Theologian in Training Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085027' date='Oct 5 2006, 05:29 PM'] Theo, Compared to the stresses that other people have to face in raising and caring for a family and are expected to do so without 'escaping' to alcohol and drugs, the stresses of being a seminarian is a cakewalk. In other words, if you broke your leg and another person has 3rd degree burns, the broke leg is a cakewalk compared to burns. I'm not saying either are easy, but it's not an excuse for guys (including underage guys) to drink and get drunk.[/quote] I was not condoning it, rather, I was pointing out that seminarians do have stressful lives. [quote]Per Webster (not the short TV kid), a denomination is an organized body of similar religious congregations; the name of a class or group. Seems pretty clear to me. Start another thread if you want to challenge me on it. [/quote] But Catholicism is not a body of many religious congregations, it is not divided into separate congregations the same way most Protestant churches are. However, I really do not want to get into this, so I will leave it be. God Bless Fr. Brian
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Dave, What level seminary is this? I take it that it must be a college or HS/minor seminary, based on the statement regarding underage drinking. I would like to think that by the time one is in major/post-grad seminary he has outgrown the humor level of high-school freshman and sophomores. Note to everyone: I think that these days [i]everyone[/i] has stressful lives. But it is better to hit the weights than the bottle.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085027' date='Oct 5 2006, 05:29 PM'] Per Webster (not the short TV kid), a denomination is an organized body of similar religious congregations; the name of a class or group. Seems pretty clear to me. Start another thread if you want to challenge me on it. [/quote] Webster was not an ecclesiologist. Catholicism is not a denomination. To say such implies both that it is a collection of other ecclesial communities and also that it has many other equal, but disagreeing, counterparts. We are a Church. Demoninations, termed "ecclesial communities" by the Church, are imperfectly connected to the Church, but are not properly speaking a part of it, because, according to Lumen Gentium, "the sole of the Church of Christ...subsists in the Catholic Church." While elements of the Church can be seen outside of the Catholic Church, her deepest reality is in the visible bounds of the Catholic Church. I'm not debating, just clarifying.
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Denominations: Ones, fives, tens, twenties, hundreds..... OK, humor break over. Let's get back on topic about seminaries.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Norseman82' post='1085164' date='Oct 5 2006, 07:52 PM'] Denominations: Ones, fives, tens, twenties, hundreds..... OK, humor break over. Let's get back on topic about seminaries. [/quote] You forgot the five hundreds. [img]http://usuarios.lycos.es/carola/monopoly500.gif[/img]
Dave Posted October 5, 2006 Author Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Norseman82' post='1085133' date='Oct 5 2006, 07:21 PM'] Dave, What level seminary is this? I take it that it must be a college or HS/minor seminary, based on the statement regarding underage drinking. I would like to think that by the time one is in major/post-grad seminary he has outgrown the humor level of high-school freshman and sophomores. Note to everyone: I think that these days [i]everyone[/i] has stressful lives. But it is better to hit the weights than the bottle. [/quote] I think it's a minor seminary; however, I was told that one student who got several guys (many of them underage) on his floor drunk was 26. Maybe he just started college/minor seminary late in life, though. And as for Brendan's comments, I've actually read "Goodbye, Good Men." However, the book seemed to focus on seminaries with heterodox teachings and which promote the gay lifestyle much more so than those with merely an Animal House-type atmosphere.
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 Dave, Another thing I might ask: is this a free-standing seminary, or a seminary that is part of a larger and perhaps more liberal or otherwise not as orthodox as we'd like school? The reason I ask is that in Chicago, the archdiocesan college seminary, St. Joseph, is on the campus of Loyola University, and I've seen some comments about Loyola University in general being pretty liberal.
Dave Posted October 5, 2006 Author Posted October 5, 2006 Norseman, Now that you've mentioned it, I think it just happens to be St. Joseph's where this guy is at. I'd said earlier I'd rather not say which seminary it was; however, I really just plain couldn't remember. Thanks for jogging my memory.
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Dave' post='1085170' date='Oct 5 2006, 07:01 PM'] I think it's a minor seminary; however, I was told that one student who got several guys (many of them underage) on his floor drunk was 26. Maybe he just started college/minor seminary late in life, though. And as for Brendan's comments, I've actually read "Goodbye, Good Men." However, the book seemed to focus on seminaries with heterodox teachings and which promote the gay lifestyle much more so than those with merely an Animal House-type atmosphere. [/quote] That sounds like a college seminary to me. I can't imagine a HS seminary having someone who is 26 years old except if it is a teacher/staff member, and if that is the case he can and should be criminally charged. I didn't read the "Goodbye, Good Men" book; I probably should, since I hear that it has some comments regarding the HS seminary I attended so I can see how much of it is actually true (since I was actually there).
prose Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 I am taking some courses out of the college here that has the seminary. I take classes with the seminarians. I don't see that here at all
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Dave' post='1085177' date='Oct 5 2006, 07:09 PM'] Norseman, Now that you've mentioned it, I think it just happens to be St. Joseph's where this guy is at. I'd said earlier I'd rather not say which seminary it was; however, I really just plain couldn't remember. Thanks for jogging my memory. [/quote] I have an idea of who the PMer might be based on previous postings. A priest that used to be at my parish that I used to work with in our young adult group is now doing formation and liturgy at St. Joe's.
Anomaly Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1085083' date='Oct 5 2006, 04:49 PM'] I was not condoning it, rather, I was pointing out that seminarians do have stressful lives. But Catholicism is not a body of many religious congregations, it is not divided into separate congregations the same way most Protestant churches are. However, I really do not want to get into this, so I will leave it be. God Bless Fr. Brian [/quote]Theo, We all have stressful lives. Even a college student believes his life cannot be anymore stressful. As many problems as I have to deal with, I don't have a wife with leukemia. I wanted to make it clear that 'cutting some slack, let them get drunk' for stress is b.s. If you want to be a priest, smell of elderberries it up, don't say t he stress is too much. If you want to be a dad, smell of elderberries it up, don't say not getting sleep w/ a sick kid is too much. I'm not surprised on you 'not wanting to get into this'. It's a typical response. The fact is, the range of beliefs within catholicism is as much different denominations as the various Baptist denominations. One wouldn't have to look long just on this website to see that. I'll be nice, though, and let you slide. I'll drop it.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085188' date='Oct 5 2006, 08:33 PM'] I'll be nice, though, and let you slide. I'll drop it. [/quote] Don't tempt mercy.
Norseman82 Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 (edited) Fr. Brian is not advocating alcohol abuse by priests; he's rather pointing out that priests are human, and [i]many times we in the pews seem to forget that[/i]. That's one reason I don't give a priest (or anyone else, for that matter) a hard time if he wants an occasional afternoon off to play a few holes of golf or hit the weights. It's a lot better than some of the alternatives. And please keep in mind where he is coming from: [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1084951' date='Oct 5 2006, 02:48 PM'] After living in a seminary for four years these things no longer surprise or scandalize me. Perhaps I have just grown indifferent, or been able to accept it, but either way, it is not surprising. [/quote] Anomaly, I don't know if what you are criticizing is that Fr. Brian may have grown indifferent, but if you want someone to "smell of elderberries it up", sometimes one has to grow a thick skin to get through the day. I don't know if that is what Fr. Brian is saying "between the lines" (he can verify or refute it), I'm just going by what I know of human nature Edited October 6, 2006 by Norseman82
Anomaly Posted October 5, 2006 Posted October 5, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Raphael' post='1085196' date='Oct 5 2006, 06:46 PM'] Don't tempt mercy. [/quote]Precisely! Norse, Of course. Hitting a few, coming over for dinner and a few beers, going camping with the boy scouts & playing cards and drinking scotch with the men. Been there, done that. They're humans. Getting drunk and acting beyond decency. No. I have higher standards for myself, and the adults I'm around. It's not okay to justify it with 'stress'. Edited October 5, 2006 by Anomaly
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085205' date='Oct 5 2006, 08:51 PM'] Precisely! [/quote] You missed my point. You hold that Catholicism varies as much as any denomination, but you perhaps fail to see that there are different amounts of variance allowed as matters of discipline and pious devotion because the Church has not ruled on them and there are also amounts of variants which are not allowed. Anyone holding the latter is lacking in Catholicity insomuch as they hold heterodox ideas. Therefore, these beliefs are not Catholic.
Theologian in Training Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='Anomaly' post='1085205' date='Oct 5 2006, 08:51 PM'] Precisely! Norse, Of course. Hitting a few, coming over for dinner and a few beers, going camping with the boy scouts & playing cards and drinking scotch with the men. Been there, done that. They're humans. Getting drunk and acting beyond decency. No. I have higher standards for myself, and the adults I'm around. It's not okay to justify it with 'stress'. [/quote] Ok, let me clarify, I am by no means justifying such behavior as the result of stress. As I stated, seminarians do have stressful lives, I lived as one for 4+ years, but I would never justify such behaviors as getting drunk and going beyond the level of "decency," which is why I also stated the importance for seminarians to also be men of prayer, because it is by that prayer that they have the strength and endurance to persevere. Second, I choose not to engage in a debate with you on whether or not Catholicism is a denomination because based on every response you have made to me, you seem more intent on "picking a fight" than actually discussing matters. Besides, being on a Catholic board, and as one who "represents" the Church, I felt it necessary to correct your inference that Catholicism is nothing more than a denomination among denominations, because letting such misinformation go confuses those who read these message boards. God Bless Fr. Brian
iKonstantin Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 I've done both, and from my experience, the Seminarian lifestyle is far more extreme, although I would not hesitate to saying the pastoral life is slightly less so, but even so, it takes EFFORT. I repeat EFFORT to deny yourself a family, to deny yourself a monatery job, to lift yourself off of the social supports and relying on your laity to keep you fed. It is called Humility, and I think I am going to write a lecture on it now. Thank you for your obtusiviness, for it has inspired me. May the Master forgive your ignorance. Also, it was not stated that these men are drunks. It says that they were drunk. There is an extreme difference. A good rule of thumb is that if they are not able to drive for more than 1/8th of their concious time, they are drunks. I would hope that a seminarian is never drunk more than 1/52th of the time, or even under the influence. Though, the Eastern Churches use strong wine for the Pascha... brat Konstantin
Thy Geekdom Come Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='iKonstantin' post='1085255' date='Oct 5 2006, 10:08 PM'] Thank you for your obtusiviness, for it has inspired me. May the Master forgive your ignorance. [/quote] Whom are you addressing?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now