jmjtina Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 :drool: My precious. yes, csdancing I have read all books and have seen both movies. I think that is a fair question. I think that's what has made me even more passionate about it.
Circle_Master Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I've been a Tolkien fan since I was very little. No Tolkien bashing or I'll get you! And yeah, Harry Potter would be milk and LotR meat. I've read lots of fantasy books, I could recommend a bunch that are better than our friend Harry Potter.
cantstopdancin9 Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Just checking hee hee, because my best friend's mother wouldn't let her read the books because of what she heard from other people and she hadn't even read them herself. I do understand the difference between LOTR and HP though. And I also understand that this has effected some children. But then again, I also have to think that almost everything in movies, TV, and books has created the world we have today. It's not just the HP books. There are constantly things that bring people away from the faith or cause people to sin, and out of all those things, I just really don't think the HP books are the biggest problem. However, I still respect all of your opinions. ^_^
BLAZEr Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I've read them, I liked them, I'm not crazy. I'm a faithful catholic. I'm concerned about young people. I don't see the problem. I was looking for a book about superstitions when I was young. I accidentally picked up a book on witch craft. I read it. I didn't ever read another one. I'm not evil. I think the real issue is whether or not parents are responsible in raising their kids. If you are not providing any moral or religious guidance to your child and all he reads is Harry Potter, then yes, maybe he will go and practice Witchcraft. However, that's probably the least of your worries since they will be equally susceptible to drug and alcohol abuse, sexual promiscuity, and the entire aray of the culture of death. The problem isn't Harry Potter it's bad parenting. Oh, yeah, and both Fr. Mitch Pacwa and Mother Theresa Angela F.D.M. (Franciscan Daughters of Mary) both think the Harry Potter books harmless. Fr. Mitch is an expert on the occult and Mother Theresa Angela is a former Wicca priestess who had a profound Christian reversion and has begun a Franciscan religious community dedicated to pro-life work. They, along with my good sense, tell me we have nothing to fear from Harry Potter.
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 But momma said momma said momma said LOTR is the Devil
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 I see no diffrence. To say a diffrence is a sham. Complete Madness. That is All. I like the pagan elves and talking trees. :loco:
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Wasnt there a wizard making evil orcs for a fiery bloodshot eye?
jmjtina Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Al, you are mad. :skitzo: too much..... :heymon: haha. Blaze, where in samhill have you been? :wavey: You are crazy! :fluffy air extraction: And FS, they are not trees, they are Ents. Can't even get it right even AFTER I correct you.... :P
Ash Wednesday Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 But momma said momma said momma said Medulla Oblongata!!! You wrong Colonel Sanders!!!!!!! I have to agree with BLAZEr -- I don't think Harry Potter is exclusively the problem. And if it is, then there are a whole lot of other things out there that are going to lead kids astray as well, some much more dangerous than Harry Potter. I never really got into Potter, myself. I think of this kid in school we used to call "Toilet Boy" because his last name was Potter, too.
littleflower+JMJ Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 patrick madrid. father of eleven explained it very well when i attended his seminar and a concerned parented asked about harry potter. i wish you should have seen how he answered, no wishy-washy, serious-tone and made sure everyone in the room (there was over a thousand of us there) made sure we knew what danger harry potter is. that he would not allow any one of his eleven children pick up that book and for a good reason too. this is from a scholar who has studied extensivly over this matter. and thats the point we miss. sure harry potter seems great, exciting, heck, even fun. but of course we would see no reason in it, what do we know? no we're not sinning or condemned for reading Harry Potter but we have to question what the motive is behind these series that have send us red flags up but yet, so many do not pay heed to them. parents have concern, former occult ppl who are now catholic have fears over it, even kids have come up (from catholic school teachers making them read harry potter and some have been known to make their students further their study into the pagan and witchcraft through projects and readigns) and we should address them, for something that has made such an impact on us and our children, its worth addressing. have these people read whats in the book? patrick madrid knows latin, and in the book, and says that is mentioned numerous times is saying, "by the head of the dragon", how would anyone know its what its saying unless you knew latin? and we all know what "dragon" we are calling upon when saying it. remember the devil is and acting like a devouring lion, waiting for a chance, and our children are the ones we're risking. i would never let my little brothers read such a thing because your allowing the devil to use that innocent little book to open dark doors of magic and so forth. your responsible of protecting your children, and i would never allow my children to even get a glimspe of that "darK"world that rowling writes of. why not something good and with God? (patrick madrid) like tina's articles point out, how many of us have had any kinds of experiences from the dark world of magic in reality to know the danger and risks such playfullness it contains? we are nto scared because we have not opened those doors yet, harry potter is the same game, just a different name. i trust patrick madrid and other ppl about the danger of harry potter because they know and have done research on it. we have only merely open a book and read, without realizing we're opening a can of worms in the process. this is something serious and something we need to all question. for us who are strong in faith, and older and mature, we might go unscarred, but what about all the thousands of others, that the harry potter books are planting seeds of in? thats all it takes, especially for a vunerable child. think about it as this....what if you had a glass of water and 90% of good water but 10% was poison. would you still drink that glass of water? much less your children? You wouldn't because even though its just 10% of poison, poison is poison. to hear anyone who has converted from the occult okay something like this, alarms me, who could one who was soo close to evil at one time, okay it later on? if they know the potential it has.. if they know the real stuff, first hand, why allow it for children also? that just like fire, its not something to be played with harry potter books are getting darker, and they will continue to get darker, trust me. as parents, i would make sure you do your part in protecting your child. be responsible and read first whatever you allow your child to read. and us speaking up for the kids who may not have that watchful parent eye over their shoulder all the time, this is for them and for all children in danger. and however we shall come to harry potter as, harmless, fun, its our choice..but no matter how many different faces it may partake in, we shall NOT fail to recognize and know that magic is magic. as for parents saying no, thank them. we should be all be grateful for parents who care enough to stop us from any possible harm. God bless! +JMJ and thats my two cents....no refunds! :D
Circle_Master Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 i'll just throw a few things out the good guys don't win by using what the evil guys use (i.e. the ends do not justify the means) LotR is mystical and faerie in nature and is obvious to not be this world LotR also has magic restricted to a very few people, no one normal. Magic in LotR is limited as well, the movies put much more magic in than the books ever had. To defeat evil, good must resist greed and pride (to get the ring to mt. doom) Tolkien was a Christian and didn't study the occult ok this one is weak
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 :lol: and the midget with the AX? Im just being fussy for Tinas sake. :loco:
littleflower+JMJ Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Tolkien was a Christian and didn't study the occult ok this one is weak *ahem* tolkien was a devout catholic :P
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 BOO-YAH! Ive always wanted to do that.... :loco:
Circle_Master Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 tolkien witnessed to C.S. Lewis too, although you might not care about that. I love both authors.
Circle_Master Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 *ahem* tolkien was a devout catholic :rolling: <_<
foundsheep Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 Excuse me, we are PC here, those are munchkins not midgets.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now