Oik Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 (edited) Okay, the whole myth part of this thread can easily be a touchy subject. This is one of those thing where you either see the fruitfulness of the method or not. It's really a matter of opinion. The Historical-critical method does have problems. The idea of calling things myths is very destructive in many senses. For me, though, the idea that the OT employs myth and mythic language, whether or not this is a conclusive idea, provides some insight into the influence those things had on the author. It is illuminative. Micah, as for the sons of heaven, I am in a different camp on that. Here is that footnote: Genesis footnotes, NAB: [1-4] This is apparently a fragment of an old legend that had borrowed much from ancient mythology. The sacred author incorporates it here, not only in order to account for the prehistoric giants of Palestine, whom the Israelites called the Nephilim, but also to introduce the story of the flood with a moral orientation--the constantly increasing wickedness of mankind. A "fragment of an old legend that had borrowed much from ancient mythology" that the sacred author incorporated into the text is hardly promulgating the mythology of Pagans. A fitting story, or part of, that is used tp explain morality (and if its was modified we don't know) doesn't bother me, which seems to be a more accurate rending. This is an example in the Bible is which literary genre comes into play. Are you scandalized by the Song of Songs? I know many are. Its poetry. Edited May 6, 2006 by Oik
Brother Adam Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 [quote name='Oik' post='973488' date='May 6 2006, 12:57 PM'] Thanks. I have to say it really took me by surprise that I preferred the NAB. I used to really hate it! It really just came about by reading tha text. I acutally don't own an NAB translation until recently, as I got rid of mine (I don't remember what I did with it) just before I came to school here. You should read my 2 exegesis' I did for Dr. Minto, one for PBS I, on Isaiah and the other for PBS II on John. [/quote] Send them my way. I will read them over the summer. I'd be interested in seeing what is expected since I will have to do one in the Fall.
Oik Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 : Will do! I might even stop by and drop off the physical copies. Who are you taking? D. Bergsma, Dr. Miletic, or Dr. Minto? What do you all have to do in terms of an exegesis?
Brother Adam Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 Dr. Bergsma. The other two kept on him about making his classes do an exegesis so now we do. I'll have him in the fall for pbsII. From what I know it isn't an exegesis in the traditional sense, as most people do not know original languages, but they had to use at least 3 different commentaries and each exegesis had a whole bunch of different sections.
Brother Adam Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 John 18:5 "The band, with which Judas shood, answered the question: 'whom seek ye?' by using the ordinary designation of the master: 'Jesus of Nazareth': cf. Mrk 10:47. The words "I am he", uttered by him who could say "I am who am', caused what Jn undoubtedly attributes to miraculous power, namely, a backward stampede, involving an impressive fall to the ground of many, at least, of the arresting party." The Old Catholic Commentary on Holy Scripture: John XVIII, 5
Oik Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 : Great commentary! You have to show it to me. Alos, I wanted to add that the historical-critical method has gotten a bad rap, especially in its use in the NAB footnotes. For those we wish to know what then Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope John Pope the Great (yeah, that's what I call him!), and The Pontifical Biblical Commission thinks about the Historical-Critical method and Biblical Interpretation in general, PLEASE, do your self and others around you a favor. READ the PBC's [i]The Interpretation of the of the Bible in the Church[/i]. All you steubei students can pick it up in the Bookstore. It is pretty much the Bible for Interpretation for the Catholic Exegete (or any one for that matter!).
Brother Adam Posted May 6, 2006 Posted May 6, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Oik' post='973980' date='May 6 2006, 08:42 PM'] : Great commentary! You have to show it to me. Alos, I wanted to add that the historical-critical method has gotten a bad rap, especially in its use in the NAB footnotes. For those we wish to know what then Cardinal Ratzinger, Pope John Pope the Great (yeah, that's what I call him!), and The Pontifical Biblical Commission thinks about the Historical-Critical method and Biblical Interpretation in general, PLEASE, do your self and others around you a favor. READ the PBC's [i]The Interpretation of the of the Bible in the Church[/i]. All you steubei students can pick it up in the Bookstore. It is pretty much the Bible for Interpretation for the Catholic Exegete (or any one for that matter!). [/quote] So important in fact, that it was one of two documents I included on the old website (with Dei Verbum) on the Bible. It will be one of many when my catechetical website is finished. Funky how I've read it many times and still remain a 'creationist'. It's also in the "Biblical Documents" from LTP, "Welcome the Catholic Church" CD, and on the Vaticans website. Edited May 6, 2006 by Brother Adam
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now