Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Top ten changes I would love to see in the Church


Recommended Posts

Posted

TOP TEN CHANGES I WOULD LOVE!!!!

10. No kneelers - AND everyone physically able is REQUIRED to kneel. How's that for a lesson in mortification???
9. Confession required once a week.
8. At every mass, the priest lists off the commandments (and the grave obligations/prohibitions listed by the CCC) with the congregation replying, "I believe. I submit. Amen." at the end.
7. At every mass, the priest swears to the congregation that he will obey the Church and remain faithful to Catholic norms for the liturgy.
6. Eucharistic fast increased to three hours before receiving.
5. Leonine prayers at Mass back in action!
4. Abstinence every Wednesday and fasting every Friday of the year. (Lent & Advent would be fasting on both days and Abstinence for the whole season.)
3. Choir lofts in every parish - or at least the musicians and singers are required to do their thing in the back and out of sight.
2. Annointing of the Sick received MUCH more frequently and new explorations of the sacrament.
1. Perpetual Adoration in every parish.

missionseeker
Posted

10-not short people friendly. I know that sounds stupid but if you are short, you know what I mean.

9-That kind of takes away the freewill thing. PLUS we would never get to Mass. The preist would be in the confessional 24/7

8-not sure. I do think that IF it were to happen, it would have to be gradual because it would scare people away.

7-not sure.

6-I would faint. If I don't eat every so often my blood sugar goes wack. I'm able to keep the fast at an hour(most times). If I were not able to keep the fast any time, I would feel really guilty even if it wasn't my fault. I know it's not bout how I feel or about me at all but still.. And I know I'm not the only one.

5- what are those?

4- I can see Fridays but Wednesdays are a strech for me. Of ourse, that's my own little opinion and if the said do it, I'd do it.

3-Most Def.

2- Ditto

1_ditto

Noel's angel
Posted

10. wouldn't work-what about elderly people with bad knees?? Kneelers should stay.
9. Wouldn't work. No priest has time to hear the Confession of every parishoner every week.
8. Maybe not at every Mass
7. Priest's shouldn't have to do this-they've made their vows and should stick to them.
6. I couldn't walk to Mass in the morning without having something to eat beforehand
5. That would be pretty cool. Might stop people gossiping after Mass too
4. I like it
3. It's the only way to go. We have them in all the Churches in our parish
2. Yup
1. Yup, yup.

thessalonian
Posted

Let's start with getting them to confession once a month rather than once every 5 years. :(

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

How about an increased understanding of our faith among Catholics and catechism classes that actually teach Catholicism? I didn't grow up Catholic, but a lot of my friends did and I am mystified at some of the very basic stuff they don't know after years and years of "religion" class. Of course, none of them are actively Catholic today... if it weren't for the Protestant churches, they probably wouldn't be Christians at all.

And the second thing I want to see is the discipline of celibacy in the priesthood changed to match what we currently require of deacons. I believe the Church is suffocating from a lack of pastors. Simply changing the current discipline to allow married men into active ministry as priests would be like a breath of fresh air for the current priests who are overworked and the many parishes that would no longer have to share pastors.

And if that happens, there is almost no doubt I would enter the priesthood. As of now though, I feel like I'm on that "God or the Girl" show and the Girl currently has the lead by a nose ;-)

Edited by LouisvilleFan
EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

More Gregorian chant (in the west, of course)! A direct statement on holding hands during the Lord's Prayer! St. Michael prayer! Meaningful homilies!

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+


[quote]Let's start with getting them to confession once a month rather than once every 5 years. [/quote]

True...[i]Sad[/i]. But true. <_<

Norseman82
Posted

1) Let's work on implementing/obeying the rules that we already have regarding the liturgy.
2) Add an announcement on Christmas/Easter that if you've been blowing off Sunday/HDO (Holy Day of Obligation) Mass all year you have to go to confession before receiving communion since blowing off Sunday/HDO Mass is a mortal sin.

Posted

I'm glad I'm not the only one who has reservations about some of these...
[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='990109' date='May 24 2006, 10:15 PM']
10. No kneelers - AND everyone physically able is REQUIRED to kneel. How's that for a lesson in mortification???
9. Confession required once a week.
8. At every mass, the priest lists off the commandments (and the grave obligations/prohibitions listed by the CCC) with the congregation replying, "I believe. I submit. Amen." at the end.
7. At every mass, the priest swears to the congregation that he will obey the Church and remain faithful to Catholic norms for the liturgy.
6. Eucharistic fast increased to three hours before receiving.
5. Leonine prayers at Mass back in action!
4. Abstinence every Wednesday and fasting every Friday of the year. (Lent & Advent would be fasting on both days and Abstinence for the whole season.)
3. Choir lofts in every parish - or at least the musicians and singers are required to do their thing in the back and out of sight.
2. Annointing of the Sick received MUCH more frequently and new explorations of the sacrament.
1. Perpetual Adoration in every parish.
[/quote]

10. Nice as a devotional, but many people aren't physically able to do it. Plus some people (children at least) cannot see over the pew in front of them if not on a kneeler.
9. The Church has spoken on this... for some it may contribue to scrupulousness. I think this works better as an optional devotion too.
8. Eh? Catechise the congregation, and that statement is implied during the Nicene Creed.
7. He shouldn't have to.
6. same as 9+10.
5. ?? What's that?
4. I don't think I'd mind abstinence on Fridays (Fish Fridays!) as it was pre-Vatican II, but I don't think that is necessary.
3. I don't think that's necessary.
2. I could go for that.
1. This is the only one that I would really really support. I think it should be a goal for every parish. However, I do know that parishes with very small congregations, particularly those in remote areas, can only realistically have adoration some of the time.

Noel's angel
Posted

Leonine prayers are a set of prayers that used to be said after low Mass. They were institued by Pope Leo XIII (hence Leonine) but seemed to disappear in the 60s

Posted

The thing about Perpetual Adoration is that you need people willing to volunteer. Where I live, both at college and at home, there's one Perpetual Adoration parish within a short-ish driving distance, and even they have trouble filling all of the time slots. If we had adoration at every single parish, I fear that we'd either have a lot of people having to commit 70 hours a week, or we'd have a lot "alone time" for Jesus. Sad, but that's the nature of the beast.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='990225' date='May 25 2006, 06:53 AM']And the second thing I want to see is the discipline of celibacy in the priesthood changed to match what we currently require of deacons. I believe the Church is suffocating from a lack of pastors. Simply changing the current discipline to allow married men into active ministry as priests would be like a breath of fresh air for the current priests who are overworked and the many parishes that would no longer have to share pastors. [/quote]ummm, no. :mellow:

Posted

I agree with Lil Red. Not that there is anything evil or wrong with married priests, but it's the tradition of the Latin Church not to let priests be married.

Posted

I like the idea of priestly celibacy.

If God gives you the vocation, he will give you the grace to live it. People aren't going to respond to true vocations because they can get married.

Posted

Most of the mainline Protestant churches allow for pastors to be married, and they too have a shortage of pastors. I don't think celibacy is the issue.

From what i have noticed vocations (priestly, religious life) come from strong Catholic families and communities. When the faith is vibrant, and people are growing, vocations come. When the parish life is dead, so are vocations.

Posted

besides, a man can't serve two masters. when it comes down to a situation where you have to choose needs of family over needs of parish, which wins?

the answer: noone :mellow:

married priest might look like a short-term fix but opens the door to looooong term problems. not to mention the beatufiul theology of celibacy in teh kingdom of God.

Read Theology of the Body and you'll be procelibacy all the way! ^_^

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

From a practical standpoint, how can priests be paid enough to support a family?

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote]And the second thing I want to see is the discipline of celibacy in the priesthood changed to match what we currently require of deacons. I believe the Church is suffocating from a lack of pastors. Simply changing the current discipline to allow married men into active ministry as priests would be like a breath of fresh air for the current priests who are overworked and the many parishes that would no longer have to share pastors. [/quote]

In our diocese the problem of vocations to the priesthood is being resolved by more orthodoxy in the Seminary, resulting in some solid young priests WHO ARE PREACHING THE TRUTH, leading to more vocations. Our local seminary is currently at capacity + 50%. That is the better solution.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='thedude' post='990497' date='May 25 2006, 02:13 PM']From a practical standpoint, how can priests be paid enough to support a family?[/quote]AMEN! people complain enough about supporting their parish! people don't even tithe enough to support their parish! how are they going to support a priest's family?

Posted (edited)

The Orthodox and Protestant churches are able to support married pastors, so I don't think we can say it is impossible. But I don't believe it is ideal/condusive to family life. The Bizentine do it as well and they are in communion to Rome. But I think there is something theologically to be said for giving yourself completely to God in a way that leaves you free to serve him alone.

There is a great book from Ignatiuos Press on this, "Celibacy In The Early Church" [url="http://www.ignatius.com/ViewProduct.aspx?SID=1&Product_ID=626&SKU=CEC-P&ReturnURL=search.aspx%3f%3fSID%3d1%26SearchCriteria%3dcelibacy"]http://www.ignatius.com/ViewProduct.aspx?S...eria%3dcelibacy[/url]

"Heid presents a penetrating and wide-ranging study of the historical data from the early Church on the topics of celibacy and clerical continence. He gives a brief review of recent literature, and then begins his study with the New Testament and follows it all the way to Justinian and the Council in Trullo in 690 it the East and the fifth century popes in the West. He thoroughly examines the writings of the Bible, the early church councils, saints and theologians like Jerome, Augustine, Clement, Tertullian, John Chrystostom, Cyril and Gregory Nazianzen. He has gathered formidable data with conclusive arguments regarding obligatory continence in the early Church."

Edited by Kristen

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...