Anomaly Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='iKonstantin' post='1085255' date='Oct 5 2006, 08:08 PM'] I've done both, and from my experience, the Seminarian lifestyle is far more extreme, although I would not hesitate to saying the pastoral life is slightly less so, but even so, it takes EFFORT. I repeat EFFORT to deny yourself a family, to deny yourself a monatery job, to lift yourself off of the social supports and relying on your laity to keep you fed. It is called Humility, and I think I am going to write a lecture on it now. Thank you for your obtusiviness, for it has inspired me. May the Master forgive your ignorance. Also, it was not stated that these men are drunks. It says that they were drunk. There is an extreme difference. A good rule of thumb is that if they are not able to drive for more than 1/8th of their concious time, they are drunks. I would hope that a seminarian is never drunk more than 1/52th of the time, or even under the influence. Though, the Eastern Churches use strong wine for the Pascha... brat Konstantin [/quote]take it up on the Debate Board...
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 A kid from my high school I think was at St. Joseph's. I do not know where he is now. I never really knew him so I can't ask.
Socrates Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 While not having personal experience of this seminary, I can't really make a good judgment on the situation, I will say that a seminary should not NOT have an "Animal House" party lifestyle. Now I realize much as everyone that seminarians are human, and have human failings, an atmosphere in which things like drunkeness and masturbation are openly engaged in, and winked at, is NOT good preparation for the vocation of Holy Orders. Making excuses based on "stress" and the state of contemporary society is not going to cut it. In today's climate, and with the problems facing the Church today, it is especially imperative that priests be trained in extraordinary virtue, and to be set apart from the standards of secular society. A seminary should in fact be quite different from typical secular college life. A few months back I read an article in which the author recalled a conversation of some elderly priests with some younger priests. The older priests recalled their seminary training (in the '40s or early '50s, I believe). The seminarian training then consisted of a heavily regimented, almost military-style schedule. Strict discipline was enforced, and a rigorous, round-the-clock schedule of activity was kept. There was no time to be idle. This was compared to the same seminaries later on, when discipline was considerably slackened. The older priests from the era of hard discipline were a different breed from the priests trained in the soft atmosphere of seminaries in later times. The priesthood and training of priests needs to be taken seriously. The future of the Church depends on it.
iKonstantin Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 Oh, from my limited personal experience (4 or 5, including two Roman) of seminaries, ALL OF THEM have had EXTREME standards that had to be kept. They turned away and kicked out more people than they kept and lasted. So consider that your story possibly might be designed to hurt our Mother Church. Those monks are keeping the faith... brat Konstantin
Era Might Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 [quote name='Socrates' post='1085293' date='Oct 5 2006, 09:52 PM']A few months back I read an article in which the author recalled a conversation of some elderly priests with some younger priests. The older priests recalled their seminary training (in the '40s or early '50s, I believe). The seminarian training then consisted of a heavily regimented, almost military-style schedule. Strict discipline was enforced, and a rigorous, round-the-clock schedule of activity was kept. There was no time to be idle. This was compared to the same seminaries later on, when discipline was considerably slackened. The older priests from the era of hard discipline were a different breed from the priests trained in the soft atmosphere of seminaries in later times.[/quote] The older Seminaries also faced their own problems because of that. Regiment is good and necessary, but much of the regiment culture in Seminaries and convents before the Council was extreme and child-like in many ways. This was one of the problems the Council was facing when it turned its attention to Priests and Seminary formation. Although there were a lot of vocations, this often hurt the quality of the Seminary, because with so many men, they became like Priest factories insted of authentic schools of formation. They were churning out Priests, but the young men didn't necessarily receive an adequate formation; many were lost in the shuffle of regiment and duty. This led to particular problems for some young men who entered Seminary after high school. Because they were young, and perhaps had been in a high school Seminary even before, they didn't have an adequate human and psycho-sexual formation, which led to sexually and socially immature Priests, many of whom went on to commit acts of sexual abuse.
Didymus Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 The issues you are talking about (excessive drinking and unchaste joking) are more a maturity issue on the part of the seminarians. We can say all we want about seminarys not dealing with these issues, but when you're talking about younger guys in the seminary, there's always ways to get around the disciplinary measures. They (the priests) can preach till they're blue in the face, it won't do anything (with these issues at least) until the particular seminarians grow up. This is totally different than the issue on gay activity, which is something that would need direct and immediate action on the part of the institution
Franimus Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 Makes me feel like we should go and evangelize to the seminarians..
Didymus Posted October 6, 2006 Posted October 6, 2006 (edited) It's alot different in the seminary than most people think on the outside. I sometimes find it alot easier to live out my Faith now than when I was in the seminary. There's always a pressure for finding the balance between growing in holiness, and not becoming obsessive with it. many times you find seminarians who are pompous and think they are liturgically superior to the rest of the congregation, almost like junior priests. On the other hand, you will find these seminarians who act (unfortunately) more like the stereotypical college guy who drinks and laughs at dirty jokes and all that. Many times alot of them don't mature as soon as they're in the semianry because they are repulsed by the attitude given off by the pompous ones. They know what's right and what's wrong, but too many times they take too long to grow up and find the balance between being a normal college age guy and a guy who needs to strive for the ultimate holiness. That's the path to the priesthood... Edited October 6, 2006 by Didymus
iKonstantin Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 (edited) Sick, some of you are so sick. You cannot seem to understand. When you enter a seminary or monastery, you don't leave anything behind! It is impossible! You can slowly work out bad habits and such (There are many different strategies of weeding out sin that have been endorsed by Saints), but no more. We are all human, we all have emotional baggage, addictions, loves, things that make us angry etc. Why do you assume that once one becomes a priest - no - not even a priest, that they suddenly cease to be human? I am sorry that they are not as Holy as Thou, but truthfully, I do not know if I would like my priest to be as Holy as some of you seem to emit. Also - I am almost positive that the very idea of a seminary was to train and educate the possibly-to-be-priest whilst they discern the final step (ordination, vows etc.) Could it be that they are discerning by have a drink of alcohol? Here is something for you to think about; Peter denied the Master THREE times. Yet, in the end this sin made he so much more Holy, for he was at the bottom, which enabled him to reach the top. Could it be that The Father will use these boy's (which they are, for they are not Priests, and are like the younger Brothers in a large family), temptations and indulgences to carve out a Holier Man? brat Konstantin I forgot: Before you decide to hurt yourself with your accusations and evil words, let me be blunt - there must be no tolerance for established homosexuals in the priesthood. (I say established, for there are some sneaky freaks that might get by, but God-Willing, they can keep their demons under control) If an established homosexual wishes to enter the church, there are many completative communities that could use more members. brat Konstantin Edited October 7, 2006 by iKonstantin
Theologian in Training Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 Konstantin, I don't think anyone is disagreeing with you or telling you that you are definitively wrong. It is just that as men studying to be priests they should have a higher standard for themselves. That does not mean they are not human or become holy overnight, rather, it means that they realize that if they are called to the priesthood they need to take it more serious and remember that though they are in a college environment, they should not be the typical "college kid." Whether they realize it or not, once they agreed to even just become seminarians, they became an example (positive or negative) on religion, the Church, and what it means as one striving for holiness. People still do have respect for priests and they want to see what kind of priest that man will be by observing them in the seminary. It is not the ideal and we would rather not think about that, and just want to be an "ordinary guy," but once we said yes we ceased being an "ordinary" guy insofar as the demands placed upon us are different and what is expected of us is also different. A seminarian does not walk around with a halo over hid head, no, but people are looking for good and holy priests, and when they see what happens in a seminary they do get scandalized. I have a thicker skin, as a result, but some don't grow that extra layer or skin, they do other things, some of them leave. No one is perfect but Christ Himself taught us that we should always be striving for perfection, a perfection that consists of being face to face with God alone. God Bless Fr. Brian
Franimus Posted October 7, 2006 Posted October 7, 2006 James 3:1 "Not many of you should presume to be teachers, my brothers, because you know that we who teach will be judged more strictly." ^There's there warning.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now