pope down the road.  HEY, it could happen!!
Are you going to let this control and ruin your life?
Let the demon go.
[right][snapback]885017[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I'm 16. And it's the principle, just because I may not be called to Opus Dei doesn't mean there aren't other love children called to it. They need to change the rule.

Edited by catholicinsd
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='Feb 12 2006, 08:24 PM']Phamily:  what is more appropriate for public display - complaining about an injustice, or saying you like it:
Actually, if you actually like mean-spirited rules that punish innocent people for the sins of others that they have no control over, then it is [i]you[/i] that need prayers.  Remember that what you do to the least of these you do to Christ.  Don't be counted among the goats on judgement day.
[right][snapback]885059[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

I think it is unfair to assume that a certain rule happens to be mean-spirited simply because we don't agree with it. None of the people speaking about the rule are members of Opus Dei, and none of us were there when the rule was created or understand the reasoning behind it. I highly doubt it's intention is to punish innocent people for the sins of others. Remember also do not judge lest you be judged.

For the sake of Christian charity, it is our [b]duty[/b] to try to always assume the best of people and organizations based on the facts we know. All we know is that the rule exists, it is our duty to assume there must be a good reason for it unless we know for sure there is not.

A wise person once said, "Repeat all the good you hear about, and only the evil you see with your own eyes."

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 07:33 PM']I'm 16. And it's the principle,  just because I may not be called to Opus Dei doesn't mean there aren't other love children called to it. They need to change the rule.
[right][snapback]885072[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Then you need to take it up with Opus Dei, as well as the Vatican, because they approved of it. We cannot do anything about a rule you don't like.

Let me tell you something personal. I would really love to be a Priest. Honestly, I would. However, I have this problem, and its called same sex attraction. Now, Its not like the typical SSA you would think of, its very complicated for me. But, that is besides the point.

As you know, the Vatican released its document which talks about it's policy of ordaining men with SSA. At this point, I am not sure whether or not I could still become a priest because of my struggle. If I cannot, well then I cannot. However, you do not see me ranting about that possibility. Do I think that men who have SSA could been good priests? Of course. But, does the Vatican have to allow men with SSA to be priests? No. Being a priest is a huge honor and privilege, not a right.

Now, while this is not exactly the same as your situation, it has simularities. Joining an order of any kind is not a right by any means. They get to make the rules, and the Vatican must approve. Well, the Vatican approved the rules of Opus Dei. So, clearly, there must be a reason. We must respect the Vatican's judgment. I respect their judgment about the ordination of men with SSA, even though I think there are many men who could be great priests despite their struggle.

Just remember that. Its not a right, its a privilege to be part of any group. If you feel like you honestly want to join, but cannot because of a rule, talk to them about it. They are the only ones who can explain anything to you about it. We cannot.

Posted

Ya know what? Screw it. Opus Dei can go to heck. I don't wanna be in a group that allows only certains people to join.

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' date='Feb 12 2006, 07:22 PM']I think it is unfair to assume that a certain rule happens to be mean-spirited simply because we don't agree with it.  [right][snapback]885157[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

You don't need to have Phd in math to know 2+2=4.

[quote name='morostheos' date='Feb 12 2006, 07:22 PM'] I highly doubt it's intention is to punish innocent people for the sins of others. [right][snapback]885157[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Well, guess what - that's what such rules do!

[quote name='morostheos' date='Feb 12 2006, 07:22 PM']A wise person once said, "Repeat all the good you hear about, and only the evil you see with your own eyes."[right][snapback]885157[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Yeah, well, guess what....when I see people associated with Opus Dei verifying the existence of such a rule, that is enough for my own eyes. But as I stated in my previous posts, I hope it is all just a misunderstanding. If it turns out it is true, then it is evil.


[quote name='morostheos' date='Feb 12 2006, 07:22 PM'] Remember also do not judge lest you be judged. 
[right][snapback]885157[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

Who said I was judging?????

Posted

Hey, Opus Dei is a good organization!

God has a plan for you, just pray to see what it is, you already helped save a baby and the baby's mother from abortion, according to another one of your threads, think of how many wonderful things you can do through the will of God, just be open. Maybe Opus Dei isn't where your calling lies

Posted

edit: posting error

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 09:34 PM']Ya know what? Screw it. Opus Dei can go to heck. I don't wanna be in a group that allows only certains people to join.
[right][snapback]885170[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Well good that you're moving on. Try not to hold a grudge, it will only hold you back.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

*Note my edit in my previous post*

Posted

[quote name='catholicinsd' date='Feb 12 2006, 09:34 PM']Ya know what? Screw it. Opus Dei can go to heck. I don't wanna be in a group that allows only certains people to join.
[right][snapback]885170[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]

And you need to learn what a vocation is. Opus Dei is not a fraternal organization. It is not open to anyone who wants to join, legitimate or not. I have several friends who felt a call, but for whatever reason (not for me to divulge or even know), they were not admitted.

Opus Dei is a vocation, it is not a right. You have completely misunderstood the mission of Opus Dei. Until you have a better understanding of the Work, I would strongly suggest that you refrain from commenting.

As a member of the Work, I would appreciate it. However, do not beaver dam the Work, because you are not called to that particular vocation. There are many other vocations within the Church in which you can be an asset, once you are old enough to discern and be accepted.

Posted

I can't get the song out of my head.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' date='Feb 12 2006, 08:24 PM']Actually, if you actually like mean-spirited rules that punish innocent people for the sins of others that they have no control over, then it is [i]you[/i] that need prayers. [/quote]
As Cam said, Opus Dei isn't a fraternity. A big free-for-all for whoever wants to join. Are you going to complain about the Church for having strict policies against similiar events?

Half of that post was said in jest and in reference to the poster's fanaticism with being illigitimate. It's not healthy, point blank.

[quote]Remember that what you do to the least of these you do to Christ.  Don't be counted among the goats on judgement day.
[right][snapback]885059[/snapback][/right]
[/quote]
Fully aware. I am not passing judgment. I'm recommending (strongly) guidance from a trained professional rather than internet sympathies on a message board.

If you're taking my posts as mean-spirited or judgmental, then you are reading too much into them.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...