frozencell Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 i'll just throw a few things out the good guys don't win by using what the evil guys use (i.e. the ends do not justify the means) LotR is mystical and faerie in nature and is obvious to not be this world LotR also has magic restricted to a very few people, no one normal. Magic in LotR is limited as well, the movies put much more magic in than the books ever had. To defeat evil, good must resist greed and pride (to get the ring to mt. doom) Tolkien was a Christian and didn't study the occult ok this one is weak I think that if you are going to lobby against HP then you have to look at all angles. littleflower did that, I appreciated her view although I didn't agree with it. First, whether this world or a fictional one doesn't really matter. Mysticism is mysticism. And very few people having magic doesn't matter either. As littleflower said - magic is magic. I think them both harmless. If you oppose HP it only seems logical to oppose LOTR, too. Until tomorrow.... :D --End Transmission--
jmjtina Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 here's some more good reading..... :read: Disturbing Religious Elements I further noticed some disturbing religious elements in the books — an apparent twisting of Catholic terminology, symbolism, and even theology. Whether or not all the instances of such twisting were intentional, the dangerous confusion resulting in the minds of young readers remains the same. Picture this. In Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, pages 51-52, Harry is hidden in a shop that sells paraphernalia of the Dark Arts. He sees a customer express interest in a withered hand sitting on a cushion. Turns out it’s called the “Hand of Glory,” and it’s considered the “best friend” of thieves and plunderers. Wait a minute. “Glory” is a term of worship used by angels and humans alike. Why is it being used to describe the favorite tool of robbers? Later, when attending a “deathday party” for ghosts, Harry and his friends notice “a group of gloomy nuns . . . and the fat friar” (p. 132). This was a dark and dreary party of obviously tortured souls, and the friar and the nuns could have easily been left out. Did Rowling think this was cute or did she mean to give insult? Blink and you’d miss it, but in two short paragraphs of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Rowling twists and perverts the meaning of a word of tremendous significance to Catholics. The word is “transfiguration,” which should call to every Catholic child’s mind the glorification of our Lord on the mountaintop with Moses and Elijah. Instead, Rowling uses the word to mean “some of the most complex and dangerous magic you will learn”: that of changing one object into another (p. 134). Having thus assigned “transfiguration” a decidedly un-Christian meaning in the first book, she peppers the second book with numerous references to the subject. My heart breaks when I think of how many children will forever more listen to the Gospel reading about the Transfiguration, and will find their minds drawn to the Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. The book of Revelation is arguably the least understood book of the Bible, but the significance of one element in it is generally agreed upon: The number “666” is the diabolical number of the beast (see Rev 13:18), and it’s not a good thing. Yet J. K. Rowling has chosen to use this number as significant for one of the most unselfish and noble of her characters, Mr. Nicolas Flamel. Always portrayed as a good character, at the end of the first book he is raised to heights of actual heroism when he decides to lose his life for the sake of the world. We the readers are introduced to Flamel when Harry and his friends read Flamel’s biography on page 220. Figuring prominently in this biography is the fact that last year Mr. Flamel celebrated his six hundred and sixty-fifth birthday. That means that the year in which his biography was written, the year in which he is immortalized for all of us, Mr. Flamel is in the 666th year of his life. The symbol of the beast for Christians is the age of the savior of humanity for Hogwarts. Rowling then presents a perversion of Catholic theology when a unicorn is killed just before the climax of the first book. “The blood of a unicorn will keep you alive, even if you are an inch from death, but at a terrible price,” writes Rowling on page 258. Drinking blood will keep us alive? When I first read this, I wondered if we were about to see a Catholic metaphor that might redeem the entire book. The next phrase kept my hope alive, “You have slain something pure and defenseless to save yourself. . . .” Yes, I thought, we are about to see a Eucharistic analogy, but then my eyes traveled to the next line on the page: “You will have but a half-life, a cursed life, from the moment the blood touches your lips.” I felt as if I’d been punched in the stomach. It isn’t the crime of killing the pure and defenseless unicorn that curses, but the act of drinking its blood. What a horrendous twisting of the biblical promise that drinking the blood of Jesus, who is the purest of the pure, will bring us eternal life. The antithetical notion that a pure creature’s blood will bring us “a half-life, a cursed life” is a slap in the face of Catholics. Okay so you don't agree. The arguments made against HP are very grave and shouldn't be taken lightly. It attacks at our faith with witchcraft in the making at our children. To say LOTR is guilty of the same charge is illogical. Have you read the LOTR's? they are nothing alike. If you have read the book Gandalf's role isn't that of a typical wizard, he is a protector, a care taker who isn't a wizard to the definition except that he wears a pointy hat. (And not all the time! haha) He is like the main advisor who advises all to not use the ring. Gandalf, nor Suarmon never try to teach or attempt to recruit or train anyone in how to use magic or spells. There is no possibility for any of the hobbits (or any of the men) to become wizards. If you understand LOTR it is symbolic of our own battle good and evil here on earth. HP is a wizard by definition. The spells, the potions, the tarot cards, the blood. He is a wizard in training along with all the hogwarts alumni. Remember the focus of the LOTR isn't Gandalf and his magic, but the destruction of evil in the ring. (wow, i summarized all three books in less than a sentence.....) Harry Potter is about magic and his use of it. 2115: God can reveal the future to his prophets or to other saints. Still, a sound Christian attitude consists in putting oneself confidently into the hands of Providence for whatever concerns the future, and giving up all unhealthy curiosity about it. Improvidence, however, can constitute a lack of responsibility. 2116: All forms of divination are to be rejected: recourse to Satan or demons, conjuring up the dead or other practices falsely supposed to "unveil" the future. Consulting horoscopes, astrology, palm reading, interpretation of omens and lots, the phenomena of clairvoyance, and recourse to mediums all conceal a desire for power over time, history, and, in the last analysis, other human beings, as well as a wish to conciliate hidden powers. They contradict the honor, respect, and loving fear that we owe to God alone. 2117: All practices of magic or sorcery, by which one attempts to tame occult powers, so as to place them at one's service and have a supernatural power over others—even if this were for the sake of restoring their health—are gravely contrary to the virtue of religion. These practices are even more to be condemned when accompanied by the intention of harming someone, or when they have recourse to the intervention of demons. Wearing charms is also reprehensible. Spiritism often implies divination or magical practices; the Church for her part warns the faithful against it. Recourse to so-called traditional cures does not justify either the invocation of evil powers or the exploitation of another's credulity. I still don't think we should let the minority of the kids who read HP fall into the occult for the majorities entertainment. The Catholic Apologist, Patrick Madrid gave some great reasons why as flowery stated. Besides as a teacher, I would definitely argue that there is BETTER literature than HP. haha. oh and Foundsheep. your getting confused with the Wizard of Oz and LOTR. How many times must I correct you? :squash: And watching the extended versions don't count as reading the books foundsheep......haha. i am such a night owl. :ph34r: :ph34r: ninja vanish.
TABBY Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 (edited) The ones who disagree with Harry Potter...since you have expressed your thoughts on HP i was wondering what your thoughts on Bewitched is considered bad as well? Edited December 31, 2003 by TABBY
Live4Him Posted December 31, 2003 Posted December 31, 2003 But momma said momma said momma said LOTR is the Devil JRR Tolkin was a faithful Catholic. Lord of the rings shows how evil can control us if we become attached to worldly things. You want to know something Adam Sandler is closer to the devil have you seen his crudness to humans.
hopeful1 Posted January 1, 2004 Posted January 1, 2004 (edited) JRR Tolkin was a faithful Catholic. Lord of the rings shows how evil can control us if we become attached to worldly things. You want to know something Adam Sandler is closer to the devil have you seen his crudness to humans. well, i'm not one to judge, but he was the star of little nicky, in which he played the son of the devil. but heck....um, wrong choice of words, lets rethink that.....but HEY! I liked the movie and Adam Sandler. anyways, i was skeptical about Harry Potter before, i used to think that the most offensive thing about them is that i saw adults reading them, and if kids read them it's fine so long as they don't become wiccans . at least the kids are reading. i'd let my kids ( if i ever had them) read HP before i would ever let them read the Left Behind series, at least they wouldn't be confused about their faith. but after reading some of the stuff in the phorum i'm begining to rethink this. however i do have a question, I used to love to read fantasy books when i was younger ( ok i do now too, just don't have the time to do it), for example stuff by Mercedes Lackley, i'm intrested in reading LOTR's. and i love mangas/anime like Magic Knight Rayearth and Sailor Moon, and play RPGs (ie Final Fantasy) which often have magic in them. What about classics like King Author and Merlin type stuff? does this make them inheritly sinful, even if i can distiquish it from reality? Edited January 1, 2004 by hopeful1
jasJis Posted January 1, 2004 Posted January 1, 2004 Like just about EVERYTHING, Harry Potter stories can be harmful when there is a lack of parental guidance and participation. I would not agree with all of cappie's 10 points in his initial post, but I do agree with many. The greater danger facing kids today is TV. That medium continually undermines Christian values and moral principals but people rarely burn them, turn them off, or monitor and control what their children watch. Watch 3 episodes of "Friends" or "Will & Grace" with your 12 yearold, and then tell me if Harry Potter stories scare you as much.
foundsheep Posted January 1, 2004 Posted January 1, 2004 And Thats always a perfect example to all not to let the TV babysit.
cappie Posted January 1, 2004 Author Posted January 1, 2004 I did not realise that the Harry Potter thing should cause so much debate though it is interesting. One of my points was that our Cardinal Pell, Archbishop of Sydney who is also a member of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith is not worried by the books and has been seen reading the books to children. I was wondering if we are not becoming too reactionary???? :wacko:
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now