Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Must We Believe This Teaching On The Perpetual Virginity Of Mary?


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I started this topic in Open Mic and realized I probably ought to have put it here. It concerns the perpetual virginity of Mary and whether Catholics must believe this particular teaching concerning this found in the [i]Catechism of the Council of Trent[/i]. (and also the [i]CCC[/i])

I wrote up my query in a precise way with only one question, as I am going to submit it to the Ask an Apologist thread on the Catholic Answers site. I thought I would ask it in Phatmass's Q&A too but then thought, Transmundane Lane could bring up several good replies also.

I was debating over this a bit in Open Mic but more so in my family, so the person I refer to here is not a phatmasser.

Here is my question:

I know the Church teaches that Mary was a virgin before, during, and after the birth of her only Son.[quote] [i]United States Catholic Catechism[/i] for Adults, glossary: Perpetual Virginity: Mary was a virgin in conceiving Jesus, in giving birth to Him, and in remaining always a virgin ever after.[/quote] I was recently debating over the word here – during, and whether this is an infallible teaching. I believe that this teaching means that Christ was born in a unique way of Mary, without affecting her physical virginity. This seems to be the only logical conclusion to this statement of Mary being a virgin during the birth of Christ.

I found this quote from the [i]Catechism of the Council of Trent[/i], Part 1 - The Creed, Article III:

[quote]He is born of His Mother without any diminution of her maternal virginity, just as He afterwards went forth from the sepulchre while it was closed and sealed, and entered the room in which His disciples were assembled, the doors being shut; or not to depart from every-day examples, just as the rays of the sun penetrate without breaking or injuring in the least the solid substance of glass, so after a like but more exalted manner did Jesus Christ come forth from His mother's womb without injury to her maternal virginity.[/quote]
However, the person with whom I was arguing, insisted that even though this is written here, it is not a defined dogma, like the Assumption, so the faithful need not necessarily believe it. He insisted that the way in which Christ was born of Mary does not matter for the faithful to confess her perpetual virginity.

My question for you here is, is this true, that the faithful need not necessarily believe every word written here from the [i]Catechism of the Council of Trent[/i]?

I went on to look this up in the [i]Catechism of the Catholic Church[/i] and found a similar line:

[quote]499 The deepening of faith in the virginal motherhood led the Church to confess Mary’s real and perpetual virginity even in the act of giving birth to the Son of God made man. [/quote]

a couple added questions, I just thought of:

It seems that when most people think of the perpetual virginity of Mary, they think of the fact that she was a virgin in conceiving Jesus, and that after the His birth, she remained a virgin. But what about the part mentioned that she was a virgin in the act of giving birth to Christ (as it says in the [i]CCC[/i])? This would seem nothing else but that the Church is saying her physical virginity was not affected, as it states using examples in the quote from the [i]CCof Trent[/i]. I don't believe this would be written for no reason in all three of these sources.

The Church's teaching on the perpetual virginity of Mary is incredibly important. I remember Fr. Corapi's voice proclaiming this in his Catechism series, and that he would be willing to die for the fact that Mary was a virgin before, during, and after the birth of her only Son.

So going back to my original question, must Catholics believe, in particular, this teaching found in the [i]CCofTrent[/i] (and supported by these quotes from other more recent sources) ?

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted (edited)

If I recall properly, there are 4 dogmas regarding Mary and (at least) 1 doctrine.

Dogma:
Immaculate Conception
Mother of God (Theotokos)
[b]Perpetual Virginity[/b]
Assumption

Doctrine:
Mediatrix, Co-Redemptrix, Advocate (it is only 1 doctrine, though)

I don't remember the proclamation for Perpetual Virginity, though. (I'm not even sure if I read through it.)

Edited by scardella
Posted

Mary's virginity before, during, and after the birth of Jesus is [i]De Fide.[/i] It is certain, and Catholics must believe it.

Source: Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Dr. Ludwig Ott, p. 205-207

-------------------------------
Blessed Father Damien, pray for us!

Posted

Many Protestant fathers believed in the ever virginity of Mary. John Wesley, John Calvin, Martin Luther, and Zweligi

kenrockthefirst
Posted

What matter of faith is at issue vis-a-vis Perpetual Virginity? Within the historical and cultural context of Judaism / Israel, having children was a blessing, e.g. Sarah and Abraham, Mary's cousin Elizabeth. So what's at stake if Mary had children with Joseph the "normal way" *after* Jesus' immaculate conception and virgin birth?

Posted

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1136460' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:27 PM']
What matter of faith is at issue vis-a-vis Perpetual Virginity? Within the historical and cultural context of Judaism / Israel, having children was a blessing, e.g. Sarah and Abraham, Mary's cousin Elizabeth. So what's at stake if Mary had children with Joseph the "normal way" *after* Jesus' immaculate conception and virgin birth?
[/quote]
I argue that what could be potentially compromised by changing this teaching is our whole view of the human body and human sexuality... not just the divinity/humanity of Jesus.



Also, a very thought-provoking book would be [i]Mary and Human Liberation[/i] by Fr. Tissa Balasuriya, O.M.I. It was written in the late 90s and Fr. Tissa was excommunicated later that decade. The book [b]is [/b]under papal censure. I suggest it for those who are fully aware of where it "stands" in the Church and for the strong in faith.

kenrockthefirst
Posted

[quote name='shortnun' post='1136463' date='Dec 6 2006, 01:31 PM']
I argue that what could be potentially compromised by changing this teaching is our whole view of the human body and human sexuality...[/quote]

I'm not sure what you mean. Both the human body and sexuality are good, although both currently corrupted as a result of the Fall. Jesus has a glorified human body, as will we all, by God's grace, and sexuality, when expressed in the correct manner, is an essential element of our humanness.

Posted

[quote]My question for you here is, is this true, that the faithful need not necessarily believe every word written here from the Catechism of the Council of Trent?[/quote]

One must believe that Mary was a [b]perpetual[/b] virgin, before, DURING, and after. If one has a speculation about how exactly that virginity was left in tact during Jesus birth, there might be some room for debate. But I see no reason to doudt the councils words that it miraculously happened.

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1136483' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:47 PM']
I'm not sure what you mean. Both the human body and sexuality are good, although both currently corrupted as a result of the Fall. Jesus has a glorified human body, as will we all, by God's grace, and sexuality, when expressed in the correct manner, is an essential element of our humanness.
[/quote]


It depends on what you mean by essential. God gave us our sexuality so that we like him could be givers of life. A part of his image and likeness that we are made of. But i would argue that sexuality, if the meaning of that is sex is not essuantial to humanity. The evidence for this is in Christ's words regarding celibacy "to some this has been given for the kingdom". Also we are told that in heaven we are neither married, nor given in marriage, but live as angels. I.e. our use of our sexuality in order to generate life is apparently only for this side of life. It is not for the eternal. Sexuality is good in the context that God made it and a part of the context of sexual reproduction is this life.

The person who chooses celibacy, does so for the kingdom, i.e. so that he can devote his life, studies, works, etc. totally to the furthing of the kingdom of God. He in essence begins living on some level, though imperfectly, the heavenly reality now. The purpose of a celibate priesthood (which your question also drives at) is not to show that sex and marriage is bad, but that it is good but there is a greater good. That is why Paul says in 1 Cor 7 that he wishes that they would not marry.

Blessings

Posted

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1136460' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:27 PM']
So what's at stake if Mary had children with Joseph the "normal way" *after* Jesus' immaculate conception and virgin birth?
[/quote]

Joseph probably would've dropped dead.

[quote name='NAB']When they came to the threshing floor of Nodan, Uzzah reached out his hand to the ark of God and steadied it, for the oxen were making it tip. But the LORD was angry with Uzzah; God struck him on that spot, and he died there before God.
- 2 Samuel 6:6-7[/quote]

Mary is holier than the first Ark of the Covenant, and God smote Uzzah for touching it. She contains God, Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity. The first Ark is a foreshadowing of her.

Plus, her perpetual virginity protects the truth of Jesus' Divinity.

Posted

just to clarify - trent wasnt the first time the church spoke on mary's perpetual virginity. the dogma was defined at the 1st lateran council in 649 and was later affirmed at the ecumenical council of constantinople - pope martin I approved it. and it was defined then in its three parts: virginity before, during, and after.

just to clarify - trent wasnt the first time the church spoke on mary's perpetual virginity. the dogma was defined at the 1st lateran council in 649 and was later affirmed at the ecumenical council of constantinople - pope martin I approved it. and it was defined then in its three parts: virginity before, during, and after.

so regardless of trent, yes we must believe it. it was defined and approved by the pope at an ecumenical council...

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I was taught it simply meant Mary never had sex before or after Jesus was born.
I don't see the necessity to insist her hymen remained unbroken during childbirth. Virginity is more that a peice of skin.

Posted

cmp,

The problem with that is that the proof of her virginity would be gone. The father's said she was a "perpetual virgin". This refers to physical virginity and must include the during.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1136820' date='Dec 6 2006, 07:41 PM']
cmp,

The problem with that is that the proof of her virginity would be gone. The father's said she was a "perpetual virgin". This refers to physical virginity and must include the during.
[/quote]
I will never quite get the necessity of this. Its not like they had ob/gyns who could tell you. We know she didn't have relations with St Joseph before or after He was born- so that covers the perpetual virginity. But during childbirth??
Virginity is more than a piece of skin. Some women are stretchable, and can look like a virgin a long time after the fact. And virgins can get pregnant, and give birth. I would think it more important to recognize she never had marital relations, than try to convince people she didn't give birth naturally.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1136836' date='Dec 6 2006, 07:59 PM']
I will never quite get the necessity of this. Its not like they had ob/gyns who could tell you. We know she didn't have relations with St Joseph before or after He was born- so that covers the perpetual virginity. But during childbirth??
Virginity is more than a piece of skin. Some women are stretchable, and can look like a virgin a long time after the fact. And virgins can get pregnant, and give birth. I would think it more important to recognize she never had marital relations, than try to convince people she didn't give birth naturally.
[/quote]

It doesn't just have to do with proving virginity. The Song of Songs implies that being a virgin is being "a closed gate." The definition of virginity according to the fathers seems to be not just "celibate" but also "never having had the womb opened." That's what it means...she was a virgin during labor because even then, she held her special virginal integrity of having a womb that was never opened.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1136836' date='Dec 6 2006, 06:59 PM']
I will never quite get the necessity of this. Its not like they had ob/gyns who could tell you. We know she didn't have relations with St Joseph before or after He was born- so that covers the perpetual virginity. But during childbirth??
Virginity is more than a piece of skin. Some women are stretchable, and can look like a virgin a long time after the fact. And virgins can get pregnant, and give birth. I would think it more important to recognize she never had marital relations, than try to convince people she didn't give birth naturally.
[/quote]

But what I am asking here is about the teaching of the Church, not what's more important in convincing people. I'm asking is this a part of The Faith. People come to The Faith, not just by others who have faith trying to convince them, but through the enlightenment of the Holy Spirit - others convincing/teaching them are only small instruments of God.

Yes, I totally get your point. Absolutely virginity is much more than just this physical matter - [i]absolutely[/i].

But this is not what I was asking about here, nor am I really asking a question that's open to debate.

I'm trying instead to understand fulling the teaching of the Church, and whether we as Catholics are obliged to believe this definition of perpetual virginity - before, during, and after. I found it very easy to believe since I first heard it. And just a few days ago, when I realized there is a specific teaching regarding Mary remaining a virgin during the birth of Christ, and after looking it up in the [i]CCC[/i], I thought, okay, here's a new thing I learned that all of us are obliged to believe as Catholics.

That's why I'm definitely submitting this to the Ask an Apologist thread on the Catholic Answers site (www.catholic.com) as they always give incredibly to the point, what the Church teaches exactly, objective responces - though I don't experience any doubt in my mind that these 3 ways of Mary being ever virgin are part of [i]De Fide[/i] - The Faith.

Yes, I actually did personally believe in this unique birth of Christ before, based on private revelation accounts like St. Bridget of Sweden's and Venerable Mary of Agreda's. But I knew absolutely that these were not at all a part of The Faith. And whether or not Our Lady experienced pain in childbirth, I believe, there is definitely no official obligatory teaching on (only these private accounts that say she didn't, which, again, is not a part of The Faith.)

But when I first read the lines from the [i]CCofTrent[/i] saying Christ passed through Mary as he passed through doors after the Resurrection, I thought - whoa, I didn't know the Church actually taught this officially. And then it came to my mind, the familar one-liner that is The Faith - Mary was a virgin [i]before, during, and after[/i] the birth of her only Son. So this is how I came to look it up in our new [i]CCC[/i] and [i]USCC for Adults[/i], and was convinced that this is truly our Faith especially since the major book, the [i]Catechism of the Catholic Church[/i], went out of the way to say she remained a virgin even in the [i]act of giving birth[/i].

But then my sister was saying that even though this is written in the Catechism, it may not be something like a dogma that we have to believe - which I thought was a strange statement. I was sure she was wrong. I asked my dad and he wasn't totally sure either, and didn't realize this exact teaching himself. So I knew I'd do the Ask an Apologist thing, but also posted here to see what you guys had to say.

Sorry I've gone so much on and on about this one minute detail. But I think it's incredibly important to understand this as part of our Faith. Otherwise we would just be confessing - Mary was a virgin before, and after the birth of her only Son - but the Church says during - so I want to know what that means if it's part of The Faith. It should be something we're willing even to die for, as Fr. Corapi proclaimed, "I would be willing to die for the fact that Mary was a virgin before, during, and after the birth of her only Son, and I hope you would too!"

Edited by Margaret Clare
Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1136952' date='Dec 6 2006, 09:03 PM']
Yes, I actually did personally believe in this unique birth of Christ, before based on private revelation accounts like St. Bridget of Sweden's and Venerable Mary of Agreda's. But I knew absolutely that these were not at all a part of The Faith. And whether or not Our Lady experienced pain in childbirth, I believe, there is definitely no official obligatory teaching on (only these private accounts that say she didn't, which, again, is not a part of The Faith.)
[/quote]
Mary did not experience pain in childbirth. That would be a result of the fall. Mary was sinless.

The fathers said that she gave birth to Christ as light passes through windows.

No passage through the birth canal (which is dogma), no pain.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Raphael' post='1137002' date='Dec 6 2006, 08:47 PM']
Mary did not experience pain in childbirth. That would be a result of the fall. Mary was sinless. [/quote]

Yeah, that's exactly what I thought. But then I realized that all pain is a result of the fall. And Jesus and Mary both experienced pain, and thus both suffered the consequences of the fall, even though they were sinless.

Still, I believe she did not suffer pain in childbirth because this was a particular sentence given after the fall, and she was Immaculate (and then I also believed this based on private revelation accounts that all say this).

[quote name='Raphael' post='1137002' date='Dec 6 2006, 08:47 PM']
The fathers said that she gave birth to Christ as light passes through windows.

No passage through the birth canal (which is dogma), no pain.
[/quote]

Raphael, thanks for this reply! That's exactly what I needed to know - "no passage through the birth canal, which is dogma, no pain."

That is what I read in private revelation, and believed, but could never know for certain, let alone, defend my position.

Do you or does anyone here know where can I find the documents of this dogma of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary? Then it will be much easier to be able to show my sister this is indeed Church dogma.

I did read the whole [i]CCC[/i] a couple years ago, but still how little I know about all the facts of The Faith!

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted

[quote name='scardella' post='1136439' date='Dec 6 2006, 11:44 AM']
If I recall properly, there are 4 dogmas regarding Mary and (at least) 1 doctrine.

Dogma:
Immaculate Conception
Mother of God (Theotokos)
[b]Perpetual Virginity[/b]
Assumption

Doctrine:
Mediatrix, Co-Redemptrix, Advocate (it is only 1 doctrine, though)

I don't remember the proclamation for Perpetual Virginity, though. (I'm not even sure if I read through it.)
[/quote]

Thanks! I knew of these dogmas, (and the doctrine) but didn't think to go to the source and read the whole of what the dogma on the Perpetual Virginity actually says. duuuh to me! Thanks again!

[quote name='Katholikos' post='1136451' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:19 PM']
Mary's virginity before, during, and after the birth of Jesus is [i]De Fide.[/i] It is certain, and Catholics must believe it.

Source: Fundamentals of Catholic Dogma, Dr. Ludwig Ott, p. 205-207

-------------------------------
Blessed Father Damien, pray for us!
[/quote]

Thanks for this precise reply with the source!

Posted (edited)

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1136460' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:27 PM']
What matter of faith is at issue vis-a-vis Perpetual Virginity? Within the historical and cultural context of Judaism / Israel, having children was a blessing, e.g. Sarah and Abraham, Mary's cousin Elizabeth. So what's at stake if Mary had children with Joseph the "normal way" *after* Jesus' immaculate conception and virgin birth?
[/quote]

The Perpetual Virginity of Mary is a dogma/infalliable truth of the Catholic Church. This is our Faith.

According to our Church, founded by Jesus Christ, to believe Mary and Joseph had children after Jesus is a heresy.

"Heretics called Antidicomarites are those who contradict the perpetual virginity of Mary and affirm that after Christ was born she was joined as one with her husband" (Heresies 56 [A.D. 428]). " - St. Augustine

This teaching has nothing whatsoever to do with thinking contrary to the fact that having children is a blessing - "Be fruitful and multiply." Of course Catholics believe having children is a blessing. Real Catholic families are supposed to be some of the biggest families out there.

And also the Immaculate Conception is not the conception of Jesus in Mary's womb by the power of the Holy Spirit. That is the definition of the virgin birth. The Immaculate Conception is the dogma that says that the Blessed Virgin Mary " ... in the first instance of her conception, by a singular privilege and grace granted by God, in view of the merits of Jesus Christ, the Saviour of the human race, was preserved exempt from all stain of original sin." (the dogma pronounced December 8, 1854 by Pope Pius IX)


[quote name='semmab' post='1136783' date='Dec 6 2006, 05:56 PM']
just to clarify - trent wasnt the first time the church spoke on mary's perpetual virginity. the dogma was defined at the 1st lateran council in 649 and was later affirmed at the ecumenical council of constantinople - pope martin I approved it. and it was defined then in its three parts: virginity before, during, and after.

so regardless of trent, yes we must believe it. it was defined and approved by the pope at an ecumenical council...
[/quote]

Thanks!

Edited by Margaret Clare
Posted

[quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1136483' date='Dec 6 2006, 12:47 PM']
I'm not sure what you mean. Both the human body and sexuality are good, although both currently corrupted as a result of the Fall. Jesus has a glorified human body, as will we all, by God's grace, and sexuality, when expressed in the correct manner, is an essential element of our humanness.
[/quote]
What makes a virgin superior to a woman who "lost her virginity" to her husband?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...