Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Top ten changes I would love to see in the Church


Recommended Posts

MC IMaGiNaZUN
Posted

external controls do not make for holy saintly people. In fact, as far as my experience tells me the really courageous saints of the church underwent the harshest of persecutions.

Anyways, now to your top ten...

10. I like the idea of removing kneelers. Self mortification is a valuable asset on our way to holiness. However, it would be uncharitable to demand that everybody kneel, for some it would harm them physically. Forcing them to kneel does not produce the inner reverence towards God that their soul needs intrinsically. Rather it is that desire for reverence that produces kneeling and sacrifice. (When i first read this i had the mistaken notion that you were in league with some of the modern churches that remove the kneelers altogether because signs of submission are archaic)

9.Confession is a valuable thing on our way to heaven. I do not know where i would be without it. However, i know of many times that it has helped, and many times it has not. Confession at some times has put me in a position where i become comfortable with my sin knowing that i could just go to confession at the end of the week. At times when confession was not available, i was actually more open to God's grace to actually overcome temptation and avoid near occasions of sin. I go once or twice a month. (But it is also important to keep in mind there are some catholic communities, with no priest, who only comes once a month to do baptisms, weddings, and mass to leave the consecrated hosts for the remainder of the month. Some people do not have the previlage we have of the sacraments. Further, i know of many priests who comment that they will sit in the confessional for a whole hour and spend less than a quarter of that time actually hearing confessions.)

8. I do not know that this has actually ever been a part of the mass in the history of the church, i could be wrong and would be open to hearing it. I would have mentioned above, and i think it is proper here, i know of many many people who avoid church, or God, or just confession believing that God WILL NOT or CANNOT forgive them. They are not proud of their sins, or even themselves. They carry constant shame in their hearts and some i worry suffer from depression. Although a thorough examination of conscience is seriously due in our liturgy, i highly favor this. The approach is important as well. People do feel rejected by a church that constantly shows them that they are not good enough. But i do think this would fit into the penitential rite, and could be effective.

7. This one is cool. I think they do it at their ordination. I do not know that it meant much to the priests of our previous generation. But i do see that it means their lives to many recently ordained priests (thos of the past ten years or so). But of course, to those who this means nothing to, well anybody can be forced to make a half hearted vow of voided careless. But what good is it to us and to the individual priest if it means nothing to him.

6. This is a good idea. Prudence is required to see what an adequate exception can be. Most of the time i usually fast about two hours before. However, there have been emergencies where i havent eaten in hours and might eat within an hour of mass starting. I VEHEMTLY TRY TO AVOID SUCH SITUATIONS, and so should all of us.

5. I Completely agree. To those who are lost... Pope Leo XIII instituted the Salve Regina, Ave Maria, and St. Michael pray to be said following each Mass. This was removed for the Novus Ordo. But yeah, i completely agree with this one.

4. I don't know what good this may bring about, but i really do believe that our fasting rules have become something that a devout Muslim or Jew can justifiably laugh at. It should be clear, for all those younger than such ought to fast. Two times a week seems adequate. It does seem a bit much to demand that some people who have physically straining work fast heavily on fridays. But it is also important to remove ourselves from the superficial comfort of unnecessary things. I would support a variation on this one.

3. The choir is TOO distracting. Some churches, like you know the real large ones, have choirs behind the sanctuary. What is important is get the choirs and musicians out of sight, i see too many people who would prefer to sit by them so they could watch them play.

2. The problem here is that it needs to be requested. The priest is not omnipotent, and does not know who needs it. People should feel that it is readily available.

1. I know of one parish somewhere that is so tiny, the amount of people it holds is less then two dozens. It would be impractical to demand that parishes requires people to spend time that they may not even have. I however favor a return to Eucharistic Devotion. Perpetual adoration that demands a grand sacrifice, i do not believe would be practical. I do however think we ought to introduce holy hours once a week, or have once or twice a week when the Eucharist can be exposed for a period of twelve hours, and getting people organized. Eventually that time could be greater.

SHALOM

missionseeker
Posted

What if the kneelers were stone? I know this might sound dumb but the kneeler are a great learning/teaching tool for little kids. 2 and 3 and 4 year olds get bored easily (esp. boys) and they can see what the priest is doing if there are kneelers. they ask questions and learn what is going on. Or a parent can lean over them and tell them what is going on. They also like to be able to say that behaved in Mass. The kneelers are big part of why my little brothers CAN be good at Mass. If they had to kneel on the floor they would start pretending to play cars or something. They might start wrestling. I don't know.


I think that the kneeler has a place. If the cushions were taken off you get the same effect. Sometimes the cushions are worse, If you ask me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...