cappie Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I don't know if the Harry Potter books and movies have made a splash in USA but they have been quite popular in Australia and caused a little controversy. In a recent homily I asked the young members of our parish community why they enjoyed reading Harry Potter novels. Though most just shrugged, smiled, and tried to avoid looking at me, the seventh grader Johnny quietly responded, “Because you never know what’s going to happen next.” It is the same element of suspense that led the magi who never knew what road the Spirit was going to take them down next. Today’s readings invite us to have the curiosity of Amy and Johnny to find out the ‘epiphany’ of our God in every one, everywhere and every event. I received the following on the net. Our Cardinal George Pell is a great reader of the novels, so I’m not sure what he would make of the following: Ten Christian arguments against Harry Potter series 1) It is a long duration project to change the cultures of mankind. 2) Harry Potter never fights against the evil. 3) It glorifies the world of witchcraft, sorcery and enchantment. 4) What is above nature is demonic; the divine symbols are perverted. 5) There is nobody in Harry Potter who likes the good and the noble. 6) The reader is not able to distinguish between the good and the evil. 7) Here the young generation is seduced to magic and their imagination is filled with pictures of a world there the evil has upper hand. 8) Here the belief in a loving God is systematically destroyed. 9) Don’t forget who is behind is the money hungry gigantic multimedia who is tyrannically indoctrinating innocent world who looks only for entertainment, enjoyment and novelty. 10) Harry Potter will affect the psyche of the reader. It is no book for children. The scenes of terror and tension are too much for the reader who will be led to anguish, fear, fright, rage, fury and frustration.
frozencell Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Ten Christian arguments against Harry Potter series 1) It is a long duration project to change the cultures of mankind. 2) Harry Potter never fights against the evil. 3) It glorifies the world of witchcraft, sorcery and enchantment. 4) What is above nature is demonic; the divine symbols are perverted. 5) There is nobody in Harry Potter who likes the good and the noble. 6) The reader is not able to distinguish between the good and the evil. 7) Here the young generation is seduced to magic and their imagination is filled with pictures of a world there the evil has upper hand. 8) Here the belief in a loving God is systematically destroyed. 9) Don’t forget who is behind is the money hungry gigantic multimedia who is tyrannically indoctrinating innocent world who looks only for entertainment, enjoyment and novelty. 10) Harry Potter will affect the psyche of the reader. It is no book for children. The scenes of terror and tension are too much for the reader who will be led to anguish, fear, fright, rage, fury and frustration. I, personally, was able to tell very clearly between the good and the evil. The evil people even had an evil name assigned to their little group or whatever it is. And I think No. 10 is absurd. It's a good read, albeit, maybe a little on the mystical side. But any child who hasn't been correctly taught a Christian viewpoint should know better anyhow. I have a 12 year old brother-in-law who loves these books. He's pretty mature for his age and doesn't find anything in these books so disturbing that it would lead to nightmares and lifelong fears. Even someone who is immature for their age isn't going to plagued by constant fear by these books. Just my opinion. Some people just seem too uppety.
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Didnt anyone read fantasy stuff when they where kids. I like them because the books are very large. Im glad my son started reading them because i was kind of tired of the Dr. Suess :P
frozencell Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Didnt anyone read fantasy stuff when they where kids. I like them because the books are very large. Im glad my son started reading them because i was kind of tired of the Dr. Suess Amen. No one ever said you could only read the Bible and things deemed Christianly religious. I like fantasy, horror, all kinds of stuff. Give it a rest.
jmjtina Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Click Here Sorry I disagree. Since I don't have much time now to post why.....maybe this will help. Burn Harry Potter.
frozencell Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Click Here Sorry I disagree. Since I don't have much time now to post why.....maybe this will help. Burn Harry Potter. I will concede that there are some things in the Harry Pooter books that seem a little unnecessary, but I do not feel that it's anything that is dangerous when explained to a child that this is only a story. I know that it makes references to occultism and what-not. My wife has an interest in fairies, but that doesn't necessarily mean that she's going go running out into the woods rattling off names of little flying friends only she can see! I also think that some of these things in this article are taken a little too seriously. What about The Never-Ending Story? I'm sure everyone can find little tidbits of occult in it, too, but I don't remember anyone raising a big stink over it. I guess I think that people are getting a little bit over-protective nowadays. Go figure. ;)
musturde Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 (edited) I personally don't plan on reading them but I've watched the movie and played a bit of the game. I believe it depends on how it will affect the person... If it's gunna entice u to try magic then forget it. If it has not affect ur aware about then it shouldn't be too much of a prob... By the ways: Is the author Pagan? I heard that someboy sent the author a letter telling her that she became a witch cuz of her book or sometin like that... is that true? Edited December 31, 2003 by musturde
littleflower+JMJ Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=1347&st=0
Live4Him Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Sure the stuff “Harry Potter” can do is cool. Sure the story is exciting and very interesting. Sure the author has a great way of writing and sure many people love “Harry Potter”. But all of this does not make it right. What we need to look at is, in the story what is glorified. Love, as in Cinderella? Charity, as in Beauty and the Beast? Loyalty, as in Snow White? Each one of those movies has magic. But not one of those movies glorifies witchcraft as something that can be used for good. This is where the problem sets in. “Harry Potter” uses witchcraft for good. In high school I knew some guys and girls who started studying witchcraft. Let me start by saying it was a simple thing like “Magic the Gathering” cards and “Dungeons and Dragons” that got them interested in black magic. So can something as simple as “Harry Potter” take our eyes off Jesus? Yes and No. Yours and mine most likely not. Eight to twelve year olds, yes it could easily distract them. It will defiantly distract the ones who don’t know Jesus at all. You might say, “Well this is not my problem”. Wrong it is your problem even if it does not affect you or someone you know and the only one it affects is some kid you don’t know. If you supported it, it will be in part your fault for supporting it. “Harry Potter” is fantasy but remember it is not like “Lord of the Rings” “Harry Potter” is post Christian, where “Lord of the Rings” is not. “Harry Potter” takes Place in a real city England and it takes place today in a world that knows Christ. “Lord of the Rings” takes place in a fantasy world and time. Harry Potter is wrong! It is that simple.
frozencell Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Sure the stuff “Harry Potter” can do is cool. Sure the story is exciting and very interesting. Sure the author has a great way of writing and sure many people love “Harry Potter”. But all of this does not make it right. What we need to look at is, in the story what is glorified. Love, as in Cinderella? Charity, as in Beauty and the Beast? Loyalty, as in Snow White? Each one of those movies has magic. But not one of those movies glorifies witchcraft as something that can be used for good. This is where the problem sets in. “Harry Potter” uses witchcraft for good. In high school I knew some guys and girls who started studying witchcraft. Let me start by saying it was a simple thing like “Magic the Gathering” cards and “Dungeons and Dragons” that got them interested in black magic. So can something as simple as “Harry Potter” take our eyes off Jesus? Yes and No. Yours and mine most likely not. Eight to twelve year olds, yes it could easily distract them. It will defiantly distract the ones who don’t know Jesus at all. You might say, “Well this is not my problem”. Wrong it is your problem even if it does not affect you or someone you know and the only one it affects is some kid you don’t know. If you supported it, it will be in part your fault for supporting it. “Harry Potter” is fantasy but remember it is not like “Lord of the Rings” “Harry Potter” is post Christian, where “Lord of the Rings” is not. “Harry Potter” takes Place in a real city England and it takes place today in a world that knows Christ. “Lord of the Rings” takes place in a fantasy world and time. Harry Potter is wrong! It is that simple. I'm not totally clear how the setting of either movie affects it's moral or ethical influences. I also don't think that any large number of children are going to go run off to the local witch store and buy volumes on pagan worship and black magic, either. As I pointed out earlier, let's look at The Never-Ending Story (the name itself implying eternity). At the end, the princess says that all the boy had to do in the first place was call out the new name of the princess and everything would be saved from the evil "Nothing". It you want to get as nit picky about all this as it is getting we could all say, "Oh, no! They're making a reference to man becoming God and speaking things into existence with only the power of his words (like Creation)!" The same line of thinking can be taken on Star Wars (the original, good ones!). I even had a book that supposedly outlined the similarities between the Jedi and the Christian realm and how it was so anti-Christian, but these movies are classics and loved by people of all ages. Anyone can take a lot of things the wrong way (not just Harry Potter) and end up with any number of bad situations. Common sense needs to come into play here. There is a line that seperates just plain entertainment from dangerous material (i.e. House of 1000 Corpses), but sometimes we need to take a step back and just let ourselves (and kids) have fun without pulling apart the smallest things and screaming fire and rape all the time.
BLAZEr Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I like em, I read em, and I don't see the big deal.
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Click Here Sorry I disagree. Since I don't have much time now to post why.....maybe this will help. Burn Harry Potter. Tina,Tina tina, please miss LOTR. Elves? Magic Ring? Ugly monster wanting the precious. :lol:
MrsFrozen Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I read the article "Harry Potter: Agent of Conversion," but I must say, I disagree. I like these books and am strong in my faith. My 12-year-old brother likes these books, and is strong in his faith. I can see how this would disturb someone who had bad experiences with the occult, though. I see it as fantasy, just like LOTR. You can't defend LOTR in this situation, because they're both about good magic and bad magic and fantasy. I think that article blows HP way out of proportion. I actually thought it was written by Fundamentalists at first. Especially regarding the thing about the guy dying at age 666.. It is possible to have turned 665 last year and still be 665. I certainly don't believe in practicing magic, but these are make-believe books. Come on, no Hogwarts really exists! It's just for fun. Also, I found all those ten arguments to be kind of boloney, too.. Especially the part about Harry never fighting against evil! That's the whole plot of the books! God bless.. :)
cantstopdancin9 Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Just to let yawl know from a kid's point of view, I read the book and enjoyed it. I only read it for entertainment. It hasn't changed my view of the faith or any of my other opinions. I still love being Catholic just as much as before I read the book. Only if you take everything out of hand does it become a problem. Know what I mean? -_- :)
nikkan_hanil Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 No offense to anyone, but I don't like Harry Potter because it invokes demon names, but because it's so darn popular. I hate the mainstream...<_<
TABBY Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 (edited) I was actually a bit slow at reading the series it took me about two to three years AFTER the first one was on the market. Before I read them I wasnt really that intrested in reading it...however where ever I went I saw someone reading it....I saw people from young to old reading these books...and then when I aided my kids class I noticed they had HP on the shelves. I wanted to know what my kids were being read...so I then took it upon myself to read the first book. I got done with that book in a day and a half (estemating)...and then I went to the store and bought all four books (the fifth one wasnt out at the time), and I was amazed how well these books are. It is a good read, with good morals. It is all fanatsy...just like star treck, and star wars... The pheoniminal thing is not only the people from young to old is reading them it is that you can read it again and still get the same enjoyment. My kids and myself enjoy reading these books, and is waiting for the 6th book.... Edited December 31, 2003 by TABBY
jmjtina Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I also don't think that any large number of children are going to go run off to the local witch store and buy volumes on pagan worship and black magic, either. No. Your right. It's probably JUST ONE kid (out of ten) who will go and buy books in pagan worship and black magic. This book is getting darker and darker. LOTR isn't about BEING A WIZARD. Talk to immaculata or cmom for a while....haha. I just don't think it's worth the entertainment of the majority to lose even ONE kid to the occult. Cmom said it before. Harry potter is like milk. LOTR is like MEAT. They are different. LOTR has a wizard, but it doesn't show you a wizard growing up, using spells. That ISN"T the point of it. Reading both LOTR and Harry Potter, one is definetly a "classic" and I can term HP as generic in comparison. Patrick Madrid came a spoke to our diocese and FINALLY took a stand to this witchcraft. He has watched HP emerge and He studied latin and told us that one of the phrases Harry Potter says is "By the Head of the Dragon." I don't know about you, but whether you understand it or not, I wouldn't want my kids exposed to be saying that AT ALL. I think we are truly playing with fire from Hell. Spells and Brews What are some of these images and their ensuing dangers? In her 1991 book, Ungodly Rage, Donna Steichen shared this insightful quote from a repentant former practitioner of Wicca, Carmen Helen Guerra: When I was a witch, I performed rituals. I evoked spirits. I called entities. I cast spells, burned candles, concocted brews. The only thing I didn’t do was fly on a broom, but I probably would have figured it out if given time. But where did it lead to? Into darkness, depression, and the creation of an aura of gloom around me. I was frequently under demon attack. The house where I lived was alive with poltergeist activity . . . due to residual “guests” from rituals. My friends and family were afraid of me. I knew I had no future; all I had was a dark present. I was locked in by oaths and “destiny.” But I had power, something I’d always wanted. It wasn’t Satan’s fault. He didn’t exist — or so I thought. I gave it all up, and came to Jesus on my knees. . . . He freed me from the oppression and gave me back my soul — the one I had so foolishly given to evil in exchange for power.6 Does this have anything to do with Harry Potter? You bet. Though it’s all dressed up as sweetness and light, the first Harry Potter book has rituals (for example, “the Sorting Ceremony,” pp. 117-122); spells (Hermione casts the full Body-Bind spell on Neville, p. 273); spirits and other non-human entities (Voldemort inhabits Quirrell’s body, pp. 293-295, and the myriad ghosts of Hogwarts); candles (thousands floating above the tables at Hogwarts, p. 116); and brews (Professor Snape’s potions class, pp. 136-139). It’s not pleasant to contemplate, but there really are people out there who practice witchcraft, who cast spells and perform rituals, and who see results. J. K. Rowling writes as if their powers can be channeled into good, and that is the great danger of her books. Rituals and spells and brews are used by witches in the real world, and they work because of the power of evil spirits. As such they can never lead to good. Portraying these innately evil practices as if they can be harnessed for good is a dangerous lie. Rowling further confuses the issue by portraying witchcraft not as a moral issue, but as an issue of heredity. In Rowling’s world, the ability to practice witchcraft is inherited. But in reality, you don’t need to possess a particular bloodline in order to make witchcraft work. All you have to do is tap into evil spirits, turn over your will, and leave Jesus Christ for the world of the occult. We thus have two falsehoods presented to the children who read these books: first, that their status as a witch is written in their genes; and second, if they’re one of the “lucky” ones, they can use their powers for good. These are harmful lies to teach, because the reality is so different and so dangerous. Just ask Carmen Helen Guerra. The Church’s Warning The Catechism of the Catholic Church states unequivocally: “All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one’s service and have a supernatural power over others — even if this were for the sake of restoring their health — are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. … The Church for her part warns the faithful against it” (2117). This is strong language in the catechism, the same language used to condemn lust, fornication, and abortion. Catholics cannot in good conscience take such a warning lightly. If Harry were using lust, fornication, or abortion to save his friends at Hogwarts, would we still think these books were acceptable children’s fare? It’s important to note that the witchcraft about which Rowling writes stands in stark contrast to fantasy magic as it’s portrayed in Tolkien and Lewis. The good characters in Middle Earth and Narnia don’t cast spells on people, don’t call up spirits and commune with them like beloved neighbors, don’t perform rituals, and don’t mix potions. The good characters at Hogwarts do. In Narnia, a ring transports you to another world, and in Middle Earth lightning flashes at a critical time to perform some powerful feat. But at Hogwarts, the evil Voldemort enchants a diary to take possession of a girl’s soul. These are vast and substantial differences, requiring us to view Rowling’s witchcraft in a much different light from Tolkien’s and Lewis’s magic. As Kilroy said once (and thus has become one of my fave quotes too) : My new favorite Simpson's quote: Ned Flanders, reading a Harry Potter book to his kids: "And Harry Potter and all his friends died and went to Hell for practicing witchcraft. The end!" Kids in unison: "YAAAAAAYYYY!!!" Ned tosses the Harry Potter book in the fire. As it should be.
cantstopdancin9 Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Just wondering, not to be rude or anything, but how many of you that disagree with this book have actually read it? (and i mean from cover to cover) :unsure:
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now