Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I want to become a Catholic but I'm starting to get discouraged


Recommended Posts

Guest Rick777
Posted

Longing Catholic,

I'm so happy to hear you want to become Catholic! Thats great news! I'm very sorry to hear that you feel people are judging you, I think it's quite the opposite. Just becuase a "fellow Catholic" :) isn't praising your actions that doesn't mean that they are being judgemental, they see that your going to be doing something wrong and just want to help you avoid the problems it may cause for you in the future. It's actually very charitable and even though this may sound wierd you should feel kind of honored because they have shown such care for your situation. :saint: If I were you I would try and pray as much as possible, read about Catholicism as much as possible, and just be happy! This is a great time! :D: Talk to a good priest in your area, it will help loads.


P.S.- The title of this thread should also include the words" And Come and Bash Sam!" :unsure: Sam has just provided the truth in this thread so why the negativity towards him? Tata126 what does this mean, [b]"Extra Ecclesia Nulla Salus, as your name suggests, you take an extraordinarily negative attitude towards discussions, and it doesn't help people understand. It just makes them angry, at you, at the teachings you claim to defend, and at the Church which teaches them, and that is exactly the opposite of what you should be doing. Your duty is to lead people IN by being welcoming and loving, not push people OUT by being too harsh."[/b]? As your name suggests? There is nothing negative about that name. :pinch: The truth is the truth. :idontknow:

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1002837' date='Jun 10 2006, 11:00 PM']
P.S. EENS, weren't you just very recently lapsed and left the Church or something? Or did you change your mind? Just wondering -- I would hope that you would have yourself straightened out from a spiritual standpoint before trying to have a go at wrangling with someone else in an attempt to give them guidance. It doesn't really work so well that way. Physicians can't treat others when they're sick themselves. Just a thought... God bless you Sam.
[/quote]

yeah I'm back ^_^

Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000540' date='Jun 8 2006, 12:41 PM']
Many times RCIA is just for people whose Spouse is Catholic and wants them to convert or something like that. do not be suprised if it is full of liberalism or what not. My mom went through RCIA, just her and my dad and a priest. The priest never told her about the real presecence, EENS, or anything else....what a waste.
[/quote]

Not all RCIA programs are like that. I went through a really great program. RCIA is not a waste. Regardless of what others may think, RCIA classes are a must. Please, don't make the situation worse by saying how bad RCIA is when it isn't in all circumstances.

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1000558' date='Jun 8 2006, 12:49 PM']
Don't you have to be free from mortal sins as well?
that is what the schismatic Orthodox think
[/quote]

You're in schism too though.

[quote name='curtins' post='1000605' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:08 PM']
I don't mean to tell you what to do but if your being married outside the church that is not a valid marriage in the eyes of God and so cohabitation is not an option. You can however get married in a Catholic church even if you are not Catholic- especially since you plan on becoming one.

Also a question on perfect act of contrition:

is it that it should only be used in extreme circumstances where you really can't get to confession- and isn't it basically being completly sorry for your sins 100% becaues of God's love not the fear of hell?
[/quote]

I think a priest should teach about contrition because obviously it really isn't the point of this thread and it's causing a debate when we are supposed to be helping this girl. When she goes through RCIA, she will learn about contrition. Until then, can we just stick to the thread. And EENS, you are really not helping at all. You are going into detail about an issue this person knows little to nothing about in the first place and it has gaps and errors in how you are explaining it.

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1002639' date='Jun 10 2006, 04:34 PM']
how am i pushing someone out? i tried to be welcoming, and nice and all that. When the person told us about how she planned to commit a mortal sin, and when we admonished her, and she called us "judgmental", that is when i got angry. It's very typical behavior really. someone who justifies his/her actions by claiming that everyone sins (which is true, but off topic nonetheless), and calling us mean or unwelcoming. Alleuia, someone has entered the Church, (this is good news), but when someone sins, and then refuses not to sin, after we have explained the sin, makes me question WHY this person wants to enter the Church in the first place. The Church is not a big love fest of "non-judgmental" people, She is the Bride of Christ, and through her is the only possible entrance into Heaven. This person needs to stop trying to justify the sin she is about to commit, and get over it.
[/quote]

We're not here to judge someone though. Your living in sin because you belong to the SSPX. Everybody is a sinner dude. Jesus gave us His life for our sins. He gave us the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Who in the heck do you think you are for judging someone who clearly is wanting to learn more about the Catholic Church. You push people away in that respect. Nobody wants to feel like that. Let God be the judge, not you.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='Anthony' post='1003165' date='Jun 11 2006, 11:55 AM']
Not all RCIA programs are like that. I went through a really great program. RCIA is not a waste. Regardless of what others may think, RCIA classes are a must. Please, don't make the situation worse by saying how bad RCIA is when it isn't in all circumstances.
You're in schism too though.
I think a priest should teach about contrition because obviously it really isn't the point of this thread and it's causing a debate when we are supposed to be helping this girl. When she goes through RCIA, she will learn about contrition. Until then, can we just stick to the thread. And EENS, you are really not helping at all. You are going into detail about an issue this person knows little to nothing about in the first place and it has gaps and errors in how you are explaining it.
We're not here to judge someone though. Your living in sin because you belong to the SSPX. Everybody is a sinner dude. Jesus gave us His life for our sins. He gave us the Sacrament of Reconciliation. Who in the heck do you think you are for judging someone who clearly is wanting to learn more about the Catholic Church. You push people away in that respect. Nobody wants to feel like that. Let God be the judge, not you.
[/quote]

I do not belong to the SSPX. i am not a member of the priestly society, i am not an SSPX nun, nor am I an SSPX third order member. I am not in schism. I am not judging. I am telling someone that they should not sin. that is not judging. you need to understand that as Catholics, we have to correct sin when we see it.

If you are going to continue to slander me by calling me a schismatic please justify yourself, as i see no evidence of such a charge.

Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1002338' date='Jun 10 2006, 09:29 AM']
Thank you for the suggestion as well as keeping me in your prayers. I really do appreciate your positive feedback.

I was starting to feel like I was making the wrong decision to become catholic since so many people decided to bash me for the decisions that I was making in my life. Before I even thought about learning more about Catholicism, I felt as if most (and I don't mean everyone though)...i felt most Catholics were very judgemental and very forceful with their religion. I know that isn't completely true but some people on here had me feeling that way again and questioning why would i even want to go where people were not welcoming. I realized a few things though. Most importantly they aren't the ones who judge me in the end. I know from prior readings that Jesus always opened his arms to sinners because he wanted to help them. I also know that Jesus would really look down on how most people reacted by judging me and calling me a sinner instead of preaching the word of God to give me guidence. I know that I will soon be baptized and forgiven for my wrongdoing....and in the end I believe in my heart that Jesus will forgive me and open his arms to me.

Another thing that I realized is that no matter what you do in life or where you go.....people will always be judgemental. Even though most of you were negative towards me, I know this isn't about you. This is about my own personal relationship with God.

I hope in the future most of you will not be so quick to judge others and practice the word the way that Jesus would have wanted you to by welcoming sinners not bashing them over the head and repeatidly telling them what they did wrong. If someone is sinning, maybe in your practicing it does say to let them know but come one...there is certain ways to do it. Most of you had a cold heart and really made me feel unwelcome. Regardless....you are not God and you do not have a say so in whether I go to heaven or not.

Someone pointed out earlier that you all do not know the situation and yes...that is true...it isn't your business to know...and to make it very clear...there are not inlaws involved and there is no parents involved. We are having a private ceremony. My decision to get married wasn't based on the fact that I want to defy God in any way shape or form or sin purposly. All of the wedding plans were made well before I even considered becoming Catholic. BUT EVERYONE SEEMED TO LOOSE SIGHT OF THE REAL REASON WHY I CAME HERE. Some of you did not read my initial posting or just chose to ignore or forget what I said. I didn't come here asking for any one of you help regarding my marriage or a blessing of my marriage. I came to you all hoping that you would welcome me into your Catholic community and give me guidence on how to become a Catholic...not make me question why I would want to in the first place.

I really do appreciate those of you who stood up for me as well as those who gave me positive feed back. Even though for a split second I questioned becoming a Catholic...I realized that the Devil will try to sway you and try to get you to change your mind. I still feel a compelling want to become Catholic and no matter what people say or do...that will not change.

I have found a lot of hope in Pope John Paul II and maybe some of you should read about him. He would have never had said things to me the way that some of you have. He forgave someone for almost killing him...he never pointed the finger at that person and never said "you are such a sinner and you are 'probably' going to go to hell for your actions". He was a beautiful man that had so much to teach all of us. Maybe you guys should sit down and read about him too.

And don't forget....Jesus was the one who turned to the sinner on the cross and said that he will see him in paradise and forgave him. You never read anything about him saying..."YOU SINNER YOU!!!"
Try not to play God and worry about your own closet before worrying about mine.

I hope you keep me in your prayers and I will do the same for you.
[/quote]
:welcome:

Honestly, and I don't know why this is, but the internet is [b]not[/b] the best place to find an accurate sampling of solid and devout Catholic. They tend to be considerably less forceful in real life than they appear to be on the internet. Maybe it's just because the internet is not the most personal place to meet, and you don't get to see our utterly sweet and attractive facial expressions, expressions that suggest we're not really angry at you or anything. I'm not sure.

However, I think the most important thing in your Catholic faith journey is to find a devout group of Catholics. Get involved with a local pro-life group, or another activist group that supports Catholic values, find a Rosary group, maybe a Bible study, go to daily Mass, volunteer for a retreat, go on a retreat (many of us will highly recommend Steubenville retreats :)). Finding a group of people who share your faith and garnering some friendships (and accountability) with them will do wonders for you. I know this from experience, from other peoples' experience, my own intuation, and some of the best advice I've ever heard. If you

A few other points:
1) If you can find a spiritual director, that could be a good help. If you go that route, make sure it a very devout, orthodox Catholic. Orthodoxy does count. :topsy:
2) Don't be afraid of constructive criticism--anybody who has ever sinned could benefit from it once in a while. :D: I know what it's like to get slammed, and if somebody tries to shove something down your throat, you have every right to be upset about that. On the other hand, you'll never be perfect, so it is always vital to be open minded towards those who tell us stuff we don't necesarily want to hear. And we all hear those kinds of things. It really does happen to the best of 'em.
3) Don't enter any dry t-shirt contests. Such a degrading waste of not-water. :nocomment:

Posted

I agree with you XIX. I didn't think about hooking into a good young adult group or bible study. There are some great conferences for young adults given at the Franciscan University at Steubenville. Prayers for you.

thessalonian
Posted

I do not think that one should be criticized by fellow Catholics (Sam) for admonishing the sinner. We are all sinners and need some of that of course. The act of getting married outside the Church by a CATHOLIC (which here fiance is, though she is not) is wrong and will have negative consequences for both of them. I do not know that longing can be held accountable or admonished for this though. That is the problem I see in this thread. But I also do not think she should be encourage to go through with a non-church approved marriage with a CATHOLIC. I do however hope that through all of this the Lord will be patient with this couple and that even if they do get married outside the Church that he will use Longing to bring her fiance back in to the grace of the Church as the Lord once did for me. I think there is much hope for this. I've been through the path that longing's fiance is going through.

Blessings

Posted (edited)

Of all things in this world Faith and Hope is hard to hold but, worth it in the end. Your baptizm and RCIA will come. Have faith that God will lead you. And, also get the jump on things here at phatmass we have a load of articles about Catholic issues in our Catholic Defense Directory under resources in the navigational bar. Check them out and see what you can find. You can also go to www.Catholicanswers.com thats sorta where I started out.

Your Friend In Christ

-Chris

Edited by Convert4888
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1002570' date='Jun 10 2006, 02:25 PM']All this arguing isn't setting a good example either. Just pray that longing_catholic finds a good and holy priest to direct her conversion, who can help her sort out her issues.[/quote]amen. please everyone, let us pray and sacrifice for longing_catholic and her soon-to-be-husband.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...