Chiquitunga Posted December 7, 2006 Author Posted December 7, 2006 (edited) [quote name='shortnun' post='1137103' date='Dec 6 2006, 10:52 PM'] What makes a virgin superior to a woman who "lost her virginity" to her husband? [/quote] I don't think a virgin is considered superior to a woman who "lost her virginity" to her husband - especially to her husband. Instead of referring to this as a woman loosing her virginity, in a marriage, it would be more said, that the marriage was consummated, and the two become one, as Christ said in the Gospels. Edited December 7, 2006 by Margaret Clare
XIX Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 Well people are never inherently superior to one another, but according to my understanding of Church Teaching, it is Canon Law that celibate vocations are higher callings. This does not make marriage any less important, it only elevates the importance of celibate vocations. Part of what makes celibacy so incredible is that you are sacrificing, in a sense, the incredible gift of sexuality and giving it directly over to God. So virginity wouldn't be as great if not for the fact that marriage is incredible in and of itself.
thessalonian Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 Fr. Rocky this morning explained it that marriage shows the spousel unity of us all and celibacy shows the spiritual union of us all. Both are in he image and likeness of God. The union in heaven is spirtual between us and God and spousel with regard to our relationship with God.
kenrockthefirst Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1137034' date='Dec 6 2006, 10:44 PM'] The Perpetual Virginity of Mary is a dogma/infalliable truth of the Catholic Church. This is our Faith. According to our Church, founded by Jesus Christ, to believe Mary and Joseph had children after Jesus is a heresy. [/quote] I accept that's what the church teaches. What I'm asking is, what article of faith is at issue? What would it mean to our faith if Mary had children with Joseph after the birth of Jesus?
thessalonian Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 Mary is a type of the Church. The Church produces spiritual children as did Mary. We are not members by flesh but by spirit. The Old Testament Jews were members of Judaism by flesh (i.e. physical birth). We are members by spiritual birth. Mary being our spiritual Mother.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 (edited) [quote name='kenrockthefirst' post='1137342' date='Dec 7 2006, 12:46 PM'] I accept that's what the church teaches. What I'm asking is, what article of faith is at issue? What would it mean to our faith if Mary had children with Joseph after the birth of Jesus? [/quote] Probably better to take this question to the Ask An Apologist board, but a couple of things come to my mind. For one, it is widely believed, partly because of Mary's question to Gabriel at the Annunciation, that she had taken a vow of celibacy. Haven taken the vow, she didn't know how she would bear a son, hence the question. If she had not taken the vow, the answer would be obvious because she was betrothed to Joseph. Secondly, there's a parellel between the Fall and the Crucifixion where both involved a tree, virgin, and death. At the Fall, there was the Tree of Knowledge, Eve was a virgin, and by sinning they brought death into the world. At the Crucifixion, Christ hung on a wooden cross, Mary was present (still a virgin), and Christ died. Also, if you look at Mary as an icon of the Church, her virginity testifies to her complete obedience and commitment to Jesus. Her love was given completely to her one son and Lord. Likewise, the Church is called to complete obedience and commitment to Jesus through whatever vocation God calls us to. But this is more of a layman's answer... I don't know how Perpetual Virginity relates theologically to other Church teachings. Edited December 9, 2006 by LouisvilleFan
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1137020' date='Dec 6 2006, 10:12 PM'] Yeah, that's exactly what I thought. But then I realized that all pain is a result of the fall. And Jesus and Mary both experienced pain, and thus both suffered the consequences of the fall, even though they were sinless. [/quote] It was not natural pain, though. It was inflicted by others maliciously. Think of it this way...if the first sin had been Cain murdering Abel, would he have been able to do it? Yes, because by his ill-will in the very act, mankind would immediately be of a fallen nature. It seems to me, then, that pain inflicted by the evil intention of another does lead one to experience pain. Childbirth, however, would not be one of these instances...the Passion would be. [quote]Raphael, thanks for this reply! That's exactly what I needed to know - "no passage through the birth canal, which is dogma, no pain." That is what I read in private revelation, and believed, but could never know for certain, let alone, defend my position. Do you or does anyone here know where can I find the documents of this dogma of the Perpetual Virginity of Mary? Then it will be much easier to be able to show my sister this is indeed Church dogma.[/quote] Mary, ever-virgin ("Aeiparthenos") was declared by Pope Martin I at the First Lateran Council and later upheld at Constantinople II. It is based on Isaiah 7:14 and Luke 1. The fact that she was a virgin during the Nativity, meaning that the womb was not opened, is supported by Sts. Ambrose, Augustine, Clement of Alexandria, Jerome, and Thomas Aquinas, as well as Pope Pius XII. *Taken from my Mariology notes from Rev. Dr. Mark Miravalle, STD.
thessalonian Posted December 10, 2006 Posted December 10, 2006 One other point to make in this regard is that North, South, East, West in the early Church the writings of the Fathers spoke of the perpetual virginity of Mary. There is a book I have by Gambrini called I think "Mary and the Church Fathers" in which he goes in to extensive detail regarding the quotes of the Church Fathers regarding her. Tertullian is the only one if I recall that dissented. There were about 30 from different parts of the known world who either explicitly or stongly implicitly spoke of here perpetual virginity. Noone with the exception of perhaps tertullian and a heretic that Jerome wrote a tract against questioned it that we know of. There of course were some that didn't write on the matter. So this doctrine is pretty solidly documented as a part of historical and Sacred Oral Tradition. Blessings
mulls Posted December 10, 2006 Posted December 10, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1137002' date='Dec 6 2006, 09:47 PM'] No passage through the birth canal (which is dogma), no pain. [/quote] then........how?
Resurrexi Posted December 10, 2006 Posted December 10, 2006 Like he passed through the Tomb or through the Door
Chiquitunga Posted December 12, 2006 Author Posted December 12, 2006 Here's another thread in Open Mic discussing this: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61634"]Mary in The Nativity Story[/url]
mulls Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1139370' date='Dec 10 2006, 07:49 PM'] Like he passed through the Tomb or through the Door [/quote] umm.... as an infant? i really want to know.
Chiquitunga Posted December 12, 2006 Author Posted December 12, 2006 [quote name='mulls' post='1140231' date='Dec 12 2006, 01:29 AM'] umm.... as an infant? [/quote] He was a Divine Infant.
Aloysius Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 the stone of the tomb was rolled away... but the door to the upper room never even opened. that is the analogy best fitting to describe the miracle of the virgin birth. I'm not sure that's dogmatic, though. she was certainly virgin before during and after the birth, but whether that means she was physically virgin in that way I am not sure of.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 [quote name='Aloysius' post='1140395' date='Dec 12 2006, 12:38 PM'] the stone of the tomb was rolled away... but the door to the upper room never even opened. that is the analogy best fitting to describe the miracle of the virgin birth. I'm not sure that's dogmatic, though. she was certainly virgin before during and after the birth, but whether that means she was physically virgin in that way I am not sure of. [/quote] What else could "virgin during" mean? If she was a virgin before the birth, then of course she was a virgin during the birth...no one loses virginity during a birth, if you're defining virginity as never having had intercourse. Why would the Church even bother to specify that she was a virgin during the birth if that's kinda obvious? It's pretty clear that the Church meant something else, not just never having had intercourse.
Era Might Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 As I understand it, "during" means that her hymen didn't break, not that Our Lord didn't pass through the womb. I don't think the wording of the Lateran Council goes into detail (is this correct Raphael?); is there any pronouncement of the Church which actually teaches that Jesus did not pass through the womb? I am inclined to believe this is a pious tradition, not Church doctrine. Assuming (for the sake of argument) that Our Lord didn't pass through the womb, that doesn't necessarily mean that Our Lady was without birth pangs. In the same way that Our Lord suffered the wages of sin without committing sin himself, so Our Lady may have suffered the pangs of birth without Our Lord physically passing through her womb. As far as I know, the Church does not teach that she was without birth pangs, although it is a pious tradition; and it is certain that there was nothing strictly preventing her from experiencing birth pangs, save divine privilege. It goes without saying that you should look to the Church for a definitive answer; but this is my understanding of what the Church teaches.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 I don't know. I believe Dr. Miravalle...he's got cardinals calling him up on a weekly basis to discuss apparitions and such...I'd imagine that he knows what he's talking about. Now, Mary could have had birth pangs, I suppose, if she had offered herself to be subject to them, but they wouldn't belong to her, properly speaking.
Era Might Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 All respect to Dr. Miravalle, but there's a difference between pious tradition and Catholic doctrine. If we are going to make a case that something is Catholic doctrine, it has to be clearly taught by the Church; the text of the Lateran Council doesn't go into detail (unless I missed part of it), and neither does the Catechism. If there is no actual pronouncement from the Church that Our Lord didn't pass through Our Lady's womb, I don't believe it can be imposed as Catholic doctrine. What is established is that Our Lady was a virgin during Our Lord's birth; this much is clearly Catholic doctrine. But has the Church elaborated on what this means? As I have always understood it, it means that Our Lady's hymen did not break. I could be wrong, but I have not seen a substantial citation from the Church to classify this matter (Our Lord's non-passage through the womb) as Catholic doctrine.
Era Might Posted December 12, 2006 Posted December 12, 2006 I came upon this from Pope John Paul II. It doesn't go into much detail, although it does cite Pope St. Hormisdas to the effect that Our Lord opened the womb without destroying Our Lady's virginity: [quote]Her virginity "during and after giving birth", although implicit in the title virgin already attributed to Mary from the Church's earliest days, became the object of deep doctrinal study since some began explicitly to cast doubts on it. [b]Pope St Hormisdas explains that "the Son of God became Son of man, born in time in the manner of a man, opening his mother's womb to birth [cf. Lk 2:23] and, through God's power, not dissolving his mother's virginity" (DS 368).[/b] This doctrine was confirmed by the Second Vatican Council, which states that the firstborn Son of Mary did not diminish his Mother's virginal integrity but sanctified it (Lumen gentium, n. 57). As regards her virginity after the birth, it must first of all be pointed out that there are no reasons for thinking that the will to remain a virgin, which Mary expressed at the moment of the Annunciation (cf. Lk 1:34) was then changed. Moreover, the immediate meaning of the words. "Woman, behold, your son!", "Behold, your mother" (Jn 19:26), which Jesus addressed to Mary and to his favourite disciple from the Cross, imply that Mary had no other children. [url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP960828.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/PAPALDOC/JP960828.HTM[/url][/quote]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1140648' date='Dec 12 2006, 05:18 PM'] All respect to Dr. Miravalle, but there's a difference between pious tradition and Catholic doctrine. If we are going to make a case that something is Catholic doctrine, it has to be clearly taught by the Church; the text of the Lateran Council doesn't go into detail (unless I missed part of it), and neither does the Catechism. If there is no actual pronouncement from the Church that Our Lord didn't pass through Our Lady's womb, I don't believe it can be imposed as Catholic doctrine. What is established is that Our Lady was a virgin during Our Lord's birth; this much is clearly Catholic doctrine. But has the Church elaborated on what this means? As I have always understood it, it means that Our Lady's hymen did not break. I could be wrong, but I have not seen a substantial citation from the Church to classify this matter (Our Lord's non-passage through the womb) as Catholic doctrine. [/quote] I think Dr. Miravalle's point is that the ancient concept of virginity was broader than ours and that the Church picked up on it. If that's the case, then the Church of then couldn't have been expected to know that our connotation for "virginity" would be narrower than theirs. Therefore, the case could be made that they [i][b]did[/b][/i] pronounce that He didn't pass through the birth canal, but that there definition is unclear because of our modern connotations. As for your quote from the pope, it doesn't prove anything. Pope Hormisdas was not speaking with infallible character and precedes the First Lateran Council by hundreds of years. As we know, a pope's theological interpretations won't all be infallible, only those that fit the requirements of the charism. Thus, some popes have held positions which were condemned by later councils (one pope was even posthumously anathematized). I'm not trying to be difficult...I'm just not going to abandon my understanding of this unless I see something definitive. Looking at the pronouncement, it seems at the very least that the hymen did not break. Edited to add: my beloved fiancee adds that "during" doesn't make any sense in a context of virginity referring only to a lack of intercourse, since it doesn't make sense to specify virginity before and after birth and then to have, "oh, and during sex, too." Of course, if you're talking about the intercourse definition, you'd have to be a virgin during if you were a virgin after and before. However, it seems to me that the virgin-birth is referring more directly to the mode of the birth...Christ was born in a way that kept His mother a virgin...kept her womb closed. It's a what, but it's also a how. He wasn't just born of a virgin, but He was born virginally.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now