Dave Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 (edited) I won't name names here, but a friend of mine and fellow PMer who's now in seminary (again, I won't say which one) has just told me that so often the atmosphere seems like Animal House. He said he's seen fellow seminarians get drunk (some of whom are underage), and they don't think it's the least bit sinful. He said others like to joke about masturbation at times. So of course, he really feels scandalized by all that. Now, I know there are numerous seminaries out there that are heterodox or which are hotbeds of gay activity. Of course, that is much worse than the type of stuff going on at this guy's seminary, but it's very upsetting nevertheless. I shudder to think what kind of priests those guys are going to be. I would hope most truly reputable seminaries wouldn't tolerate that sort of thing for a moment. At any rate, I always thought the new generation of priests was for the most part very orthodox, but now I'm not so sure. Edited October 4, 2006 by Dave
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 Pray for our seminaries and our seminarians.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted October 4, 2006 Posted October 4, 2006 What kind? A bad one, I would say. I wonder if the people in charge know about this stuff. It'd be awesome to tell one of the priests (not naming names or anything) and have him deliver a slam dunk homily at the next day's Mass.
Anomaly Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 It's not surprising, really. Hasn't this been an ongoing problem? The catholic denomination has reoccurring problems with self-discipline. That symptom was Mr. Luther's original motivation. If you don't jump on bishops gettng married, why do you think you can get seminarians to behave?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1084445' date='Oct 4 2006, 11:04 PM'] It's not surprising, really. Hasn't this been an ongoing problem? The catholic denomination has reoccurring problems with self-discipline. That symptom was Mr. Luther's original motivation. If you don't jump on bishops gettng married, why do you think you can get seminarians to behave? [/quote] Catholicism isn't a denomination.
Old_Joe Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Unfortunately, too many seminaries don't have enough spiritual formation. I know one of the seminarians here said that when he went to finish up his training the seminary he went to catered to several dioceses and some of the students had had little or no spiritual formation.
brendan1104 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Goodbye. Goodmen. Google it if you don't know what I'm talking about. What you told me isn't a suprise at all, because I've read the book.
Theologian in Training Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 After living in a seminary for four years these things no longer surprise or scandalize me. Perhaps I have just grown indifferent, or been able to accept it, but either way, it is not surprising. Pray for our seminarians, as you can see, they are indeed in need of prayers. God Bless
Ash Wednesday Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Well, hopefully these seminarians will either grow up, or realize they don't actually have a vocation. Praying for priests and seminarians!
iKonstantin Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 (edited) This seminary sounds more acceptable than most of you assume. You realize that we are halting the aging process of the youth in the first world society. Twenty-seven is 'young' to marry, and most university students are heavily involved with their parents. The youth are dependent. Alcohol and promiscuity prevail -everywhere- in our society. Be thankful that there is no promiscuity, and that the problem is limited to alcohol... which incidentally I do not see the issue with, for the stress on a modern seminarian (if you haven't experienced, you will not understand) is so much greater than ones of the previous generations. Why deny them the little life that they live? Did not the Master chastise Martha for complaining about how her sister was lazy? If they chose to do it, don't condemn them, and if you are worried, pray for them. If you wanted to effect them (either for positive or negative, I haven't thought it out yet) send them some wine or alcohol when the exam sessions are over. Oh an on the self-pleasuring jokes: It is a social norm, people who enter the seminary do not (unfortunatly) cease being human. And if they are guilty of it, I am fairly certain that they know that they are 'guilty' and are doing the best they can to improve themselves. And finally; Tell me, would you rather have an active homosexual as a shepard or one who touches himself? brat Konstantin Edited October 5, 2006 by iKonstantin
Era Might Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='iKonstantin' post='1084957' date='Oct 5 2006, 02:57 PM']Tell me, would you rather have an active homosexual as a shepard or one who touches himself? brat Konstantin[/quote] I would rather have a Priest who stayed true to the standard of chastity that all other Christians are called to live. Age is no excuse. If they have no sense to realize that drunkeness and impurity are contrary to Christian living, let alone Seminarian living, then forget about Seminary, they need to go back to CCD. If you're old enough to go to college, you're old enough to take moral responsibility of your life, especially if you are studying to be a Catholic Priest. And if this is going on with the knowledge of the Priests who run the Seminary, they should be ashamed as well. It's not a question of being imperfect; of course Seminarians and Priests are imperfect. But that does not excuse a culture of liceity in a Catholic Seminary. Seminaries should be schools of formation in holiness, and that should be reflected in how the residents conduct themselves. However, I wonder if it's a regular Seminary, or a college Seminary? If so, maybe there's less oversight because it's technically considered a college, and not a major seminary. Still, Seminarians should know better.
Tom Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 I think that if a seminarian has problems with alcohol abuse or chastity, it often reflects deeper underlying problems. In my seminary these would be addressed through human development sessions, and if the staff felt that the person would still not be suitable, they would be asked to leave. I don't see any problem with seminarians enjoying a drink, but if it is used as an escape from reality, I think there are questions that need to be raised. From my experience in my seminary and visiting friends in others, I haven't found it to be that common, and where there has been an issue the staff has been very good at dealing with it. Ultimately I think that Seminary is about profound conversion to Christ, and this will involve conversion from destructive behaviours. While we remain profoundly flawed, someone who will obviously cause public scandal should not be ordained. Thank you so much for all your prayers for seminarians. I know these have been of tremendous impact on me.
Anomaly Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Over-indulgence of alcohol is not acceptable, no matter what the excuse. Stress in a seminary? Try providing for a family, taking care of a sick child, aging parents, a house, bills, etc. Deny them the little life they live? Come on. That's a frigging cake walk. Also, I'm disappointed to hear that this seminary is better than most. I thought it was typical of the really bad ones. And here I thought I was being cynical, but I was really being a Polly Anna. The catholic denomination is even further out of touch with Christian norms than what I thought.
scardella Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='brendan1104' post='1084942' date='Oct 5 2006, 02:24 PM'] Goodbye. Goodmen. Google it if you don't know what I'm talking about. What you told me isn't a suprise at all, because I've read the book. [/quote] A buddy of mine was interviewed for that book (they quoted him in there somewhere, I've seen). He was not accepted into the seminary basically because he was normal, not w/ wierd tendencies.
Theologian in Training Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085001' date='Oct 5 2006, 04:41 PM'] Stress in a seminary? Try providing for a family, taking care of a sick child, aging parents, a house, bills, etc. Deny them the little life they live? Come on. That's a frigging cake walk. [/quote] I would definitely not call it a "cake walk." Seminarians do have a lot of stress, between papers, exams, formation, apostolic assignments, meetings, and organizing major functions. Yet, that is still no excuse, that is why seminarians need to learn to be men of prayer, because much can be accomplished and much can be dealt with when the power of prayer is sustaining them. BTW, as Raphael pointed out Catholicism is not a denomination. God Bless
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='brendan1104' post='1084942' date='Oct 5 2006, 03:24 PM'] Goodbye. Goodmen. Google it if you don't know what I'm talking about. What you told me isn't a suprise at all, because I've read the book. [/quote] I read some of the feedback on that's book's site and was thoroughly disgusted. Assuming it is all true, it would be correct to say that the seminary Dave is talking about is not one of the worst. Is it really that widespread? I am thinking about reading the book, but on the other hand I don't know if I want to. Then again, if I ever pursued the seminary - I'de like to know what I'm getting into.
Anomaly Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Theo, Compared to the stresses that other people have to face in raising and caring for a family and are expected to do so without 'escaping' to alcohol and drugs, the stresses of being a seminarian is a cakewalk. In other words, if you broke your leg and another person has 3rd degree burns, the broke leg is a cakewalk compared to burns. I'm not saying either are easy, but it's not an excuse for guys (including underage guys) to drink and get drunk. Per Webster (not the short TV kid), a denomination is an organized body of similar religious congregations; the name of a class or group. Seems pretty clear to me. Start another thread if you want to challenge me on it.
Maria Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Thankfully, I doubt our seminary is like that. I'll ask a/some relatively new priest(s) and/or a/some seminarian/(s) I know. BTW, it's mostly from being somewhat familiar with our seminarians (and diocese and priests) that I doubt our seminary is anything like that.
Ash Wednesday Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 For some reason this thread makes me think of the priest that was on EWTN who had the near death experience and was going to go to hell because he wasn't reallly living his vocation as priest. Mary interceded for him and he was given a second chance.
Era Might Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Ash Wednesday' post='1085042' date='Oct 5 2006, 04:43 PM']For some reason this thread makes me think of the priest that was on EWTN who had the near death experience and was going to go to hell because he wasn't reallly living his vocation as priest. Mary interceded for him and he was given a second chance.[/quote] Fr. Steven Scheier That's one of my favorite episodes of Mother Angelica Live. You can download it here: [url="http://www.ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/dload1.asp?rafile=iq_2509.ra&source=frmselectseries.asp&seriesID=&T1=scheier"]http://www.ewtn.com/vondemand/audio/dload1...&T1=scheier[/url]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now