Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I want to become a Catholic but I'm starting to get discouraged


Recommended Posts

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000558' date='Jun 8 2006, 12:49 PM']
Don't you have to be free from mortal sins as well?
that is what the schismatic Orthodox think
[/quote]

No. Baptism forgives mortal sin.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1000561' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:50 PM']
No. Baptism forgives mortal sin.
[/quote]

[quote]Many times in Africa I heard one of our catechumens say to me, “Father, baptize me straightaway because if I die before you come again, I shall go to hell.” I told him “No,[b] if you have no mortal sin on your conscience[/b] and if you desire baptism, then you already have the grace in you.”[/quote]


so is this theologically wrong?

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000560' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:50 PM']
Thank you everyone for being so kind and encouraging. I have to say that when I had my initial contacts with the church secretaries it was very upsetting but I now know to be patient. I never thought about being Catholic or even Christian before so I know there is something inside of me that is opening up my eyes to God.

Does anyone have any suggestions on good "basic" reading that I would understand since I do not have a religious background?
[/quote]

if you are looking for the basics of the faith i would read the Baltimore Catechism.

thessalonian
Posted

EEns,

Sorry. I confused the bottom part of the post with the top. You were refering to Baptism of Desire with the top statement. "Don't you have to be free of mortal sin also". I was thinking in terms of actual baptism. Your point is a good one. I guess they would have to be with Baptism of Desire. Therefore perhaps your position on perfect contrition is a valid one. I will have to think about that.

Janana8706
Posted

have you talked to any of the priests? What about the one marrying you?? I know my cousin got to do RCIA by himself, but I think thats b/c he went to Mass every week w/ his wife and kids. I'd try talking directly to the priest.

Posted

Read this:

"Catholic Matters" by Fr. John Neuhaus

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

As thessalonian said, perfect contrition is very hard. so here is how to get it.

[quote]

[url="http://www.catholicfirst.com/thefaith/prayers/perfectactcontrition.cfm"]http://www.catholicfirst.com/thefaith/pray...tcontrition.cfm[/url]
The Act of Perfect Contrition



The act of contrition as it is found in the Small Catechism of the Catholic Religion by Bishop John Neumann of the Congregation of the most holy Redeemer, Fourth Bishop of Philadelphia, Imprimatur by the Most Rev. James Gibbons, Archbishop of Baltimore, given 24 July 1884:



"O my God, I am heartily sorry for having offended Thee, and I detest all my sins, because I dread the loss of Heaven and the pains of Hell, but most of all because they offend Thee, my God, Who art all-good and deserving of all my love. I firmly resolve, with the help of Thy grace to confess my sins, to do penance and to amend my life. Amen."



Since this form of the act of contrition incorporates all the elements of the act of perfect contrition, I urge all of you, one and all, to memorize and use this act of contrition.



There are 5 qualities or elements that must be in the act of perfect contrition. Whether they are in the form of the contrition or not, they must be present. Hence, you see why I insist on the above wording, for it is flawless, and it incorporates all the 5 qualities of the act of perfect contrition. By the way, name the contrition properly. It is "an act of perfect contrition," not "a perfect act of contrition."




The 5 qualities of the act of perfect contrition are:



Interior,

Supernatural,

Universal,

Supreme, and

Intense.



We shall study each of these qualities:




Interior



What do we mean when we say that the act of perfect contrition must be interior? We mean that it is an interior act of the mind and will. When a priest says his Divine Office correctly but with distractions (hopefully not intended) he fulfills his obligation that the law imposes on him. If, while you confer the sacrament of baptism, you say the words carefully with the intention to baptize as the Church baptizes, you confer the sacrament even though you had distractions during the rite. The act of contrition does not work as the above cases. It is something even independent of spoken words. The mind and heart must determine everything that is said in the above form of contrition. The mere perfect recitation of the form, as one says his prayers, is not sufficient.




Supernatural



There are many elements or divisions in this quality. The act of contrition must be supernatural as to the "power" with which it is performed. It must be made under the influence of actual grace. Actual grace is the supernatural assistance that enlightens the mind to know the will of God and strengthens the will to do the will of God. Hence, before starting the act of contrition, it is good (and I encourage you to do so) to ask for this special grace. Without it, the act of contrition is useless.



Secondly, the act must be supernatural as to "motive." Here we have 2 motives. The inferior motive (imperfect contrition) has to do with the dread of the loss of heaven and the pains of hell. The superior motive (perfect contrition) has to do with the fact that we have offended God who is all good. Together with the sacraments of Baptism and Penance, the inferior motive (fearing the loss of heaven and the pains of hell) is sufficient for forgiveness of all sins. However, outside of those sacraments, only the superior motive (being sorry for having offended God who is all good) will suffice for the forgiveness of all sins.



We must answer this question. Just why are you sorry for your sins. Is it because drinking made you sick? That is a natural motive, and it has no relation to forgiveness. While the natural motives are good in themselves, they will never work for forgiveness.




Universal



The act of contrition must include all of the mortal sins. One may never keep even one pet sin. Thus, if a person living in adultery is very sorry for his sins of eating meat on Fridays, but will not give up his sinful life of adultery, he cannot get rid of even one sin. One either leaves all of his sins behind, or he keeps all of them for God's just judgment at the moment of death. Unlike teeth, which when left alone, will pass away, sins, however, when left alone will never pass away.




Supreme



When We say that the act of contrition must be supreme, we are saying that we must determine that we would rather die than commit a mortal sin. We must hate mortal sin (venial sin too, if possible) even more than death itself. Just think how careful we are about our lives. We avoid death at great sacrifices. A man will throw his possessions over-board to save his life. He will avoid the company of those who have a contagious sickness in order to save his life. In like manner, we must hate sin, in the act of contrition, as the greatest evil on earth.




Intense



In the above form of contrition, we express this determination with the word "detest." I might say that I do not like to eat spinach. However, I say that I "detest" eating rotten crow. In like manner, we do not say that we just do not like sin, but we detest it as we detest eating rotten crow.




Purpose of Amendment



There is a final element that is not mentioned in the qualities of the act of contrition, and that is the purpose of amendment. In practical speech, we make a division in regard to contrition and the purpose of amendment. However, there is no real distinction between the two except the element of past and future. If one is sorry for his sins, he determines automatically not to sin again. Any time that a person living in adultery is really sorry for his sins, he automatically leaves his sinful way of life. A person who is in bad company is not merely sorry for his sinful life-style, but he determines to give up one and all of his evil companions.




Intention to Confess



Once one knows the divine law of confession, he must also determine to confess all the mortal sins he has committed after baptism. To say that one is sorry without that intention to confess the sins, when one has a chance to do so, is a false act of contrition. One must determine to obey all God's commandments, and one of those commandments is that one must confess all mortal sins committed after baptism to a duly authorized priest. If there is no priest to be had, then God accepts the will for the deed. He will not accept the will for the deed if there is a duly authorized priest available. Remember the act of perfect contrition always takes away all sins immediately.




Fulfill the Obligations



For the act of contrition to be complete, one must fulfill all the obligations that follow from ones sins. A thief must return that which he has stolen. Likewise, a person who has taken away the good name of another must do what he can to give that good name back again.




The Merciful Hands of God



When one has done all that he can in regard to the act of perfect contrition, he still does not have an infallible assurance that he has sanctifying grace. However, he can and should have moral certitude that he is in the state of sanctifying grace. He should rest his case in the merciful hands of God.




An Act of the Will



Very briefly, we will say it this way. When we make the act of perfect contrition, we should pay very close attention to every word in the form, and we are to make the acts that are required by the form. Never say, I pray the act of contrition. Do say, I make the act of contrition. When persons get married, they do not merely say a formula, but they make an act of the will to join themselves in matrimony. When a person makes vows in religion, he does not merely recite a formula, but he makes an act of the will (expressed in words) to embrace the religious life. In like manner, the act of contrition is an act by which one is sorry for past sins, and that sorrow extends into the future so that it also requires the purpose of amendment never to commit those sins or any sins, for that matter, in the future. [/quote]

longing_catholic
Posted

We are getting married by a non-demoninational officient. We plan to re-marry in a Catholic church when I become Catholic and develope my own personal relationship with God. I didn't try to talk to the Priest directly yet...I came here trying to find some help with my situation before taking more drastic matters.


In the event that I have to wait, does anyone know of any good study material that I can work at home with prior to the program?

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000597' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:04 PM']
We are getting married by a non-demoninational officient. We plan to re-marry in a Catholic church when I become Catholic and develope my own personal relationship with God. I didn't try to talk to the Priest directly yet...I came here trying to find some help with my situation before taking more drastic matters.
In the event that I have to wait, does anyone know of any good study material that I can work at home with prior to the program?
[/quote]

is your Soon to be husband a Catholic?

just based on the fact that you want to become catholic, your marriage in a non-denominational Church may be invalid...

Posted

I don't mean to tell you what to do but if your being married outside the church that is not a valid marriage in the eyes of God and so cohabitation is not an option. You can however get married in a Catholic church even if you are not Catholic- especially since you plan on becoming one.

Also a question on perfect act of contrition:

is it that it should only be used in extreme circumstances where you really can't get to confession- and isn't it basically being completly sorry for your sins 100% becaues of God's love not the fear of hell?

heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000513' date='Jun 8 2006, 12:31 PM']
Thank you so much for your positive responses. I just don't understand why the program starts at that time of the year. You can enter in the middle of the program? Luckily I am getting married next Friday to a great guy who is Catholic and we plan to do a weekly study together and attend church weekly!
[/quote]
Early congrats on getting married! Being married to a catholic will hopefully make this easier to get thru for you.
God bless and good luck.

thessalonian
Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000597' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:04 PM']
We are getting married by a non-demoninational officient. We plan to re-marry in a Catholic church when I become Catholic and develope my own personal relationship with God. I didn't try to talk to the Priest directly yet...I came here trying to find some help with my situation before taking more drastic matters.
In the event that I have to wait, does anyone know of any good study material that I can work at home with prior to the program?
[/quote]

I would not recommend that. Your Catholic friend is committing a grave sin in doing this. If you love him you will not be a part of this sin, though it appears you are likely an unknowing party to it. It sounds like you want to do what is right. Go with him to a priest and discuss the whole situation pronto!

longing_catholic
Posted

My soon to be hubby is Catholic. We in fact are not even getting married in a church...(its an outside wedding). I am completely aware that in the Catholic churches eyes, our marriage will not be valid. But like I said in a previous posting, we plan to remarry in a Catholic church when I become Catholic and have my own personal relationship with God.



[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000601' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:06 PM']
is your Soon to be husband a Catholic?

just based on the fact that you want to become catholic, your marriage in a non-denominational Church may be invalid...
[/quote]

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted (edited)

[quote name='curtins' post='1000605' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:08 PM']
I don't mean to tell you what to do but if your being married outside the church that is not a valid marriage in the eyes of God and so cohabitation is not an option. You can however get married in a Catholic church even if you are not Catholic- especially since you plan on becoming one.

Also a question on perfect act of contrition:

is it that it should only be used in extreme circumstances where you really can't get to confession- and isn't it basically being completly sorry for your sins 100% becaues of God's love not the fear of hell?
[/quote]


It is being Sorry for killing the Lord. It can be done whenever, but you have to go to confession before communion.

I think it would be a sin to me married in a non-catholic marriage.....

Edited by Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
thessalonian
Posted

prayers for you both. As I said I do not recommend the path you are choosing and have personal insight which I will share with you in a pm. Check your box shortly.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote]3. The Catholic who contracts a mixed marriage before a minister contracts no marriage at all, commits a mortal sin and cannot be admitted to the Sacraments.

Catholics who act thus are declared to be guilty of mortal sin, because they sin through disobedience, by refusing to conform to the precepts of the Church; they give great scandal, and deny the faith; they turn their back upon the sacraments of the true Church and receive the rites of an heretical sect. Thus they give the preference to a false Church, or at least allow its equality with the true one. They cannot be re-admitted to the sacraments unless they manifest sincere contrition on account of their sinful union, and are ready to comply with the requirements of the Church. Many a one takes a just view of his conduct on his death-bed. Conscience often slumbers, like a volcano, which for long years shows no signs of activity, then suddenly bursts into flame; so conscience awakens at last, and the unhappy soul is consumed by the flames of remorse and despair. No one who firmly believes the Catholic to be the only true and saving faith will be content to see his children brought up in soul-destroying error; and it may safely be affirmed, that in the majority of cases, those who contract mixed marriages sooner or later heartily regret the step they have taken. [/quote]

heavenseeker
Posted

I also do not recomend having a non-catholec wedding even though outdoor weddings are beautiful they are not recomended or reconised by the church. You seem to understand this tough being that you plan to get re-married in the church. I just think it would cause less stress to just get it done properly the first time though.

longing_catholic
Posted

"They cannot be re-admitted to the sacraments unless they manifest sincere contrition on account of their sinful union, and are ready to comply with the requirements of the Church."


As I stated before I plan on getting married in the Catholic once I become a Catholic.

I am sorry that this whole positive experience of me wanting to become a Catholic has turned into such a negitive debate. Thank you to those who will keep me in your prayers.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

if you were sorry, you wouldn't do it in the first place.

if the marriage is going to be invalid, what is the point of it?

heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000622' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:19 PM']
"They cannot be re-admitted to the sacraments unless they manifest sincere contrition on account of their sinful union, and are ready to comply with the requirements of the Church."
As I stated before I plan on getting married in the Catholic once I become a Catholic.

I am sorry that this whole positive experience of me wanting to become a Catholic has turned into such a negitive debate. Thank you to those who will keep me in your prayers.
[/quote]
I am truly happy for you, I just wish you would symplify things for yourself.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

i just want to apologize if i was rude, i was trying to get the truth across.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...