Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

I want to become a Catholic but I'm starting to get discouraged


Recommended Posts

heavenseeker
Posted

[quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1000703' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:17 PM']
Congrats on your desire to become Catholic, longing_catholic!

I will pray for you on your journey.

I echo MichaelF's suggestion above regarding marrying in a church--think of it as part of your journey to the Catholic faith. I do not think that the others were trying to be condemning--they were just concerned for you. It just doesn't seem to make much sense to say that one wants to be Catholic-- but only after they've been officially received into the Church. You don't have to wait to act like a Catholic until after you've been received into the Church at Easter Vigil. You can get married in a Catholic Church. Thus, you wouldn't have to get "remarried", you could simply have your marriage blessed after the Easter Vigil ceramonies.

But I think the best plan of action would be to find a good and holy priest to discuss all these issues and concerns with.
[/quote]
I believe that is what all of us were trying to say but just couldnt find the proper words to do so.

longing_catholic I hope you understand that we were not judging you. May your path be blessed and you be happy.

Pontifite 7 of 10
Posted

If you ever have doubts and think of turning back...DON"T! God will be with you forever! And the Sacerments ROCK your world. Don't give up, God Bless. :saint:

Posted

Don't worry about people throwing around the idea of sin. A lot of it depends on where you are (this statement does not declare actions right though). Focus instead on growing closer to Jesus each day. You don't necessarily have to be formally received into the Church to do that. It will also put you miles ahead when the RCIA does start.

I would encourage your fiance to read things with you. it would be nice to discuss things with each other. After this reception, i am not sure if you want to bring up serious questions here again, but you can ask questions (especially in the questions forum) that will be answered by scholars/etc.

i would thank God for your desire to be Catholic and do things like read the Catechism. (the official one)

--

I don't really think it is a good idea for the rest of you to start throwing around mortal sins (considering that only the person can tell if it is one). Hello! they want to join the Church. i would pm some people, but it is not possible.

Posted

Jezic- I think youre right but we cannot stand by idly while someone is doing something thats really harmful and potentially a mortal sin (thats why i sed if all 3 factors are present)

I 'm very glad she wants to join the church

Michael Lopez
Posted

Longing, i recently went through the RCIA program and was confirmed. I had alot of personal stuff i had to iron out b4 i started the program, and i also had things to think about too. What i did was go real early b4 mass just stare at the Tabernacle and ask Jesus how to get through this, and The Holy Spirit will guide you. If you can find a local parish with perpetual adoration spend time with Our Lord the more you surrender to silence and sit in from of the Blessed Sacrament, the more The Holy Spirit will intoxicate you and move you to make the right decisions b4 you start the RCIA process. When i started my Jounrney Last May i dropped everything literally my old gang banging friends from when i was 13-29, I was always on a money chase so I stopped working and dealing dope(MONEY AND METH WERE MY IDOLS AT THIS TIME), I DROPPED EVERYTHING AND HEARD THE CALL OF "FOLLOW ME" AND LIKE SIMON AND ANDREW, LEFT WHAT I WAS DOING THERE AND PICKED UP A CROSS AND JESUS GOT AND THE OTHER SIDE OF IT WITH ME AND WE DRUG THAT THING ALL THE WAY THROUGH RCIA. I HOPE YOU DO THE SAME. WALK WITH THE LORD GET TO KNOW HIS CHURCH, THEN HOLD A BIG FIESTA IN THAT CATHOLIC CHURCH FOR YOUR MARRIAGE. BELIEVE ME YOU HOLD OFF UNTIL YOU FINISH RCIA AND THEN MARRY IN THAT CHURCH AFTER YOUVE TAKEN THIS JOG WITH JESUS.....IT WILL ALL BE WORTH IT....M

Posted

[quote name='MichaelF' post='1000681' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:01 PM'][url="http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0764553917/qid=1149796636/sr=2-1/ref=pd_bbs_b_2_1/104-2234260-6183135?s=books&v=glance&n=283155"]http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/076455391...glance&n=283155[/url]

Catholicism for Dummies. Never mind the title, it's a very good, very orthodox, introduction to the Church. Fr John has, for several years, been on EWTNs "Web of Faith" show, answering questions from viewers ("How many times/week can I go to Mass", etc).

Also, watch EWTN (usually, it's in the higher 300-series channels, if you have Digital Cable). Lots of good catechetical info on there.[/quote]:thumbsup: great suggestion![quote name='Fides_et_Ratio' post='1000703' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:17 PM']But I think the best plan of action would be to find a good and holy priest to discuss all these issues and concerns with.[/quote]that is a great idea...please do this.

[quote name='jezic' post='1000740' date='Jun 8 2006, 02:42 PM']Don't worry about people throwing around the idea of sin. A lot of it depends on where you are (this statement does not declare actions right though). Focus instead on growing closer to Jesus each day. You don't necessarily have to be formally received into the Church to do that. It will also put you miles ahead when the RCIA does start.

I would encourage your fiance to read things with you. it would be nice to discuss things with each other. After this reception, i am not sure if you want to bring up serious questions here again, but you can ask questions (especially in the questions forum) that will be answered by scholars/etc.

i would thank God for your desire to be Catholic and do things like read the Catechism. (the official one)

--

I don't really think it is a good idea for the rest of you to start throwing around mortal sins (considering that only the person can tell if it is one). Hello! they want to join the Church. i would pm some people, but it is not possible.
[/quote]agreed :thumbsup:

thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote]I don't really think it is a good idea for the rest of you to start throwing around mortal sins (considering that only the person can tell if it is one). Hello! they want to join the Church. i would pm some people, but it is not possible.[/quote]

I've said it is a grave matter and it is. If you have a problem with my saying that oh well. I have an obligation to say it. It's great that she wants to join the Church and perhaps this conversation should not have been had with her. She does not understand. Further I have great hope that even if they choose this path God will use it to bring them in to the fullness of the faith. But I speak from personal experience on this matter. You see, he was me 9 years ago and she was my wife I am not pleased to say. And it is a very difficult path. My wife did not understand when my family told her it was the wrong thing to do. I can tell you from experience David's penetential Psalms ring true. My soul was parched as I stayed away from the Eucharist and confession. I shudder to think what would have happened had I died in that state, as I know I was not in grace. Thank God he had mercy and was patient with me. I have every hope he will be here as well. But today both my wife and I would say it would have been better had we waited and done it the Churches way. Okay, there's my story. Now maybe your happy.

Edited by thessalonian
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='jezic' post='1000740' date='Jun 8 2006, 03:42 PM']
Don't worry about people throwing around the idea of sin. A lot of it depends on where you are (this statement does not declare actions right though). Focus instead on growing closer to Jesus each day. You don't necessarily have to be formally received into the Church to do that. It will also put you miles ahead when the RCIA does start.

I would encourage your fiance to read things with you. it would be nice to discuss things with each other. After this reception, i am not sure if you want to bring up serious questions here again, but you can ask questions (especially in the questions forum) that will be answered by scholars/etc.

i would thank God for your desire to be Catholic and do things like read the Catechism. (the official one)

--

I don't really think it is a good idea for the rest of you to start throwing around mortal sins (considering that only the person can tell if it is one). Hello! they want to join the Church. i would pm some people, but it is not possible.
[/quote]


yes. lets ignore all the mortal sins, and make it quite possible that this person could go to hell.

and i always thought salvation of souls was the highest law of the Church? :mellow:

thessalonian
Posted

By the way, I don't think we should judge this thread and it's outcome by the fact that it was upsetting to her. If she is being drawn to the Church with a true heart the Holy Spirit will wrestle with her soul on the matter. I do ask that all be patient and kind however.

Posted

I am not saying ignore sins Sam, what i am saying is that you don't gain much by "beating people to a pulp" as it were with everything they had done. Rather encourage devotion to Christ and repentence, forgiveness, and holiness will follow. Besides you cannot say they are mortal sins, only they are grave matter. You do not know the situation the person is in. You are also not the judge.

Christ welcomed the saints and the sinners alike. He demanded they change, but he still welcomed them.

Besides, the doctrine of mortal and venial sin might not be something the OP even knows about yet. In which case, instead of judging, you could explain it to her.

Extra ecclesiam nulla salus
Posted

[quote name='jezic' post='1001157' date='Jun 9 2006, 10:39 AM']
I am not saying ignore sins Sam, what i am saying is that you don't gain much by "beating people to a pulp" as it were with everything they had done. Rather encourage devotion to Christ and repentence, forgiveness, and holiness will follow. Besides you cannot say they are mortal sins, only they are grave matter. You do not know the situation the person is in. You are also not the judge.

Christ welcomed the saints and the sinners alike. He demanded they change, but he still welcomed them.

Besides, the doctrine of mortal and venial sin might not be something the OP even knows about yet. In which case, instead of judging, you could explain it to her.
[/quote]


there was no beating to a pulp. we were just making the person aware of the consqunces of her actions. there was no judging involved, it was simple admonishing of a sinner.

Guest phatdaddy
Posted

People,

This is not the proper forum for this discussion. This is a very complex situation. It is very delicate.
All have spoken the truth concerning sin and validity but this is too much for her where she is. She needs to speak to a orthodox priest that will gently guide her through this. She is a 'brusied reed" go easy.

I know you all mean well but just point her in a direction and perhaps put her in touch with a Catholic Priest that will give her the one-on-one counciling she needs. To guide her correctly he will learn her circumstance and deal with them accordingly.

Of course we can pray for her and we should. And if something specific [u]must[/u] be said to her, say it privately for cryin out loud. These things always seem to turn into PM'r debates.
Mr. Ray

thessalonian
Posted

It probably comes accross as beating to a pulp in this kind of a forum with this much agreement. Basically she had a half dozen people telling her something she did not want to here. It's time for prayer now. Holy Spirit help ltbc to know the truth and grow in holiness. Lead her and her fiance to the fullness of communion with the one, holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church given to us by our Lord Jesus Christ.

Amen.

Fidei Defensor
Posted

[quote name='Extra ecclesiam nulla salus' post='1001162' date='Jun 9 2006, 09:52 AM']
there was no beating to a pulp. we were just making the person aware of the consqunces of her actions. there was no judging involved, it was simple admonishing of a sinner.
[/quote]
Sam, with all due respect, and I mean this in the most loving way I can, please shut up.

Posted

There is a big difference between being right and being persuasive.

Some people have been beating her over the head with a catechism instead of a Bible.

In all things charity.

In order for a sin to be mortal, it must meet three conditions:

Mortal sin is a sin of grave matter
Mortal sin is committed with full knowledge of the sinner
Mortal sin is committed with deliberate consent of the sinner

Just because she has been informed her action is considered a sin (which can be done with charity), does not mean she has full knowledge of it. Most likely it is a sin but not mortal by either her or her future husband if he has been away from the Church for so long.

You can catch more flies with honey than you can with vinegar.

Posted

The linchpin of this discussion is -why- the Wedding must be nonCatholic, as her fiance is Catholic and she -wished- to be Catholic.

So, why a nonCatholic wedding?

The answer may illuminate the whole situation.

My guess is the problem originates with the in-laws. "You are going to be married at the Statue of Liberty Bible Baptist Church, or your Father and I are not coming!!!", etc.

Posted

But if she is getting married in six days I doubt the situation will change.

Fides_et_Ratio
Posted (edited)

Either way, the best place for this discussion is with longing_catholic and a good and holy priest.

I think those have been correct to encourage a Catholic wedding-- for it does not make sense to want to be Catholic, but not act like a Catholic until a later point in time. But there may be circumstances (i.e., inlaws, parents, etc.) that weigh in here... but the best judge in this case is a holy priest. I pray that longing_catholic understands and seeks one out.

Edited by Fides_et_Ratio
Posted

[quote name='longing_catholic' post='1000560' date='Jun 8 2006, 01:50 PM']
Thank you everyone for being so kind and encouraging. I have to say that when I had my initial contacts with the church secretaries it was very upsetting but I now know to be patient. I never thought about being Catholic or even Christian before so I know there is something inside of me that is opening up my eyes to God.

Does anyone have any suggestions on good "basic" reading that I would understand since I do not have a religious background?
[/quote]


Hey, as a convert to Catholicism from no religious background myself, i found these two books helpful, "Why Do Catholics Do That" and "The Basic Book of Catholic Prayer" A good Catholic study Bible is also a good thing to own to get to know God through his Word. I will definetely keep you in my prayers. God Bless as you get to know Him and His Church.:)

longing_catholic
Posted

Thank you for the suggestion as well as keeping me in your prayers. I really do appreciate your positive feedback.

I was starting to feel like I was making the wrong decision to become catholic since so many people decided to bash me for the decisions that I was making in my life. Before I even thought about learning more about Catholicism, I felt as if most (and I don't mean everyone though)...i felt most Catholics were very judgemental and very forceful with their religion. I know that isn't completely true but some people on here had me feeling that way again and questioning why would i even want to go where people were not welcoming. I realized a few things though. Most importantly they aren't the ones who judge me in the end. I know from prior readings that Jesus always opened his arms to sinners because he wanted to help them. I also know that Jesus would really look down on how most people reacted by judging me and calling me a sinner instead of preaching the word of God to give me guidence. I know that I will soon be baptized and forgiven for my wrongdoing....and in the end I believe in my heart that Jesus will forgive me and open his arms to me.

Another thing that I realized is that no matter what you do in life or where you go.....people will always be judgemental. Even though most of you were negative towards me, I know this isn't about you. This is about my own personal relationship with God.

I hope in the future most of you will not be so quick to judge others and practice the word the way that Jesus would have wanted you to by welcoming sinners not bashing them over the head and repeatidly telling them what they did wrong. If someone is sinning, maybe in your practicing it does say to let them know but come one...there is certain ways to do it. Most of you had a cold heart and really made me feel unwelcome. Regardless....you are not God and you do not have a say so in whether I go to heaven or not.

Someone pointed out earlier that you all do not know the situation and yes...that is true...it isn't your business to know...and to make it very clear...there are not inlaws involved and there is no parents involved. We are having a private ceremony. My decision to get married wasn't based on the fact that I want to defy God in any way shape or form or sin purposly. All of the wedding plans were made well before I even considered becoming Catholic. BUT EVERYONE SEEMED TO LOOSE SIGHT OF THE REAL REASON WHY I CAME HERE. Some of you did not read my initial posting or just chose to ignore or forget what I said. I didn't come here asking for any one of you help regarding my marriage or a blessing of my marriage. I came to you all hoping that you would welcome me into your Catholic community and give me guidence on how to become a Catholic...not make me question why I would want to in the first place.

I really do appreciate those of you who stood up for me as well as those who gave me positive feed back. Even though for a split second I questioned becoming a Catholic...I realized that the Devil will try to sway you and try to get you to change your mind. I still feel a compelling want to become Catholic and no matter what people say or do...that will not change.

I have found a lot of hope in Pope John Paul II and maybe some of you should read about him. He would have never had said things to me the way that some of you have. He forgave someone for almost killing him...he never pointed the finger at that person and never said "you are such a sinner and you are 'probably' going to go to hell for your actions". He was a beautiful man that had so much to teach all of us. Maybe you guys should sit down and read about him too.

And don't forget....Jesus was the one who turned to the sinner on the cross and said that he will see him in paradise and forgave him. You never read anything about him saying..."YOU SINNER YOU!!!"
Try not to play God and worry about your own closet before worrying about mine.

I hope you keep me in your prayers and I will do the same for you.




[quote name='avemaria40' post='1002292' date='Jun 10 2006, 09:34 AM']
Hey, as a convert to Catholicism from no religious background myself, i found these two books helpful, "Why Do Catholics Do That" and "The Basic Book of Catholic Prayer" A good Catholic study Bible is also a good thing to own to get to know God through his Word. I will definetely keep you in my prayers. God Bless as you get to know Him and His Church.:)
[/quote]

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...