phatcatholic Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='990225' date='May 25 2006, 07:53 AM'] And the second thing I want to see is the discipline of celibacy in the priesthood changed to match what we currently require of deacons. I believe the Church is suffocating from a lack of pastors. Simply changing the current discipline to allow married men into active ministry as priests would be like a breath of fresh air for the current priests who are overworked and the many parishes that would no longer have to share pastors. [/quote] read some articles bro: [b]--[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/ISSUES/CELIPROB.TXT"]Celibacy Isn't the Problem[/url] --[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=549"]Priestly and Religious Celibacy: Is it Dead, or Should It Be?[/url] --[url="http://soli.inav.net/~jfischer/jan99/patriciadixon.html"]Why a Married Priesthood Won't Remedy the Priest Shortage[/url] --[url="http://www.holyspiritinteractive.net/columns/guests/georgesimjohnston/marriedpriests.asp"]Why Not Married Priests?: The Case for Clerical Celibacy[/url][/b] [b]--[url="http://catholiceducation.org/articles/sexuality/se0071.html"]Celibacy: The Solution, Not the Problem[/url][/b] for more on celibacy, go here: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/615"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat_id/615[/url] pax christi, phatcatholic
Socrates Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='990109' date='May 24 2006, 09:15 PM'] TOP TEN CHANGES I WOULD LOVE!!!! 10. No kneelers - AND everyone physically able is REQUIRED to kneel. How's that for a lesson in mortification??? 9. Confession required once a week. 8. At every mass, the priest lists off the commandments (and the grave obligations/prohibitions listed by the CCC) with the congregation replying, "I believe. I submit. Amen." at the end. 7. At every mass, the priest swears to the congregation that he will obey the Church and remain faithful to Catholic norms for the liturgy. 6. Eucharistic fast increased to three hours before receiving. 5. Leonine prayers at Mass back in action! 4. Abstinence every Wednesday and fasting every Friday of the year. (Lent & Advent would be fasting on both days and Abstinence for the whole season.) 3. Choir lofts in every parish - or at least the musicians and singers are required to do their thing in the back and out of sight. 2. Annointing of the Sick received MUCH more frequently and new explorations of the sacrament. 1. Perpetual Adoration in every parish. [/quote] I tend to second a lot of what others have posted here, but: 10) Keep the requirement to kneel at appropriate times, but keep the kneelers, for the sake of the elderly, etc. Reverence does not require a test of being "hardcore." 9) Maybe once a month - but regular confession should be done out of love and devotion, not something forced - Where Catholics are well-informed about this, and love God, they will go to regular confession. Priests should preach the importance of this sacrament. 8) No need to "add" to the liturgy. Proper catechesis and teaching from the pulpit is the answer. 7) Redundant. 6) Good idea - this was more like it was in the past. A one-hour fast is hardly a sacrifice for most people. Dispensations could be made for people with medical conditions. 5) ok 4) Not sure we need to go that far - how about just bringing back abstinence every Friday? 3) Good idea - the choir should not be "stage performers." 2) Unnecessary innovation - seems to me this would cheapen this sacrament. Wouldn't want to see the annointing of the sick used for every stubbed toe and head cold! 1) Absolutely (wherever this is possible)
LouisvilleFan Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 In regards to celibacy in the priesthood, the shortage of priests is one factor, but I'm also concerned with how priests in many parts of Africa still bear children because celibacy is a foreign to their cultures. They interpret it as not getting married, but still having wives and kids. Do we even want to get into the number of abortions priests have ordered nuns to have in order to cover up their sins? I know there isn't a magical solution to these problems, but at the same time we can't ignore them. [quote name='Kristen' post='990470' date='May 25 2006, 02:46 PM'] Most of the mainline Protestant churches allow for pastors to be married, and they too have a shortage of pastors. I don't think celibacy is the issue. From what i have noticed vocations (priestly, religious life) come from strong Catholic families and communities. When the faith is vibrant, and people are growing, vocations come. When the parish life is dead, so are vocations. [/quote] Well, mainline Protestantism is effectively irrelevent in the U.S. anyway. I know one person in their 20's who is a mainline Protestant. He's Episcopalian and is currently considering Catholicism. Those churches are filled with Baby Boomers, but few of their kids stuck around. Catholic churches tend to be a little better, even if it's only because a lot of Catholics don't want to leave what's familiar to them. On the other hand, Baptist, Reformed, Christian, and non-denominational churches are growing and they have no shortage of pastors, not just for existing churches but to plant new ones. [quote name='kateri05' post='990474' date='May 25 2006, 02:49 PM'] besides, a man can't serve two masters. when it comes down to a situation where you have to choose needs of family over needs of parish, which wins? the answer: noone married priest might look like a short-term fix but opens the door to looooong term problems. not to mention the beatufiul theology of celibacy in teh kingdom of God. Read Theology of the Body and you'll be procelibacy all the way! [/quote] When it comes to serving two masters, or three or four, what about all these priests who are juggling their time among different parishes? How is anyone winning in that situation? We would not lose celibacy alltogether. There's no reason for religious orders to change their rules and I'm all in favor of maintaining the requirement for bishops. Celibacy is tradition, but it isn't dogma. [quote name='thedude' post='990497' date='May 25 2006, 03:13 PM'] From a practical standpoint, how can priests be paid enough to support a family? [/quote] We currently have over 200 married priests in the U.S. already... how do their parishes pay for it? I grew up in a little Lutheran church of about 200 members and we paid for a married pastor. We cannot ordain women because it's a matter of dogma, but there is clearly nothing wrong with ordaining married men. Maybe during this time when society is trying to redefine marriage and premarital sex and birth control are almost as acceptable within the Church as they are outside, the Church needs relevant examples of good Catholic marriages in the priesthood. But that's just my opinion... definitely not my decision to make
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 I never want the Church to become the fundraiser that so many Protestant churches have become. I doubt Protestant churches with married pastors can support the wide array of charitable causes that the Catholic Church supports while at the same time paying out a subsistance income. The priest would have to make three times his current stipend to be above poverty. Then consider housing, etc. with a family in the picture. Two married priests with less time for pastoral activity is no better than one priest who can devote his whole life. Think of the many complications a married seminarian going through his formation would encounter. He would almost have to have a job on the side (perhaps leading to longer formation periods). On top of that, many married clergy would get sick of the lifestyle and leave the priesthood. A nine-year educational investment by the diocese pretty much wasted. [url="http://soli.inav.net/~jfischer/jan99/patriciadixon.html"]http://soli.inav.net/~jfischer/jan99/patriciadixon.html[/url]
kateri05 Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 noone said it was a dogma. however, celibacy is a time honored tradition striaght from the moutht of Christ himself. i agree that we need relevant examples of good catholic marriages... but thsoe marriages shouldn't be coming from the priesthood. besdies, what does it say about the onotological reality of the sacrament of holy orders that one may NOT be married AFTER receiving it?
thessalonian Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 Actually celibacy is doctrine. That is that there is a role for celibacy in the Church. That is what is lost in Protestant Churches. Matt 19 and 1 Cor 7 are ignored. Celibacy as Paul tells us leaves one free to do the Lord's work. I heard a poll some years back that 60% of Protestant pastors said that if they had it all to do over again they would not be pastors and have a family because of the time it took away from the family. The priest shortage is a problem. But not one solved by loosening rules on celibacy. Orthodox teaching is the solution to the matter. "Do we even want to get into the number of abortions priests have ordered nuns to have in order to cover up their sins?" Oh goody, more scandal. Where are you pulling this from. Have there been some? I am sure. But the grace to remain celibate is available in africa as well as anywhere else. The problem is not marriage. It is education and submission. Your proposing that we cover over the problems, rather than rely on God's grace to overcome them.
Resurrexi Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 (edited) they are, in no particular order a. The Pope wearing the Tiara again b. The disposal of Altar Boyesses c. The disposal of Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion except in hugely extraordinary circumstances d. The re-emphasis of Confession e. The disposal of versus poplum (except when versus poplum is ad orientam, like in St. Peter's) f. The revival of excommunications g. The disposal of "Communion on the hand" h. The disposal of the Novus Ordo Missae (except by indult from His Holieness) with the Traditional Latin Mass of AD 1962 replacing it i. The recanonization of the "de-canonized" Saints j. The making of kneelers manditory in all Roman churches Edited May 26, 2006 by StThomasMore
jezic Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 nevermind, this is spam. If you would like place your ideas in the other thread with the exact same name.
Resurrexi Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 This is not spam! Do you think I would have spent all the time I spent making this post when I could have gone to the lame board and got my post rank higher in like two seconds?
jezic Posted May 26, 2006 Posted May 26, 2006 I don't think celibacy is the issue and it wouldn't help matters anyway. Vocations are there whether you think you can be married or not. It is not by man's rules but a CALL from GOD himself. Our liberal media in the US tends to think the Church deprives her priests of something and totally misses that the Church gives them so much more than they are missing. There are a few priests who would like to be married, but the vast majority say that God has given them the grace to live a celibate life.
jezic Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 There is another thread exactly like this one that you could post your information in. Then people would be able to read it in the same topic. That makes this spam.
goldenchild17 Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 (edited) 1. Restoration of the... Oh nevermind... : Edited May 27, 2006 by goldenchild17
Mercy me Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 Wow! this thread has been highjacked! I was add that I agree that frequent confession should be encouraged. However, we need more priest to hear those confessions. I no longer can go to confession at my own parish because of the priest shortage. They have stopped offering confession before mass. There were always at least 15 people waiting for confession when they offered it before mass. Unfortunately I am not able to attend on the day they offer confessions. As to the other ideas I am not too keen on them.
peach_cube Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 a. It's just a tiara, though it would be sweet I would not put it in the top ten. b. I'm not sure about disposal, but I feel it should be stressed for young boy primarily c. agreed d. agreed e. Ad orietam would be nice, but I would not put it in my top ten f. As in more excommunications? If done for the right reasons sure. g. Disagree. Though I prefer on the tongue there is enough historical basis for it that you could not dispose it. see[url="http://matt1618.freeyellow.com/communion.html"]red herring[/url] h. Disagree. Rather the rubrics to be strictly followed with very little "interpretation" i. They have not actually been "decanonized" in the sense that they are no longer regarded as saints, just that their "cult" is no longer universal but local j. Well it would be a shame to put kneelers in the gothic cathedrals, I would say people who are able should kneel, if their are no kneelers then bring a pillow to kneel if it bothers you.
cappie Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 [quote name='Mercy me' post='991289' date='May 27 2006, 01:01 PM'] Wow! this thread has been highjacked! I was add that I agree that frequent confession should be encouraged. However, we need more priest to hear those confessions. I no longer can go to confession at my own parish because of the priest shortage. They have stopped offering confession before mass. There were always at least 15 people waiting for confession when they offered it before mass. Unfortunately I am not able to attend on the day they offer confessions. As to the other ideas I am not too keen on them. [/quote] People should be ENCOURAGED to go to confession more often.....to make it as suggested required once a week... all I can say is that you have never had to deal with people with scruples
Resurrexi Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 In the old cathedrals you could provide extra long pillows that were made for kneeling.
phatcatholic Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 everyone please be mindful of the fact that this board is not the place for debate. thanks, phatcatholic
Resurrexi Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 oops, my last post was supposed to go in the other thread that has the exact same name. OOOOH! Now i get it, these two threads were merged together.
phatcatholic Posted May 27, 2006 Posted May 27, 2006 yup two threads w/ the exact same title and subtitle, and on the same subject, is not necessary.
shortnun Posted May 30, 2006 Posted May 30, 2006 [quote name='XIX' post='990370' date='May 25 2006, 11:46 AM'] The thing about Perpetual Adoration is that you need people willing to volunteer. Where I live, both at college and at home, there's one Perpetual Adoration parish within a short-ish driving distance, and even they have trouble filling all of the time slots. If we had adoration at every single parish, I fear that we'd either have a lot of people having to commit 70 hours a week, or we'd have a lot "alone time" for Jesus. Sad, but that's the nature of the beast. [/quote] I'd rather see people going to weekday Mass and become more involved in the life of the parish than I would want to see people go to Adoration one hour a week and that's it. *clink, clink* <------------ my two cents
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now